CHINNATHAYI ALIAS VEERALAKSHMI versus KULASEKARA PANDIYA NAICKER AND ANOTHER
Supreme Court of India | Decided 14 December 1951 | [1952] 1 S.C.R. 241 | 1951 INSC 57
Key facts
- Decided
- 14 December 1951
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, SIR SYED FAZL ALI, N. CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 29/1949
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1952] 1 S.C.R. 241
- Neutral citation
- 1951 INSC 57
Text of the judgment
241
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
S.C.R.
CHINNATHAYI alias VEERALAKSHMI
1951
ti.
Dec. U.
KULASEKARA PANDIYA NAICKER
AND ANOTHER
•
(and connected appeals)
I
[SAIYID
FAzL
Au,
MEHER CHAND MAHAJAN
CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR
JJ.]
and
lmpartible estate-Succession-Extinction of branch-Disputes
to succession-Compromise-Construction of deed-Disruption
of family-Renunciation of right to succession by junior membePs of
other branches-Sufficiency of evidence-Right to effect partitiQ1l·
Effect of general words of release.
11S
To establish that an impartible estate has ceased to be JOint
family property for purposes of succession it is necessary to prove
an intention, express or implied, on the part of the junior
members of the family to give up their chance of succeeding to
the estate. In each case it is incumbent on the plaintiff to adduce
satisfactory grounds for holding that the joint ownership of the
defendant's branch in the estate was determined so that it became
the separate property of the last holder's branch. The test to
be applied is whether the facts show a clear intention to renounce
or surrender any interest in the impartible estate or a relinquishment of the right of successsion and an intention to impress
upon the zamindari the character of separate property.
,...
The right to bring about a partition of an impartible estate
cannot be inferred from the power of alienation that the holder
thereof may possess. In the case of an impartible estate the
power to divide it amongst the members does not exist, though
the power in the holder to alienate it is there, and from the
existence of the one power the other cannot be deduced, as it is
destructive of the very nature and character of the estate and
makes it partible property.
A member of a joint family owning an impartible estate can
on behalf of himself and his heirs renounce his right of succession
but any such relinquishment must operate for the benefit of all
the members and the surrender must be. in, favour of all the
branches of the family as representing all its members.
General words of release in a release deed do not mean release
of rights other than those then put up, and have to be limited to
the circumstances which were in the contemplatiqn of the parties
when it was executed.
242
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1951
On the death of the holder of an impartible estate who represented the first branch his widow K got into possession claiming
Chinnathayi
that the estate was the separate property of her hu.sband and
also under a will. Disputes arose between her and the members
alias
Veeralak.shmi of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th branches of the family and these were
settled amicably. S who \Vas the senior member of the 3rd
v.
branch obtained village D and one-fourth of certain pannai lands
Kulasek.ara
Pandiya Naick.er as absolute owner and executed a release deed on 6th May, 1890,
and Another. in these terms : "Whatever rights over the said zamin properties and in all other abovementioned properties S might possess
he gives up such rights absolutely in favour of the said K and
her heirs enabling them to enjoy them with the power of alienahave no claim at all to the properties shown as belonging to K."
KS Who represented the 2nd branch and had instituted a suit
tion thereof by gift, sale etc.. . . . . . . . The said S and his heirs shall
against- K compromised the suit on the 10th May, 1890, under a
deed which provided inter alia: (i) that the zamindari shall be
enjoyed by K till her lifetime and that KS and his heirs shall after
the lifetime of K enjoy the zamindari except village D 'vhich was
given to S; (ii) village B and one-fourth of certain pannai lands
shall be given to KS absolutely ; (iii) all other pannai lands, buildings and movables which belonged to K's husband shall be enjoyed
by K and her heirs absolutely." On the death of K the estate
became vested in Z, the son of KS. The death of Z without
_issue the second branch became extinct and disputes arose with
regard to the ownership of the pannai lands and buildings,
village B, and the zamindari between the widow of Z (who was
the grand-daughter of K) and the senior members of the 3rd and
.4th branches :
•
•
+-
Held (i) that as KS was competent to alienate the pannai lands
and buildings in favour of K and vest her with absolute title,
and S had also agreed to give them to her absolutely, K became
the absolute owner of these lands and buildings and these ceased
to be part of the joint estate and devolved on the grand-daughters
of K as her stridhana heirs.
' (ii) In view of the arrangement of 1890 it was not open to any
of the parties to deny that the village B was separated from the
zamindari and given to KS absolutely as his private property.
village consequently devolved on
as separate property and
on his death it devolved on his widow.
rhe
z
.
(iii) The arrangement made in 1890 did not evidence a partitiOn amongst the' members of the joint family or prove an inten.
tion on the part of the junior members of the family to renounce
their expectancy of succession by survivorship on failure of the
male lineal descendants in the branch of KS.
(iv) That the recitals in the release deed executed by S had to
be read in the light of the compromise in the suit of ·Ks, and the
~'
,, .
•
c
...
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
243
proper inference from both the documents read together was
1951
that S renounced only his right to succeed to the zamindari
immediately as the seniormost member of the family and that Ckinnat!tayi
he. did not renounce his right or the right of his branch to succeed
alias
to the zamindari by survivorship if and when occasion arose ; Veeralaksltmi
the senior member of the 3rd branch was therefore entitled
v.
to succeed to the zamindari in preference to the senior member Kulasekara
of the 4th branch and the widow of Z.
Pandiya Naicker
Vadrevtt Ranganayakamma v. Vadrevt1 Bttlli Ramaiya (5 C.L.R. and Another•.
439), Sivagnana Tewar v. Periasami (5 I.A. 51) and Thakurani
Tara Kumari v. Chaturbhttj Narayan Singh ( 42 I.A. 192) distinguished.
Sartaj Kttari's case (15 I.A. 51), Konammal v. Annadana (55 I.A.
114), Collector of Gorakhpur· v. Ram Sunder Mal (1.L.R. 56 All.
468 P.C.), Sri Raja Lakshmi Devi Garu v. Sri Raja Surya Narayana
(I.L.R. 20 Mad. 256 P.C.) and Directors etc. of L. & S.W. Ry. Co.
v. Richard Doddridge (L.R. 4 H.L. 610) referred to.
The ludgment of the Madras High Court affirmed.
-
"'
•,
CIVIL APPELLATE
JurusDicTION: Civil
Appeals
Nos. 29 to 33, 89 and 90 of 1949.
Appeals from the Judgment and Decree dated the
30th October 1945 of the High Court of Judicature at
Madras (Lionel Leach C. J. and Rajamannar J.) in
Appeals Nos. 230, 300-302, 355, 356 and 413 of 1943.
G. S. Pathak (T. S. Santhanam, with him) for the
appellant in Civil Appeals Nos. 28 and 29 of 1949,
respondent No. 1 in Civil Appeals Nos. 30, 32 and 33
of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil Appeal No. 31
of 1949, for respondent No. 3 in Civil Appeal No. 31 of
1949 and for respondents Nos. 1 and 2 in Civil Appeals
Nos. 89 and 90 of 1949.
V. V. Raghavan, for the appellant in Civil Appeals
Nos. 31 to 33 of 1949, respondent No. 1 in Civil Appeals
Nos. 28 and 29 of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil
Appeal No. 30 of 1949.
B. Somayya (K. Subramaniam and Alladi Kuppuswami, with him) for the appellant in Civil Appeals
Nos. 30, 89 and 90 of 1949, respondent No. l in Civil
Appeal No. 31 of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil
Appeals Nos. 28, 29, 32 and 33 of 1949.
1951. December 14. The Judgment of the Court
. was delivered by MAHAJAN J.
244
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeralakshmi
v.
Kulasekara
P•ndiya Naicker
and Another.
Mahajan f.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19521
MAHAJAN J.-These eight appeals arise
out of a
common judgment of the High Court of Madras dated
the 30th October, 1945, given in seven appeals preferred to it against the judgment of the District Judge
of Madura in four suits, O.S. Nos. 2, 5, 6 and 7 of 1941,
all of which related to the zamindari of Bodinaickanur
in the Madura district and the properties connected
therewith. The appeals were originally before the
Privy Council in England, some by leave of the High
Court and others by special leave and are now before
us for disposal
The zamindari of Bodinaickanur is an ancient impartible estate in the district of Madura, owned by a
Hindu joint family. The genealogical tree of the
family is as follows :-
-
'
\;
~
·'
"
j
.!
.........
(4)
.I
..
.
(5)
.
I
Kulasekara Pand1a
Naicker (No. I)
(Died after 10-5-1889
but before 1902)
Chokkalinga,ami
Naicker (Died
after 10-5-1889
but before 1902)
~I~-----'-----;!
Bangaruswami
Naicker (Died
before 1902)
I
Muthu
Bangaruswami
Naicker (Died)
V. ~ulasel~iua
Pand1ya Na1cker
(!st Deft.)
I
Tiruma!Ji Bodaya
Sundararaj Pandiya
N aicker (Died)
I
.
I
.
V1swanathaswam1
Naicker (Died)
I
Thirumalai Muthu Vijaya
Dalapathi Pa.ndiya
Naicker (Died)
Ra.ja~a
T.B.S.S.
Pa.ndiya
Naicker (Plainti,ft)
I
Kulasekara Pandiya
Naicker (No. 2)
(Died before 1902)
I
.
I . a1·ias
Satpur
Chumathay1
Zamindar
Vecralakshmi
Ammal {2nd Deft.)
T.V.K. Kamaraja
PandiaNaieker,
late Zamindar
I
-~--[
Vadamalai Thirumalai
Muthu
Bodaya
Kula>ekara Sundararaja
Pandiya
Pandiya
Naicker
Naicker
I.
.
Chokkahngasam1.
Naicker (Died)
I
I
.
T.J).M.S.K. Pand1ya
Naicker
1
Seelaraja Pandiya
Naicker (Died
on 25-9-1931)
I
~
~
a;::
tT1
8d
~
I
T. lJ. Kamaraja
Pandiya
Naicker
~
~
Vl
r
Pandiya Raja
Naicker
1
Seela Bodi
Na!cker
,_,__ ,.I
.
Cho........ 1ngaswam1.
Na!cker
I
Kamaraja Pandiya
Naicker
(Died)
~
246
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952J
1951
The zamindari was last held by Kamaraja II of the
second branch. He died on 16th February, 1941,
Chinnathayi
without male issue, but leaving him surviving a widow
alias
Chinnathayi
alis Veeralakshmi Ammal, and members
Veeralak_shmi
v.
of the family belonging to the third, fourth and fifth
Kulasekara
branches. Succession to the zamindari_ is admittedly
Pondiya Naicker governed by the rule of lineal primogeniture modified
and Another.
by a family custom according to which the younger
son by the senior wife is preferred to an elder son by
Mahaian J.
a
junior
wife.
According
to
this
custom
T.B.S.S. Rajaya Pandiya Naicker of the third branch
was entitled to the zamindari after the death of
Kamaraja II of the second branch. His claim was
denied by the widow and by Kulasekara Pandiya
Naicker of the fourth branch, both of whom claimed
the zamindari on different grounds. It was alleged by
the widow that the zamindari was the separate and
exclusive property of her husband and that being so,
she was entitled_ to it under the rule of Mitakshara
applicable
1b
devolution
of
,separate property.
Kulasekara of the fourth branch claimed it on the
basis that Sundara Pandiya Naicker of the third
branch who died in 1893, had separated from the
family and had renounced his and his descendants'
rights of succession to the zamindari and the third
branch having thus lost all interest in the joint family
zamindari, he was the next person entitled to it by
survivorship.
On 28th April, 1941, the revenue officer allowed the
claim of Kulasekara and held that he was entitled to
possession of the zamindari and the pannai lands (homefarm lands) which were in the possession of Kamaraja II. As regards one of tl1e villages comprised in
the zamindari, viz., Boothipuram, tlie title of the
widow was recognized. In pursuance of tliis order,
Kulasekara got into possession of the zamindari and
the pannai lands after the death of Kamaraja II.
Boothipuram village remained in the possession of the
widow. Dissatisfied with the order of the revenue
officer, the parties have instituted_ . the suits out of
which these appeals arise.
-. '
•
'
'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
247
1951
On the 22nd June, 1041, the widow (Chinnathayi)
brought suit No. 5 of 1941 for possession of the zaminChinnathayi
dari against Kulasekiara of the fourth branch, Rajaya
alias
and his uncle Seelabodi Naicker of the third branch, V eeralakshmi
T. B. M. S. K. Pandiya Naicker and Kamaraja Pandiya
v.
Naicker of the fifth branch, on the allegations set out Kulasek_ara
Pandiya Naicker
above.
On the 4th July, 1941, she and her sister instituted
suit No. 2 of 1941 against the same set of defendants
for cancellation of the deed of release that had been
executed by her and her sister in favour of Kamaraja
II on the 9th June, 1934, in respect of the pannai
lands that were in the possession of Kulasekara of the
fourth branch under the order of the revenue officer.
The third suit, 0. S. No.. 6 of 1941, was brought by
Rajaya of the third branch on 27th August, 1941, for
possession of the zamindari, Boothipuram village and
the pannai lands, against Kulasekara of the fourth
branch and the two plaintiffs in suit No. 2 of 1941, on
the allegation that under the rule of lineal promogeniture he was the person next entitled to succeed to the
zamindari after the death of Kamaraja IJ.
The last suit, 0. S. No. 7 of 1941, was instituted by
Kulasekara of the fourth branch on 13th Oetober, 1941,
against the widow and Rajaya, his rival claimants to
the zamindari for a declaration that he was the rightful heir and successor to the zamindari and was entitled to possession of Boothipuram village registered in
the name of the widow.
The zamindari of Bodinaickanur originally consisted
of fifteen villages mentioned in schedule (A) to the
plaint in 0. S. No. 6 of 1941 and of certain pannai
(home farm) lands and buildings.
Tirumalai Bodi
Naicker was the holder of this impartible raj. He was
succeeded by his son Rajaya Naicker who died in 1849,
leaving him surviving five sons, Bangaru Tirumalai
Bodi Naicker, Viswanatha Naicker., Sundara Pandiya
Naicker, Kulasekara Pandiya Naicker and Chokkalingaswami Naicker, representing the first, second,
third, · fourth and fifth branches respectively;
Rajaya
and Anotht:r.
Mahajan /.
248
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
V erralakshmi
v.
Kulasekara
Pandiya Naicker
and Another.
Mahaia'n /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
Naicker was succeeded by his eldest son Bangaru
Thirumalai Bodi Naicker who died on the 27th October, 1862, and was succeeded by his son. T. B. Kamaraja Pandiya Naickier (Kamaraja I) who remained as
zamindar till his death on 15th December, 1888. He
had no son and on his death his widow Kamuluammal got into possession of the estate. Proceedings
for transfer were taken in the revenue court for registry of the zamindari and statements of the male members of the family belonging to the second, third
fourth and fifth branches and of the widow were recorded by the Deputy Collector. On 18th December,
1888, the representatives of these branches stated that
they had no objection to Kamuluammal enjoying the
zamindari. On the 19th Kamuluammal asserted that
her husband by his will had bequeathed the zamini.
dari to her and· had given her permission to make an
adoption. On the same date the representatives of all
branches of the family made a joint statement before
the Deputy Collector. The relevant portion of it is in
these terms :"We fonr persons are his heirs to succeed and
yet we agree to his widow Kamuluammal taking and
enjoying the above said zamin and all other properties save the undermentioned lands set apart for our
maintenance. Remission of the tirwah of the said
lands allowed to us and of the tirwah of the lands registered in our nathes and enjoyed till now, should be
granted to us."
544 kulies of pannai lands under the Bangaruswami
tank and tl1e Marimoor tank were earmarked for the
maintenance of the four branches. The widow made a
statement on 20th accepting this arrangement
The
Deputy Collector submitted his report on the 5th of
January, 1889, to the Collector upholding the Will.
The Collector in his turn also recorded the statements of the representatives of the several branches of
the family. Persons representing the third, fourth
and fifth branches adhered to the previous statements
made by them but Kandasami of the second branch
resiled from his earlier statement and asserted that the
'
,,
'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
249
1951
family being divided he was the next heir to the
zamindari. No notice was taken in these proceedings
Chinnatha'ft
of Vadamalai, the half-brother of Kamaraja I. Sundara
alias
Pandiya's statement before the Collector on the 9th Vecralakshmi
v.
January, 1889, was in these terms :Kulastkfhll
"The wish of the family is that the widow should Pandiya Naid(er
be in charge of the estate. I know nothing about the and Another.
execution of the will. After the death of the widow,
Mahajafl f.
He is Kandaswami,
the next heir should succeed.
son of Viswanathaswami Naicker, my eldest brother,
deceased."
To the same effect were the statements of Kulasekara
of the fourth branch and of Chokkalingaswami of the
fifth branch. Kandaswami's statement was recorded
on the 14th January, 1889, and he said as follows :"I am the next heir to the zamin, the family
being undivided. I must get it."
He repudiated his earlier statement on the ground
that at that time he was ill and was drowned in sorrow
and "some rogue imitated his signature" and put it• on
his previous statement. The revenue Officer ordered
that the widow's name be registered as the next person
entitled to the zamindari subject to any order that the
civil court might make in the case.
On the 1st May, 1889, Kandasami filed 0. S. No. 16
of 1889 in the court 0£ the Subordinate Judge of
Madura impleading the widow and the Collector as
defendants for recovery of the entire zamindari as it
then existed, including the villages of Boothipuram
and Dombacheri and the pannai lands.
He alleged that he as a member of the undivided
Hindu family was entitled to rncceed to the zamindari
by survivorship and in accordance with the established
rule applicable to the devolution of this zamindari.
Kamuluammal denied this claim and asserted that
the zamindari was the separate property of her husband
and she was entitled to it in preference to her husband's
collaterals. She also based her claim on the alleged
will of her husband. Sundara Pandiya of the third
branch laid a claim to the zamindari and the
250
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeralakshmi
v.
Kulasekara
Pandiya Naicker
and Another.
Mahaian '}.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
pannai lands on the ground that he as senior in age
amongst the family members was entitled to them in
preference to Rajaya on the rule of simple primogeniture. In view of the pending and threatened litigation
the contesting parties thought it fit to end their disputes by a mutual settlement beneficial to all of them.
Sundara Pandiya was the first to strike a bargain
with the widow. On the 6th May, 1890, a deed of
release (Exhibit P-17) was executed hy him in favour
of Kamuluammal incorporating the terms of the
agreement. He managed to get from her in consideration of the release the village of Dombacheri absolutely
for himself and his heirs. She bound herself to pay
the peishkush and road cess of the said village without
any concern about that on the part of Sundara
Pandiya. He was also allowed to enjoy free of rent
from generation to generation with power of alienation
by way of gift, sale etc. the one-fourth share in the'
pannai lands under the irrigation of the Bangaruswami
tank and the Marimoor tank and · mentioned in the
joif\t statement made by tl1e several branches of the
family before the Deputy Collector in December 1888.
Over and above tbis, he received a cash payment of
Rs. 3,000. With the exception of Dombacheri village
and of the one-fourth share in the said pannai lands,
all the other properties which belonged to Kamaraja I
were to be held and enjoyed with all rights by
Kamuluammal and her heirs with the power of alienation thereof by way of gift, sale etc. absolutely. The
fourth clause of the release is in these terms :"Whatever rights over the said zamin Rroperties
:ind in all the other abovementioned properties, the
said Sundara Pandiya Naicker Avargal might possess,
he gives up such rights absolutely in favour of the said'
Kamuluammal Avargal and her heirs enabling them
to enjoy them with the power of alienation thereof by
way of gift, sale, etc. and whatever rights the said
Kamuluammal might possess over the Dombacheri
village and over the lands lying under the 1rngation
of the Bangarusami tank and the Marimoor tank and
specified i,n the third colmru1 of the schedule hereto,
•
.
S.C.R.
• _,.,>...;io
•
. ' a_1
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
251
1951
which are given up to the aforesaid Sundara PandiyaNaicker A vargal, the said Kamuluammal Avargal
Chinnathayi
hereby gives up such rights absolutely in favour of the
alias
said Pandiya Naicker Avargal and his heirs, enabling Veeralakshmi
them to enjoy them with the power of alienation
v.
Kulasekara
thereof by way of gift, sale etc."
Pandiya Nait:ker
Clause 5 runs thus :and Another.
"The said Kamuluammal and her heirs shall have
Mahajan f.
no claim at all to the properties shown as belonging to
Sundara Pandiya Naicker Avargal as aforesaid and
the said Sundara Pandiya Naickier Avargal and his
heirs shall have no claim at all to the properties shown
as belonging to the said Kamuluammal Avargal."
This deed was presented for registration on JOth
May, 1890. On the same day O.S. No. 16 of 1889, i.e.,
Kandasami's suit, was also compromised. Exhibit P-18
contains the terms of that compromise. The following
are its important provisions :(a) the zamindari shall be enjoyed by Kamuluammal till her lifetime and she shall have no right to
mortgage those properties in any way prejudicial to
the plaintiff.
(b) Kandasami and his heirs shall after the lifetime of Kamuluammal, enjoy the zamindari excepting
Dombacheri village together with such rights if any as
the first defendant Kamuluammal may have acquired
under the deed of release executed between her and
Sundara Pandiya.
( c) Boothipuram village shall be given to the
plaintiff by Kamuluammal so that she may enjoy it
with absolute rights. The entire peishkush and the
road cess for the entire zamindari inclusive of the said
village shall be paid by Kamuluammal.
( d) The one-fourth share in pannai lands situated
on the irrigation areas of Bangaruswami tank and
Marimoor tank shall be enjoyed by Kandaswami
and his heirs with powers of alienation and with
absolute rights.
( e) Rs. 35,000 shall be paid to Kandasami by
Kamuluammal.
252
1951
Chinnatht;yi
alias
Veera}akshmi
v.
Kulasekt;ra
P~ndiya Naicker
1111d An.other.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952J
( f) All the other pannai lands, buildings and
movables which belonged to the deceased Kamaraja
Pandiya Naicker shall be held and enjoyed by Kamuluammal and her heirs with powers of alienation etc.
and with absolute rights free from any future claim
on the part of Kandaswaini and his heirs.
•
(g) The movable and immovable properties which
may be acquired hy Kamuluammal from out of the
income of the zamindari shall belong to her with
power of alienation etc. and shall go to her own heirs
after her lifetime.
(h) Kamuluammal shall not make an adoption.
By the proceedings taken before the Collector and by
the arrangement made under Exhibits P-17 and P-18,
the disputes that had then arisen in the family were
settled. Kamuluammal, however, did not with good
grace part with the properties which she had agreed
to give to others under the arrangement. The terms
of the compromise had to be enforced against her by
a number of suits and actions one by one. Be that
as it may, it is not denied now that the arrangement
arrived at was eventually acted upon.
Kandasami
and his sons enjoyed the Boothipuram village and
one-fourth of the pannai lands in the two tanks absolutely. Sundara Pandiya and his descendants enjoyed
Dombacheri and one-fourth pannai lands, the fourth
and fifth branches obtained possession of one-fourth
share of the pannai lands under the two tanks.
Kamuluammal secured revenue registration and remained in possession of the property down to the date
of her death on 13th January, 1921. On her death
the estate becaine vested in the possession of Kamaraja.
II, the sole male representative of the second braP.ch,
his father Kandasami and his brother Viswanathaswami having predeceased Kamuluammal.
He had
been. married to Chinnathavi (Veeralakshmi) one of
the. grand-daughters of Kainuluainmal during her
lifetime.
In the year 1925, the zamindar of Saptur, the son of
Kamulu's deceased daughter Meenakshi,
instituted
•
•.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
253
1951
0. S. No. 7 of 1925 against his sisters, Chinnathayi
-.and Periathayi, and Kamaraja II, for recovery of the
Chinnathayi
pannai lands and buildings which had vested absoalias
lutely in Kamulu under the compromise decree, on <:he Veera/aksh mi
allegation that these were held by her as a widow's
v.
Kulasekara
estate and that he as the daughter's son was entitled
to succeed to them. The suit was resisted by the two Pandiya Naicker
and Another.
sisters on the plea that these lands were stridhanam
properties of Kamulu and they as stridhanam heirs
Mahajan f.
were entitled to them in preference to their brother.
Kamaraja II contended that he was entitled to these
lands and buildings as they formed an integral part
of the zamindari and were treated as such by Kamulu.
This suit was dismissed and the plea of the two sisters
was upheld. On 9th June, 1934, both of them executed a deed of release in favour of Kamaraja II whereby
they conceded his claim to the pannai lands and the
to the zamindar~ in
buildings as being appurtenant
consideration of his agreeing to pay Rs. 300 per mensem
for life to each of them.
-
...
•
On the death of Kamaraja II on the 16th February,
1941, as already stated, the second branch of the
family became extinct, and disputes arose in regard
to the succession to the zamindari, pannai, lands,
As
buildings etc. and the village of Boothipuram.
above stated, the claimants to the zamindari are three
in number, Rajaya of the third branch, Kulasekara of
the fourth branch, and Chinnathayi alias Veeralakshmi,
the widow of the late zamindar. The District Court
and on appeal the High Court have concurrently held
that Rajaya was the person entitled to the zamindari.
The District Court further held that the village Qf
Boothipuram continued to be part of the zamin and
decreed the same to the plaintiff Rajaya. As regards
the pannai lands, it was held that these had been conveyed absolutely to Kamulu under Exhibit P-18 and
that her daughter's daughters, Periathayi and Chinnathayi, succeeded to the same as her stridhanam heirs
and that the release deed executed by them on the 9th
June, 1934, was invalid and inoperative to convey a
valid title to Kamaraja II. On appeal the High Court
254
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952)
1951
confirmed the findings of the District Court as regards
the pannai lands and buildings but reversed its findings
Chinnathayi
as regards succession to Boothipuram. It held that
alias
Kandasami
obtained Boothipuram village as his selfVeeralak.shmi
acquired property and that Chinnathayi was entitled
v.
Kulasek.ara
to succeed, to the same on the demise of her husband
Pandiya Naick.er Kamaraja II. The various sets of parties have preand Another.
ferred the above appeals against the decision of the
High Court to the extent it goes against them.
Mahajan /.
'
'
The points for determination in these appeals are
the following :1. Who out of the three claimants is entitled .to
the zamindari.
2. Whether Boothipuram village is still an integral part of the zamindari or did it become the
self-acquired property of Kandasami by the compromise, Exhibit P-.18.
3. Whether the pannai lands and buildings are
part of the zamindari or became the stridhanam of
Kamuluammal by the compromise decree and did not
merge in the zamindari by the release deed of 1934:
The question relating to the pannai lands and buildings can be shortly disposed of. Both the courts below
have held that · under the arrangement arrived at
amongst the members of this family in the year 1890
these lands became the stridhanam of Kamuluammal
and passed on to her stridhanam heirs, i.e., her granddaughters Chinnathayi and Periathayi, and that the
deed of .release executed by the two sisters in favour
of Kamaraja II was. vitiated by fraud and was not
binding on Chinnathayi and the other heirs. This
finding could not be seriously disputed by Mr.
Somayya appearing for Rajaya or by Mr. Raghavan
appearing for Kulasekara. It was faintly argued that
the pannai lands were left with the widow in the same
status in which she was allowed to retain the zamindari. This contention is contrary to the clear recitals
of the compromise deed.. Kamuluammal was a forceful personality and it seems clear that she agreed to
accept the title of Kandasami as next entitled to the
-
•
'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
255
1951
ertate and to give up her contention based on the will
because she was given the zamindari for her lifetime
Clsinnathayi
:md these pannai lands and buildings absolutely.
alias
Kandasami in whom the inheritance had vested was Ve"alalcshmi
competent, in view of the decision in Sartaj Kuari's
case(1), to alienate these lands in her favour and to Kulasekara
vest her with absolute interest in them. It has there- Pandiya Naicker
and Another.
fore been rightly held that Kamulu became the absolute owner of the lands which in due course devolved
Mahaian /.
on her grand-daughters and ceased to be part of the
joint family estate. Moreover, it do'es not lie in the
mouth of Sundara Pandiya's descendants to challenge
Kamuluammal's absolute title to these lands while
retaining absolute title in the village of Dombacheri
which under the same arrangement Sundara Pandiya
got absolutely with rights of alienation. It was conceded that to the family arrangement arrived at in the
year 1890 and evidenced by the statellJe!).ts made before the Collector, the recitals contained in the release
deed, Exhibit P-17, and those made in the compromise
deed, Exhibit P-18, all the members of the family
were either parties or they accepted it and acted upon
it. The result is that the widow Chinnathayi is entitled to the possession of those lands and no other
person has any right to them whatever.
"·
As regards Boothipuram village, the point ts a
simple one. Under the compromise, Exhibit
P-18,
this village was left with Kandasami, the person next
entitled to the zamindari after the death of Kamaraja I.
It was separated from the zamindari est<\te which
remained in possession and enjoyment of Kamulu..._
ammal for her lifetime. It was said in the compromise
that Kandasami would be the absolute owner of this
village. It was argued by Mr. Somayya, and the same
was the view taken by the trial Judge, that Kandasami being the holder of an impartible estate could
not by his own unilateral act enlarge his estate and
take a 'part of this estate in a different right than the
right of a holder of an impartible zamindari and that
he could not make it separate property by his own act.
(1) (1888) 15 I.A. 51.
2-4 S. c. lndia/71
256
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1951'
The High Court did not accept this view but reached
the decision that all the branches of the family agreed
Chinnathayi ·
to Kandasami having this village as his private proalias
perty and that by , common consent it was taken out
Veeralakshmi
v. ·:,.
of the zamindari and given to him absolutely and it
Kulasekara
was thus impressed with the character · of separate
Pandiya Naicker
property. On Kandasami's death it devolved on his
and Another.
son by succession and not by survivorship and
Chinnathayi has a widow's estate in it after the death
Mahajan /.
of her husband. In the High Court it was conceded
that all the members of the family were aware of the
terms of the family arrangement and were bound by
them. In view of this concession it seems to us that it
is not open to any of the parties to these appeals to
deny at this stage the right of the widow to this village
as an heir to her husband's estate.
The main fight in all these appeals centres round the
title and heirship to the zamindari.
The question for
our determination is, whether the zamindari by some
process became the separate property of Kanda£ami
and that of his son Kamaraja II. If it became the
separate property of Kamaraja II, then Chinnathayi,
his widow, would succeed to it on. his death ; on the
other hand, if the zamindari retained its character of
joint family property in the hands of Kamaraja II,
then the question to decide is whether as a result of
Sundar;i Pandiya
the arrangement made in 1890
relinquished his right to succeed to the family zamindari on the failure ·of nearest male heirs of Kandasami.
If such relinquishment on his part is held satisfactorily
established, then Kulasekara of the fourth branch
would be entitled to succeed to the zamindari ; otherwise Rajaya of Sundara Pandiya's branch alone is
entitled to it under the rule of succession applicable to
the devolution of the zamindari.
The claim made by the widow that the zamindari
became by the arrangement of 1890 the separate property of Kandasami was disallowed by the High Court
on the short ground that the documents, Exhibits
P-17 and P-18, read along with the various statements
made in 1889 cannot be read as changing the charactet
-
•.
S.C.R.
,. .
-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
257
1951
of the estate from that of an impartible estate belonging to the joint family to an estate owned by KandaChinnathayi
sami in his individual right. In the view of the High
alias
Court the only change effected by the arrangement so Ve~alakshmi
far as the estate was concerned was to defer the right
y.
Kulasekara
of Kandasami to its possession as the next in succession until after the death of Kamuluammal.
Kanda- Pandiya Naicker
and Another.
sami could not himself make it his own private property and this was conceded by all.
After hearing
Mahaian /.
Mr. Pathak at considerable length we are m agreement
with the High Court on this point.
Mr. Pathak argued that on the true construction of
Exhibits P-17 and P-18 and on the evidence furnished
by there two documents and the statements made
antecedent to their execution and also in view of the
subsequent conduct of the parties, the correct inference
to draw was that all the five branches of the family
separated in the year 1890 and thus put an end to the
joint family character of the zamindari: that Kandasami was allotted the zamindary, Boothipuram village
and one-fourth pannai lands under the two tanks,
Sundara Pandiya was allotted Dombacheri village · and
one-forth of the pannai lands and that the fourth and
fifth branches in lieu of their share were assigned onefourth of the pannai lands irrigated by the two tanks
mentioned above and by these allotments the joint
family was eompletely disrupted and the properties
allotted to the different branches became their separate
properties.
Reference was made to the decisions of the Privy
Council in Vadrevu Ranganayakamma v. Vadrevu
Bulli Ramaiya(1); Sivagnana Tevar v. Periasami(2) ;
Thakurani Tara Kumari v. Chaturbhuj Narayan
Sin:gh( 3 ) ; and it was contended that the present case
was analogous to the facts of those cases and should
be decided on similar lines. We are of the opinion that
the facts of none of those cases bear any close resemblance to the facts of the present case. The decision in
(l) (1880) 5 C.L.R. 439.
(2) ( 1877) 5 I.A. 5 I.
(3) (1915) 421.A. 192.
258
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1951
each one of those cases was given on their own peculiar
set of circumstances.
Ckinnathayi
In the first case the owner of an impartlble zaminalias
V ceralak.shmi
dari forming part of family property died leaving
V~~ r
four sons and an infant grandson by his eldest son.
Kulasck_ara
During the minority of the grandson the four survivPandiya Naicker
ing
sons executed a sanad which directed that
and Another.
the zamindari should be held by the grandson
Mahajan /.
and that they should take an equal share of
the inam lands and also manage the zamindari
during the infancy of the grandson, which on
his attaining majority had to be handed over to
him, each confining himself to the share of the inam
lands allotted to them. Certain family jewellery was
also divided in a similar manner. This grandson then
died leaving a son, who also died without any issue
but leaving a widow. Her title to the zamindari was
denied by the descendants of the four sons of the
·zamindar. It was held that the sanad amounted to
an agreement by which the joint family was divided
and that on the death of the last holder his widow
was entitled to the zamindari. It was observed in
this case that having partitioned the lands, the parties
to the sanad proceeded to partition the jewels and this
·circumstance was inconsistent with the supposition
that the document was executed with the intention of
merely providing allotments in lieu of maintenance.
It is clear from the facts of this case that the family
owned other coparcenary properties besides the zamindari and the zamindari in dispute fell to the lot
of the grandson as his separate property.
There
·were other materials in the case indicating that there
was complete separation between the members of
this family.
In the next case an impartible zamindari had
devolved on the eldest of three undivided Hindu
brothers. He executed an instrument appointing his
second brother to be zamindar. The instrument recited that if the widow of the deceased who was pregnant
did not give birth to a son but a daughter, he and his
offspring would have no interest in the zamindari of
'
·•
<
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
259
1951
which his younger brother would be the sole zamindar
who would also allow maintenance to the third
brother. The widow gave birth to a daughter and the Chinnathayi
alias
second brother took over the zamindari. The third Veeralakshmi
brother also died without issue. On the death of the
v.second brother his son succeeded and the zamindari Kulasekara
devolved on him who died leaving a widow. The son of Pandiya Naicker
the eldest brother who had renounced the zamindari and Another.
sued to recover the estate against the widow. It was
Mahajan /.
held that the instrument executed by the eldest
brother was a renunciation by him for himself and his
descendants of all interests in the zamindari either as
the head or as a junior member of the joint family and
consequently it became the separate property of the
second brother and the widow was entitled to succeed
to it in preference to the line of the eldest brother.
The document on the interpretation of which this
decision was given was in these terms:-
-
"l and my offspring shall have no interest in the
said palayapat, but you alone shall be the zamindar
and rule and enjoy the same, allowing, at the same
time, as per former agreement to the younger brother,
P. Bodhagnrusami Tevar,-who in the pedigree is
called Chinnasami,-the village that had been assigned to him before."
•·
These words were interpreted as amounting to a
renunciation of all interest in the palayapat either as
the head of or as a junior member of the joint family.
The rights of the youngest brother Chinnas<!_mi were
expressly reserved. It was said that the effect of the
transaction was to make the particular estate the property of the two instead of the three brothers, with,
-0f course, all its incidents of impartibility and peculiar
course of the descent, and to do so as effectually as if
in the case of an ordinary partition between the elder
brother on the one hand and the two younger brothers
on the other, a particular property had fallen to the
lot of · the other two. Other clauses in the deed and
the attending circumstances fully corroborated the
'Construction placed upon it.
260
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
J
[1952]
1951
In the last case the holder of an impartible estate of
a
joint
Hindu family made a mokurari grant to his
Chinnathayi
younger
brother for maintenance. The grantee built :r
alias
separate house, divided from his brother's by a waU,
Veeralakshmi
v.
established therein a tulsi pinda and thakurbari, and
Kulasekara
lived there separately from his brother. He defrayed
Pantliya Naicker the marriage expenses of his daughter subsequently
and AnoJ}ier.
to the grant. Upon these facts it was held that there
was a complete separation between the brothers, and
Mahajan f.
that the irnpartible estate consequently became sepa·
rate property of the holder whose widow was entitled
to succeed and have a widow's estate in the zamindari.
It was observed that the evidence clearly proved that
there had been complete separation between Thakur
Ranjit Narayan Singh and
his
brother Bhupat
Narayan Singh in worship, food and estate.
In our
opinion, the decision in this case must be limited to
the facts therein disclosed and can have no general
application to cases of impartible estates where the
only right left to the junior members of the family is
the right to take the estate by survivorship in case of
failure of lineal heirs in the line of the last zamindari.
The Junior members can neither demand partition of
the estate nor can they claim maintenance as of right
except on the strengtl1 of custom, nor are they entitled
to possession or enjoyment of the estate.
In our opinion, division amongst the members of
this family by allotment of properties was not possible as the only property known to belong to the
family was the impartible zamindari of which parti·
tion could not be made or demanded. To establish
that an impartible estate has ceased to be joint family
property for purposes of succession it is necessary to
f>rove an intention, express or implied, on the part of
the junior members of the family to give up their
chance of succeeding to the esta,te. In each case, it is
incumbent on the plaintiff to adduce satisfactory
grounds for holding that the joint ownership of the
defendant's branch in the estate was determined so
that it .became the separate property of the last
holder's branch. The test to be applied is whether the
••
·•
S.C.R.
..
t •
-
...
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
261
facts show a clear intention to renounce or surrender
any interest in the impartible estate or a relinquishment of the right of succession and an intention to
impress upon the zamindari the character of separate
property.
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeralakshmi
v•.
Kulasekara
to the Pandiya Naic'k_er
and Another.
Reference in this connection may be made
decision of the Privy Council in Konammal v.
Annadana(1).
In that case on ~he death of a
son
being feeble in mind,
holder, his
elder
his younger son succeeded to the zamindari by
an arrangement with the adult members of the family
in the vear 1922. The estate then descended from
father t~ son till 1914 when the junior branch became
extinct and possession was taken by a senior member
of the branch who ·claimed it by survivorship, while
the mother of the last holder claimed the estate as an
heir to separate property, and it was held that the
setting aside of the elder son in 1822 did not deprive
his descendants of their rights as. members of the
family to succeed on failure of the junior branch. In
this case there was complete passing over of one
branch of the family to succession vested in the next
junior branch ; yet · when that branch failed, the
members of the senior branch were held yet to possess
their right to succeed to the zamindari by survi~
vorship.
In Collector of Gorakhpur v. Ram Sundar Mal(2), the
claim of a Hindu to succeed by survivorship to an
ancestral impartible estate was in issue in the suit.
The family admittedly had been 1omt. It appeared
that the common ancestor of the deceased holder and
of the claimant had lived 200 years before the suit,
that for a long period there had been a complete separation in' worship, food and social intercourse between
the claimant's branch of the family and that of the
deceased holder, and that upon the death of the
holder the claimant had not disputed that the widow
of the deceased was entitled to succeed. It was held
that there was not to be implied from the circumstances
(1) (1928) 55 I.A. ll4.
(2) (1934\ l.L.R. 56All.468 (P.C.).
·Mahajan /.
262
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeral~kshmi
v. /
Kulasekara
Pandiya Naicker
.and Another.
.Mahajan /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
stated above a renunciation of the right to succeed so
as to terminate the joint status for the purposes of
that right.
In Sri Raja Lakshmi Devi Garu v. Sri Raja
Surya Narayan'tl Dlzatrazu Balzadur Garu('), the last
zamindar died without any issue in 1888, and when
his widow was in possession, the suit was brought for
possession by a male collateral descended from a great
grandfather common fo him and to the last zamindar.
The plaintiff claimed to establish his right as a member of an undivided family holding joint property
against the widow who alleged that her husband had
been the sole proprietor. In proof of this she relied on
certain arrangements as having constituted partition,
viz. that in 1816, two brothers, then heirs, agreed
that the elder should hold possession, and that the
younger should accept a village, appropriated to him for
maintenance in satisfaction of his claim to inherit ;
again, that in 1866, the fourth zamindar compromised
a suit brought against him by his sister for her in.heritance, on payment of a stipend to her, having
already, in the claim of his brother, granted to him
two villages of the estate ; and by the compromise,
this was made conditional on the sister's claim being
settled ; again, that in 1871, the fourth zamindar
having died pending a suit brought against him to
establish the fact of an adoption by him, an arrangement was made for the maintenance of his <laughter,
and two widows, who survived him, the previous grant
for maintenance of his brother holding good, the adop,tion being admitted, and tlie suit compromised.
It
was held that there was nothing in the arrangement
which was inconsistent with the zamindari remaining
part of the common family property and that the
. course of the inheritance had not been altered. The
facts of this case were much stronger than those of the
·present one. The mere circumstance that by an arrange. ment a village out of the z~mindari was given to one
,of the brothers was not inconsistent with the zamindari remaining part of tl1e common family property.
(I) (1897) l.L.R. 20 Mad. 256 (P.C.).
.
-.•
....
.
S.C.R.
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
263
The document executed by the brother in the reported
·case was in these terms :-
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
"I or my heirs shall not at any time make any
Veeralakshmi
claims against you or your heirs in respect of property
v.
movable or immovable, or in respect of any transac- Kulaukara
tion. As our father put you in possession of the Belgam Pandiya Naicker
zamindari,
I or my heirs shall not make any claim and Another.
against you or your heirs in respect of the said
Mahajan/.
zamindari."
-
....
-
It was observed by their Lordships that they did
not find any sufficient evidence in the arrangement
made by these documents of an intention to take the
. estate out of the category of joint or common family
property so as to make it decendible otherwise than
according to the rules of ·law applicable to such property, that the arrangement was quite consistent with
the continuance of that legal character of the property,
that the elder brother was to enjoy the possession of
the family estate, and the younger brother accepted
the appropriated village for maintenance in satisfaction
of such rights as he conceived he was entitled to and
that it was nothing more in substance than an arrange"
ment for the mode of enjoyment of the family property which did not alter the course of descent.
The evidence in the present case is trival and inconclusive and from the documents above mentioned
no intention can be deduced on the part of the junior
members or on the part of any other member of the
family · of disrupting and dividing the family and
renouncing their expectancy of succession. On the
other hand, the statements made in 1889 and 1890 by
·the members of the family clearly indicate that none
of them had any intention of giving up his rights of
heirship to the zamindari. There was no change of this
frame of mind at any later stage of the family arrangement. Sundara Pandiya on the 9th January, 1889,
clearly stated that the wish of the family was that
the widow. should be in charge of the estate and after
her the next heir should succeed and that it was
Kandasami. Kanda~ami said that he was the next
264
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19521
1951
heir, , the family being undivided. In the compromise
tlli$ statement was reiterated. Their intention was to
Chinnathayi
preserve
their rights to t2ke the zamindari if the line
alias
of Kandasami became extinct.
Ve"1'alakshmi
v.
Mr. Pathak then put his case from a different point
Kulasekara
of
view. He urged that Kandasmi had the power to
Pandiya Naicker
alienate. the zamindari or any part of it and by an
and Another.
act of alienation he could defeat the right of survivorMahajan /.
ship vesting in the other members to claim ~he
zamindari on failure of his line. Similarly he said he
could divide the impartible estate amongst the different members of the family and tl1at is what he must
be presumed to have done in the present case. The
argument, though plausible, is fallacious.
The right
to bring about a partition of an impartible estate cannot be inferred from the power of alienation that the
holder thereof may possess. In the case of an impartible estate the power to divide it amongst the members does not exist, though the power in the holder to
alienate it is there and from the existence of one
power the ·other cannot be deduced, as it is destructive
of the very nature and character of the estate and
makes it partible property capable of partition.
It seems to us that Kandasami instead of intending
to separate from tl1e family wa.1 by !us action consolidating the family unity. By the family arrangement
he no doubt successfully got himself declared as the
next person entitled to hold the joint family zamindari, but he evinced no imention of converting it into
his own separate property. He preserved the estate
for the family by saving it from the attack of the
widow who wanted to takie' it under the will of her
husband and antagonistically to the family.
By tile
suit which he brought and which was eventually compromised he successfully avoided that attack on the·
family estate at the sacrifice of his right of enjoying
it during the lifetime of the widow. He also by this
arrangement safeguarded himself against the attack of
Sundara Pandiya on his title as an heir. By his act
tl1e rule of descent of lineal primogeniture prevailing
in the family with regard to tl1e zamindari was firmly
-
.
....
...
..
••
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
265
1951
established. It would be unjust and uncharitable to
conclude from the circumstances that the actions of Chinnathayi
Kandasami in 1890 were in any way hostile to the
alias
interests of the family. As he was throughout acting Veeralakshmi
v.
for the benefit of the family his actions were approved
by all the members and they got a provision made for Kitlasekara
Naicker
themselves for their maintenance in the arrangement. Pandiya
·and Another.
In the suit that he filed against Kamuluammal he
in 'unambiguous terms alleged thkt he was clahning the Mahajan /.
zamindari as a member of the undivided Hindu family
and it was in that status that he made the compromise with her and agreed to obtain possession of the
estate after her death.
After Kandasami's death when the zamindari came
by descent to Kamaraja II, he also followed in the
footsteps of his ancestor. During the period of his
stewardship of the estate he tried to implement it by
recovering the pannai lands which under the compromise had gone out of the estate to Kamulu absolutely.
. He was successful in his efforts though as a result of
the decision in the present case his labours in this
direction have proved futile as the release deed has
been held to be vitiated by fraud .
For tbe reasons given above we hold that there
exist no satisfactorv grounds for holding that the
arrangement made in 1890 evidences a partition
amongst the members of the joint family or proves
an intention on the part of the junior members of the
family to renounce their expectanc.y of succession by
survivorship on failure of male lineal descendants in
the second branch of the family. The question whether
there was separation among the mambers of the family
is primarily a question of fact and the courts below
having held that it is not proved, there are no valid
grounds for disturbing that finding. Chinnathayi's
claim therefore to the zam1ndari must be held to have
been rightly disallowed.
As. regards . the claim of Kulasekara to the zamindari, it has been disallowed in the two courts below on
the ground that the deed of release. Exhibit P-17,
2(i6
1951
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1952]
does not extinguish the right of survivorship of the
third branch to take the estate on the second branch
Chinnath•yi.
becoming
extinct and that the document could not be
alias
Vecral•kshmi.
read as evidencing an intention on the part of Sundara
....
Pandiaya to surrender the right of succession of his
Kulasek_ara
branch. It has been further held that the release was
Pandiya Naick_er
not
executed in favour of the head of the family or in
and Another.
favour of all the members of the family in order to be
operati,ve as a valid relinquishment. There can be
Mahojan /•
no doubt that a member of a joint family owning an
impartible estate can on behalf of himself and his
heirs renounce his right of succession ; but any such
relinquishment must operate for the benefit of all the
members and the surrender must be in favour of all
the branches of the family, or in favour of the head
of the family as representing all its members. Herc
the deed was executed· in favour of the widow of a
deceased coparcener who as such was a stranger to
the coparcenary, the family being admittedly joint at
the death of Kamaraja I.
It was contended that in
view of the attitude taken by the parties before the
High Court that the deed of release and the compromise evidenced only one arrangement to which all the
members were in reality parties it should be held that
the surrender of his rights by Sundara Pandiya was
made in favour of Kandasami, the head of the family,
and it extinguished the rights of the third branch in
the family zamindari.
We think, however, that
Kandasami in dealing with Sundara Pandiya was
safeguarding his own right of succession against the
attack personally directed against him and was successful in buying him off by agreeing to hand over to
him a village. Both of them were claiming headship
of the family on different grounds and both were asserting that the zamindari belonged to the joint
family. In the compromise Kandasami was acting
for hi; own benefit and was not making any bargain
with Sundara Pandiya on behalf of the family. The
family as such could not have been prejudiced in any
way by the circumstance that succession went to one
or the other. Be that as it may, we think the decision
.
.
·-·
-
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
267
1951
of this case can be made to rest on a more solid foundation than furnished by the considerations set out
above.
-· .
Cllinnathayi
alias
Veeralak_shmi
.;. /
>,
..
The whole
emphasis of Mr. Raghavan who
l'.
represented Kulasekara was on the words of the Kulast!lcara
out
above. Pandiya Naidr,,er
deed
contained in
clause 5 set
Sundara Pandiya by this clause
stipulated that and Another.
he will have no right to the property shown as belongMaliaian J.
ing to the widow. Sundara Pandiya was then agreeing
that the widow should retain the zamindari absolutely,
his mind being affected by the will. Later on by the
compromise made in Kandasmai 's suit what had been
given absolutely to the widow was .converted into a
life estate with the exception of the pannai lands and
Kandasami was acklnowledged as the rightful heir.
The recitals in the release deed therefore have to be
read in the light of the terms and conditions of the
deed of compromise and the proper inference from
these is that Sundara Pandiya relinquished his rights
to succeed to the zamindari immediately as the seniormost member of the family but that he did not renounce his contingent right of succeeding to it by
surviorship if and when the occasion arose. It is
well settled that general words of a release do not mean
release of rights other than those then put up and
have to be limited to the circumstances which were in
the contemplation of the parties when it was executed :
vide Directors etc. of L & S. W. Ry. Co. v. Richard
Doddridge Blackmore(1). In that case it was said that
general words in a release are limited to those things
which were specially in the contemplation of the
parties when the release was executed. This rule is
good law in India as in England. The same rule has
been stated in Norton on Deeds at page 206
(2nd Ed.) thus:"The general words of a release are limited always
to that thing or those things which were specially in
the contemplation of the parties at the time when the
release was given, though they were not mentioned in
'
the recitals."
1
(1) L.R. 4 H.L, 610.
I
268
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeralakshmi
v.
Kulasekara
f'andiya N aicker
and Another.
MahaiaTJ /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19521
In Hailsham's Edition of Halsbury's Laws of
England, Vol. 7, at para 345 the rule has been stated
in these terms :"General words of release will be construed witb
reference to the surrounding circumstances and as
being controlled by recitals and context so as to give
effect to the object and purpose of the document. A
release will not be construed as applying to facts of
which the credito;- had no knowledge at the time
when it was given."
In Chowdhry Chintaman Singh v. Mst. Nowlukho
Kunwari('), where the document was drafted in
almost the same terms as Exhibit P-17, it was .said
that though the words of the petition of compromise
were capable of being read as if the executants were
giving up all rights whatever in the taluka of Gungore,
yet in the opinion of their Lordships the transaction
amounted to no more tban an agreement to waive tbe
claim to a share in and to the consequent right to a
partition of the taluka and there was no intention to
change the character of the estate or the mode in
which it was to descend. The parties in the year
1890 were not thinking of their future rights of
survivorship at all. What Sundara Pandiya must be
taken to have said by this release was "I am giving
up . my present rights as a senior member in favour of
Kandasami whom I recognize as the rightful heir to
the zamindari as a member of the joint Hindu
family." Kandasami agreed to give him the village
of Dombacheri in lieu of recognition of his title by him.
It was not within the ken of tbe parties then as to
what was to happen to the zamindari in case
Kandasami's line died out.
For the reasons given we are of the opm10n that by
the release Sundara Pandiya did not renounce his
rights or the rights of his branch to succeed to the
zamindari by survivorship in case the line of Kandasami became extinct.
We hold therefore tbat
(I) (1874) 2I.A. 263.
·-'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
269
Kulasekara's claim was rightly negatived in the courts
below arrd that of Rajaya was rightly decreed.
In the result all these appeals fail and are dismissed
with costs.
Appeals dismissed.
1951
Chinnathayi
alias
Veeralakshmi
v.
Kulasekara
Pandiya Naicker
Agent for the appellant in Ci.vii Appeals Nos. 28 & and Another.
29 of 1949, respondent No. 1 in Civil Appeals Nos.
30, 32 & 33 of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil Appeal No. 31 of 1949 and for Respondent No. 3 in
Civil Appeal No. 31 of 1949 : M. S. K. Sastri.
Agent for the appellant in Civil Appeals Nos. 31 to
33 of 1949, respondent No. 1 in Civil Appeals Nos.
28, 29 of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil Appeal
No. 30 of 1949 : M. S. K. Aiyangar.
Agent for the appellant in Civil Appeals Nos. 30, 89,
and 90 of 1949, respondent No. 1 in Civil Appeal No.
31 of 1949 and respondent No. 2 in Civil Appeals
Nos. 28, 29, 32 & 33 of 1949: S. Subrahmanyam.
Agent for the respondents Nos. 1 and 2 in Civil Appeals Nos. 89 and 90 of 1949: V. P. K. Natr!biyar.
RAM KUMAR DAS
1951
ti,
Nov. 26
JAGADISH CHANDRA DEB DHABAL DEB
AND ANOTHER.
[PATANJALI SAsTRI C. J., MuKHERJEA, DAs
and VMAN BosE JJ.]
Transfer of Property Act (IV of 1882), ss. 106, 107-Duration of
lease-Presumption-Kabuliyat for 10 years-Payment of annual
rent for two years only-Kabuliyat inoperative-Nature of possession after the two years-Whether adverse, as tenant from year to
year, or as monthly tenant-Applicability of s. 106 to implied tcnan·
cies-Prcsumption from payment of annual rent.
The rule of construction embodied in s. 106 of the Transfer
of Property Act applies not only to express leases of uncertain
duration but also to leases implied by law which may be inferred
from possession and acceptance of rent and other circumstances,
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org