High_Court_of_Himachal_Pradesh_Case_Flow_Management_Subordinate_Courts_ Rules_2005
Rules made under The Himachal Pradesh Courts Act, 1976
- Made under: The Himachal Pradesh Courts Act, 1976
This text is shown as one document.
Full text
1
HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,SHIMLA–171001
No. HHC/Rules/C.P.ADR/05- Dated 19.12.2005
NOTIFICATION
HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH CASE FLOW
MANAGEMENT (SUBORDINATE COURTS) RULES, 2005
In exercise of the powers conferred by Part X of the Code
of Civil Procedure 1908, (5 of 1908), Section 29 of Himachal Pradesh Courts
Act, 1976 (23 of 1976) and all other powers enabling it, the High Court of
Himachal Pradesh hereby makes the following Rules, in regard to case flow
management in the subordinate courts in the State of Himachal Pradesh.
Title 1 1) These Rules shall be called High Court
of Himachal Pradesh Case Flow
Management (Subordinate Courts)
Rules, 2005.
2) These Rules shall come into force from
the date of publication in the official
gazette.
Division of Civil
Suits and appeals
into tracks
2 1) Based on the nature of dispute, the
quantum of evidence to be recorded
and the time likely to be taken for the
completion of suit, the suits shall be
channeled into different tracks. Track 1
may include suits for maintenance,
divorce and child custody and visitation
rights, grant of letters of administration
and succession certificate and simple
suits for rent or for eviction (upon
notice under Section 106 of Transfer of
Property Act). Track 2 may consist of
money suits and suits based solely on
negotiable instruments. Track 3 may
include suits concerning partition and
like property disputes, trademarks,
copyrights and other intellectual
2
property matters. Track 4 may relate to
other matters. All efforts shall be taken
to complete the suits in track 1 within a
period of 9 months, track 2 within 12
months and suits in track 3 and 4
within 24 months.
Note:- It will be for the judge
concerned to make an appropriate
assessment as to which track any case
can be assigned.
2) Once in a month, the administrative
staff of each Court shall prepare a
report as to the stage and progress of
cases which are proposed to be listed in
next month and place the report before
the Court. When the matters are listed
on each day, the Judge concerned may
take such decision as he may deem fit
in the presence of counsel/parties in
regard to each case for removing any
obstacles in service of summons,
completion of pleadings etc. with a view
to make the case ready for disposal.
3) The Judge referred to in clause (2)
above may shift a case from one track
to another depending upon the
complexity and other circumstances of
the case.
4) Where computerization is available, the
monthly data will be fed into the
computer in such a manner that the
judge referred to in clause (2) above,
will be able to ascertain the position
and the stage of every case in every
3
track from the computer screen. Over a
period, all cases pending in his Court
will be covered. Where computerization
is not available, the monitoring must be
done manually.
5) The judge referred to in clause (2)
above, shall monitor and control the
flow or progress of every case, either
from the computer or from the register
or data placed before him in the above
manner or in some other manner he
may innovate.
ORIGINAL SUIT
Fixation of time
limits while issuing
notice
3 The following time limits while issuing notice
shall be observed.
(a) Wherever notice is issued in a suit, the
notice should indicate that the Code
prescribes a maximum of 30 days for
filing written statement (which for
special reasons may be extended up to
90 days) and, therefore, the defendants
may prepare the written statement
expeditiously and that the matter will
be listed for that purpose on the expiry
of eight weeks from the date of issue of
notice (so that it can be a definite date).
After the written statement is filed, the
replication (if any, proposed and
permitted), should be filed within six
weeks of receipt of the written
statement. If there are more than one
defendant, each one of the defendants
should comply with this requirement
within the time limit.
4
(b) The notice referred to in clause (a) shall
be accompanied by a complete copy of
the plaint and all its
annexure/enclosures and copies of the
interlocutory application, if any.
(c) If interlocutory applications are filed
along with the plaint, and if an ex-
parte interim order is not passed and
the Court is desirous of hearing the
respondent, it may, while sending
the notice along with the plaint, fix
an earlier date for the hearing of the
application (than the date for filing
written statement) depending upon
the urgency for interim relief.
Service of
Summons/notice
and completion of
pleadings
4 In this connection the following guidelines
shall be observed:
(a) Summons may be served as indicated
in clause (3) of Rule 9 of Order V of
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
(b) In the case of service of summons by
the plaintiff or a courier where a return
is filed that the defendants has refused
notice, the return will be accompanied
by an undertaking that the plaintiff or
the courier, as the case may be, is
aware that if the return is found to be
false, he can be punished for perjury or
summarily dealt with for contempt of
Court for abuse of the provisions of the
Code. Where the plaintiff comes forward
with a return of ‘refusal’ the provisions
of Order 9A Rule (4) CPC will be
followed by re-issue of summons
5
through Court.
(c) If it has not been possible to effect
service of summons under Rule 9 of
Order V CPC, the provisions of Rule 17
of Order V CPC shall apply and the
plaintiff shall within 7 days from the
date of its inability to serve the
summons, to request the Court to
permit substituted service. The dates
for filing the written statement and
replication, if any, shall accordingly
stand extended.
Calling of Cases
(Hajri) or Call Work
or Roll Call
5 The present practice of the Reader calling all
the cases listed on a particular day at the
beginning of the day in order to confirm
whether counsel are ready, whether parties
are present or whether various steps in the
suit or proceeding has been taken, is
consuming a lot of time of the Court,
sometimes almost two hours of the best part
of the day when the judge is fresh. After such
work, the Court is left with very limited time to
deal with cases listed before it. Formal listing
should be first before a senior officer of the
Court to be nominated by the District Judge
in respect of each court under his
administrative control, one or two days before
the listing in Court. He may give dates in
routine matters for compliance with earlier
orders of Court. Cases will be listed before
Court only where an order of the Court is
necessary or where an order prescribing the
consequences of default or where a
peremptory order or an order as to costs is
required to be passed on the judicial side.
6
Cases which have to be adjourned as a matter
of routine for taking steps in the suit or
proceeding should not be unnecessarily listed
before Court. Where parties/counsel are not
attending before the court officer or are defiant
or negligent, their cases may be placed before
the Court. Listing of cases on any day before a
Court should be based on a reasonable
estimate of time and number of cases that can
be disposed of by the Court in a particular
day. The Courts shall, therefore, dispense with
the practice of calling all the cases listed
adjourned to any particular day. Cases will be
first listed before a nominated senior officer of
the Court, nominated for the purpose.
Procedure on the
grant of interim
orders
6 The following guidelines shall be observed by
the subordinate Courts:-
(a) If an interim order is granted at the first
hearing by the Court, the defendants
would have the option of moving
appropriate applications for vacating
the interim order even before the
returnable date indicated in the notice
and if such an application is filed, it
shall be listed as soon as possible even
before the returnable date.
(b) If the Court passes an ad-interim ex-
parte order in an interlocutory
application, and the reply by the
defendants if filed, and if, thereafter,
the plaintiff fails to file the rejoinder (if
any) without good reason for the delay,
the Court has to consider whether the
stay or interim order passed by the
7
Court should be vacated and shall list
the case with that purpose. This is
meant to prevent parties taking
adjournment with a view to have undue
benefit of the ad-interim orders. The
plaintiff may, if he so chooses, also
waive his right to file a rejoinder. A
communication of option by the
plaintiff not to file a rejoinder, made to
the Court Officer will be deemed to be
the completion of pleadings in the
interlocutory application.
Reference to
Alternate Dispute
Resolution
7 In the hearing before the Court, after
completion of pleadings, time limit for
discovery and inspection, and admission and
denials, of documents shall be four weeks.
After the completion of admission and denial
of documents by the parties, the suit shall be
listed before the Court (for examination of
parties under Order X of the Civil Procedure
Code. A joint statement of admitted facts shall
be filed before the said date). The Court shall
thereafter, follow the procedure prescribed
under the Alternative Dispute Resolution and
Mediation Rules, 2002.
Procedure on the
failure of Alternate
Dispute Resolution
8 1) On the filing of report by the Mediator
under the Mediation Rules that efforts
at Mediation have failed or a report by
the Conciliator under the provisions of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, or a report of no settlement in the
Lok Adalat under the provisions of the
Legal Services Authority Act, 1987 the
suit shall be listed before the Court
Officer within a period of 14 days. At
8
the said hearing before the Court
Officer, all the parties shall submit the
draft issues proposed by them. The suit
shall be listed before the Court within
14 days thereafter for framing of issues.
2) When the suit is listed after failure of
the attempts at conciliation, arbitration
or Lok Adalat, the judge may merely
inquire whether it is still possible for
the parties to resolve the dispute. This
should invariably be done by the judge
at the first hearing when the matter
comes back on failure of conciliation,
mediation or Lok Adalat.
3) If the parties are not keen about
settlement, the Court shall frame the
issues and direct the plaintiff to start
examining his witnesses. The procedure
of each witness filing his examination-
in-chief affidavit and being examined in
cross or re-examination will continue,
one after the other. After completion of
evidence on the plaintiffs side, the
defendants shall lead evidence likewise,
witness after witness, the chief
examination of each witness being by
affidavit and the witness being then
cross-examined or re-examined. The
parties shall keep the affidavit in chief
examination ready whenever the
witness’s examination is taken up. As
far as possible, evidence must be taken
up day by day as stated in clause (a) of
proviso to Rule 2 of Order XVII. The
parties shall also indicate the likely
9
duration for the evidence to be
completed, and for the arguments to be
thereafter heard. The judge shall
ascertain the availability of time of the
Court and will list the matter for trial
on a date when the trial can go on from
day to day and conclude the evidence.
The possibility of further negotiation
and settlement should be kept open
and if such a settlement takes place, it
should be open to the parties to move
the Court Officer for getting the matter
listed at an earlier date for disposal.
Reference to
Commissioner for
recording of
evidence
9 Regarding referring the matter for recording of
evidence to the Commissioner, the following
instruction shall be observed:-
(a) The High Court shall after conducting
an examination of eligible advocates on
the subjects of the Code of Civil
Procedure and Evidence Act, shall
appoint them as Commissioners for
recording evidence. They shall be
ranked according to the marks secured
by them in such examination.
(b) It is not necessary that in every case
the Court should appoint a
Commissioner for recording evidence.
Only if the recording of evidence is
likely to take a long time, or there are
any other special grounds, should the
Court consider appointing a
Commissioner for recording the
evidence. The Court should direct that
the matter be listed for arguments
fifteen days after the Commissioner files
10
his report with the evidence.
Note:- The Court may initially fix
a specific period for the completion of
the recording of the evidence by the
Commissioner and direct the matter to
be listed on the date of expiry of the
period, so that Court may know
whether the parties are co-operating
with the Commissioner and whether
the recording of evidence is getting
unnecessarily prolonged.
(c) Commissioners should file an
undertaking in Court upon their
appointment that they will keep the
records handed over to them and those
that may be filed before them, safe and
shall not allow any party to inspect
them in the absence of the opposite
party/counsel. If there is delay of more
than one month in the dates fixed for
recording evidence, it is advisable for
them to return the file to the Court and
take it back on the eve of the adjourned
date.
Costs 10 So far as awarding of costs at the time of
judgment is concerned, awarding of costs
must be treated generally as mandatory in as
much as the liberal attitude of the Courts in
directing the parties to bear their own costs
had led parties to file a number of frivolous
cases in the Courts or to raise frivolous and
unnecessary issues. Cost should invariably
follow the event. Where a party succeeds
ultimately on one issue or point but loses on
number of other issues or points which were
11
unnecessarily raised, costs must be
appropriately apportioned. Special reasons
must be assigned if costs are not being
awarded. Costs should be assessed according
to rules in force. If any of the parties has
unreasonably protracted the proceedings, the
judge should consider exercising discretion to
impose exemplary costs after taking into
account the expense incurred for the purpose
of attendance on the adjourned dates.
Proceedings for
perjury
11 If the Trial Judge, while delivering the
judgment, is of the view that any of the
parties or witnesses have willfully and
deliberately uttered blatant falsehoods, he
shall consider (at least in some grave cases)
whether it is a fit case where prosecution
should be initiated for perjury and order
prosecution accordingly.
Adjournments 12 The amendments to the Code have restricted
the number of adjournments to three in the
course of hearing of the suit, on reasonable
cause being shown. When a suit is listed
before a Court and any party seeks
adjournments, the Court shall have to verify
whether the party is seeking adjournment due
to circumstances beyond the control of the
party, as required by clause (b) of proviso to
Rule 2 of Order XVII. The Court shall impose
costs as specified in Rule 2 of Order XVII.
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATIONS
13 The proceedings in a suit shall not be stayed
merely because of the filing of Miscellaneous
Application in the course of suit unless the
Court in its discretion expressly thinks it
12
necessary to stay the proceedings in the suit.
FIRST APPEALS TO SUBORDINATE COURTS
Service of Notice of
Appeal
14 1) First Appeals being appeals on question
of fact and law, courts are generally
inclined to admit the appeal and it is
only in exceptional cases that the
appeal is rejected at the admission
stage under Rule 11 of Order XLI CPC.
In view of the amended CPC, a copy of
the memorandum of appeal is required
to be filed in the subordinate Courts. It
is clarified that the requirement of filing
a copy of appeal memorandum in the
sub-ordinate Court does not mean that
appeal memorandum cannot be filed in
the Appellate Court immediately for
obtaining interim orders.
2) Advance notice should simultaneously
be given by the counsel for the party,
who is proposing to file the appeal, to
the counsel for the opposite party who
appeared in the Subordinate Court so
as to enable the respondents to appear
if they so choose, even at the first
hearing stage.
Essential
Documents to be
filed with the
Memorandum of
Appeal
15 The Appellant shall, as far as possible, file,
along with the appeal, copies of essential
documents marked in the suit for the purpose
of enabling the appellate court to understand
the points raised or for purpose of passing
interim orders.
Fixation of time
limits in
16 Whenever notice is issued by the appellate
Court in interlocutory matters, the notice
13
interlocutory
matters
should indicate the date by which the reply
should be filed. The rejoinder, if any, should
be filed within four weeks of receipt of the
reply. If there are more parties than one who
are respondents, each one of the respondent
should comply with this requirement within
the time limit and the rejoinder may be filed
within four weeks from the receipt of the last
reply.
Steps for
completion of all
formalities/(Call
Work) (Hajri)
17 The appeal shall be listed before the Court
Officer for completion of all formalities
necessary before the appeal is taken up for
final hearing. The procedure indicated above
of listing the case before a senior officer of the
appellate court for giving dates in routine
matter must be followed to reduce the ‘call
work’ (Hajri) and only where judicial orders
are necessary such cases should be listed
before Court.
Procedure on grant
of Interim-orders
18 1) If an interim order is granted at the first
hearing by the Court, the respondents
would have the option of moving
appropriate applications for vacating
the interim order even before the
returnable date indicated in the notice
and if such an application is filed, it
shall be listed as soon as possible even
before the returnable date.
2) If the Court passes an ad-interim ex-
parte order and if the reply is filed by
the respondents and if, without good
reason, the appellant fails to file the
rejoinder, Court shall consider whether
it is a fit case for vacating the stay or
interim order and list the case for that
14
purpose. This is intended to see that
those who have obtained ad interim
orders do not procrastinate in filing
replies. The appellant may also waive
his right to file the rejoinder. Such
choice shall be conveyed to the Court
Officer on or before the date fixed for
filing of rejoinder. Such communication
of option by the applicant to the Court
Officer will be deemed to be completion
of pleadings.
Filing of Written
Submissions
19 1) Both the appellants and the
respondents shall submit their written
submissions two weeks before the
commencement of the arguments in the
appeal. The cause list should indicate if
written submissions have been filed or
not. Wherever they have not been filed,
the Court must insist on their being
filed within a particular period to be
fixed by the Court and each party must
serve a copy thereof on the opposite
side before the date of commencement
of arguments. There is no question of
parties filing replies to each other’s
written submissions.
2) The Court may consider having a
Caution List/Alternative List to take
care of eventualities when a case does
not go on before a court and those
cases may be listed before a Court
where for any reason the scheduled
cases are not taken up for hearing.
Costs 20 Awarding of costs must be treated generally as
mandatory in as much as it is the liberal
15
attitude of the Courts in not awarding costs
that has led to frivolous points being raised in
appeals or frivolous appeals being filed in the
courts. Costs should invariably follow the
event and reasons must be assigned by the
appellate Court for not awarding costs. If any
of the parties have unreasonably protracted
the proceedings, the judge shall have the
discretion to impose exemplary costs after
taking into account the costs that may have
been imposed at the time of adjournments.
Application/petition
under special Acts
21 The Practice/ directions in regard to Original
Suits should mutatis mutandis apply in
respect of such applications/petitions filed
under Special Acts like the Industrial Disputes
Act, Hindu Marriage Act, Indian Succession
Act.
CRIMINAL TRIALS AND CRIMINAL APPEALS TO
SUBORDINATE COURTS
Criminal trials 22 1) Criminal trials should be classified
based on offence, sentence and whether
the accused is on bail or in jail. Capital
punishment, rape and cases involving
sexual offences or dowry deaths should
be kept in Track 1. Other cases where
the accused is not granted bail and is
in jail, should be kept in Track II. Cases
which affect a large number of persons
such as cases of mass cheating,
economic offences, illicit liquor tragedy
and food adulteration cases, etc. should
be kept in Track III. Offences which are
tried by special courts such as POTA,
TADA, NDPS, Prevention of Corruption
16
Act, etc. should be kept in Track IV
while cases involving all other offences
shall be kept in Track V.
2) The endeavor should be to complete
Track 1 cases within a period of nine
months. Track II and Track III cases
within twelve months and Track IV
within fifteen months.
Note: The High Court may
classify criminal appeals pending before
it into different tracks on the same lines
mentioned above.
Criminal appeals 23 1) Wherever an appeal is filed by a person
in jail, and also when appeals are filed
by State as far as possible, the
memorandum of appeal may be
accompanied by important documents,
if any, having a bearing on the question
of bail.
2) In respect of appeals filed against
acquittals, steps for appointment of
amicus curiae or State Legal Aid
counsel in respect of the accused who
do not have a lawyer of their own
should be undertaken by the
Court/(State Legal Services Authority)
immediately after completion of four
weeks of service of notice. It shall be
presumed that in such an event the
accused is not in a position to appoint
counsel.
3) Advance notice should simultaneously
be given by the counsel for the party
who is proposing to file the appeal to
the counsel for the opposite party in the
17
subordinate Court, so as to enable the
other party to appear if they so choose
even at the first hearing stage.
Notice issued under
S. 80 of Code of
Civil Procedure
24 Every public authority shall appoint an officer
responsible to take appropriate action on a
notice issued under S. 80 of the Code of Civil
Procedure. Every such officer shall take
appropriate action on receipt of such notice. If
the Court finds that the concerned officer, on
receipt of the notice, failed to take necessary
action or was negligent in taking the
necessary steps, the Court shall hold such
officer responsible and recommend
appropriate disciplinary action by the
concerned authority.
In-consistency
between these rules
and provisions of
CPC or Cr.P.C
25 Whenever there is any inconsistency between
these rules and the provisions of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Code of Criminal
Procedure 1973 or the Himachal Pradesh
Courts Act, 1976 or any other statutes, the
provisions of such Codes and Statues shall
prevail.
BY ORDER
REGISTRAR (RULES)