RAJA BRAJA SUNDAR DEB versus MONI BEHARA AND OTHERS
Supreme Court of India | Decided 27 March 1951 | [1951] 1 S.C.R. 431 | 1951 INSC 22
Key facts
- Decided
- 27 March 1951
- Bench
- MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN*, BIJAN KUMAR MUKHERJEA, N. CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR
- Bench size
- 3
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 42/1948
- Disposal
- Case Partly allowed
- Citation
- [1951] 1 S.C.R. 431
- Neutral citation
- 1951 INSC 22
Text of the judgment
S.C.R.
431
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1951
RAJA BRAJA SUNDAR DEB
March 21;
ti.
MONI BEHARA AND OTHERS
[MEHAR CHAND MAHAJAN, MuKHERJEA
CHANDRASEKHARA AIYAR
and
JJ.]
Fisheries-Fisherm;n of particular villages allowed to fish for
.several years by zemindar-Acqu1stion of right to fish-PresumpJion of lost grant-Prescription-Adverse possession-Proceedings
.under s. 145, Cr. P. C., effect of.
_,
A right exercisable by the inhabitants of a village from
time to time is neither attached to any estate in land nor is it
such a right as is capable of being made the subject of a grant, '
there being no ascretainable g(ant~es.
The doctrine of lost grant originated as a technical device
to enable title to be made hy prescription despite the impossibility
-of proving immemorial user and since it originated in grant, .its
-owners, whether original or by devolution, had to be such persons
as were capable of being the recipients of a grant.
Where all that appeared from the evidence was that the
fishermen who were residents of certain villages had been . for a
long time exercising the right of fishing in certain rivers which
flowed through a zemindari with the consent of some of the
zemindars : Held, that the fishermen residing in these villages
cannot be treated as a corporate body or a kind of unit in whose
favour a lost grant could be presumed or who could acquire a
:right to fish either by adverse possession or by prescription.
Where, however, there were proceedings under section 145 of
the Criminal Procedure Code between the zemindars and certain
:fishermen and the Magistrate found that the fishermen were in
possession of the disputed fishery and he directed the issue of an
order declaring their possession until ~victed therefrom in due
course of law and forbidding all disturbance of such possession
until such eviction, and no steps were taken by the zcmindars to
set aside the order of the Magistrate within three years as required
by article 47 of the Limitation Act : Held, that so far as the
fishermen who were parties to the proceedings under section} 45,
the order of the Magistrate had become final and they were entitled to remain in possession of the fishery.
An exclusive right of fishing in a given place means that no
other
person has a co-extensive right with the claimant of the
The mere fact that some other person has a right to a
parncular class of fish in the fishery or that another person is
righ~
432
1951
&jaBr41a
Sumlar Deb
v.
Moni Beluzra
and Others.
SUPREME COURT REPORT.S
[1951}
entitled to fish at a certain, time of the year docs not destroy
right of exclusive fishing in any manner
the
C1VIL APPELLATE JuRISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 42
of 1948.
Appeal against the judgment and decree dated the
21st April, 1943, of the High Court of Judicature at
Patna (Faz! Ali C. J. and S. C. Chatterji J.) in First
Appeal No. 17 of 1939 arising out of decree dated the
19th July, 1939, of the Subordinate Judge at Puri in
Original Suit No. 62 of 1936.
Manohar Lal (G. P. Das, with him) for the appellant.
B. N. Das (Sir Kant Mahanti, with him)
respondents.
1951, March 27. The
delivered by
Mahajan].
for the
Judgment of the Court was
MAHAJAN J.-The dispute in this appeal is between
the fishermen residing in nine villages of Killa
Marichpur, a permanently settled zamindari in the
Puri Collectorate (Orissa State) and the Raja of Aul,
the owner of seven annas, seven pies, and ten karants
share in the zamindari. The other shares in the
zamindari are defendants 19 to 29. Within the ambit
of the estate flows "Devi Nadi," with its several
branches and tributaries. Three fisheries "Madhurdia,"·
"Marichpurdia" and "Maladia"
appertain to this
estate. The controversy in this appeal concerns die
fishery known as the "Madhurdia" fishery.
In the year 1936, three suits, Nos. 62, 63 and 64,
were brought by the Raja of Aul against defendants
1 to 18 on behalf of themselves and other fishermen
residing in the nine villages of Killa Marichpur for a
declaration in respect of his rights in the three above
mentioned fisheries. All these suits were decided in
his favour by the trial court. The defendants, preferred
no appe:il in suits 63 and 64, with the result that the
controversy regarding the two fisheries involved in
these two suits stands concluded by the decision of the
trial court. In suit No. 62 of 1936, however, the
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
433
defendants preferred an appeal to the High Court and
it was partially allowed. The decree ·of the trial Judge
in favour of the' plaintiff was modified and it was held
that the defendants had exclusive rights as· tenants at
will to .fish in this fishery during the Hilsa season
(Margasir to Baisakh) and that the plaintiff was not
entitled to a declaration or an injunction in respect of
that period. The plaintiff thereupon obt;Uned leave to
appeal to His Majesty in Council and that appeal is
now before us for decision.
It was alleged in the pl:iint that the proprietors of
Marichpur zamindari are the exclusive owners . of the
fishery in question and have all along been exerc1smg
their right of catching fish in the same sometimes by
employing fishermen and 5ometimes by letting out the
fishery to them, that the plaintiff has ever since his
acquisition of the .zamindari interest been the owner
in khas possession of the fishery right according to his
share in the zamindari, that the · defendants-fishermen
were never in possession of the ~d fishery, nor have
they anv right to it, that in the yea.r 1918 they started
proceedings under section 145, Criminal Procedure
Code, to create evidence of their possession but in spite
of those proceedings the plaintiff continued to be in
possession of the fishery and has been catching fish
by employing fishermen, that by taking advantage of
the fact that there are several co-sharers in the
zamindari and there is mismanagement of the estate,
·the defendants wrongfully and unlawfully trespassed
on the fishery from time to time between May, 1933,
and November, 1933, and disturbed the plaintiff in the
enjoyment of his right and have caused loss to him
and his co-sharers by catching large quantity of fish
without any leave or licence. On these allegations,
the plaintiff claimed a declaration to the effect that
defendants 1 to 18 in their personal and representative
capacity have no right or title in the fishery known as
"Madhurdia" fishery or to the fishery in the southern
portion of the area recorded as the ~iver block; Risilo
and Husgarh. :Prayer was also made f~r the grant of
a perpetual injunction restraining the defendants from
1951
Raja Broja
Sundar Deb
v.
Mani Belwra
and Others.
Mahajan].
434
1951
Raja Brqja
Sundar Deb
v.
Mani Behara
and Othns.
Mahqjan].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951}
fishing in the above fishery and in the above mentioned blocks and for the award of a sum of money by way
of damages and on account of price of Ii.sh.
The defendants contested the allegations made in
the plaint and asserted thai: the fishermen of Killa
Marichpur including the principal defendants and
their ancestors, about 846 persons in all, have all
along remained in undisturbed actual physical possession of the fishery known as "Charkhatia" alias
"Madhurdia" fishery on a fixed annual rental of
Rs. 135-7-0, and have a right to remain in possession
in perpetuity on payment of that rent ; that they have
acquired this right in all possible ways, i.e., by grant,
custom, adverse possession and easement.
On these plcadi!lgs of the parties the trial Judge
framed as many as nine issues, the material ones being
issues 6 an.d 7, which are in these terms :"6. Has the plaintiff any title to the disputed
fishery ?
7. Have the defendants Nos. 1 to 18 · acquired
any right, by adverse possession,
prescription or
custom"?
The trial Judge on these issues hdd that the defendants neither in their personal nor in their representative capacity had any right or title in the fishery in
question and issued a permanent injunction against
them from fishing in it. The claim for damages was
disallowed. It was obserVed by the learned Judgi::
that the defendants did not claim the right to catch
all the Ii.sh found in the fishery but that they had
confined their claim in respect to Hilsa Ii.sh only
during the Hilsa season between the months of
Margasir and Baisakh (November to April) and that
as regards the other varieties of Ii.sh found in these
waters during the rest of the year they did not assert
any right to catch Ii.sh. He also observed that the
defendants did not deny that the plainrilf was the
owner· of the zamindari and as such owner of the soil
and of the waters of the fishery, hut that they claimed
a subordinate right, i.e., the right of fishing in ~e
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
435
waters belonging to the plaintiff and his co-sharers
during the Hilsa season to the exclusion of the plaintiff
and his co-sharers. In view of these contentions the
onus was laid on the defendants to prove their permanent right of fishing in these waters by grant,
custom, prescription or adverse possession and it was
held that the defendants failed to discharge the onus
that rested on them. Acquisition of the right by
grant, prescription and adverse possession was held
not provable in law in favour of an indeterminate and
fluctuating body of persons. The claim for permanent tenancy in the fishery was negatived on· the
ground that there was no evidence to show that the
tenancy came
by descent to these 846 persons
from the persons who actually took it in the
year 1842, or that
it was obtained from all
the sixteen anna landlords, or that
there was
any fixity of rent. It was funher said that there
was no cenainty as to who were the owners of
the right, as to the local area over which the right
was to be exercised, as to the measure of the right
and of the periods during which the right could be
exercised
and that in these circumstances the
defendants' claim could not be upheld. The defendants' contention that under article 47 of the Indian
Limitation Act the plaintiff had lost his right was
held unsustainable and the plea of custom was ruled
out on the ground that the custom alleged would be
of an unreasonable kind.
All the questions raised in the trial court exceotin~
the question of custom were canvassed by the defendants before the High Court. The High Court in a
judgment, by no means clear or satisfact.ory, reached
the conclusion that the defendants since the time of
their predecessors had all along been fishinrr in the
disputed fishery as of right under a lost ~rant and
that the plaintiff'-s story that he had been in enjovment of the fishery was not true and that the defendants' right to fish in the disputed fisherv was established. One would have thought that in view of this
finding the plaintiff's suit would have been dismissed
1951
RajaBrda
Sundor Deb
v.
Mani Bthara
and Others.
Mahajan]
436
1951
RojaBrq.ia
Sund"' D,b
v.
Mani Be!wro
and Others
Mahajan].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951]
but this did not happen. The High Court proceeded
to find that though from the evidence it appeared that
the right was being exercised by the defendants or
their predecessors from a very long time, that is to say,
from the year 1842, yet there . was no evidence to
iutisfy the inference that they had got a permanent
right. The defendants' plea, therefore, that they were
permanent tenants of the fishery in dispute was not
upheld. As regards the defendants' contention that
the plaintiff was bound by the order passed in proceedings under section 145, Criminal Procedure Code, it
was found that he not having challenged that order
within the prescribed period, his right to khas possession of the disputed fishery except to the extent of five
pice share was extinguished under section 28 of the
Limitation Act but that his proprietary right subsisted as it · was never denied. It was funher held that
the plaintiff's right to khas possession of this fishery
was also extinguished by operation of anicle 144 of
the Indian Limitation Act. Plaintiff's evidence that
he had been catching fish during the Hilsa season by
employing other fishermen was disbelieved and it was
held that the defendants had been exercising exclusive
right to fish in the disputed fishery during the Hilsa
season adversely to the plaintiff and the other co-sharers
for more than twelve years. In spite of these findings
the High Coun reached the somewhat strange conclusion that the defendants acquired by adverse possession a mere tenancy at will and that it could be determined by the entire body of landlords and the plaintiff
being only a co-sharer could not bring the present suit
in his own behalf and it had not the effect of determining the tenancy and hence the plaintiff could not be
granted the declaration and the injunction restraining
the defendants from fishing during the Hilsa season.
As regards the point raised by the plaintiff that by
reason of the change in the course of the river the
fishery . in. dispute was not the same regarding which
an order· was made under section 145 proceedings or in
which the defendants have been exercising their right, it
was held that this contention was without force because
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
437
the river· was identical and the channels, whether old
or new, which comprise the Madhurdia or Charikhati
fishery, have always formed one. connected sheet of
water and that fishing in different parts of such a connected sheet of water comprised in the same fishery can
hardly be said to be a separate act of aggression
so as to disturb the continuity or extent of adverse
possession and that the fishermen though a fluctuating
body, have unity of interest and possession and could
not be described as several independent trespassers.
As a result of these findings the decree of the trial
Judge was modified and the plaintiff was given a
permanent injunction restraining the principal defendants from fishing in the disputed fishery except during
the Hilsa season (Margasir to Baisakh) during which
the defendants were declared to have exclusive right
of fishing.
A~st the decision of the .Hig1i Court no appeal
was preferred by the defendants though tliey had only·
been found to be in possession _l)f the fishery in the
status of mere tenants at will. The plaintiff challenged
this decision and contested the finding that the defendants we~e lawfully in possession of the fishery and
could exercise their right of fishing during the Hilsa
season exclusively. The real grievance of the plaintiff
seems to be that by the decision under appeal the
High Court has declared a fluctuating body of persons
tenants at will, and that such a tenancy cannot be
determined as its constitution is liable to vary with
each birth and death and with influx or efflux of fishermen to and from these villages. It was argued that
the High Court has erroneously found that the defendants were in possession of the fishery and were in
enjoyment of the fishing right under a lost grant and
that the plaintiff's right to khas possession of the
fishery had been extinguished by operation of articles
47 and 144 of the Limitation Act read with section 28
of the Act. It was contended that from the evidence
placed on the record the only correct conclusion to
draw was that from time to time some fishermen were
allowed to fish in these waters by a number of landlords
1951
RajaBraia
Surular D•b
v.
Moni Behara .
and Othn's.
MahaianJ.
438
1951
Ra_;a Broja
Sundar Deb
v.
Moni Behara
and Others.
Mo.haj,,,n].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951]
on payment of rent but that the prdent defendants were
not the descendants of those fishermen who were occasionally granted leave to fish and that those isolated
acts of letting the fishery were not connected with one
another and from these it could not be inferred that
the defendants or their predecessors were in continuous
possession of the fishery on payment of a fixed rent
and that the present defendants were mere trespassers
and had no right to fish in the disputed fishery. It
was further contended that no title of any kind could
be presumed to exist in the defendants to the fishery
in suit and on the basis of a lost grant as in this case
there was no capable grantee and that even title by
adverse possession or prescription could not be acquired
by them as they form an indeterminate and Auctuating body of persons. As regards the finding of the
High Court that the plaintiff's suit was barred by
article 47 of the Limitation Act and his title to khas
• possession was extinguished by operation of the provisions of section 28 of the Indian Limitation Act, it
was contended that the proceedings that took place in
the year 1918 were wrongly labelled under section 145,
Criminal Procedure Code, and that in substance the
order made in tho5e proceedings fell within the ambit
of section 147 of the Code and therefore article 47 had
no application to the case and the plaintiff was not
bound to bring his suit within three years of that
order to enforce his right. It was further contended
that the order could only benefit the parties impleaded
in those proceedings and the other defendants could
not derive any assistance from it, that in any case the
order could not bind the plaintiff to the extent of the
share purchased by him from co-sharers not made
parties in those proceedings and that the river having
changed its course in the year 1925, the fishery as it
stood in 1918 was no longer in existence and in the
substituted fishery the plaintiff's right could not be
held to have been extinguished by the effect of the
order made in section 145, Criminal Procedure Code
proceedings. The learned counsel for the respondents
contended that the defendants had in the status of
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
439
tenants an exclusive right to fish in the fishery and
were entitled to remain in enjoyment of it on payment
of a fixed rent of Rs. 135-7-0 in perpetuity, that the
plaintiff's right of fishing in the fishery during Hilsa
season had become extinguished by operation of article 47 and article 144 of the Indian Limitation Act.
It was denied that by a change in the course of the
river, if any, the defendants' right had in any way
been affected. In order to appreciate the respective
contentions of the parties it is necessary to state a few
facts which emerge from the documentary evidence
produced in the case.
The State of Orissa came under ihe British rule in
the year 1803. A revenue settlement of the State was
made in 1904-05. From the village note prepared
during the settlement, it appears that Killa Marichpur
was originally owned by one Padmalav Mangaraj and
that during the time of his great grandson Balabhadra
Mangaraj the estate was sold in auction for satisfaction
of debts incurred by him and was purchased by (1)
Mohan Bhagat, (2) Chakradhar Mahapatra, and (3)
the ancestors of one Haziran Nisa Bibi in equal shares.
From the jamabandi of the year 1842 (Exhibit C) it
appears that the jalkor income of Killa Marichpur
zamindari at that time was Rs. B5-7-0, and this was
being realised from Hari Behera and Brundu Anukul
Singh, two fishermen. It is not clear from this document in what status they were paying this amount and
what was the nature of their tenancy. Exhibit A is
a kabuliyat of the year 1845 by Brundu Anukul Singh
and Hari Behera in favour of Babu Mohan Bhagat
and Bibi Mobarak Nisa, and it shows that these two
fishermen took a lease of the fishing right in Devi
river on payment of Rs. 135 as rent, from the landlords. It was stated therein that these fishermen will
catch fish from these waters according to former custom and will pay "machidia sarbara" of Rs. 135 in
accordance with the instalments. There is no indication in the kabuliyat that these two persons were
executing it in a representative capacity or that the
lease taken by them was of a permanent character or
1951
RajaBf!ia
Sundar Dlb
v.
Marti.Btluwa
and Othm
Mahqjaa J,
440
1951
Raja BroJa
.Sundar Deb
v.
..Mani Behara
and Others.
Mahajan].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951]
that the rent payable was not liable to enhanceent in the future. It was contended on behalf of the
defendants that these two persons executed the kabuliyat in a representative capacity and on behalf of all the
fishermen who originally resided in four villages
of Killa Marichpur and who subsequently came to
reside in the nine villages mentioned in the plaint.
The only evidence placed on the record in support of
the suggestion and relied upon by the High Court is
the statement of D. \V. 11 who was born some time in
the year 1873, about 28 years after the execution of
the kabuliyat, and who has no special means of knowledge to depose as to the relationship of persons
mentioned in the kabuliyat with the defendants in the
present case or to know the capacity of persons who
executed the kabuliyat. It is not possible, therefore,
to hold that the kabuliyat was executed in a representative capacity by these two -persons and on behalf
of all the persons interested in the presenc controversy.
There is no evidence on the record to prove the .state
of affairs of this fishery between the years 1845 and
1873. Reliance . was placed bv the defendants on a
number of rent receipts produced by them in evidence.
The first of these is dated 30th .March, 1873, and was
executed by one of the Mahapatra co-sharers on
account of the instalment of fishery rent of "Charkbati"
paid through Hari Behera and Rama Behera in the
sum of Rs. 8-12-0. All the co-sharers were not parties
to this receipt and it is not stated what was the total
rent payable for the whole fishery. On the 11th May,
1875, another receipt was executed by Bibi Masudannisa and others, co-share.rs of five anna four pies in the
zamindari in favour of Hari Behera and Ananta Hehera
and others for a sum of Rs. 18. It seems that different
co-sharers were giving permission to different persons
to fish in the fishery on payment of certain sums of
money. There is no evidence whatsoever connecting
the receipt of 1873 given by two co-sharers to two
persons with the receipt given by
another set of
co-sharers to these two persons and it is not possible to
say that these payments were made towards a fixed
S.C.R,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
441
rent of Rs. 135-7-0 payable for the whole fishery.
The state of affairs of this fishery between 1876 to 1893
remains shrouded in mystery as no evidence for that
period has been filed on the record. On the 1st May,
1894, Mohan Bhagat's descendant gave a receipt to
Pandab Behera and Phagu Behera for Rs. 10, which
was to be set off against fishery rent. It is difficult to
connect this receipt with the other receipts or to treat
it as evidence in .support of the defendants' case of a
permanent tenancy. Similar receipts by different
co-sharers in favour of different persons were executed
on the 1st May, 1895, 5th May, 1896, 9th May, 1897,
and 22nd October, 1899 ; but in' none of those receipts
is any mention made of any fixed rental of Rs. 135-7-0
for the fishery in respect of the whole year and payable.
to all the landlords. A printed rent receipt on behalf
of one of the proprietors to Hurshi Behera and Agani
Bchera of village Alsahi was given on the 22nd October,
1899. The receipt relates to payment of tw:elv.e annas
· as arrears of fishery rent and in the receipt it is stated,
that the cash rent payable was Rs. 150. This receipt,
if it relates to the rent payable to all the co-sharers, is
inconsistent with th~ defendants' case that the fishery
had been leased out from time immemorial on a fixed
rent of Rs. 135-7-0. On the 23rd August, 1902, a
receipt was given on behalf of nine anna seven pie
co-sharers in the zamindari to Maguni Behera and Ram·
Behera of Kalia Kona· and to Sapani Behera of some
other village in the sum of Rs. 83-12,11 stating that
the amount of total. rent of which Rs. 83-12-11 w:as
the fractional share of these landlords was a sum of
Rs. 135-7-0. It was contended on behalf of the
defendants that the sum of Rs. 135-7-0 mentioned in
this receipt was the identical amount that was. men.
tione<l in the jamabandi of 1842 as P,?yable to the
zamindars as income of the jalker and from this entry
an inference should be drawn that the fishery had been
continuously leased for this sum from 1842 to the date
of this receipt. The coincidence reli!!d upon undoubtedly exists, but on that basis it is not possible to draw
the inference suggested as such an inference . would be
1951
RajaBraja
Sundar Deb
v.
Mani Beharac
and Othns.
Mahajan J ..
442
1951
liq/a Jhqja
-Swuiar 1"6
v.
Mofti &hara
""'1 Otiw1.
Ma/14ian].
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951]
of a conjectural nature. All these receipts are consist·
cnt with the contention of the plaintiff that from time
to time different co-sharers permitted different fishermen to fish in the· fishery on payment of a certain
rental. A receipt similar to the one above mentioned
was also executed on the 5th March, 1906, by certain
co-sharers owning eight pies in the zamindari in favour
of some fishermen, the annual rent ·being Rs. 135-7-0.
The "Remarks Column" states that i~ the rent is more
than mentioned therein, the further amourtt due would
be made good. Same remarks arc applicable to this
receipt as to the previous one. The next rent receipt
is dated 19th April, 1907, and is for a sum of
Rs. 168-6-0. No inference either way can be drawn
from this receipt. On the 21st June, 1912, a receipt
was given in favour of twelve persons in respect of rent
for the year 1317. The receipt was given by the nine
anna seven pie co-sharer in the zamindari but it is not
clear how this amount was made up. On the 4th
February, 1914, a receipt was given by an eight pie
co-sharer in the zamindari to 174 persons, aescribed as
tenants and residing in different villages of the zamindari for a sum of Rs. 5-13-0 as rent for the year 1319.
The entry in the "Remarks" column is similar to the
receipt above mentioned. The amount of annual rent
is mentioned as Rs. 135-7-0 and it is stated that it is
being paid in accordance with a decree of court No. 181.
It ·is difficult to connect this receipt with the other
documents previously discussed. Another receipt dated
30th March, 1914, was given by nine anna seven pie
co-sharers in the fishery to twelve persons for the year
1320. It seems to us that these occasional receipts
given to different persons by different sets of co-sharers
can lead to no definite conclusion in regard to the
rights of the parties. They are consistent with the case
argued on behalf of the plaintiff that by leave and
licence a number of fishermen used to fish in the
waters from time to time and they do not necessarily
lead to the inference of the existence of a permanent
tenancy of the fishery in favour of the defendants on
a fixed rent of Rs. 135-7-0.
S.C.R.
"'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
443
By a registered deed dated 24th May, 1914, the
plaintiff for the first time acquired an eight pie interest
in the zamindari in the name of Smt. Mahisthali
Patamahadei, his wife, from one Balaram Das Bhagat,
.a descendant of Mohan Bhagat. Subsequently he in
his own name and sometimes in the name of the Rani
purchased some further shares in the zarnindari and
eventually became the owner of seven anna seven pie
.and ten kranth share in it. The acquisition of interest
by the plaintiff (Raja of Aul) in the zamindari coincides with the period of the first world war, the
.aftermath, of which was a rise in prices. Fish which
was a cheap commodity and brought no appreciable
income to the · fishermen or to the owners became a
s111urce of considerable income and this circumstance
led to disputes between the owners of the fishery and
the fishermen. A number of letters of the years 1914
to 1918 have been proved on behalf of the plaintiff
:showing that he was deriving income from this fishery.
Similar letters for subsequent periods have also been
proved but no regular accounts of the income so realized
were produced in the case. The enhanced income of
the fishery created a scramble for its possession between the landlords and the fishermen and there was
an apprehension of a breach of pc;tce which resulted
in proceedings under section 145, Criminal Procedure
Code. A report was made to the police on the 11th
February, 1918, that a dispute had arisen which was
likely to cause a breach of the peace between the landlords of Killa Marichpur and twelve fishermen in
regard to the possession of Charikhati fisheries in Debi
river. The Magistrate on receipt of the police repotl
issued notice to the parties for the 19th February,
1918, and decided the case on. the 10th June, 1918.
From his order it appears that notice was given to all
concerned and they were irivited to put their respective
claims as regards the facts of the actual possession of
the fishery in dispute before him. On behalf of certain
co-sharers evidence was led to prove that they were in
possession of the fishery through one Sundari Behera
and other fishermen numbering about 100. The Rani
1951
&ija Bri ·a
Sundar 'Eb
v.
Moni Be/UJra
and Othlrs•
Mahajan],_
444
1951
114fer· Brqja
Sund"' Deb
v.
MOllilhhara
and Olhtrt.
Ma!iqjanJ.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ 1951)
of Aul who had then eight pie interest in the zamindari
as benamidar of her husband led evidence to establish
that she was in possession of the fishery through
fishermen employed by her agent. Ram Behera,
Hrushi Behera and other fishermen of the second · party,
twelve in number, led evidence to show that. they were
in possession of the fishery on payment of rent and
that the owners of the. zamindari had never been in
actual possession of the fishery.. The Magistrate found
that this contention was true. He disbelieved the story
of the witnesses produced by the Rani of Aul, and also
rejected the testimony of the witnesses produced by
othc1 owners. Some Aul fishermen were produced on
behalf of the Rani but their evidence was also not
accepted. The same kind of documentary evidence that
has been placed on this record on behalf of the plaintiff
wn also placed before the Magistrate but it was not
acceptea by him. From these proceedings, it further
appears that all the sixteen anna owners of Killa Marichpur issued a notice to the. second party, the fishermen,
for surrendering possession of the fishery with effect
from September, 1917, but after service of notice they
took no legal steps to eject them from possession of
the fishery ; on the other hand, they took the law into
their own hands and made attempts to take forcible
possession of the fishery. These attempts, however,
were unsuccessful. The result of these proceedings was
that the Magistarte found that the fishermen (the
second party) were in possession of the disputed fishery
and he directd the issue of an order declaring their
possession until evicted therefrom in due course of law
and forbidding all disturbance of such possession until
such eviction. This order indicates that though all the
landlords were not named as parties in the case, yet
all of them had notice of the proceedings and all of
them were actually interested in turning out the fishermen from possession by forcible means, and notice
had been given to them on behalf of all of them. It
also appears from those proceedings that though one
dozen people were named as second party in the case
there were certain other persons also interested in the
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
445
fishery along with them, but it is difficult to ascertain
their nwnber, names and addresses from these proceedings. Evidence has been led on behalf of the plaintiff
to prove that afrer the· determination of these proceeding5 the plaintiff has been deriving income from this
fishery by leasing }}is right through the agency of
fishermen of Aul. The High Court has not placed any
reliance on this evidence and, in our opinion, rightly.
It is not possible to believe that after a successful fight
in the criminal court, the fishermen would have allowed
the men of the Raja or of the Rani to fish in these
waters during the Hilsa season. Both parties led oral
evidence to prove that each party exercised exclusive
right of fishing during Hilsa season in the fishery. We
have been taken through the evidence and after
examining it, have reached the conclusion that it is of
an unsatisfactory character and valuable rights cannot
be decided on its footing. No steps were taken by the
landlords to question the order of the
Magistrate
within three years from its date as required by
article 47 of the Limitation Act. The landlords, how~
ever, refused to receive any rent from these persons·
after the termination of the proceedings and they have
been depositing it in court under the provisions of the
Orissa Tenancy Act.
The last purchase by the Raja of Aul of some interest
in the zamindari was made in the year 1935 and
having acquired by this date a substantial interest in
it and having discovered that the fishery was a paying
proposition, he brought this suit in the year 1936 on
the allegations set out above and asserted that since
about three years the defendants had started disturb..
ing his possession of the fishery in dispute. In the
circumstances mentioned above this assertion cannot
be taken seriously. In order to get out of the effects
· of the proceedings urider section 145, Criminal Procedure Code, he alleged that he had been in possession
of the fishery in spite of the proceedings taken under
that section and that his possession had only been
disturbed recently. The evidence on this point was
2-62 S. C. India/58
1951
R4fa Br<!fo;
SOllrttlar D11>
v.
M""i lhltllrt1
tl1ld Oth1r1.
Moluija11J.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1951
Riga Br1!i4
Su"'1ar Ih6
[l~l]
rejected by the High Court and we sec no reason to
disagree with that finding.
It is now convenient to consider the different points
canvassed before us by the learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the parties. We find it difficult to uphold
the view of the High Court that the defendants were
in possession of the disputed fishery under a lost g~ant.
This doctrine has no application to the case of inhabitants of particular loc;ilities seeking to establish rights
of user to some piece of land or water. As pointed out
by Lord Radcliffe in Lakshmidhar Misra V. Rangalal ( 1 )
the doctrine of lost grant originated as a technical
device to enable title to be made by prescription despite the impossibility of proving immemorial user and
that since it originated in grant, its owners, whether
original or by devolution, had to be such persons as
were capable of being the recipients of a grant, and
that a right exercisable by the inhabitants of a village
from time to time is neither attached to any estate in
land nor is it such a right as is capable of being made
the subject of a grant, there being no admissible
grantees. Reference in this connection may be made
to a Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court in
Asrabulla V. Kiamatulla(•) wherein the law on this
subject has been examined in some detail. In that
case the question arose whether the right of pasturage
claimed by a whole body of villagers could be acquired
by grant, express or presumed. Aft,r an examination
of a ·number of English and Indian cases it was held
that no lost grant could be presumed in favour of a
Buetuating and unascertained body of persons who
constitute the inhabitants of a village and that such a
right could only be acquired by custom. The defendants in this case are a fluctuating body of persons
and their number increases or decreases by each birth
or death or by influx or clBux of fishermen to or from
these villages. From the evidence of D. V•!. 11 it appears
that formerly the Kouts (fishermen) claiming the right
to fish were residents of four villages, then some of
them shifted to other villages on account of their
(1) A.l.R. 1950 P.C. 56.
(•) A.l.R. 1937 Cal. •45.
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
447
houses being washed away, and settled themselves in
-other villages. At the time of the suit they were residing in nine villages. He further deposed that during
the last ten or twelve years there were 600 bohanias
and that· their families increased, their present number being 846. It is in evidence that since this evidence
was given their number has gone up to 1500. From
the documentary evidence it appears that up to the
year 1918 their number was not very large. Only
.twelve persons were impleaded in the section 145,
Criminal Procedure Code, proceedings ·and it was said
that there were som~ more interested. The maximum
number given in one or two receipts is 174.
It is again not possible to hold that the fishermen
residing in these villages arc a corporate body and
that being fishermen by profession it has the effect of
incorporating them. We find ourselves unable to sub:Scribe to the view of the High Court that the defendants constitute some kind of a unit simply because
they are a body having a common interest to fish in
this fishery; unless the defendants-fishermen form a
corporate body, or it is found that a trust was created
for their benefit, such a body of persons could acquire
no right by the doctrine of lost grant. A right to fish
from the fishery based on mere inhabitancy is capable
of an increase almost indefinite and if the right exists
in a body which might increase in number it would
necessarily lead to the destruction of the subject
matter of the grantt Moreover, there could not be a
valid grant to a body so incapable of succession in any
reasonable sense of the word, so as to confer a right
upon each succeeding inhabitant.
For the reasons given above, the defendants' right to
remain in possession of the fishery on the basis of ::i
lost grant or on the basis of prescription or adverse
possession stands negatived. All that appears from
the evidence is that a number of fishermen from time
to time have been. exercising the right of fishing with
the leave and licence of some of the owners. This is
not sufficient for the acquisition of the right either by
1951
Raja Braja
Sundar Dt~
v.
Mani Bthara
and Others.
Mahajan J.
448
1951
Raja BraJa
$uNlar D16
v.
•«ttni Bthara
.JIUi 0th,,,.
-'lfalugan ]_.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1951}
adverse possession or by prescription. Further, no
finding can be given in their favour as the evidence
does not establish that they have been paying uniformly the same amount of rent.
The next finding of the High Court that the landlords have lost their right to khas possession of the
fishery in dispute by reason of the operation of article 47
of the Indian Limitation Act is, in our opinion, sound.
The High Court, however, was not right in holding
that the order made in the section 145, Criminal
Procedure Code, proceedings was not binding on the
plaintiff to the extent of five pies share. Its true scope
and effect do not seem to have been fully appreciated.
The order appears to have been made after nqtice to
:ill the landlords and was brought about by reason of
the action of all of them and binds the full sixteen
a1llla interest in the zamindari. In clear and unambiguous terms the Magistrate declared that the second
party were in exclusive possession of the disputed
fishery and that the landlords had no right to disturb
their possession and they were directed to being a suit
to establish their right to possession. This they failed
to do with the result that the order became final and
the right of the landlords to get into possession of the
fishery became extinguished. This order therefore
affirmed the defendants' possession of the fishery on
payment of a certain rental. This right, however, can
only be exercised by those who were parties to the
section 145, Criminal Procedure Code, proceedings or
their successors in interest. It was argued by the
learned counsel for the appellant that the proceedings
that took place in the year 1918 were in substance
under section 147, Criminal Procedure Code, and were
wrongly labelled under section 145 of the Code. We
are not able to accede to this contention because the
dispute raised in the year 1918 related to possession of
the fishery itself and was a dispute concerning any
water or the boundaries thereof in the language of
section 145, Criminal Procedure Code. Sub-section 2 of
section 145 provides that for the purpose of the section
the expression "land or water" includes fisheries. It
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT. REPORTS
was then argued that in any case the benefit of· the
order made under section 145, Criminal Procedure Code,
could only be taken by the persons in whose favour
that order was made ani:l that it could not operate for
the benefit of all the 846 fishermen represented by ·the
eighteen defendants or in favour ·,of all fishermen who
would oome to reside in these nine villages in times to
come. In our opinion, this contention bas force and
the High Court was in error in holding otherwise.
There is no evidence whatsoever to show · that besides
the twelve persons mentioned as second party in the
section 145, Criminal Procedure Code, proceedings who
else was represented by · them and we are therefore
bound ·to hold that the benefit of that order can only
be given to those defendants who arc . represented by
those twelve persons. The learned counsel for the
appellant gave us a list of the persons who were parties
in Section 145 proceedings and of those out of the
<lefendants who stand in their shoes. According to
this list, defendants 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 7, 9 and 12 are the
persons· who themselves or through their predecessors
in interest were parties in the former case arid are
entitled to the benefit of the result of those proceedings. ·
All the other defendants, whether impleaded' personally
in this suit or in a representative capacity, or those
whom they represent, are not entitled to take advantage
<>f those proceedings. · The result therefore is that the
<lefcndants above mentioned only are entitled to
remain in possession of . the fishery on payment of a
rent of Rs. 135-7-0 per annum till it is enhanced in
due course of law or for good cause ·they lose their
right to remain in possession of the fishery. In an
earlier litigation it has been decided that the right to
possession of the fishery for fishing during Hilsa season
is not assignable or transferable, it however can be
enjoyed by the heirs and successors.
The contention that there has been a change in the
of the river and that the fishery now in ,
dispute is not the same fishery which was in dispute
on the proceedings of 1918 cannot be sustained. We
see no reason to differ from the view of the High Court,
~ourse
1951
RajaBroja
Sundar D•b
v.
Mooi Behara
and Othtrs.
Mahajan J,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
1951
RajaBrl.Jia
S.Niar Di•
v.
Moni Bl/wo
and Ot!Ws.
•Vahaju].
[1951]
that the change in the course of the river has not in any
way affected the defendants' possession as the channels.
whether old or new, which comprise the Madhurdia or
Charkhati fishery form one connected sheet of water.
It is well settled that the fish follow the course of the
river and the fishermen follow the fish .
It was then argued that an exclusive right of fishing.
could not be acquired in respect of a particular kind.
of fish and during any particular season. This argument is not tenable in view of section 145, Criminal
.Procedure Code,. proceedings. Moreover an exclusive:
right of fishing in a given place means that no other
person has a coextensive right with the claimant of the:
right. The niere fact that some other person has a
right to a particular class of fish in the fishery or that
another person is entitled to fish at a, certain time of
the year does not destroy die right of exclusive fishing .
in any manner (Vide Halsbury's Laws of England,.
Hailsham Edn., Vol. 15, para. 59).
The result is that . the appeal is · allowed partially.
the decree of the. High . Court is modified and the:
plaintiff's suit for· a declaration and injunction is decreed ·
as follows :-'· ·
(i) It is declared that the plaintiff is entitled to fish
in the disputed fishery except during the Hilsa · season
( Margasir to Daisakh) during which season defendants l, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9 and 12 have an. exclusive right of
fishing in the fishery in respect. to Hilsa fish which
right they can exercise either personally or with the
help of other fishermen, on payment of a rent of
Rs. 135-7-0 per year till it is enhanced in due · course
?f law o~ for food cause they lose their right to remain
· .
m possess10n o the fishery ;·
(ii) The defendants are · restrained. ftom interfering with his right· of fishing during the months during
which the defendants named above have not the
exclusive right of fishing;
(iii) That defendants other than defendants I, 2, 3,
5, 6, 7, 9 and 12 have no right of any kind whatsoever
S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
451
.RAM SINGH
"·
THE STATE Of DELHI AND ANOTHER
BALRAJ KHANNA
t'.
THE STATE OF DELHI AND ANOTHER
RAM NATH KALIA.
• t'.
THE STATE OF DELHI AND ANOTHER
c. J.,
[SHRI HARILAL KANIA
PATANJALI SASTRI,
MEHR CHAND MAHAJAN, S. R. DAs and VIVIAN
BosE JJ.J
Constitution of lnaia, Arts. 19(1) & (2), 22 (5)-Freedom of
speech-Preventive detention to prevent speeches with a view to maintain public ordei-Omission to state objectionable passages ill
grounds supplied-Legality of detention.
The District Magistrate of Delhi, "being satisfied that with
a view to the maintenance of public order in Delhi it is necessary
to do so" ordered the detention of the petitioners under s. 3 of
the Preventive Detention Act, 1950. The grounds of detention
communicated to the petitioners were "that your · speeches
generally in the past and particularly on the 13th and 15th
August, 1950, at public meetings in Delhi has been such as to
excite disaffection between Hindus and Mussalmans and thereby
prejudice the maintenance of public order in Delhi and that in
order to prevent you from making sucft speeches it is necessary
to make the said order." The petitioners contended that under
the Constitution the maintenance of public order was not a purpose for which restriction can be imposed on the freedom of
1951
Jfpil, 6.
Report an error or ask for masking: grievance@lawgrids.org