JOSHI GIRJADHARJI AND ANOTHER versus LACHMANJI PANTH AND OTHERS.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 25 April 1952 | [1952] 1 S.C.R. 645 | 1952 INSC 24
Key facts
- Decided
- 25 April 1952
- Bench
- M. PATANJALI SASTRI*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, SIR SYED FAZL ALI
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 64/1951
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1952] 1 S.C.R. 645
- Neutral citation
- 1952 INSC 24
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
645
JOSHI GIRJADHARJI AND ANOTHER
v.
LACHMANJI PANTH AND OTHERS.
•>
[PATANJALI SASTRI c. J., SAIYID FAZL ALI,
MuKHERJEA and DAs JJ.]
U. P. Debt Redemption Act (XIII of 1940), ss. 2 (9), 21"Loan". "Suit to which Act applies", meanings of-Decree on
mortgage--Person who is not agriculturist when advance is madeW hether eatitled t-0 relief.
-,
A mortgage was executed by several persons on the 28th
July, 1931. The term of the mortgage, namely six years, expired
in July 1937, the mortgagees instituted a suit in May 1938 and
a decree was passed in March 1939. An application for relief
under the U. P. Debt Redemption Act (XIII of 1940) was made
on 11th April, 1942, and this application was resisted on the
ground that S, one of the mortgagors, had been assessed to
income-tax and was therefore not an agriculturist, and the suit
was not consequently "a suit to which the Act applied." The
evidenoe showed that S was earning a month! y salary of Rs. 90
and that from February 1932 he had been assessed to income-tax
till the year 1936. The High Court held, relying on the Full
Bench ruling in Ketki Kunwar v. Ram Saroop (I.L.R. 1943 All.
35), that under sec. 21 of the Act the mortgage money could be
recovered only from the mortgaged property and not personally
and that the proviso to sec. 2 (9) of the Act. had therefore
no application and the question whether S was an agriculturist
on the date of the mortgage was immaterial. As S was admittedly an agriculturist on the date of the suit, the High Court held
that the judgment debtors were entitled to relief under the Act"
On appeal
Held, that, assuming that the proviso to sec. 2 (9) applied
and that in order to be a "loan" within the meaning of the Act
it must be shown that the advance was made to one who at
the date of the advance was an agriculturist, S was not an agriculturist on the 28th July, 1931, as the Indian Finance (Supplementary and Extending) Act of 1931 which reduced the taxable
minimum from Rs. 2,000 to Rs. 1,000 was passed only in
November 1931 · and income-tax was first deducted from his
salary only in February, 1932.
Quaere : Whether the Full Bench decision in Ketki Kunwar
v. Ram Saroop (I.L.R. 1943 All. 35) is correct.
CIVIL
APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil
Appeal
No. 64 of 1951. On Appeal from the Judgment and
5-7 SCI/71
195Z
April 25
646
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
Decree dated the 16th April, 1948, of the High Court of
/oshi Girjadharji Judicature at Allahabad (Malik C. J. and Prasad J.)
in First Appeal No. 358 of 1943 arising out of the
and Another
Judgment and Decree dated the 22nd February, 1943,
v.
l..achmanji Panth of the Court of the Additional Civil Judge, Benares,
and Others.
in Original Suit No. 33 of 193.8.
1952
Gopi Nath Kunzru (K. B. Asthana, with him) for
the appellants.
,
Krishna Shankar for the respondents.'
1952. April 25.
delivered by
The judgment of the Court was
DAs J.-This appeal arises out of an application
by five out of ten judgment-debtors made under section 8 of the U. P. Debt Redemption Act (No. XIII
of 1940) for ascertaining the amount due by them in
accordance with the provisioqs of sections 9 and 10
of that Act and for amerid!rig the decree passed on
March 31, J939, by the' 'Additional Civil Judge,
Banaras, in O.S. No. 33 of 1938. The facts material
for the purposes of this ap.P.eal may now be briefly
stated.
By a mortgage deed e11~Gute9, . Qn. Ju.ne 22, 1922,
Madho Ram Sita Ram, Jai Ram and Lakshman, all
sons of Pandit Raja Ram Pant Sess, mortgaged certain immovable properties in favour of Damodarji,
son of Kamta Nathji, owner of the Kothi Joshi
Shivanath Vishwanath for the due repayment of the
sum of Rs. 8,000 advanced on that date by a cheque
together with interest thereon at 12 annas per cent. per
mensem with quarterly rests. On July 28, 1931, the
said mortgagors and their sons executed a mortgage
over the same properties irt favour of Kothi Kamta
Nathji Vishwanathji for the due repayment of
Rs. 3,000 with interest thereon at ·twelve annas · per
cent. per mensem with quarterly rests. It is recited
in the deed that the sum of Rs. 8,000 was advanced
on this date by a cheque anc;l that the amount was
utilised in paying up the amount due under the earlier
'y
·r
··
S.G.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
mortgage deed to Damodarji
Shivanath Vishwanath.
proprietor of
647
Kathi
In 1935
y
-
'
1952
/oshi Girjadharii
and Another
the U. P. Agriculturists' Relief Act
v.
(No. XXVII of 1934) came into force. On May 19,
Lachmanji Panth
1938, Girjadharji, son of Damodarji, and Murlidharji,
and Others.
minor son of Gangadharji who was another son of
Damodarji, filed suit No. 33 of 1938 in the Court of
Das/.
the Additional Civil Judge Benaras, against
the
mortgagors
and their sons for the recovery of
Rs. 9,477-2-0 due as principal and interest up to date
of suit and for further interest under the mortgage
deed of July 28, 1931. It appears from the judgment
of the High Court under appeal that in their written
statement the mortgagors claimed the benefit of the
U. P. Agriculturists' Relief Act (No. XXVII of 1934).
The plaintiffs contended that the mortgagors were
members; of a joint Hindu family and as Sita Ram one
of the mortgagors was assessed to income-tax the
mortgagors were not agriculturists as defined in section 2(2) of that Act and, therefore, could not claim
the benefit conferred on the agriculturists by that Act.
The trial Court, by its judgment dated March 31, 1939,
. hel(l that though Sita Ram was assessed to incomer;{!>;. for .the year 1931-32, the amount of such incometax did not exceed the amount of cess payable on the
land held by him and consequently the second proviso to section 2 (2) did not apply to him and he was,
therefore, an agriculturist and as the other mortgagors
. '"'.ere ·also agriculturists all of them were entitled to the
~benefits under the Act. Accordingly,
after scaling
. down the interest, a sum of Rs. 9,497-14-1 was
declared to be due for principal, interest and costs up
to March 31, 1939, and a preliminary mortgage decree
for sale was passed in that suit.
. I11 'I940 the U.P. Debt Redemption Act
(No. XIII
On April 11, 1942, five of
the judgment -debtors made an application under
section 8 of this Act before the Additional Civil Judge,
Banaras, who passed the decree. In the petition it
was stated that the debt was actually advanced in
1922, that the petitioners were agriculturists within
o1 1940) came into force.
648
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1952
the meaning of Act XIII of 1940, that the decreeholders can only get interest at the reduced rate of
/oshi Giriadharii
Rs. 4-8-0 per cent. per annum from 1922, and that
and Another
after adjustment of accounts nothing will be found
v.
Lachman;i Panth outstanding against the petitioners. The prayer was
and Others.
that an account of the money-lending business be
made from the beginning of 1922 and the decree in
Das/.
suit No. 33 of 1938 be modified by reducing the
amount due thereunder. The decree-holders filed a
petition of objection asserting, inter alia, that the
petitioners were by no means agriculturists, that they
and the respondents Nos. 3 to 7 were members of a
joint Hindu family at the time of the execution of the
mortgage deed of July 28, 1931, that Sita Ram used
to pay income-tax at the date of the mortgage in
suit and paid even at the time of the application,
that all the members of the petitioners' family
were not agriculturists within the meaning of the Act
and were, therefore, not entitled to the benefits thereof, that the debt advanced under the mortgage deed
of July 28, 1931, was not a "loan" as defined in the
Act and, therefore, the Act did not apply. It will be
noticed that although the judgment-debtors-applicants
specifically prayed for the accounts being taken from
1922, when the loan was said to have been actually
advanced, the decree-holders, in their petition of
objection, did not contest that position.
At the hearing of the application before the
Additional Civil Judge, the learned pleader for the
decree-holders admitted that with the exception of
Sita Ram the remammg judgment-debtors
were
agriculturists under Act No. XIII of 1940 but that as
Sita Ram was a party to the mortgage in suit they
were not entitled to the benefit of the Act. Two
witnesses, namely Suraj Mani Tripathi and Sita Ram,
were examined on ' behalf of the judgment-debtors
applicants. Sita Ram stated that since 1907 he had
been a teacher in Harish Chandra Intermediate
College of Banaras, that in 1930 his salary was Rs. 90
per month, that since February 1932 to 1936 he paid
income-tax and that after that he paid no income-tax.
•
-.,-··
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT .._REPORTS
649
1952
His evidence was corroborated by Suraj Mani Tripathi
)-
',
-
'
•'
...
-~
....
,
who was the Accountant of the College from 1930 to foshi Girjadharji
1942.
Referring to the College Acquittance Roll Suraj
and Another
Mani Tripathi deposed that the pay of Sita Ram was
v.
Rs. 90 per month throughout 1930, that in 1930 no Lachmanji Pantli
and Others.
income-tax was levied, that in 1931 also his salary
was Rs. 90 per month and that no income-tax was
Das f.
deducted in 1931 too, that the first deduction of
income-tax from his salary was made in February
1932. No rebutting evidence was adduced by the
decree-holders on the hearing of the application under
section 8 of the Act of 1940. The income-tax assessment form filed during the trial of the mortgage suit
and marked as exhibits is dated February 9, 1933,
and shows that on that date Sita Ram was assessed at
Rs. 1-14-0 as income-tax on Rs. 180 for the year
1931-32.
By his judgment delivered on February 22, 1943,
the Additional Civil Judge found that Sita Ram was
not assessed to income-tax either at the date of the
application under section 8 or at the date of the mortgage of 1931 and, therefore held that the applicants
were agriculturists and that the case related to a loan
as defined in Act XIII of 1940. He then went on to
discuss the question whether the account should be
reopened from June 2, 1922, when the earlier mortgage
was executed or from July 28, 1931, when the mortgage
in suit was executed. The decree-holders who did not
adduce: any evidence on the hearing of the application
evidently relied on the ,evidence adduced in suit No. 33
of 1938. After discussing that evidence the learned
Judge came to the conclusion that so far as the judgment-debtors were concerned the mortgagees in the
two mortgages were one and the same. He adversely
commented on the non-production of the books of
account by the decree-holders.
Re-opening the
accounts from Jl!ne 2, 1922, the learned Judge concluded that the whole of the principal and interest
payable according to the Act had been fully discharged
and that nothing remained due by the judgmentdebtors under the decree in suit No. 33 of 1938. He
•
650
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952}
1952
accordingly declared that the decree stood discharged
in
full and directed a note to that effect to be made in
/oshi Giriadharji
the
Register of Suits.
and Another
v.
The decree-holders having appealed to the High
Lachmanii Panth
and Others.
Court, a Division Bench (B. Mallik, C. J. and Bind
Das/.
Basni Prasad J.) by its judgment delivered on April 16,
1948, held that the question whether Sita Ram was or
was not an agriculturist on July 28, 1931, was not
material as it was not denied that all the judgment,
debtors were agriculturists on the date of suit.
Reference was made by the learned Judges to section 21
and it was stated that by reason of that section the
mortgage amount could be recovered only from the
mortgaged property and not personally from
the
mortgagors and accordingly the proviso to the definition of "loan" in section 2 (9) of the Act had no
application and it was, therefore, not necessary to
show that the borrowers were agriculturists at the
date when the advance was made and that as the
judgment-debtors were admittedly agriculturists at
the date of the suit, the case was fullv covered bv the
Full Bench decision of that High Court in Ketki
Kunwar v. Ram Saroop('). The High Court, therefore, dismissed the appeal on this point alone. The
question whether the account should be reopened
from 1922 or from 1931 was not raised by the
decree-holders at all. The decree-holders have now
come up on appeal before ·us on a certificate
granted by the High Court under section 110 of the
Code of Civil Procedure.
--
'
Sri G. N. Kunzru appearing in support of this
appeal has strongly questioned the correctness of the
(Full Bench decision relied on by the High Court and
the interpretation put by the High Court on section 21 and section: 2(9) of the Act. As we think this
appeal can be decided on a simpler ground· we do not
consider it necessary, on this occasion, to express
any opinion on either of these questions which are by
no means free from doubt.
( 1)
•
I.L.R. (1943] All. 35; A.LR. 1942 All. 390; (1942) A.L.J. 578.
'
S.C.R.
)
-
...
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
651
1952
The present application ha.<! been made under section 8 of the U. P. Debt Redemption Act, 1940, subJoshi Giriadhar;i
section (1) of which, omitting the proviso, runs as and Another
follows:v.
"Notwithstanding the prov1sions of any
decree Lachmanji Pantk
or of any law for the time being in force, an agricultu- • and Others.
rist or a workman liable to pay nhe amount due under
•[ sva
a decree to which thi~ Act applies passed before the
commencement of this Act, may apply to the Civil
Court which passed the decree or to which the execution of .the decree has been transferred, for the amendment of the decree by reductron according to the
provisions of this Act of the amount due under it,
and on receipt of such application the Court shall,
after notice to the opposite party, calculate the amount
due from the applicant in accordance with the provisi1ons of sections 9 and 10 and shall amend the decree
accordingly."
It is clear from the wording of the sub-section that
there are three pre-requisites for exercise of the right
conferred by it, namely, (1) that the application must
be by an agriculturist and (2) that that agri'culturist
must be liable to pay the amount due under a decree
to which this Act applies and (3) that that decree was
passed before the commencement of this Act. That
the judgment-debtors applicants were agriculturists
at the date when suit No. 33 of 1938 was filed and
also in 1942 when the application under section 8 was
made is conceded by Sri G. N. Kunzru. The decree
in that suit was passed on March 31, 1939, which was
well before the commencement of the Act. The only
question that remains is whether the amount was due
under a decree to which the Act applies. Under
section 2(6) of the Act the phrase "decree to which
this Act applies" means a decree passed before or
after the commencement of this Act in a suit to which
this Act applies. Section 2(17) defines the phrase
"suit to which this Act applies" as meaning any
suit or .proceeding relating to a loan. The question
then, .arises : was the decree under which the judgment-debtors applicants are liable passed in a suit
652
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952)
relating to a loan ? Loan is thus defined in secfoshi Girjadhar;i tion Z( 9) :
and Another
"'Loan' means an advance in cash or kind made
v.
before the first day of June, 1940, recoverable from
Lachmanji Panth
and Oth<Ts.
an agricu1turist or a wor k man or f rom any sueh
person and other pesrons jointly or from the property
Das ].
of an agriculturist or workm:fn and includes any
transaction which in substance amounts to such
advance, but does not include an advance the liability
for the repayment of which has, by a contract with
the borrower or his heir or successor or by sale in
execution of a decree been transferred to another
person or an advance by the Central or Provincial
Government to make advances or by a co-operative
society or by a schedule bank :
1952
Provided that an advance recoverable from an
agriculturist or from an agriculturist and other persons
jointly shall not be deemed to be a loan for the purposes of this Act unless such advance was made to an
agriculturist or to an agriculturist and other persons
jointly."
, , ...
. ... .iii
In order to be a "loan" the advance must be recoverable from an agriculturist. The word "recoverable" seems, prima facie, to indicate that the crucial
point of time is when the advance becomes recoverable, i.e., when the amount advanced becomes or falls
due. Under the mortgage of 1931 the date of redemption was 6 years from the date of execution, i.e., in
July 1937. Sri Kunzru concedes that Sita Ram was
not assessed to income-tax since 1936. Assuming,
but without deciding, that the proviso to section 2 (9)
applies and that in order· to be a "loan" it must be
shown that the advance was made to one who, at the
date of the advance, was an agriculturist as defined
in section 2(3) of the Act the question has yet to be
answered, namely, had Sita Ram ceased to be an
agriculturist by reason of clause (b) of the proviso to
section 2(3), . that is to say, by reason of his being
assessed to i.pcome-tax on July 28, 1931. According
to the evidence of suraj Mani Tripathi and Sita Ram
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
653
1952
income-tax was first deducted at the source in the
month of February 1932 by the College authorities foslzi Girjadharii
and the actual assessment was made on February 9, and Another
1933. Therefore, Sita Ram was not assessed to incomev.
tax on July 28, 1931. It is not disputed that the Lachman;i Panth
and Others.
taxable minimum was reduced from Rs. 2,000 per
annum to Rs. 1,000 per annum by the Indian Finance
Das/.
(Supplementary & Extending) Act, 1931, which was
enacted on November 26, 1931. Therefore, at the date
of the. advance, i.e., on July 28, 1931, Sita Ram whose
,salary was below Rs. 2,000 per annum was not only
not actually assessed to income-tax but was not even
liable to such assessment. The evidence of Suraj
Mani Tripathi shows that the first deduction of incometax out. of the salary was in the month of February
1932 and the income-tax assessment form for 1931-32
(Ex. S) shows that tax was assessed on Rs. 180 which
was evidently salary for February and March 1932
being the last two months of the assessment year.
The position, therefore, is that Sita Ram was not
assessed to income-tax at the date of the advance in
1931 or on the due date under the deed, i.e., in July
1937, or on the date of s1Uit in 1938 or on the date
·of the application under section 8 in 1942. It consequently follows that he was an agriculturist on all
these dates. The other judgment-debtors were admittedly agriculturist. Therefore, the application under
section 8 was made by persons who were all agriculturists and who were liable to pay under a decree to
which the Act applies, i.e., under a decree passed in
a suit relating to a loan as defined by section 2(9).
The Courts below, therefore, were right in their conclusion that the judgment-debtors applicar.ts were
entitled to the benefit of the Act.
Sri G. N. Kunzru finally submitted that in any
·case the accounts could not be taken from 1922, for
the mortgagees under the two mortgages were different. We have already pointed out that this point
was not specifically taken in the decree-holders' petition of objection. The trial Court held as a fact that
so far as the judgment-debtors were concerned the
654
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1952]
1952
mortgagees were the same in both the mortgages ..
Although
in the petition of appeal to the High Court
Joshi Girjadharji
it was alleged that the mortgagees were different and
and Another
v.
the accounts could not be reopened from 1922, that
Lachmanji Panth ground was not specifically urged before the High
and Others.
Court. The determination of that question must
necessarily
involve an investigation into facts. We
Das/.
do not think, in the absence of a plea in this behalf
in the decree-holders' petition of objection and also in
view of their failure and neglect to raise this question
before the High Court, it will be right for this final
court of appeal, at this stage and in the circumstances
of this case, to permit the appellants to raise this
question of fact.
The result, therefore, 1s that this appeal must stand
dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Agent for the appellants : C. P. Lall.
Agent for the respondents : N atmit Lall.
1952
May 26.
THE STATE OF BIHAR
v.
SHAILABALA DEVI
[PATANJALI SASTRI C.J., MEHER CHAND
MuKHERJEA, DAs and BosE, JJ.]
MAHAJAN,
Indian Press (Emergency Powers) Act (XXlll of 1931), s. 4 (I}
(a)-Constitution of India Arts. 19(1) and 19(2)-Restrictions
imposed by s. 4(l)(a) on freedom of speech and expression-Whether fall within Art. 19 (2)-Validity of s. 4 (!)-Speeches of
political demagogues-Construction-Burden of prosecution .
.Section 4 (!) (a) of the Indian Press (Emergency Powers)
Act (XXIII of 1931) is not unconstitutional as the restrictions
imposed on freedom of speech and expression by the said sec·
tion are solely directed against the undermining
of
the security
of the State or the overthrow of it and are within the ambit of
Art. 19 (2) of the Constitution. Romesh Thapar's case ( [1950]
:-
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org