LACHMAN SINGH AND OTHERS versus THE STATE
Supreme Court of India | Decided 21 March 1952 | [1952] 1 S.C.R. 839 | 1952 INSC 17
Key facts
- Decided
- 21 March 1952
- Bench
- SIR SYED FAZL ALI*, VIVIAN BOSE
- Bench size
- 2
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 22/1950
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1952] 1 S.C.R. 839
- Neutral citation
- 1952 INSC 17
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
839
1952
invoked by the ·plaintiff, to the property held by
a wife in her own right, the foundation on which
Gokal
custom grows would be wanting. When the matter Thakur
Chand
is further probed, it appears that the plaintiff relies not
v.
only on custom but partly on custom and partly on Parvin Kumari.
the rule of Hindu la:w, namely, that the law which
Fazl Ali f.
governs the husband will govern the wife , also.
Whether the latter rule can be extended to a case like
the present ~ a question of some difficulty, on which,
as at present advised, we would reserve our opinion.
In the circumstances, we prefer to leave the issue of
custom undecided, and base our decision on the sole
ground, which by itself is sufficient to conclude the
appeal, that the plaintiff's marriage with Ram Piari
has not been clearly established.
The appeal therefore fails and it is dismissed, but
in the circumstances of the e;ase and particularly since
the appellant has appealed in f orma pauperis, we
direct that the parties will bear their own costs in all
the courts.
Appeal dismissed.
Agent for the appellant: S. D. Sekhri.
Agent for the respondent: Naunit Lal.
LACHMAN SINGH AND OTHERS
v.
THE STATE
[SAIYID FAzL Au and VIVIAN BosE
1952
March 21.
JJ.]
Evidence Act (1 of 1872), sec. 27-Statements of several accused
leading to discoveries-Admissibility-Necessity of proof as to
which statement was made first-Scope of sec. 27.
Three persons K, M and S, who were accused of murder ·
made statements to the police which disclosed that the dead
bodies after being dismembered were thrown into a stream and
the police party thereafter went with the three accused to the
stream where each of them pointed out a place where different
840
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
•.
1952
parts of the dead bodies were discovered. It was contended on
behalf of the accused that it was only the information which was
Lachma11 Singh first given that was admissible u·nder sec. 27 of the Evidence
and Others
Act, that once a fact has been discovered in consequence of
v.
information received from a person accused of an offence~ it
The State. cannot be said to be re~discovered in consequence of information
received from another accused person, and that in the absence
of evidence to show which of the accused first gave the infer·
mation the discoveries alleged cannot be proved against any of
the accused persons: Held, that, even assuming that this argu·
ment was correct, as it appeared from the evidence that S led
the police to a particular spot on the stream and it was at his
instance that some blood stained earth was recovered from a
place outside the village and he had also pointed out the trunk
of one of the dead bodies, and the High Court was satisfied that
there was an "initial pointing out" by S, the case was covered by
the rule and the evidence as to the discoveries was admissible.
\Vith regard to the rule applicable to cases where there is
clear and unimpeachable evidence as to independent and authen·
tic statements of the nature referred to in sec. 27 of the Evidence
Act having been made by several accused persons either simultaneously or otherwise, some of the decided cases have gone
further than is warranted by the language of sec. 27 of the
Evidence Act and may have to be reviewed on a future occasion.
CRIMINAL
APPELLATE
•
JURISDICTION : Criminal
Appeal No. 2i of 1950. Appeal from the judgment
and order dated 29th Juni:, 1950, of the High Court of
Judicature at Simla (Weston C.J. and Khosla J.) in
Criminal Appeal No. 432 of 1949 arising out of a judgment dated 5th August, 1949, of the Court of the Addi- ·
tional Sessions Judge, Amritsar, in Sessions Trial No.
7 <if 1949 and Case No. 8 of 1949.
fai Gopal Sethi (R. L. Kohli, with him) for the
appellants.
Gopal Singh for the State.
1952, March 21. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by·
: -. :;oo
FAzL Au J.-The three appellants were tried by the
Additional Sessions Judge at Amritsar and found
guilty of having murdered two persons named Darshan
Singh and Achhar Singh and sentenced to transportation for life. The High Court of Punjab upheld their
;..-
·-
S.C.R.
===t·'
>
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
841
1952
conviction and sentence and granted them a certificate
under article 134( 1) ( c) of the Constitution that the
Lachman Sing/,
case 1s a fit one for appeal to this Court. Hence this
and Others
appeal.
v.
The facts of the case may be briefly stated as
follows. On the evening of 16th December, 1948, a
little before sunset, Achhar Singh, one of the murdered
persons, went to the house of one Inder Singh in
village Dalam for getting paddy husked. Achhar
Singh's brother, Darshan Singh, who was working as
a driver at Amritsar, came to Dalam from Amritsar
the same evening, and, on coming, to know from his
father that Achhar Singh had gone to Inder Singh's
house, he also went there. While the two brothers
were returning home, they were attacked by the three
appellants and two of their relatives in a lane adjoining Inder Singh's house. The five assailants, who were
armed with deadly weapons, inflicted a number of injuries on the two victims, as a result of which they
died then and there. After the murder, the appellants
and their companions tied the two dead bodies in two
kheses (wrappers) and took them to village Saleempura
where two other persons, named Ajaib Singh and Banta
Singh, joined them, and the dead bodies after being
dismembered were thrown into a stream known as
Sakinala at a place about five miles from village Dalam.
Bela Singh, father of the deceased persons, who was
one of the persons who claiw; to have witnessed the
occurrence, did not leave the village at night on account
of fear, but he started about two hours before sunrise
on the next morning and lodged the first information
report at 10 A.M. at the nearest police station. A police
officer arrived in village Dalam shortly afterwards,
and after investigation a charge-sheet was submitted
against seven persons including the present appellants.
At the trial, five of the accused were charged with
offences under section 302 read with section 149 and
under section 201 read with section 149 of the Indian
Penal Code, and the remaining two accused were
charged with the offence under section 201 read with
section 149 of that Code. The learned Judge who tried
The State.
Fazl Ali/.
842
1952
Lzchman Singh
and Others
v.
The State,
Fazl Ali/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
the accused, convicted the appellants and two other
persons under section 302 read with section 149 of the
Penal Code and sentenced them to transportation for
life and convicted Ajaib Singh under section 201 read
with section 149 and sentenced him to three years'
R.I. Banta Singh, accused, was acquitted. On appeal
the Punjab High Court upheld the conviction of th~
present appellants and acquitted the remaining three
persons.
Before proceeding to discuss the evidence in the case,
it is necessary to refer to what has been described as
the motive for thy. murder. It appears, that in June,
1947, Natha Singh, father of the third appellant,
Swaran Singh, was murdered, and Darshan Singh and
Achhar Singh, the two milrdered persons in the case
before us, and their third · brother, Sulakhan Singh,
were charged with the murder of that person. As a
result of the trial, Darshan Singh was acquitted and
Achhar Singh was sentenced to 1! years' R.I., while
Sulakhan Singh was sentenced to 7 years' R.I. The
judgment of the Sessions Judge in that case was delivered shortly before the date of the present occurrence,
and it is common ground that Achhar Singh had been
released on bail by the appellate court and was at large
at _that time. It is said that the appellants and their relatives felt aggrieved by the 'acquittal of Darshan Singh
and by the light sentenced passed on Achhar Singh,
and therefore committed this murder in a spirit of
frmtration and revenge. It was conceded before us by
the learned counsel for the appellants that the facts
stated above constituted a strong motive for the
murder, but he also contended that .they constituted
an equally strong motive for the appellants being
falsely implicated in case the murder was committed,
as was suggested by him, in circumstances under which
the murderers could not be seen or identified. It therefore becomes necessary to set out the evidence adduced
by the prosecution in support of the murder.
The evidence led by the prosecution may be divided
under two main heads:-(1) Direct evidence, and (2)
Circumstantial evidence. The direct evidence consists
1
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
843
1952
oif the testimony of four eye-witnesses, namely, Bela
Singh, father of the deceased, who claims to have gone
Lachman Singh
to the scene of occurrence on hearing an outcry and to
and Others
have witnessed the murderous assault on his sons ;
v.
Th r: Statr:.
Inder Singh and his wife, Mst. Taro, to whom the
murdered persons had gone for getting paddy husked
Fazl Ali/.
and who lived in a house adjoining the lane where the
murder took place ; and Gurcharan Singh, a resident
of a different village, who states that he saw the
occurrence when he was going towards village Dhadar
on a cycle.
-'
The circumstantial evidence in the case, on which
the High Court has relied, may be briefly summarised
as follows :( 1) The second appellant, Massa Singh, who was
arrested on the 18th December, 1948, was wearing a
pyjama stained with human blood.
(2) The third appellant, Swaran Singh, who was
arrested on the 18th December, 1948, took the police
on the 19th December to his haveli which was locked,
and, on opening it two khases (wrappers) which were
·
stained with human blood were recovered.
(3) Swaran Singh pointed out a spot on the way
to Sakinala, where the two dead bodies were placed for
a short time while they were being taken to Sakinala,
and the police scrapped blood-stained earth from that
spot. He also led the police to the bank of Sakinala and
pointed out the trunk of the body of Darshan Singh
which was lying in the nala.
(4) Lachhman Singh, who was arrested on the 28th
December, 1948, pointed out· a dilapidated khola near
Sakinala where 3 spears, one kirpan and a datar, all
stained with human blood, were recovered.
The learned Sessions Judge, who heard the evidence,
seems to have been impressed by the evidence of the
eye-witnesses, and he has summed up his conclusion
in these words:"This evidence was so consistent, so reliable, and of
such nature that in my opinion it is definitely established that the five accmed Lachhman Singh, Katha
844
1952
Lachman Singh
and Others
v.
The State.
Fazl Ali J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
Singh, Massa Singh, Charan Singh and Swaran Singh
are proved to have actually murdered both Darshan
Singh and Achhar Singh. This fact is further proved
from subsequent events as deposed by P.W. 8 Bahadur
Singh and P.W. 9 Gian Singh and P. W. 11 Bhagwan
Singh. These witnesses had witnessed the various recoveries in this case which were made at the instance
of all the accused."
The learned Judges of the High 03urt, though they
repelled most of the criticisms levelled against the
witnesses, ultimately came to the conclusion that "in
all the circumstances (of the case) it would be proper
not to rely upon the oral evidence implicating particular accused ' unJess there is some circumstantial
evidence to support it". Having laid down this
standard, they examined the circumstancial evidence
against each of the accused persons and upheld the
conv>iction of the three appellants on the ground that
the circumstantial evidence, to which reference has
been made, was sufficient corrobbration of the oral
evidence.
The case of the appellants was argued at great length
by Mr. Sethi, who appeared for them, and everything
that could possibly be said in their favour was urged
by him with great force and clarity. Proceedings,
however, upon the principles laid down by this court,
circumscribing the scope of a criminal appeal after the
case has been sifted by the trial court, and the High
Court, it seems to us that the question involved in the
present appeal is a short and simple one. According
to our reading of the judgment of the High Court, the
learned Judges, who dealt with the case, did not
condemn the oral evidence outright, but, as a matter
of prudence and caution, they decided not to convict
an accused person unless there were some circumstances
to lend support to the evidence of the eye-witnesses
with regard to him. It is quite clear on reading the
judgment that the corroboration· which the learned
judges required to satisfy themselves was not
that kind of corroboration which one requires in the
case of the evidence of an approver or an accomplice,
.
S.C.R.
),
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
845
1952
but corroboration by some circumstances which would
lend assurance to the evidence before them and satisfy
Lachman Singn
them that the particular accused persons were really
and Others
concerned in the murder of the deceased. Judged by
v.
this standard, which it was open to them to prescribe,
The State.
it seems to us that the case of each of -the appellants
Fazl Ali/.
clearly fell within the rule which they had laid down
for their own guidance.
The comment of the learned counsel for the appellants with regard to the blood-stained pyjama which
was recovered from Massa Singh was, firstly, that it
was not possible to gather from the evidence the
extent of the blood stains, and secondly that it would
be highly improbabk that this accused person would
be so reckless as to continue to wear a blood stained
pyjama after having perpetrated the crime. This
criticism has been considered by the courts below,
and it does not appear to us to be of such a nature as
to affect the conclusion arrived at by them. As to
the recovery of blood-stained weapons at the instance
'Of Lachhman Singh, it was urged that the entire
evidence with regard to this recovery should be discarded, as the police investigation in the case was not
a straightforward one but was conducted in such a way
as to raise suspicion that the police were deliberately
trying to create some evidence of recovery against
each of the accused persons. It is sufficient to say
that it is not the function of this court to reassess evi<lence and an argument on a point of fact which did
not prevail with the courts below cannot avail the
appellants in this court. The comment against the
'discoveries made at \the instance of Swaran Singh was
that they are not admissible in evidence under section
27 of the Indian Evidence Act, which provides"When any fact is deposed to as discovered in
consequence of information received from a person
accused of an offence in the custody of a police officer,
so much of such information whether it amounts to a
'COnfession or not, as relates distinctly to the fact thereby discovered, may be proved."
846
1952
Lachman Singh
and Others
v.
The State.
Faz/ Ali/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
The main facts which it is necessary to ~tate to
understand the argument on this point may be summed up as follows:According to the prosecution, all the three
accused, namely, Katha Singh, Massa Singh and
Swaran Singh, were interrogated by the police on
the morning of the 19th December, 1948, and they
made
certain
statements
which
were
duly
recorded by the police. In these statements, it was
disclosed that the dead bodies were thrown in the
Sakinala. Thereafter, the police party with the threeaccused went to Sakinala where each of them pointed
out a place where different parts of the dead bodies
were discovered.
The learned counsel for the appellants cited a number of rulings in which section 27 bas been construed to
mean that it is only the information which is first given
that is admissible . and once a fact bas been discovered
in consequence of information received from a person·
accused of an offence, it cannot be said to be a re-discovered in consequence of information received from
another accused person. It was urged before us that
the prosecution was bound to adduce evidence to prove
as to which of the three a£Cused gave the information
first. The head constable,· who recorded the statements of the three accused has not stated which of
them gave the information first to him, but Bahadur
Singh, one of the witnesses who attested the recovery
memos, was specifically asked in cross-examination
about it and stated : "I cannot say from whom information was got first". In the circumstances, it was
contended that since it cannot be ascertained which
of the accused first gave the information, the alleged
discoveries cannot he proved against any of the
accused persons. It seems to us that if the evidence
adduced by the prosecution is found to be open to
suspicion and it appears that the police have deliberately attributed similar confessional statements relating to facts discovered to different accused persons,.
in order to create evidence against all of them, the
case undoubtedly demands a most cautious approach.
S.C.R.
-
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
847
19"2
But as to what should be the rule when there is clear
and unimpeachable evidence as to independent and
Lachman Singh
authentic statements of the nature referred to in
and Others
section 27 of the Evidence Act, having been made
v.
The States.
by several accused persons either simultaneously or
otherwise, all that we wish to say is that as at present
Faz/ Ali/.
advised we are inclined to think that some of the cases
relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellants
have perhaps gone farther than is warranted by the
language of section 27, and it may be that on a suitable occasion in future thooe cases may have to be
reviewed. For the purpose of this appeal, however,
it is sufficient to state that even if the argument put
forward on behalf of the appellants, which apparently
found favour with the High Court, is correct, the discoveries made at the instance of Swaran Singh cannot
be ruled
out of consideration. It may be that
several of the accused gave information to the police
that the dead bodies could be recovered in the
Sakinala, which is a stream running over several miles,
but such an indefinite information could not lead to
any discovery unless the accused followed it up by
conducting the police to the actual spot where parts
of the two bodies were recovered. From the evidence
of the head constable as well as that of Bahadur Singh,
it is quite clear that Swaran Singh led the police via
Salimpura to a particular spot on Sakinala, and it was
at his imtance that blood-stained · earth was recovered
from a place outside the village and he also pointed
out the trunk of the body of Darshan Singh. The
learned judges of the High Court were satisfied, as
appears from their judgment, that his was "the initial
pointing out" and tl1erefore the case was covered even
by the rule which, according to the counsel for the
appellants_, is the rule to be applied in the present
case.
The learned counsel for the appellants poinred out
that the doctor who performed the post-mortem examination of the corpses, found partially digested rice
in the stomach of the two deceased persons, and he
848
1952
Lackman Singh
and Ot'1er1
v.
Tlie State,
Fazl Ali].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
urged that from this it would be inferred that the
occurrence must have taken place sometime at night
after the deceased persons had taken their evening
meals together. This argument again raises a question of fact which the High Court has not omitted to
consider. It may however be stated that a reference to
books on medical jurisprudence shows that there are
many factors affecting one's digestion, and cases were
cited before us in which rise was not fully digested even
though considerable time had elapsed since the last
meal was taken. There are also no data before us to
show when the two deceased persons took their last
meal, and what article of food, if any, was taken by
them along with rice. The finding of the doctor therefore does not necessarily affect the prosecution case as
to the time of occurrence.
It was also contended that there being no charge
under section 302 read with section 34 of the Indian
Penal Code, the conviction of the appellants under section 302 read with section 149 could not have been altered by the High Court to one under section 302 read wlth
section 34, upon the acquittal of the remaining accused persons. The facts of the case are however such
that the accused could have been charged alternative..
ly, either under section 302 read with section 149 or
under section 302 read with section 34. The point has
therefore no force.
In our opinion, there is no ground for interfering
with the judgment of the courts below, and we accordingly disrujss this appeal and uphold the conviction
and sentence of the appellants. We however wish to
endorse the opinion of the High Court that having
regard to the gruesome nature of the crime, the sentence imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge was
inappropriate and his reasons for imposing the lighter
penalty are wholly inadequate.
Appeal dismissed.
Agent for the appellant : R. N. Sachthey.
Agent for the respondent: P. A. Mehta.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org