THE STATE OF ORISSA versus MADAN GOPAL RUNGTA.
Supreme Court of India | Decided 25 October 1951 | [1952] 1 S.C.R. 28 | 1951 INSC 49
Key facts
- Decided
- 25 October 1951
- Bench
- HARILAL JEKISUNDAS KANIA*, M. PATANJALI SASTRI, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, SUDHI RANJAN DAS, N. CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR
- Bench size
- 5
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 300/1951
- Disposal
- Appeal(s) allowed
- Citation
- [1952] 1 S.C.R. 28
- Neutral citation
- 1951 INSC 49
Text of the judgment
28
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1951
THE STATE OF ORISSA
October 25.
ti.
[1952]
\
MADAN GOPAL RUNGTA.
THE STATE OF ORISSA
ti.
ARJUN LADHA.
THE STATE OF ORISSA
ti.
MALCOLM ANGUS TULLOCK.
THE STATE OF ORISSA
ti.
MOHD. SERAJUDDIN AND OTHERS.
THE STATE OF ORISSA
ti.
S. LAL
[HARILAL KANIA C.
MuKHERJEA,
DAs
AND
J., PATANJALI SAsTRI,
CHANDRASEKHARA
A1YAR
1-
JJ.]
Constz"tution of India, Art. 226--Writs grant£ng me1·e interim
relief pending institution of civil suit without deciding rights of
parties-Legality
The High Court cannot make a direction under Art. 226 of the
Constitution for the purpose of granting interim relief only pending the institution of a suit n1erely because the suit could not be
instituted until after the expiry of 60 days from the date of a
notice under Sec. 80 of the Civil Procedure Code and in the meanwhile, unless .protected by the Court the applicant may suffer
irreparable loss.
Even though writs can be issued under Art. 226 for purposes
other than the enforce1nent of fundamental rights, the concluding
words of the article have to be read in the context of what pre..
cedes the same, and the existence of a right is the found3tion of
the exercise of jurisdiction of the Court under this article.
An interim relief can be granted only in aid of, and as ancillary
to, the main relief which n1ay be available to the party on final
determination of his rights in a suit or proceeding.
,.
f.
•
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
29
CrVJL APPELLATE JuRISDICTION: Cases Nos. 300 to
304 of 1951.
Appeals under Art. 132(1) of the Constitution of
India from a judgment dated 2nd August, 1951, of
the High Court of Judicature at Orissa (Ray C. J. and
Narasirnham J.)
in Miscellaneous
Judicial Cases
Nos. 126, 127, 128, 129 and 130 of 1951.
M. C. Setalvad, Attorney-General for India (G. N.
/oshi, with him) for the appellant in all the appeals.
N. C. Chatterjee (H. /. Umrigar and A. N. Roy, with
him) for the respondent in Case No. 300 of 1951.
Roshan Lal for the respondent in Cases Nos. 301
and 304.
N. C. Chatterjee (A. N. Roy, with him) for the
respondent in Case No. 302 of 1951.
N. C. Chatterjee (A. N. Roy, and A. N. Sinha, with
him) for the respondent in Case No. 300 of 1951.
1951. October 25. The Judgment of the Court was
delivered by
KANIA C. J.-These are five companion appeals from
the judgment of the High Court at Orissa, delivered
on five petitions filed by the respondent in each of the
appeals, to obtain from the Court a writ of mandamas
and/or directions under article 226 of the Constitution
of India.
Each of the respondents alleged that between 1941
and 1947 he had agreed to take from the Ruler of
· Keonjhar a mining lease and had entered into possession of the area. Some of the petitioners alleged that
they had spent money on the development of the
mines and installed machinery to work; the same. It
is however common ground tfuit there was no registered lease in favour of any of the respondents before
1947. On the 14th December, 1947, the Ruler of
Keonjhar eUitered into a merger agreement with the
Dominion of India and as from the 1st January, 1948,
the State was merged in the Dominion. of India. After
signing the merger agreement the Ruler gave registered
1951
T ht: Stat# of
Orissa
v.
Madan Gopal
Rungta.
30
1951
The State·of
Oriss11
v.
Madan Gopal
Ru"gta.
Kania C. /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952]
leases on the 27th December, 1947, to the respondents
in these appeals. In pursuance of the exercise of the
powers conferred on the Government of Orissa by
section 4 of the Extra Provincial Jurisdiction Act,
1949, read with Notification No. 172/IB dated 23rd
March, 1948, of the Government of India, the Government of Orissa issued a notification dated the 8th of
June, 1949, declaring, inter alia, the said leases to be
void and not binding on it. This annulment was made
expressly on the ground that these commitments were
not reasonable and bona fide. Thereafter, the respondents, along with others approached the Orissa Government to give them leai;es and the State Government
gave them temporary pdmits to work the inines in
November, 1949. On the 3rd July, 1951, however
they passed an order canck;Uing the temporary permits
and directed the respondents to remove their assets
appertaining to the respective mines within a fortnight.
The respondents thereupon filed the petitions before
the Orissa High Court praying for writs or directions
in the nature of mandamus against the State of Orissa
directing them to withdraw the notices dated the 8th
of June and 3rd of July, 1951, and to forbear from
acting upon or giving effect to the same.
The Court, after noticing the rival contentions of the
parties and rejecting the contention that the State of
Orissa had cancelled the permits and were attempting to take possession as an act of State, posed the
question "whether the law of annulment relied upm1
by the State was applicable to the mining leases granted
to the petitioners, or in the alt1ernative, whether the
State had any right in law to cancel the leases before
the period mentioned therein." Referring to the contention of the State founded on the acceptance by the
respondents of the temporary permits and the estoppel
arising therefrom, Ray C. J. in his judgment stated as
follows :-"In determining the validity of this contention (relating to the temporary permit and estoppel
arising therefrom) the circumstances under which these
applications were made and the legal implications of
such applications and the permissions gran~ed under
i
~
/
S.C.R,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
31
1951
them will have to be considered. It is remote from
our if! ten ti on to :express any opinion in this summary
The State of
proceeding as to the respective merits of the rival
Orissa
v.
contentions. I am however satisfied that in the context
of events and in the logic of circumstances attending Madan Go'pal
Rungta.
·thereto, there is .a case to be tfied." He next considered
the scope of the writ of mandamus and came to the
Kania C. 7,
conclusion that "at the mom~nt" the respondents had
no alternative legal remedy, equally convenient, beneficial and. effectual because the· respondents could not
file a suit till after the expiry of the period of sixty
days required for the purpose under section 80 of the
Civil Procedure Code and he thought that unless protected by the Court in the meanwhile the respondents
would undergo irreparable and irremediable loss of
possession of the mining leases involving a huge waste
of labour, machinery and other resources of equipments of immense value hardly capable of beirig remedied by payments of money as compensation. The
Bench therefore passed an order dated 2nd August,
1951, as follows:- "We direct that till three months:.
from today or one week after the institution of their
(respondents') contemplated suit, whichever is earlier
the Government of the State of Orissa should refrain
from disturbing the petitioners' possession over the·
mining areas in question and ~hat thereafter this order
will , cease to have effect." They gave further directions
as to how the mines were to be worked during the aforesaid period. Towards the end of the judgment it was
to the limited extent indicated above." Narasimham J.
stated. "In the result, the petitions are allowed in· part
agreed with the order set out in the judgment of
the Chief Justice although his judgment shows the
concurrence to be very halting. He stated that
although he was reluctant to exercise the powers .
under article 226 because the presen~ respondents
could file a suit, yet as jn view of section 80 of the
Civil Procedure Code there would be an unavQ!dable delay resulting in irreparable loss to the respondents he agreed that the order should be , passed
as mentioned in the judgment of the Chief Justice..
3-2 S. C. India/71
32
1951
The State of
Orissa
v.
Madan Gopal
Rungta.
Kania .C. ].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1952
Towards the end of his judgment he stated ~ follows:"It should however be clearly emphasized that the
observations contained in this judgment should not be
taken as pre-judging any question which may arise
for the consideration of the Civil Court in the event
of the petitioners filing a regular suit and seeking
interim relief from that Court by way of temporary
injunction, appointment of receiver or otherwise. If
such an application is made, the questions as to
whether the petitioners have a prima facie case for
trial or whether such a suit is maintainable or whether
the balance of convenience requires that they should
be permitted to remain in possession of the leasehold ·
property till the termination of the suit and other
allied matters should all be dealt with by the Court
concerned without being influenced in any way by the
observations
contained in this
judgment. Those
observations have been made for the limited purpose
of granting temporary relief under article 226 and are
not intended to embarass either party or the Court in
future litigation."
It appears that thereafter an application was made
,to. ~~ay the operati·on of this 'order to enable the
Government of Orissa to appeal against the order of
the 2nd of August. The same judges· on the 6th of
August stayed the operation of the order for fifteen
days and observed as follows :-"The effect of the
order (of 2nd August, 1951), is that except giving them
(respondents in these appeals) some interim measure
of relief for the period during which .the petitioners
were without remedy, we were not inclined to accept
the petition and issue a writ in the nature of mandamus,
as prayed for." The State of Orissa has come on
appeal to us and after hearing the arguments on both
sides we came to the conclusion that the order of the
High Court could not be sustained. We accordingly
passed the following order on the 15th of October:
"These five appeals are allowed and the order of the
High Court is set aside in each case. As the High
Court ha9 passed no other orders on the petitions and
indeed has stated that the Court was not prepared to
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
33
1951
pass any other orders on the petitions, the petitions
stand dismissed. T:he respondents will pay the costs
The State of
of the appeals. We shall give our reasons later on."
. Orissa
Our reasons are these:
.v.
· 1e 226 of the Constttut10n
· ·
Gopal
Arttc
of In d'ia runs as - . Madan
Rungta.
follows:-
226. (1) "Notwi~hstanding anyiliing in article 32, · · Kania C. ].
every High Court shall have power, throughout the
territories in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction,
to issue to any person or authority, including in appro~
priate cases any Government, within those territories
directions, orders or writs including writs' in the nature
of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto
and certiorari, or any of them, for the enforcement of
any of the rights conferred by Part III arid for any
other purpose.
(2) The power conferred on a High Court by
clause ( 1) shall not be in derogation of the power conferred on the Supreme Court by clause (2) of article
32." .
.
The language of the Article shows that the issuing
of writs or qjrections by the Court is not founded
only on its decision that· a right of the aggrieved party
under Part III of the Constitution (Fundamental
Rights) has been infringed. It can also issue writs or
give similar directions for any other purpose. The
concluding words of article 226 have fo be read in the
context of what J?recedes the same. Therefore the
existence of the right is the foundation of the exercise
of jurisdiction of the Court under this Article. The
judgment of the ·orissa High Court under appeal
however, shows that the Judges have decided nothing
at all in respect of the rights of the parties. Indeed
they . have , expressly stated that their observations
should not in any way be considered as deciding any
of the rights or contentions of the parties raised in the
petitions. The whole judgment shows that because of
the requirement of section 80 of the Civil Procedure
Code the present respondents could not 'file a suit
against the Government for at least sixty days, the
'
'
1
34
1951
The State of
on·ssa
v.
Madan Gopal
Rungta.
Kania C. /.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[19521
respondent's position should not in the interval be
disturbed and accordingly the Court gave the directions
in its order of the 2nd of August, 1951. If there
was any doubt about the nature of the relief
desired to be granted by the order of 2nd August the
same Judges have made it perfectly clear by their
order of the 6th of August, wherein they have stated
that except for these directions they were not prepared
to make any other order on the petitions. The result
therefore is that while the Judges declined to investigate and pronounce on the rights of the parties and
expressely kept the determination thereof in abeyance
in the suit proposed to be filed by the present respondents, they gave directions for interim relief till
such suit was filed. It must be noted that with the
passing of the order of the 2nd August, 1951, containing directions in the nature of interim relief the peti1tions were completely disposed of and have not been
kept pending for disposal. Those directions embody
therefore the final order passed by the Court on these
petitions. A preliminary objection was raised about
the maintainability of ,the appeals on the ground that
no final orders were passed on the petitions. That
objection must fail in view of the fact that with these
orders the petitions were disposed of finally and nothing further remained to be done in resp:ct of the petitions. The fact that the operation of the order is
limited to three months or a week afte~ ::he filing of
the intended suit does not prevent the or<k.r from
being final.
On behalf of the appellant it was urged that the
Court had no jurisdiction to pass such orders under
article 226 under the circumstances of the case. This
is not a case where the Court before finally disposing
of a petition under article 226 gave directions in the
nature of interim relief for the purpose of maintaining
the status quo.· The question which we have to determine is whether directions in the nature of interim
relief only could be granted under article 226, when
the Court expressly stated that it refrained from
determining the rights of, the parties on which a writ
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
I
35
J of mandamus or directio~s of a like nature could be
)
t
)
;..-.
1951
In our opinion, article 226 cannot be used for
The State of
the purpose of givirig interim relief . as the only and
Orissa
final relief on the application as the High Court has
v.
purported to do. The directions have been given here Madan Gopal
Rungta.
only to circumvent the provisions of section 80 of the
Civil Procedure Code, and in our opinion that is not
Kania C. /.
within the scope of article 226. An 'interim relief can
be granted only in aid of and as anci1lary to the main
relief which may be available to the party on final
determination of his rights in a suit or proceeding. If
):he Court was of opinion that there was no other convenient or adequate remedy open 1ro the petitioners, it
might have proceeded to investigate the case on its
merits and come to a decision as to whether the petitioners succeeded in establishing that there was an
infringement of any of their legal rights which entitled
them to a writ of mandamus or any other directions of
a like nature; and pending such determination it might
have made a suitable interim order for maintaining the
status quo ante. But when the Court declined to
decide on the rights of the parties and expressly held
that they should be investigated more properly in a
civil suit, it could not, for the purpose of facilitating
the institution of such suit, issue directions in the
nature of temporary injunctions, under article 226 of
rthe Constitution. In our opinion, the language of
article 226 does not permit such an action. On that
short ground the judgement of 1the . Orissa High Court
under appeal cannot be upheld.
i~ued.
Appeals allowed.
Agent for the appellant in all the appeals : P. A.
Mehta.
Agent for the respondent in Case No. 300 : S. P.
Varma.·
Agent for the respondent in Cases Nos. 301 and 304 :
Ganpat Rai.
Agent for the respondent in Case& Nos. 302 and 303 :
P. K. Chatterjee.
·
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org