THAKUR RUDRESWARI PRASAD SINHA versus SRIMATI RANI PROBHABHATI AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 26 October 1951 | [1952] 1 S.C.R. 64 | 1951 INSC 50
Key facts
- Decided
- 26 October 1951
- Bench
- M. PATANJALI SASTRI*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, VIVIAN BOSE
- Bench size
- 4
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 75/1950
- Disposal
- Dismissed
- Citation
- [1952] 1 S.C.R. 64
- Neutral citation
- 1951 INSC 50
Text of the judgment
64
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1951
is not being invoked here as in that case, to clothe a
person with title which he cannot acquire except by
Collector of
the pursuit of or in conformity with certain legal forms.
Bombay
Here, as pointed out already, the Corporation became
v.
Municipal Corthe full and absolute owner of the site on the lapse of
poration of the 60 years from the date of the grant.
City of Bombay
Appeal dismissed.
and Others.
Agent for the appellant: P. A. Mehta.
Agent for the respondent : R. A. Govind.
1951
Oct. 26.
THAKUR RUDRESWARI PRASAD SINHA
v.
SRIMATI RANI PROBHABHATI AND OTHERS
[PATANJALI SASTRI, MuKHERJEA, S. R. DAs and
VIVIAN BosE JJ. J
Ghatwali tenures-Nature and incidents-Alienability of Ze1nindari Ghatwalis-Taluka Kakwara whether alienable.
Taluk Kakwara was in its origin a Zemindari Ghatwali tenure
and continued to be so, and was in fact treated as such ever
since. Even if by virtue of Captain Browne's Sanad it became
a Government Ghatwali tenure, then under the Sanad of Raja
Kadir Ali or after the Permanent Settlement at any rate, it became a Zemindari Ghatwali and as ·such alienable with the
consent of the Zamindar according to the custom of Kharakpur
judicially recognised.
[Nature and incidents of Ghatwali tenures discussed] .
. CIVIL
APPELLATE
JURISDICTION :
Civil Appeal
No. 75 of 1950.
Appeal from Judgment of the High Court of
Judicature at Patna dated 22nd November, 1944, in
Appeal No. 238 of 1940 arising out of order dated
13th July, 1940, of the Subordinate Judge of Bhagalpur
in Mis. Case No. 174 of 1939. The facts of the case
appear from the judgment. The appeal was originally
preferred to the Privy Council and was subsequently
tranferred and heard by the Supreme Court.
N. C. Chatteriee (B. Sen, with him), for the
appellant.
B.
C. De (Ragunath ]ha, with him) for the
respondents.
S.C.R.
.,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
65
1951. October 26. The Judgement of the Court was
delivered by
DAs. J.-This appeal has come up for hearing before
us on transfer from the Privy Council. The appellant
is the present holder of Taluk Kakwara- which appertains to Mahalat Kharakpur. The respondents represent
the Banaili Raj which has ·also acquired the Mahalat
of Kharakpur. The respondents obtained a decree for
Rs. 11;587-14-6 against the appeallanti for arrears of
rent and cess and applied for execution of their. decree
by the attachment and sale of Taluk . Kakwara. On
August 29, 1939, the appellant judgementi-Oeb~or filed
an objection under section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure alleging that· as Taluk Kakwara was held on
Gh<ltwali tenure it could not be sold in execution of a
money decree. - This objection was rather too wide,
for all lands held on Ghatwali tenure were not necessarily inalienable. Indeed, in Kali Pershad Singh v.
Anund Roy(1) which related to the Ghatwaii Mahal of
Khara~a within the Mahalat of Kharakpur the evidence
clearly established a number of instances in which
there had been unquestioned transfers and sales applicable to Mahals in Kharakpur and it' was held by
the Privy Council that the true view to take was that
such a tenure in Kharakpur was not inallienable, and
might be transferred by the Ghatwal or sold inexecution of a decree ·against him, if such tranfer_ or sale
was assented to by the Zamindar. A sale at the instance of the Zamindar in execution of a decree for
arrears of rent necessarily implies the existence of such
assent. In the later case of Narayan Singh \'. Niranjan
Chakravarati( 2 ) which related to the Ghatwali Mahal of
Handwa, Lord Sumner recognised that the decision of
the Privy Council in the Kharna Ghatwali Mahal case
was fully supported by the evidence adduced in that
case and that that authority had been repeatedly
followed and applied in India, and, so far as the reports
showed, without proof of the wstom being required
over again. Lord Sumner, however, pointed out that
(1) (1887) L.R. 15 I.A. 18; I.L.R. 15 Cal. 471.
(2) (1923) L.R. 51 I.A. 37; I.L.R. 3 Pat. 184; A.I.R. (1924)
P.C. 5.
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and ,others.
Das/.
66
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
it was plain that as the custom depended on proof,
and as the tenure in question was one in the Zamindari
of Kharakpur and under its Zamindar, it could have
no reference to Ghatwali tenures not under him nor
forming part of his 'Zamindari. The Privy Council in
the later case referred to above saw no ground for
thinking that the custom of Kharakpur had any
application to Ghatwali tenures, which, like Handwa,
were independent of ·the Kharakpur Zamindari, even
though they might be not far off Kharakpur. In short,
it may be said to be well established-and the contrary
has not been urged before us-that Ghatwali tenures
held under the Zamidar of Kharakpur were, by custom
judically recognised, alienable with the assent of the
Zamindar while Ghatwali tenures like Handwa held
under the Goverment direct were inalienable. In this
state of the authorities, the appellant judgment-debtor
on May 31, 1940. filed a fresh petition of objection
under section 47 of the Code claiming that Taluk
Kakwara was held under a Government Ghatwali
tenure. The principal question for determination in
,those execution proceedings was whether Taluk
Kakwara was a Government Ghatwali, as alleged by
the appellant judgment-debtor, or was a Zamindari
Ghatwali held under themselves, as claimed by the
Respondents decree-holders.
The learned Subordinate Judge held that Taluk
Kakwara was a Zamindari Ghatwali under the Raja
of Kharakpur and overruled the objection of the
judgment-debtor. The judgment-debtor appealed to
the High Court. The appeal came up for hearing in
the first instance before a Bench consisting of Manohar
Lal and Shearer JJ. Manohar Lal J. came to the conclusion that Taluk Kakwara was a Government Ghatwali and was inclined to aliow the appeal. Shearer J.
took the view that while Taluk Kakwara was at one
time a Government Ghatwali, it ceased to be so and
became and remained a Zamindari Ghatwali and as
such was alienable and was inclined to dismiss the
appeal. In view ·of this difference of opinion the
appeal was referred to Chatt~rjee J. as the third Judge
,
.S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
..
67
Chatterjee J. held that Taluk Kakwara was a Zamindari Ghatwali and as such~ alienable and accordingly
dismissed the appeal. The judgment-debtor obt'!ined
leave to appeal to the Privy Council. As already
stated, the appeal has come up for hearing before us
on transfer from the Privy Council.
Although the exact origin of the .Ghatwali tenures
was generally lost in ithe confusion and obscurity of
the troublous times which preceded the British rule,
the nature of the Ghatwali tenures and their purposes
and incidents have been fully established by a series
·of. decided cases. The position of the Zamindars in or
about 1765, when the East India Company secured the
Dewani of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa, has been des'cribed by the Right Hon'ble T. Pemberton Leigh (who
subsequently became Lord Kingsdown) in his judgment
in the case of Raja Leelanund Singh v. Government of
Bengal(1) :
Many of the greater Zamindars within their res'pective Zamindaries, were entrusted with rights, - and
charged with duties, which properly belonged to the
Government. They had authority to collect from the
Ryots a certain portion of the gross prOduce of the
lands. They, in many cases, imposed taxes and levied
tolls, and they increased their income by fees, · per~
quisites, and similar exactions, not wholly unknown to
more recent times and more civilised nations. On the
. other hand, they were bound · to maintain peace and
order, and administer justice within their Zamindaries,
and, for that purpose, they had to keep up Courts of
civil and criminal justice, to employ Kazees, Canoongoes, and Thanahdars, or a police for~e. But while,
as against the Ryots and other inhabitants within
their territories, many of these potentates· exercised
almost regal authority, they were, . as against the
· Government, little more than stewards or administrators. Their Zamindaries were granted to them only from
year to year; the amount of their jumma, or yearly payment to Government, was· varied,· or might be varied annually; it was an arbitrary sum fixed by the Government
'(l) (1855) .6 M.I.A. 101 at p. 108 .
•
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v• .
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das].
68
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
officers- calculated upon the gross produce of the
Zamindary from all sources, after making an allowance
to the Zamindar for his maintenance, and for the
expenses of the collection and of discharging the public
duties with which he was entrusted by the Government."
Further down his Lordship observed :"Besides the disorder which prevailed generally
through the
Provinces, particular
Districts were
exposed to ravages of a different discription. The
mountain or hill districts in India were at this time
inhabited by lawless tribes, asserting a wild independence, often of a different race and different religion from
the inhabitants of the plains, who were frequently
subjected to marauding expeditions by their more
warlike neighbours. To prevent these incursions it was
necessary to guard and watch the Ghats, or mountain
passes, through which these hostile descents were made;
and the Mahomedan rulers established a tenure called
Ghatwali tenure, by which lands were granted to individuals, often of high rank, at a low rent, or without
rent, on condition of their performing these duties, and
protecting and preserving order in the neighbouring
Districts."
This description of the nature and incidents of a
Ghatwali tenure was adopted by the High Court
(Garth C. J. and McDonell J.) in Leelanund Singh v.
Thakoor Munranjan Singh(') ,which was a case between
the respective predecessors of the parties before us and
related to this1 very Taluk Kakwara. Said the learned
Chief Justice at p. 255 :"And it is very necessary for our present purpose
to bear in mind what was the true origin and nature of
these tenures. They were created by the Mahomedan
Government in early times, as a means of providing a
police and military force to watch and guard the
mountain passes from the invasions of the lawless
tribes who inhabited the hill districts. Large grants
of land were made in thos~ days by the Government,
(1) (1877) I.L.R. 3 Cal. 251.
i..
r
,
,
S.C.R.
Sl,JPREME COURT REPORTS
69
1951
often to persons of high rank, at a. low rent, or at no
rent at all, upon condition that they should provide
Thakur
and maintain a sufficient military force, to protect the
Rudreshwari
inhabitants of the plains from these lawless incursions;
Prasad Sinha
_and the grantees on their part sub-divided and re-grantv.
ed the lands to other tenants (much in the same way Srimati Rani ·
as military tenures were created in England in the Probhabliati
and others.
feudal age), each of whom, besides paying generally a
small rent, held their lands in consideration of these
Das;.
military services, and provided (each according to the
extent of his holding) a specified number of arrped men
to fulfil th~ requirements .of the Government".
As has been said by Lord Kingsdown in Raja Lelanund
Singh v. The Government of Bengal (supra) at p. 125
"though the nature and extent of the right of the Ghatwals in the Ghatwali villages may be doubtful, and
probably differed in different districts and iii different
families, there clearly was some ancient law or usage
by which these lands were appropriated to . reward· the
services of. Ghatwals; services which, although they
would include the performance of duties of police, were
quite as; much in their origin of a military as a civil
character, and would require _the appointment of a very
different class of persons from ordinary police officers".
Accordingly · his Lordship found that the office of
Ghatwal in the Kharakpur Zamindari was frequently
held by persons of high rank. In Munrunjan Singh v.
Raja Lelanund (1) which was also a case between the
respective predeces1sors of the parties before us and
related to this very Taluk Kakwara, the High Court at
P: 86 observed :"It appears that there . is considerable variety m
the tenures known under the general name of Ghatwali
in different parts of the country. They all agree in
this that they are. grants of land situated on the edge
of the hiJly country, and held on condition of guarding
the ghats or passes. Generally, there seems to be a
small quit-rent payable, to the Zamindar in addition
to the service rendered, and with the view of marking
(I) (1865) 3 W.R. 84.
70
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimaii Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das f.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
the subordination of the tenure. But in some Zamindaries and putnees these tenures are of a major, in
others of a minor, character. Sometimes the tenure of
the great Zamindar himself seems to have been originally of this character. More frequently large tenures,
consisting of several whole villages, are held under the
Zamindar."
Further down their Lordships said :"These inferior Ghatwalis seem to be those in
which the Zamindar or ruling power deals direct with
the individuals who do the work, assigning them pieces
of land in the established villages. The larger tenures
were more of the nature of semi-military colonies,
where a chief with his followers were settled down in
parts of the country so unsafe that it could not be
otherwise occupied."
The law relating to Ghatwali tenures has been dealt
with at considerable length by Lord Sumner in
Narayan Singh v. Niranjan Chakravarti (supra). The
variety of conditions of service to be rendered by a
Ghatwal was thus summed up by his Lordship at
pp. 50-51 :"In itself 'ghatwal' is a term meamng an office
held by a particular person from time to time, who is
bound to the performance of its. duties, with a consideration to be enjoyed in return by the incumbent of
the office. Within this meaning the utmost variety of
conditions may exist. There may be a mere personal contract of employment for wages, which take the form of
the Use of land or an actual estate in land, heritable and
perpetual, but conditional upon services certain or ·services to be demanded. The office may be public or private, important or the reverse. The Ghatwal, the guard
of the pass may be the bulwark of a whole countryside
against invaders; he may be merely a sentry against
petty marauders; he may be no more than a kind of
game-keeper, protecting the crops from the ravages of
wild animals. Ghatwali duties may be divided into
police duties and quasi-military duties, though both
classes have lost much of their importance, and the
-
>-
S.C.R.
t
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
71
1951
latter in any strict from are but rarely rendered. Again,
the duties of the office may be such as demand perThakur
sonal discharge by the Ghatwal and personal competRudreshwari
ence for that discharge; they may, on the other hand, . Prasad Sinha
v.
be such as can be discharged vicariously, by the creaSrimati Rani
tion of shikmi tenures and by the appointment and
Probhabhati
maintenance of a subordinate force, or they may1 be
and others.
such as in their nature only require to be provided for
in bulk. . It is plain that where a grant is forthcoming
Das/.
'to a man and his heirs as Ghatwal, or is to be presmped to have been made though it may have since
been lost, personal performance of the ,ghatwali services
is not essential so long as the grantee is .responsible for
them and procures them to be rq1dered: Shih Lal
Singh v. Moorad Khan, (1868) 9 Suth. W.R. 126."
Then his Lordship pointed out that the superior
who appointed the Ghatwal might be the ruling power
over the country at large, the landholder responsible by
custom for the maintenance· of · security and order
within his estates, or simply the private person, to
whom the maintenance of watchmen was, in the case
of an extensive property, important enough to require
the creation of a regular. office. Although personal
. service by the employee and personal selection and
appointment by the employer might have been ordinarily essential incidents of the relationship, yet it was
not invariably so as appears from the last quotation as
well as from the following passage in the judgment by
Lord Sumner at p. 52 :-
)
· "On the other hand, there· are great estates, whose
proprietors are found holding them or parts of them
upon the terms of providing that ghatwali services
shall be forthcoming, either regularly or when required;
services, it _is impossible for the proprietor himself to
render in his own person, and which become possible
to him and to those to whom he renders them simply
by virtue of his possession of the lands thus granted.
In such cases the ghatwali .tenure, even if not" originally
granted as heritable, easily becomes so, and is commonly found on the death of an incumbent of the
72
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Ran£
Probhabhati
and others.
Das f.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
office to descend to some member of his family, if not
necessarily to the senior member. Thus in Kharakpur
ghatwals have a perpetual hereditary tenure at a fixed
jama: Munrunjun Singh v. Lelanund Singh."
The requirement of rendering of services by a Ghatwal naturally gave ris,e to a further incident of such a
tenure, namely, the inalienability of the Ghatwali
lands, for an alienation of the Ghatwali lands might
easily deprive the Ghatwal of the whole of the means
provided to enable the services to be rendered. This
consideration peculiarly applied where the superior,
by whom the Ghatwals were appointed and of whom
the Ghatwali lands were held was the ruling power
itself. As has already been stated above, the rigour
of this incident of inalienability had, however, in the
case of Kharakpur Zamindari Ghatwalis, given way tocustom recognised as well established in the case of
Kali Pershad v. Anund Roy (supra), which has been
repeatedly followed and applied in India without proof
of the custom being requited over again.
·
From what has been stated above, it cle~rly follows
that Ghatwali tenures originated during the Moghul
period, that although the services included , police
duties, they were in their origin just as much of a·
military as a civil character and that the tenure could
be granted by the ruling power directly to the Ghatwal
who was to render the services so as to establish a
direct privity between the ruling power and the Ghatwal
or it could be granted by the Zamindar for the protection of his Zamindari or for enabling him to render
the police and military services to the ruling power
which he was bound to do under the terms of the
grant of Zamindari to him." The question then arises'
-which of these categories the Ghatwals of Kharakpur
come under.
Mahalat Kharakpur was an extensive estate and
apparently owed allegiance, real or nominal, to the
Moghul Emperor. There is no evidence on record'
showing on what terms the Raja of Kharakpur held'
the estate under the Moghuls and it is difficult to say,
. '
•
•
-.'
~
r
S.C.R.
)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
73
1951
with any amount of certainty, what kind or amount
of services, police or military, he had to render to the ·
Thakur
then ruling power. . It may, however, be safely stated · Rudreshwari
that, like all other Zamintlars; the Raja of Kharakpur Prasad· Sinha
had to preserve internal peace and order by maintain-.
v.
Srimati Rani
ing sufficient Thanas or police establishments and to
protect the tenants and other inhabitants from the Probhabhati
and others. '
incursions of lawless tribes from the neighbouring hills
by providing or arranging for a sufficient military
Das J.
force. It could not be expected that a big Zamindar
like the Raja of Kharakpur would render the police or
military ~ervices personally and consequently it was
natw;-al for him to appoint P.is own Ghatwals to protect
his Zamindari and to render services for him to the
ruling power. . As said by Lord Kingsdown in Raja
Lelanund Singh v. TM Government of Bengal (supra)
at p. 102 it was well established that long before 1765
the Zamindars of Kharakpur had created Ghatwali
tenures for the purpose of protecting their Zamindaries
· from the attacks of mountaineers and other turbulent
people in their- neighbourhood. Lord Sumner in Narayan
Singh v. Niranjan Chakravarti. - (supra) at p. 68 also
recognised that long before 1765 Ghatwali tenure_s under
the Zamindar of Kharakpur had been created by the
vai:ious holders of those lands for their ow:n purposes
and· as late as 1770-1785 Mr. Cleveland, who managed
the estate during the minority of Kadir Ali, followed
the same· policy. In Narayan Singf! v. Niranjan
Chakravarti (supra) at p. 50 Lord Sumner said :"In the Sonthal Parganas there are for practical
purposes three classes of Ghatwali tenures: (a) Government ghatwalis created by the ruling power; {b)
Government ghatwalis, which since their creation and
generallY. at the time of the Permanent Settlement
have been included in a zamindari estate and formed
into a unit.in the assessment; and (c). zamindari ghatwalis, created by the zamindar ol his predecessors and
alienable with his consent. The s,econd of these classes
is really a branch of the first."
The question, then, is-to which class the Ghatwali
tenure of Taluk Kakwara, with which we are concerned ·
74
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
.Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
.and others.
Das].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
in this case, belongs-whether it was a Government
Ghatwali or was one of the many Ghatwali tenures
created by the Zamindars of Kharakpur.
Happily, we do not have to speculate. The problem
before us is not to infer the true nature and incidents
of the original grant which could only be collected
from the evidence of what was done and left undone in
connection with Taluk Kakwara by the ruling power
and its officers. We have in evidence before us the
authentic texts of the two Sanads relating to the
Kakwara Ghatwali and we also have the provisions of
the Permanent Settlement Regulation. The nature and
incidents of that tenure must rest upon the true construction and import of those grants as well as on the
manner in which it was dealt with at the time of the
Permanent Settlement.
It will be convenient and useful, at this stage, to
give a very short history of, Mahalat Kharkpur and
Taluk Kakwara. In 1765 the East India Company
secured the Dewani of Bengal, Bihar;. and Orissa from
the Moghul Emperor. The accession of Dewani was in
effect a cession of the three provinces and the East
India Company virtually became the sovereign ruling
power over those territories. At that time one Mozaffar
Ali was the Raja of Mahalat Kharakpur. Taluk Kakwara appertained to Mahalat Kharakpur. In 1766
Raja Mozaffar Ali rose in rebellion against the East
India Company. A strong military force under the
command of Captain Browne was sent for quelling the
revolt. Eventually, in 1768 Raja Mozaffar Ali was
subdued and imprisoned. The Raja was deposed and
deprived of his estate and the East India Company
took direct charge of Mahalat Kharakpur and managed
it through its officers until the Mahalat was restored
to Raja Kadir Ali, the grandson of Raja Mozaffar Ali.
In 1776 Captain Browne, who was then in charge of
the Mahalat, granted an Amalnama or Sanad (Exhibit 1) in respect of 22 villages to two persons Rankoo
Singh and Bhairo Singh at a fixed annual Jama of
Rs. 245-12-15. That Sanad was in the following terms:
..
-·
:
l
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
75
"Seal of Captain James Browne, head of jungletari (low forest land). Know ye, the present and future
Mutasaddis of affairs, Chaudhuris, Kanungos, Zamin.'."
dars and Ghatwals of Pargana Danda Sukhwara, Zila
Jangal-tari,
appertaining
to
Kharagpur, Sarkar
Monghyr, in the Province of Bihar.
From the beginning of 1184 Fasli, Taluka Kakwara, pargana aforesaid, is let out in perpetual mukarrari, without any objection or contention, to Rankoo
Singh and Bhairo Singh, ghatwals of the said Taluka,
at a fixed jama of - Rs. 245-12-15 (rupees two hundred
and forty-five, annas twelve and gandas fifteen) in
current coins noted in the endorsement, consolidated
from all sources, including malwajhat, sair-wajhat and
all grains, and excluding the perquisites of the zamindari, nankar, chaudhuris and kanungos, parganati
expenses, lands given in charity, e.g., barhmotar,
shibotar and bishunparit lands, aima lands of jagirdars,
bargandazes (musketeers), dhupars (?.), mahus (?) etc.
It is requisite that they shouli:i peacefully cultivate
(torn) and pay the Government (torn), according to
the kabuliat, year after year and crop after crop, into
the Government treasury. They should make such
~ effort . as to increase the cultivation of the. said Taluka
from day . to day. They should hold themselves responsible for deficient cultivation. They should keep
the tenants pleased and contented with their good
·treatment and should not oppress any one and make
excessive demands, They should not fix the allowance
of the jagirdars and bargandazes etc., over and above
· the rent. They should bear this in mind. They should
provide for the protection of the tenants within their
jurisdiction and of the villages of the said Taluka.
. Whenever the chakars ( ?) be sent for by the huzur,
the sardar ( ?) should appear before him with his men.
If at any place, within their boundary limits, murder,
disturbance, dacoity, theft, . highway "robbery ·etc., be
committed, and the culprit be· traced or be found conspiring advisedly with any one ;ind the Gcwernment
work suffer, and proper punishment be meted out after
inquiry, they will be responsible ( ?) by virtue of their
1951
T.hakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das/.
76
1951
Thakur
Rudreshtvari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srin1ati Rani
Probhabhoti
and others.
Das/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
position, and will be dismissed from their ·post and
will not be re-instated (unintelligible). The amlas of
the zamindars of 'the said Taluka should on knowing
the said istimrari mukarrari rent to have been fixed,
continue to receive the mukarrari rent from year to
year and should not demand even a farthing in excess.
They should treat this as peremptory and act as
written herein.
Dated the 25th Shanwal,
7th Pu~ Bangla, 1183 Fasli.
17, corresponding to
the
•
Endorsement.
Taluka -Kakwara, pargana Danda Sukhwara, appeartaining to Kharagpur, Zila Jangaltari, Sarkar Monghyr,
in the province of .Bihar, is let out in perpetual mukarrari, without any objection or contention, to Rankoo
Singh and Bhairo Singh, Ghatwals, at a fixed jama of
Rs. 245-12-15 (rupees two hundred and fortyfive, annas
twelve and gandas fifteen) in current coins as specified
below, consolidated from all sources, including malwajhat, sair-wajhat, and all grains, excluding the perquisites of the zamindari, nankar, Chaudhuris and
Kanungos, expenses of the said Taluka, lands given
in charity, (e.g.) barhmotar, s;hibotar and Bishun-parit
lands, jagir lands of jagirdars, bargandazes, dhupars ( ?) ,
malmas( ?), etc.
Fixed jama.
Rs. 245-12-15 gandas."
Then followed the specificatio; of 22 Mouzas or
villages. It will be noticed that the grant was made
to Rankoo Singh and Bhairo Singh described as
"ghatwals of the said Taluk" which suggests that
those two persons were already Ghatwals. The duties
generally imposed on the grantees and in particular
the duty of providing protection for the tenants and
of appearing before Huzur with his men did not, in
the words of Lord Sumner in Narayan Singh v.
Niranjan Chakravarti (supra) at p. 46, "go beyond
duties then ordinarily discharged by Zamindars."
There was no stipulation either in the main body of
..
)>
S.C.R.
'
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
77
the grant or in the endorsement at the foot' for maintaining a regular body of a definite number of archers
and barkandazes such as is to be usually found in
ordinary Ghatwali grants arid indeed such as is in fact
to be found in the subsequent gram of Raja Kadir Ali
with respect · to this ·very Taluk . Kakwara. . Finally,
the admonition at the end of the principal paragraph
to the amlas of the Zamindars of the said Taluk to
receive the {ixed mukarrai rent and not to' demand
even a farthing in ·excess may well be . regarded as
indicating that the Zamindar was rea'Ily interested in
the grant. In the premises, the obsel"Vation of the
learned Judges of the High Court of Calcutta in
Munmnjun Singh v. Raja Lelanund (supra) at page 85
that the Sanad of Captain Browne seemed to them "to
be rather a confirmation of an existing tenure than the
.creation of a ne\v one" appears to have considerable
force. This view of the matter will be quite consistent
with the subsequent history of the Kakwara Ghatwali
which will be presently related.
It is, however, pointed out that at· the ·dat~ of this
Sanad there was in fact no Raja of Karakpur and that
as the Mahalat was being ·administered and managed.
by Captain Browne on behalf of the East India Company tlr'e grant made by him must be taken as 'creating
a Government Ghatwali tenure. The Seal at the ,top
of the Sanad is said to indicate that in granting the
Sanad in his capacity as Sardar of the ,Jungle Terai
Captain Browne was acting for and on behalf of the
East India Company. The Sanad was addressed to the-present. and future Mutasaddisi of affairs, Chaudhuris,
Kanungos, Zamindars and Ghatwals of Pargana Danda
· Sukhwara ·and it is urged that if Captain Browne had
been acting on behalf of the Zamindar of Kharakpur,
addressing the Sanad to the Zamindars would have
been wholly inappropriate. The fact that the grant
was to commence from the beginning of 1184 Fasli
also militates against its being only a confirmation of
· a pre-existing Ghatwali tenure: The direction to pay
according to the Kabuliat, year after year, crop after
~ crop, into the Government treasury clearly suggests
j
1951
Thakur .
Rudres'hwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Pfobhabhati
and others.
Das/.
78
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani"
Probhabhati
and others.
Das/.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
that the Sanad created a Government Ghatwali tenure.
In the Moghul period there was no fixity of the
jama and the grants were made annually and the
jamas were liable to be varied. The provision of- a
fixed annual jama in this Sanad cannot,· therefore,
it is argued, be regarded as a confirmation of an existing grant on a fixed jama. Taking all these matters
into consideration Shearer and Chatterjee JJ. came.
to the conclusion that under Captain Browne's Sanad
of 1777 Taluk Kakwara became a Government Ghatwali. This line of reasoning is not without force or
cogency although it may not necessarily be conclusive,
for Captain Browne undoubtedly acting for the East
India ·Company, might well have issued the Sanad
during the period of interregnum on behalf or in the
interest of whoever might eventually become the
Zamindar of' Kakwara. If the matter rested only with
this Sanad and nothing further had happened then
perhaps it might have been said with some plausibility
that a new tenure was created by the ruling power by
this Sanad, but the matter does not in fact rest with
only Captain Browne's Sanad, and we have to see how
this Taluk Kakawara has been subsequently dealt with
and· what effect the subsequent events have on the
statns and rights of the Ghatwal of this Taluk.
It appears that in 1780 the East India Company
restored Mahalat Kharakpur to Kadir Ali, the grandson of the deposed Raja Mozaffar Ali. Although the
formal order of the Governor-General came in 178!,
the Mahalat was actually restored to Raja Kadir Ali
in 1780. At that time Raja Kadir Ali was only a boy
of five or six yearn of age and Mr. Cleveland, the
Collector of Bhagalpur, managed Mahalat Kharakpur
for and on behalf of the minor Raja Kadir Ali. On
January 17, 1780, a fresh Sanad (Exhibit 1 (a)) was
granted in the name and under the Seal of Raja Kadir
Ali to the same two persons, Rankoo Singh and Bhairo
Singh, in the following terms :"(Seal of Raja Qadir Ali, under
Alam, the Victorious-1193).
Emperor
Shah
1
SUPREMt COURT• REPORT~
79
Know ye, the present and ·future mutasaddis of
affaii:s and the gumashtas holding the ·posts of Chaudhuris and Kanungoes of · Pargana Danda Sukhwara:
appertaining to mahals Kharagpur, Sarkar · Monghyr,
in the Province of Bihar.
1951
T!tak_ur
Rudres!twari
Prasad Sinha
v;
Srimaii ·Rani
• ProbAabhati
The Ghatwali service tenure of Taluka Kakwar
'19d others.
appertaining to the said pargana. is held, under a
DM f.
Sanad; by Bhairo Singh and Rankoo Singh, with 172
iµuskeieers ang archers including ·sardars, on the condition of allegiance. and loyalty to the. Sarkar. Of late
also, (the said tenure) being upheld and kept intact as
usual, according _ to the endorsement, is assigned and
granted with effect from the .f:ieginning of the Kharif
season of 1189 Fasli Rajwara corresponding to 1188
Fasli Muglilana. They should discharge the duties
and obligations with honesty and fidelity ana· keep the
tenants pleased and ,contented with their gooo. ,treat~
. ment, and should. watch the ghats and chaukis very
carefully and cautiously, so that no thief and· night
• robber may come around and about them. 1£, God
forbid, the properties of any one be stolen or plundered
and cattle be concealed or murder be commited, they
should trace · the thieves and night robbers with the
properties intact, restore the properties to the owne.i;
·and produce the party of the mischief mongers before
the- Huzur and prove the murder. -In case they fail to
find out• the thieves and to prc;>ve the murder and the
·concealment (theft) of cattle, · they should hold 'themselves responsible therefor. ·They ~hould continue tQ\
pay the quit-rent to the Sarkar as usual. When summoned, they should appear before the Huzur with the
body of med. It is desired that you should consider
them· as permanent Ghatwals of that place and main:
tain them in their possessions and you should not fail
to give them sound advice so as to ensure by all means
the advantage of the Sarkar and the well-being of the
tenants. Treat this as perempto17 and act accordingly.'·
Dated, th_e 17th seventh (sic)' day · of the holy
month of Muharram- of year 22, corresponding to._J 194 A.H.
.
.
.
6-2 S. C. India/71
'
80
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das/,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19521
Endorsement
The Ghatwali service tenure of taluka Kakwara
Pargana Danda Sukhwara, is granted as before to
Rankoo Singh and Bhairo Singh with 172 Musketeers
and archers including sardars with effect from the
beginning of the karif season of 1189 Fasli, Rajwara,
corresponding to 1189 Fasli Mughlana, on the condition
of allegiance and loyalty to the Sarkar.
Above-named persons (sic)-7
Musketeers arid Archers-J 65
172
'
Fixed perpetual quit rent ...
Rent
Zamindari
Rs. ,a. d.
Jly Bhairo Singh
178- 3- 5 By Rankoo Singh
Rent
...
155-14-15 Rent
Zamindari ...
22- 4-10 Zamindari
Rs. a. d.
245-12-15
215- 0-15
30-12-0
Rs. a. d.
67-9-10
59-2-0
8-7-10
Then followed a list of 16 Mauzas given in Jagir.
If Taluk Kakwara was, in its origin, a Zamindari
Ghatwali created by the Zamindar of Kharakpur and
if Captain Browne's Sanad only confirmed that existing tenure during the interregnum when he was in
charge of the entire Mahalat of Kharakpur and managed
it on behal£ of the East India . Company but in the
interest of whoever eventually became the Raja of
Kharakpur, then on the restoration of the Zamindari
to Raja Kadir Ali he would naturally clarify the position and status of the Ghatwals under him by issuing
fresh Sanads in their favour. In this view of the matter
Raja Kadir Ali's San~d only regularised the original
status of Taluk Kakwara as a Zamindari Ghatwali
tenure and specified the terms more clearly and
explicitly.
It is, however, contended on behal£ of the appellant
that the Sanad of Captain Browne created a Government Ghatwali tenure and Raja Kadir Ali's Sanad
was nothing more than a confirmation of that Government Ghatwali tenure. Reliance is placed on the
inscription in the seal at the top which refers to Emperor Shah Alam the Victorious and it is contended
""'' oru, dmly inillra•u '"" iliIB S~od ~• •I~- ~
S.C.R.
•1
,._
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
81
1951
intended to be a Government grant. We are unabie •
to accept this contention ·as sound. The reference to
Thakur
Emperor Shah Alam the Victorious might be nothing
Rudrcshwari 1
more than a mere formal recognition of a titular Prasad Sinha
v.
.figureshead. The statement that the Ghatwali service
tenure of Taluk Kakwara was "held under a Sanad by Srimati Rani
Bhairo Singh and Rankoo Singh with 172 Musketeers Pr.obhabhati
and others.
and Archers" etc. may well be taken as referring-to an
earlier Sanad which specified the number of Musketeers
Das /.
'1
·and Archers and need not necessarily refer to Captain
Browne's Sanad of 1777 in which there was, as has
been pointed out, ·no specification of any number of
Musketeers and Archers. ·under this Sanad the grantees'
tenure commenced from the beginning of the Kharif
season of 1189 Fasli, Rajwara, corresponding to 1188 /
Fasli Mughfana. This date of commencement of the
tenure is· different from the date of .commencement
mentioned in Captain Browne's Sanad. In Captain•
Browne's Sanad the .fixed Jarµa of .Rs. 245-12-15 was
delusive of Zamindari Rasoom whereas under Raja
Kadir · Ali's Sanad the .fixed perpetual quit rent of
Rs. 245-12-15 was inclusive of Zamindari Rasoom, the
rent being Rs. 215-0-15 and Zamindari Rasoom being
Rs. 30-12-0. What is still more signi.ficanr · is the apportionment of ~he quit nert between the . two grantees
which is to be found towards the end of the Sanad.
Such an apportionment was wholly inappropriate in the
case of a merely confirmatory grant. Again, this grant
comprised 16 Mauzas whereas Captain Browne's
Sanad covered 22 Mauzas:. Even the names of many
of the 16 Mauzas are not to be found' in the specification of Mauzas at the end of Captain Browne's Sanad.
The further significant fact is that in the 16 Mauzas
set out of the foot of Raja Kadir Ali's Sai.tad the two
grantees were shown to have different and distinct
shares in the .different Mauzas. In some cases, even
an entire Mauza was allotted exclusively i:o one or the
other. Further, if Captain Browne's Sanad created a
Government Ghatwali tenure, it is not intel}igible why
Raja Kadir Ali should be called upon to Gonfirm the
grant with which he · was not directly or il;ldirectly
r~ II
. .
.
82
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
1951
concerned. Again, it is well known tliat at this time 9B
of the Ghatwals of· Kharakpur took their , Sanads from
Thakur
Raja Kadir Ali while only three big Ghatwals, namely,
Rudrflshwari
those of Lachmipur, Handwa and Chandan Katoria
Prasad .Sinha
took their Sanads not from Raja Kadir Ali but from
.
v.
Srimati Rani
Mr. Dickenson who succeeded Captain Browne. This
Probhabhati
distinction can only be explained on the footing that
and others.
these 98 Ghatwalis including Taluk Kakwara were in
Zamindari Ghatwalis while the three bigger
reality
Das f.
Ghatwalis were treated as Government Ghatwalis.
The fact that Mr. Cleveland, the Collector of Bhagalpur,
was at this time in charge and management of Mahalat
Kharakpur, that these 98 Sanads were granted in the
name of Kadir Ali during the perio\I of Mr. Cleveland's
management and the fact that ever since 1780 nobody
on behalf of the Government has questioned the propriety of these Sanads as
evidencing a grant of
Zamindari Ghatwali clearly establish that Raja Kadir
Ali's Sanads really regularised the position and status
of these Ghatwals as holding Zamindari Ghatwali
tenures and specified the terms on which the tenures
were to be thenceforth held. On the other hand, even
if it be accepted that Captain Browne's Sanad created
a Government Ghatwali tenure then, in the language
of Lord Sumner in Narayan Singh v. Niranjan
Chakravarti (supra) at p. 54 it might well be said that
Raja Kadir Ali's Sanad issued during the time·
Mr. Cleveland, the Collector of Bhagalpur, was managing the Mahalat of Kharakpur, and never objected to or
quesitoned at any time thereafter by the Government
"amounted to a release by the Government of the
Ghatwali services or to a grant to a third party of the
right to receive them and of the right to appoint the
Ghatwal" and,
therefore, the original Government
Ghatwali tenure came to an end and a Zamindari
Ghatwali tenure took its place.
The matter does not even rest with Raja · Kadir
Ali's Sanad. In 1789 or 1790 there was a decennial
settlement of Mahalat Kharakpur with Raja Kadir
Ali which in 1796 was made permanent under the
P,rmanent Settlement Regulation I of 1793, As Lord
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
83
Kingsdown pointed out in R-aja Lelanund S~ngh v.
The Government of Bengal (supra) at p. 114, 1t was
beyond dispute and indeed fairly admitted that the
Ghatwali lands formed part of the Z~indari and
were included in and ·covered by the assessment of the
Zamindari. This was recognised by the. High Court
·in Munrunjun Singh v. Raja Lelanund (supra) when
they said that ,there was no doubt that the tenure was,
at the Permanent Settlement, included in·· the Zamindari of Kharakpur and that the Jama was payable to
the Zamindar. On appeal, their Lordships of the
Privy Council also pointed out -cliat the claim of the
Government to resume and reassess the Ghatwali lands
was dismissed upon the ground that the Taluk had
been assessed to revenue and was a portion of the Mal
land of the Zamindar. In Leelanund Singh v. Thakoor
Munrunjun Singh (supra) . Garth C. J. at· p. 257 said
that there could be no doubt· that at the time of the
Permanent Settlement .the Taluk Kakwara formed part
of the Kharakpur Zamindari and that the holders of
that Taluk were "dependent Talookdars" of that
. Zamindari. The holders of Taluk Kakwara were
i,
certainly nor independent Talookdars because the·
Zaµiindar had the beneficial ·interest in the tenure and
these tenures were. never registered as independent
Taluks. Lord Sumner described the attempt of Raja
Lelanund Singh to recover possession of Taluk I):.akwara
as an attempt on his part to resume "his Shikmi
Ghatwali lands." Further, Captain Browne in · his
book "India Tracts" published in 1788 had · shown
only Luchmipur, Handwa and Chandan Katoria, all
appertaining to Purgunnah Kharakpur, as three Ghat"
walis under the ·Jungle Terry Collector. Kakwara was
not shown in that list... . On February 24, 1860, a list
(Exhibit D) of Ghatwali Mahals appertaining to
Kharakpur was prepared by the Government showing
98 Ghatwali tenures appertaining to Mahal Kharakpur.
Kakwara is item 73 in that list. In 1863, at uhe time
of the composition made between the. Government and
~ .the Raja of Kharakpur. another list of Ghatwali Mah.als
appertaining to Khara~pur was prepared by the
.
r.
1951
. Thakur
Rudreshwi:lri
Prasad Sinha
v.·
.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
7lnd others.
Das/.
'
84
1951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
Das J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
Government and Kakwara is item No. 40 in that list.
In neither of these lists did Lachmipur, Handwa and
Chandan Katoria, which were under the Collector,
find a place. Again, the letters from the Collector of
Bhagalpur to the Raja of Kakwara written in 1783
and 1808 set out in Lord Kingsdown' s judgment in
Raja Lelanund Singh v. The Government of Bengal
(supra) clearly show that the Government recognised
that the right of appointment and dismissal of a
Ghafwal rested with the Raja of Kharakpur. As
Lord Kingsdown pointed out in Raja Lela11und Singh v.
The Government of Bengal (supra) at p. 114, the
Zamindars derived some benefit in money and also
had the benefit of the services of the Ghatwals and
enjoyed the valuable right of appointing the individuals, who, with the lands, were to take upon themselves the duties of the office. If the Ghatwali tenures,
created by the Sanad of Raja Kadir Ali were Government Ghatwali tenures, it is not intelligible how the
Zamindar would have the right to appoint or dismiss
the Ghatwal. · On a consideration of the facts and the
circumstances noted above, we are of opinion that
Taluk Kakwara was, in its origin, a Zamindari Ghatwali tenure and continued to be so and was in fact
treated as such down to the present time and further
that 'even if by virtue of Captain Browne's Sanad it
became a Government Ghatwali tenure, then under
the Sanad of Raja Kadir Ali, or at any rate, after the
Permanent Settlement, Taluk Kakwara became a
Zamindari Ghatwali and as ~uCh alienable with the
consent of the Zamindar according to the custom of
Kharakpur judicially recognised.
It is quite clear to us that the conC\usions arrived at
by us are in no way inconsistent with the judicial
decisions which have been cited before us. In Raja
Lelanund Singh v. The Government of Bengal (supra)
the Government sought to establish their right to
resume and assets with revenue Ghatwali lands appertaining to the Zamindari of Kharakpur. The Government claimed the right under Regulation I of 1793,
section · 8, clause (a), and contended that before the
•
•
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
85
1951 •
Permane~t Settlement · the Zamindar used to· appt'.opriate the product; of the Ghatwali lands in maintaining
'Thakur
police establishments and that, as by that .Regulation. Rudreshwari
the Government undertook the charge of maintaining Prasad ·Sinha
v.
the p:olice, the lands became liable to resumptfon in
Srimati Rani
addition to the jama assessed on the Zamindari and Prohhabhati
that the jama assessed on the Zamindari of Kharakpur
and ·ot_her.-.
- did not include any sum assessed in respect of the
Das-/.
produce appropriated for the maintenance of the police
establishments. There were .eleven suits against 11
Ghatwals. The R~ja of Kharakpur was not originally
made a party to the proce~dings but he was not eventually added as a party on his own application. . In 1885
a final judgment in favour of the Government was
pronounced by, the Special Commissioner. The Raja
of Kharakpur appealed. The Government claim was ·
. dismissed on the ground, fjrst, that the Ghatwal~ lands
were part of the ·zamindari of Kharakpur and were
included in the Permanent Settlement of the Zamindari and covered by the jama assessed on that
Zamindari and, second, that the lands of Ghatwali
tenure were not liable to' resumption under Clause ( 4),
section 8, Bengal Regulation I of 1793 as included in
allowance made to Zamindars for thana or police
establishments. There is not only nothing in the
judgment of Lord Kingsdown which militates in any
way against ~the view that the Ghatwali tenures apper·taining to .the Mahalat of Kharakpur wer<; Zamindari
Chatwali. On the other hand, the observations of his
Lordship, some of which have been quoted above,
dearly iJ1dicate that they were of the nature of Zamindari Gha,twali over which the Zamindat .had the right
of appointment and dismissal and that they for.med
part of the Zamindari and were included in and covered by the assessment of the Zamindari.
·--·---
1-- ..J
•
Munrunjan Singh v. Raja Lelanund. Singh (supra)
was a suit by the Zal\lindar of Kharakpur claiming
possession of Taluk Kakwara on the allegation that the,
lands were held for ,police services, that the appointment
·and dismiss~! of Ghatwals rested with· him, that he
r,
86
"·- .: I 1951
Thak_ur
1
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
/Jas J.
(
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
f1952]
had compounded with the Government for a money payment in lieu of police services which he was bound to
render through the Ghatwals and that those services
being no longer required, he was entitled to resume the
lands. The defences were that the Ghatwals were not
lessees liable to ejectment but held a permanent tenure,
-that it existed long before the Permanent Settlement
.being held at a fixed jama mentioned. in the Sanads
derived directly from the representative~ of the British
Government and in compensation for services in
guarding the mountainous country 9nd the passes
which service they were always ready and willing to
perform. If Taluk Kakwara was a Government Ghatwali, then the Zamindari would have had no locus standi
to maintain the suit for possession and the suit should
have been dismissed on that short ground, but no
such point was seriously taken and the case was fought
out and decided on the footing that Taluk Kakwara
was a Zamindari Ghatwali. The principal Sudder
·Amin having decreed the suit, the defendant appealed.
The High Court held that the contract between the
Raja of Kharakpur and the Government without
·authority of the legislature in no way affected the
statute and the rights of the Ghatwal and the tenure
in dispute was not a mere grant of land in payment of
service to be rendered during pleasure but was a perpetual hereditary holding on a fixed jama, leaving a
beneficial interest in the Ghatwal with a condition of
service annexed. ifhat decision was upheld on appeal
by the Privy Council.
·
The next case concerni'ng this very Taluk Kakwara
was Leelanund Singh v. Tllakoor Munrunjun Singh
(supra) which was a suit by the Zamindar of Kharakpur against the Ghatwal of Kakwara for a declaration
of his right to enhance the rent at a rate equivalent to
the Ghatwali services which had been rendered unnecessary. Again, if Taluk Kakwara was a Government
Ghatwali, tl1e Raja of Kharakpur would have no locus
standi to claim, an enhancement of rent in lieu of the
Ghatwali services. This claim of the Raja of Kharakpur
was also dismissed. There are positive observations
,,_\
'
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
87
--
in this case which indicate that Taluk Kakwara was a
19.51
"dependent" Taluk or, as Lord Sumner called it, it
Tliak.iit:
was a' "Shikmi" Taluk.
Rudresliwari
Learned counsel for the appellant has relied very Prasad Sinha
strongly on two cases, namely, Narayan Singh
v. Niranjan Chakravarti (supra) and Rani Sonabati Srimizti Rani
Kuml:lri v. Raja Kitryanand Singh(1). Both the cases . Probhabliati
and others.
related to the Ghatwali of Taluk Handwa. The endeavour of learned counsel was to show that the Sanad
Das/.
. of · Captain Browne and the Sanad of Raja Kadir Ali
relating to Taluk Kakwara were in their effect the
same as the Sanad 0£ Captain Browne and the confirmatory Parwana of Mr. Dickenson, the Collector of
Bhagalpur, relating to Taluk Handwa. In Narayan
Singh v. Niranjan Chakravarti ·the Subordinate Judge
·held that the tenure of Handwa was not Ghatwali
: tenure at all. The High Court, on appeal, held that the
parganah was held as a Moghul Ghatwali tenure before
cession but that it became a Government Ghatwali
and that ·nothing had been done to alter that position ..
They were, however, of opinion that Raja Udit ·Narayan
'Singh did not hold it -as Ghatwal and that the heirs of
:l)dit Narayan Singh could not impugn the validity of
the mortgage created by him. This decision · of the
High Court was reversed by ·the Privy Council. In
Rani Sonabati Kumari v. Raja Kirtyanand Singh(1)
Mr. Justice Faz! Ali elaborately discussed the law
.relating· to Ghatwali t~nures. ·'Learned Counsel for the
appellant before us has relied on several passages from
the judgment of' Lord Sumner and from that of Mr.
Justice Faz! Ali. These two decisions must be taken
·as based on the construction of the relevant Sanads,
namely, the Sanad of Captain Browne and the Parwana of Mr. Dickenson and the observations to be
found in the judgments in those -two cases must be
read in the light of that construction. The position of
Taluk Kakwara appears to us to be entirely different
from that of · Taluk Handwa. Mr. Justice Shearer in
his judgment refers to five points of distinction between
,the position of the two Ghatwals, namely.
.,.
...
'
,
-.-r
(1) ·(1935) I.L.R. 14 Patna 70.
88
l951
Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
:V-
Srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others.
lJa; /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
( 1) The Ghatwals of Handwa never paid any
Rasoom on the amount of the land revenue assessed
on the lands of Raja of Kharakpur ;
~·
\
(2) The Ghatwal of Handwa formerly used to
pay the quit rent directly into the Government
treasury ;
(3) In more than one list of the Ghatwali tenures
under the Kharakpur Raj prepared by the Collectors
of Bhagalpur, Handwa was not to 'be found ;
(4) After the restoration of Kharakpur Raj, the
Ghatwals of Handwa instead of obtaining a Sanad
from Raja Kadir Ali obtained a Sanad from the then
Collector of Bhagalpur, Mr. Dickenson ; and
(5) the claim made by Raja Kadir Ali to appoint
a new Ghatwal of Handwa on the occurrence of a
vacancy in the office was negatived by the Courts.
Likewise, Chatterjee J. in his judgment also points
out the essential differences in the status of the two
Ghatwals. The language used in the Sanad relating to
Taluk Handwa is somewhat different. There is no
question of payment of quit rent to the Zamindar of
Kharakpur. Although Handwa was included in the
Zamindari of Kharakpur, it was only done so in a
geographical sense and for fiscal purposes. The annual
jama of Handwa was necer treated as a part of the
Mal assets of the Raja of Kharakpur on which revenue
was assessed on him. On the contrary, Handwa, was
assessed as a separate unit and the assessment
was made payable by Handwa to the Government
through the Raja of Kharakpur. The Raja of Kharakpur has ·no beneficial interest either in money or by
way of services or any power of appointment or dismissal over the Ghatwali of Handwa. Learned coun~el
for the appellant has relied on several passages in the
judgment of Lord Sumner but those passages are
susceptible of a meaning which is consistent with the
conclusions we have arrived at on a construction of
the two Sanads relating to Taluk Kakwara. It is also
to be noted that the appellant judgment-debtor himself
mortgaged this very Taluk Kakwara with the Raja of
•
. ··i
l
,
S;C.R..
89
SUPREME COURT REPO.RTS
Kharalripur on . the allegation _ that ·Taluk Kakwara
· was alienable with "the consent of the Zami1c1dar.
..- .
I
Ip our judgment the final conclusions arrived at by
Mr. Justice Shearer and Mr. Justice Chatterjee are
clearly right and this appeal must be dismissed with
costs.
A ppe(Jl dismissed.
Agent for the appellant : I. N. Shroff.
Agent for the respondents: S. P. Verma .
1951
. Thakur
Rudreshwari
Prasad Sinha
v.
·srimati Rani
Probhabhati
and others;
1951
SRI SANKAR! PRASAD SINGH DEO
Oct. 5.
v.
UNION OF INDIA AND STATE OF BIHAR
(And Other Cases);
[HARILAL KANIA
MuKHE!lJEA,
DAs AND
c. J., PATANJALI SASTRI!
CHANDRASEKHARA
AIYAR
JJ.]
Constitution ·(First Amendment) Act, 1951, Arts, 31A, 31BValidity-Constitution of India, 1950, Arts. 13(2), 368, 379,
392-Provisional Parliament-Power to amend ConstitutionConstitution (Removal of Difficulties) Order Ng. 2 of 1950-Validity
-Amendment of Constitution-Procedure-Bill amended by Legislature-Amendment curtailing fundpmental rights-Amendment
affecting land-Validity of Amending Act.
The Constitution (First Amendment) 'Act, 1951, which has
inserted, inter alia, Arts. 31A and 31B in the Constitution of
India is riot ultra vires or unconstitutional.
The provisional Parliament is competent to exercise the power
of amending the Constitution under Art. 368. The fact that the
said article refers to the two Houses of the Parliament and the
President separately and not to the Parliament, does not lead to
the inference that the body which is invested with the power to
amend is not the Parliament but a different body consisting of
the two Houses.
.
The words "all the powers confer{ed by the provisions of this
Constitution ori Parliament': in Art. 379 are not confined to such
powers as could be exercised by · the provisional Parliament consisting of a single chamber, but are wide enough to include the
power to amend the Constitution conferred by Art. 368.
The Constitution (Removal of Difficulties} Order No. 2 made
by the President on the 26th January, 1950, which purports to
adapt Art. 368 · by omitting "either House of" and "in each
House" and substituting "Parliament" for "that House" is not
. 12
'1
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org