D.R.MADHAVAKRISHNAIAH versus THE INCOME-TAX OFFICER, BANGALORE.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 16 December 1953 | [1954] 1 S.C.R. 537 | 1953 INSC 87
Key facts
- Decided
- 16 December 1953
- Bench
- M. PATANJALI SASTRI*, MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, GHULAM HASAN, B. JAGANNADHADAS
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 209/1953
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1954] 1 S.C.R. 537
- Neutral citation
- 1953 INSC 87
Text of the judgment
s:c.R.
537
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
Dec. IG
1953
D. ·R. MADHAVAKRISHNAIAH
v.
THE INCOME-TAX OFFICER, BANGALORE.
fPATANJALI SASTRI C.J., MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN,
s. R. DAS, GHULAM HASAN and JAGANNADHADAS JJ.]
FJl)(;nce Act (XXV of 1950), s. 13, proviso--Validity thcreofConstitution of Indian, Art. 277.
The assessee challenge<l the jurisdiction of the Income-tax
Officer, Special Survey Circle, Bangalore, to assess income-tax
and Super-tax on his inco1ne accruing prior to April I, 1950, in the
State of Mysore, on the ground that the proviso to s. 13 of the
Indian Finance Act, 1950, by virtue of which he was exercising
his power was ultra vires and void as the Parliament had no power
to make a law authorising any officer appointed under the Indian
Income-tax Act to levy tax under the Mysore law prior to the
Constitution.
It was contended (i) that on general constitutional principles
the Union Parliament had no power to make a law having retrospective effect with reference to pre-Constitution period, (ii) that
the Parliament was also prohibited by Art. 277 from making a
law authorising such officers as -in the present case to act in the
S,t.1te of Mysore :
Held, (repelling the contentions) (i) that the Parliament had
such power vide the judgment delivered in Case No. 296 of 1951, (ii)
that while Art. 277 authorises the continued levy of taxes lawfully
levied by the Government of the State before the commencement
of the Constitution and their application to the same purposes
as before, even after the Constitution came into force, there
is nothing in the article to warrant any implication that such
taxes should continue to be levied,. assessed and collected by the
same State authorities as before the Constitution and there is
nothing in Art. 277 to preclude Parliament making a law providing
for -the levy and collection of income-tax and super-tax under the
Mysore Act through authorities appointed under the Indian Income-tax Act.
CIVIL APPELLATE Juruso1CT10N :
Nos. 209 and 210 of 1953.
•
Civil
Appeals
Appeals by special leave against the Judgment
and Orders dated 4th April, 1953, of the High Court
of Judicature of Mysore at Bangalore (Medapa C. J·
and Vasudevamurthy J.) in Civil Petitions Nos. 20
and 21. of 1953.
5--94 S. C. lndia/59
538
1953
D.R.
A1adhavakrishnaiah
v.
The income-tax
Officer,
Bangalore.
Palanjali Sajtri
C.J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1954]
(B.
Neelakanta,
M. Ramaswamy, Senior Advocate,
with him) for the appellant.
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General for India, (Porus
A. Mehta, with him) for the respondent.
1953. December 16. The Judgment of the Court
was delivered by
PATANJALI SASTRJ C. J.-These two connected
appeals arise out of applications made to the High
Court of Judicature at Bangalore under Art. 226 of
the Constitution challenging the jurisdiction of the
Income-tax Officer, Special Survey Circle, Bangalore,
to assess the appellant to income-tax and super-tax on
his income accruing prior to April 1, 1950, in the State
of Mysore and praying for the issue of appropriate
writs in that behalf. The applications were dismissed
by the court and leave to appeal having been refused,
the appellant has brought these appeals by special
leave of this court.
It is a matter of admission that the officer making
the ossessments was an officer appointed under the
Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, and that in making
such assessments he was applying the income-tax law
in force in the State of Mysore down to the end of the
year of account 1948-49. The officer was exer~ising
jurisdiction in the State by virtue of the proviso to
section 13 of the Indian Finance Act, 1950, which
reads as follows ;-
Repeals and Savings.-(!) If immediately before the
lst day of April, 1950, there is in force in any Part B
State other than Jammu and Kashmir or in Manipur,
Tripura or Vindhya Pradesh ·or in the me:cged territory
of Cooch-Behar any law relating to income-tax or
.super-tax or tax on profits. of business, that law shall
cease to have effect except for the purposes of the
levy, assessment and collection
of income-tax and
super-tax in respect of any period not included in the
previous year for the purposes of assessment under
the Indian · Income-tax Act, 1922, for the year ending
on· the 31st day of March, 1951, or for any subsequent
year, or, as the case may be, the levy, assessment and
..
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
539
collection of the tax on profits of business for any
chargeable accounting period ending on or before the
31st day of March, 1949 :
Provided that any reference in any such law to an
officer, authority, tribunal or court shall be construed
as a reference to the corresponding officer, authority,
tribunal or court appointed or constituted under the
said Act, and if any question arises . as to who such
corresponding officer, authority, tribunal or court is,
the decision of the Central Government thereon shall
be final. ... "
It is contended that the proviso is ultra vires and
void as the Union Parliament had no power to make a
law authorising auy officer or authority or Tribunal or
Court appointed or constituted under the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, to levy, assess and collect incometax and super-tax payable under the Mysore law prior
· to the commencement of the Constitution of India.
The contention is based on two grounds : namely,
firstly, on general constitutional principles the Union
'Parliament had no power to make a law having retros. pective operation with reference to the pre-Constitution period ; and s~condly, the Union Parliament
is prohibited by article· 277 of the Constitution
by necessary implication from making a law grafting
on the Mysore income-tax law the machinery for
assessment and collection provided under the Indian
·Income-tax Act, 1922, for purposes of assessment
· thereunder.
So far as the first ground is concerned, the case is
governed by the judgment just delivered in the
Rajasthan case [Union of India v. Madan Gopal
'](abra (') l It remains only to deal with the second
ground based on article 277. That article reads
"thus :
, . "Ally taxes, duties, cesses or fees which, immediately
before the commencement of this Constitution, were
. ,J,ieing lawfully levied by the Government of any State
:,,or.by, al!y municipality or other local authority arc
·' body . for, the purposes · of the.. ~tate, municipality,
, dist~i~t-~~0 ,pther I01=~l ,.,area, .• may, . notwithstanding,. ~hat
( 1)
Infra. P 54'.
.. '
J953
.D.R.
Madhtna~
krishn11iah
v.
Thi Income-tax
Officer,
Bangalore.
Patanj11li S•stri
.. C;J.
540
1953
D.R.
MadhavaluisJmaioJ
v.
Tiu Income-tax
O.ffiar,
Bangalore.
Palatdali Sasfri
C.J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19541
those taxes, duties, cesses, or fees are mentioned in the
Union List, continue to be levied and to be applied to
the same purposes until provision to the contrary is
made by Parliament by law."
It was urged that, inasmuch as the article authorises,
among others, the income-tax and super-tax which
was being lawfully levied by the Government of
Mysore prior to the commencement of the Constitution
to be levied and to be applied to the same purposes
even after the commencement of the Constitution until
provision to the contrary is made by Parliament by
law, and no such law was made by Parliament till
April 1, 1950, when the Indian Finance Act, 1950,
was enacted, it followed by necessary implication, the
Mysore law of income-tax must be applied for the
levy, assessment and collection of such taxes and, as
the legislative power conferred on Parliament by
article 245 is subject to the provisions of the Constitution including article 277, Parliament had no power to
legislate, grafting officers and authorities appointed
under the Indian Income-tax Act, on the Mysore State,
for the levy, assessment and collection of the tax
under the State law. We see no force in this argument. While article 277 undoubtedly authorises the
continued levy of taxes lawfully levied by the Government of the State before the commencement of the
and
their app!ication to the same
Constitution
purposes as before, even after the Constitution
came into force, there is nothing in the article 10.
warrant any implication that such taxes should
collected by
continue to be levied, assessed and
the same State authorities as before the Constitution.
As the High Court rightly pointed out, it would
obviously have been inconvenient and unnecessary to
have oflircers appointed under the Mysore Income-tax
Act continuing to function only in respect of the
earlier assessment years side by side with ofliccn
appointed under the Indian Income-tax Act also
functioning in the State for assessments subsequent to
April 1, 1950. Both as a measure of economy and
witli a view to smooth and efficient lIWl3gement, ~
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
541
was obviously necessary and desirable that the changeover frorri the Mysore income-tax law to the Indian
Income-tax Act should be in the way provided by section 13 of the Indian Finance Act, 1950. We find
nothing in article 277 of the Constitution to preclude
Parliament making a law providing for the levy and
collection of income-tax and super-tax under the
Mysore Act through authorities appointed under the
Indian Income-tax Act. Accordingly, we hold that
the Income-tax Officer, Special Survey Cirde, Bangalore, had jurisdiction to assess the appellant to incometax and super-tax in respect of the income of the
period prior to the commencement of the Constitution.
The appeals fail and are dismissed with costs.
1953
D:R.
Madhtwakrishnaiak
v.
The Income-tax
Offim,
I
Bangalore.
'·;
PataT/jali Sastri
C.J.
Appeals dismissed.
Agent for the appellant : M. S. K. Sastri.
Agent for the respondent : G. H. Rajadhyaksha.
THE UNION OF INDIA
1953
tJ.
Dec. 16.
MADAN GOPAL KABRA.
(PATANJALI SASTRI C.J., MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN,
S. R. DAs, GHULAM HASAN and
JAGANNAD HADAS JJ.J
0
Indian Income-tax Act (XI of 1922) as amended by Finance Act
(XXV of 1950), s. 3-Taxable territories-Meaning of-Section 2
(14-A) proviso ( b) (i) and (iii)-Income accruing to assessee in State of
Rajasthan in 1949-50-Liability to income-tax-Sections 3 and 4 of
Indian Income-tax Act and s. 2 of Finance Act and proviso to the
amended s. 2 (14-A)-Constitution of Indian, Arts. 245 and 246
read with entry 82 of List I of Seventh Schedule-Parliament competent to make laws with respect to taxes for the tvho/e of lndiaConstitution competent to make laws having retrospective operation
for pre-Constitution period.
Respondent was· residing and carrying on business in the
District of Jodhpur in Rajasthan, a Part B State. His income
arising therein during the accounting year 1949-50 was sought to
be assessed to income-tax for the year 1950-51 under the Indian
!nCQme-tax Act as amended by the Indian Finance Act. He
presented a petition under art. 226 to the High Court praying
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org