the Karnataka Civil Services (Validation of Selection and appointment of 2011 batch Gazettedprobationers) Act, 2022.
Karnataka Act
- Act 14 of 2022
- Enacted: 2022-03-14
- Ministry: NO MINISTRY
- Department: Department of Personnel & Administrative Reforms
- Status: no repeal is recorded
The text of this Act is shown as one document.
Full text
KARNATAKA ACT NO. 14 OF 2022
THE KARNATAKA CIVIL SERVICES (VALIDATION OF SELECTION AND
APPOINTMENT OF 2011 BATCH GAZETTED PROBATIONERS) ACT, 2022
Arrangement of Sections
Sections:
1. Short title and commencement
2. Definitions
3. Validation of selection of 2011 batch Gazetted Probationers
4. Power to remove difficulties
STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS
Act 14 OF 2022 Whereas in Notification dated 03.11.2011, applications were
invited by the Karnataka Public Service Commission from eligible candidates
for filling up of 362 Group-A and Group-B posts. The Preliminary Examination
was conducted on 22.04.2012. The main examination was held from
15.12.2012 to 06.01.2013. Result of the examination, was published on
21.03.2013.
Whereas Karnataka Public Service Commission had conducted the
interviews of qualified candidates from 07.05.02013 to 27.05.2013. When the
Viva-Voce had been conducted, a candidate by name Dr. Mythri H.P.S. had
made a complaint to the then Advocate General on 28.05.2013, in this process,
it was alleged that she [Dr. Mythri H.P.S] was eliminated and the candidate
below her, was selected to the post of the Assistant Commissioner. She also
alleged that demands were made by Dr. Mangala Sridhar, Member, KPSC to
pay bribe in order to ensure her selection.
Whereas pursuant thereto, a FIR was registered in the Vidhana Soudha
Police Station for the offences under Sections 341, 120-B, 418, 4230, 465 of
IPC and Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The Government,
by order dated 27.06.2013, directed the investigation to be conducted by the
C.I.D. In furtherance, the C.I.D. after investigation had submitted a
preliminary/interim report on 10.09.2013
Whereas based on the interim report, the Government issued
Government Order dated 15.10.2013/14.08.2014 cancelling the results of the
main competitive examination as also the Viva-Voce and directing the
Karnataka Public Service Commission to revaluate the answer script of the
main written examination and to conduct Viva-Voce, strictly in accordance
with the recommendations of HOTA Committee.
Whereas in the meantime some of the candidates had challenged the
action of the Government, by order dated 15.10.2013, by filing Applications
before the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal. Slowly, all the affected
candidates preferred applications before the Tribunal and the Tribunal granted
an „interim order‟ directing the State Government not to notify for the „362
posts‟ which was a subject matter of the 2011 Selection List, till the disposal of
the applications.
Whereas during the pendency of the proceedings before the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal, CID had submitted its final report and in its „final
report‟ had concluded that the officials, who are the then Member of the
Karnataka Public Service Commission shown as Accused Nos. 9 to 16 had
entered into criminal conspiracy and had misused the official machinery to do
favours for candidates seeking to be appointed as Group-A and B employees
under the 2011 Notification. The said 8 Accused persons have obtained illegal
gratifications from various candidates and had misused their office to grant
appointments for such illegal gratification and thereby had committed the
offences under Sections 120-B, 166, 167 of IPC R/w Section 13 (1) (d) and 13
(2) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 37 of IPC.
Whereas it is pertinent to note here that; although the names of certain
candidates find a place in the „charge sheet‟ for having maintained telephonic
contact with some of the Accused, none of them have, themselves been names
as Accused either in the charge sheet or in the FIR.
Whereas the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal, in the meantime, had
proceeded to hear the matter on merit. After hearing the matter, the Tribunal
by its order dated 19.10.2016, allowed the Applications and quashed the
Government Order dated 14.08.2014. The Tribunal thereafter directed the
State of Karnataka to issue orders of appointment to the Applicants in terms of
the provisions of Rule 11(3) of „1997‟ Rules, within a period of two months from
the date receipt of the copy of the order.
Whereas a perusal of the said charge sheet would show that, none of the
candidates who are either selected or had participated in the selection process
have been named as Accused persons. The gist of the charge sheet filed by the
C.I.D discloses that there is a commission of offence of criminal conspiracy by
the Chairman, Members and staff and some middlemen to favour certain
candidates who are otherwise ineligible or less meritorious by accepting illegal
gratifications. Who these candidates are, is not pointedly forthcoming in the
report of the C.I.D.
Whereas where these candidates have paid illegal gratification to the
Members or the middlemen is also not very forthcoming in the charge sheet. In
any view of the matter, this is an aspect to be established before the Court of
law after a full fledged trial. In pursuance to this order dated 17.03.2017 the
State Government has directed Heads of Departments to issue appointed after
verification procedure. Whereas Director, Municipal Administration issued
appointment order to 18 candidates. On 27.03.2017on the 03.04.2017 the
RDPR Department has issued appointment orders to 60 candidates.
Whereas this apart, prima-facie the CID Report does not appear to point
fingers at any of the other candidates who have participated in the Selection
process and form part of the select list. Therefore, the present issue throws up
a very pertinent question as to what should be the fate of those candidates
against whom there is no allegation or against whom nobody can point a finger
of doubt or suspicion. As is being pointed out, can these candidates who have
apparently undergone certain struggle/put in efforts to participate and get
through the selection process, be punished for no fault of theirs (without
establishing their involvement), by holding that the entire list is vitiated due to
the conduct of a few persons, if at all, any aspersions can be cast against their
conduct.
Whereas mere allegations of malpractice and commission of offences,
would not be sufficient or justify the end result of cancelling the appointments
in respect of all the candidates. It is only after the due process of law; is
undertaken and when an enquiry or investigation reaches its logical
conclusion, which is when it is so established and approval made by a Court of
the land, can it be said that the time is right to penalize the delinquent or the
offender.
Whereas the State has initiated (on finding some prima facie materials)
and awaited these proceedings to reach their logical and final conclusion;
failing which, it would defeat the very ends of justice to penalize the candidates
who find a place in select list. No member of KPSC or no Candidates has been
proved guilty of allegation or convicted in any court of trial.
In writ Petition 13617-13627/2017 Renukambike R and Others Vs the
State of Karnataka challenging the order of KAT Hon;ble Division Bench of
High Court on 09.03.2018 allowed the writ petition and upheld the G.O. Dated
04.08.2014.
date 09.03.2018 as held as follows;-
“52. In the light of above discussion, we are of the considered view
that, the Administrative Tribunal erred in substituting its opinion
and therefore, the impugned judgment quashing State
Government‟s decision to withdraw the is wholly unsustainable.
Consequently, direction to the State Government to issue
appointment orders to the selected candidates is also rendered
unsustainable in law.”
X X X
55. Resultantly, these writ petitions eminently deserve to be
allowed and accordingly:
a) Writ Petitions No. 13617-13627/2017 & 14529/2017 and writ
Petition No. 11342/2017 are allowed;
b) Common order dated 19.10.2016 passed by the Karnataka State
Administrative Tribunal, Bangalore, in Applications No.
6268/2014, 6395/2017 c/w 6432/2014 to 6444/2014
&6598/2014, 7464/2014, 7941/2014 to 7946/2014, 7950/2014
to 7966/2014, 7967/2014, 7968/2014, 7969/2014, 9112/2014 to
9126/2014, 9592/2014 to 9610/2014 and 8298/2015, is
quashed.
c) Un-official Note, C£À¢üPÀÈvÀ n¥Ààt ¸ÀASÉå: ¹D À̧ÄE 139 ¸ÉÃ¯ÉÆÃ¸Éà 2016 dated
17.03.2017, issued by Deputy Secretary, DPAR (Services),
Government of Karnataka, is quashed;
d) Official Memorandum, C¢üPÀÈvÀ eÁÕ¥À£À ¸ÀASÉå: 19457 rJAJ 32 PÉJAJJ¸ï
2016-17 dated 27.03.2017, issued by Director, Municipal
Administration, Bengaluru, is quashed;
e) All orders of appointment/s issued pursuant to FInal Select List
dated 21.03.2014 prepared by KPSC are declared illegal and shall
stand quashed; and
f) Government Order, ¸ÀPÁðgÀzÀ DzÉñÀ ¸ÀASÉå: ¹D À̧ÄE 53 ¸ÉÃ¯ÉÆÃ¸Éà 2014,
¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ, dated 14.08.2014, withdrawing requisitions issued to
KPSC for selection of Gazetted Probationers for 2011, and to close
selection process, is sustained.
“56. In view of disposal of these writ petitions, I.A.No. 16/2017 (in
W.Ps. No. 13617-13627/2017 & 14529/2017) for impleadment,
filed by the applicants claiming to be candidates in 2011 selection,
does not survive for consideration and is accordingly disposed of.”
In I.A.No. 4/2018 in Writ Petitions No. 13617-13627/2017Renukambike
R and Others Vs State The Hon‟ble High Court in Division bench has held on
13th July 2018 as follows;
“30. For the reasons recorded above, we answer the point No. (i) in
the affirmative and record our finding that results of written
examination are vitiated.”
Re-Point (ii): Whether fresh viva voce can be ordered, if
the evaluation of answer scripts are not vitiated?
31. While answering point No. (i), we have recorded that the result
of written examination are vitiated. In view of the said finding, we
answer this point in the negative and record that fresh „viva voce‟
cannot be ordered on the basis of existing results of written
examination.
Re-Point (iii): Whether fresh evaluation of answer
scripts can be ordered, if written examination results are
vitiated?
32. While considering this option, it is necessary to take note
following aspects:
that recruitment process in question is for Gazetted
Probationers, 2011;
that the preliminary written examination was
conducted on 22.04.2012;
that the written examination (main) was conducted
between 15.12.2012 to 06.01.2013;
reckoned from any angle, nearly 8 years have elapsed
from the designated year of recruitment and 5 1/2
years from the date of written examination
33. Thus, keeping in view the facts of this case and the time lapse,
we are of the clear opinion that, it is not a fit case to direct re-
evaluation of answer scripts.
On 13.08.2018: New SLP was filed by Mythri VS the State of
Karnataka bearing the dairy no: 30195/2018 before Supreme
Court challenging the Hon‟ble division bench high court order
dated 13.07.2018 and Supreme Court ordered as follows:-
we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment
and order. concequently the SLP is dismissed.”
Whereas the State Government filed a new SLP (Dairy No-21729/2019)
before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court challenging the high court order dated
13.07.2018, The Hon‟ble Supreme Court. In this case has ordered as follows:-
“We are not inclined to interfere with impugned order(s) passed by
the High Court the SLP are accordingly, dismissed.”
Pending interlocutory applications forms are disposed”.
Having examined the above judgments it is apparent that the Hon‟ble
High Court has relied in arriving at such decision based on the interim report
of the CID. Unless the tainted candidates are segregated and a detail
investigation are held and proved guilty in the court of law after due trail it may
not be proper to hold the examination as vitiated. Whereas in respect of
untainted candidates their sincere efforts has to be respected and their
legitimate expectation for having appointed shall be honoured.
It was also bound duty on the State Legislature under article 323(2) of
the Constitution to annul the withdrawal of requisition made to KPSC before
issue of Government order dated 15.10.2013 on the basis of an interim
investigation report of the CID.
It is apparent from para 45 of the High Court judgment in Renukambe
Vs. State of Karnataka case dated 9th March 2018 which reads as follows;
“45. In the light of facts recorded by the CID in it‟s investigation
report, we are of the view that there is no error in exercise of their
powers under the transaction of business by the State Government
in withdrawing the requisition given to the State Public Service
Commission.”
Here, in this case the very basis of the judgments in the vitiating the
examination process based on the CID interim report itself is misleading.
Hence, the Government Orders dated 15.10.2013 and 14.08.2014 respectively
suffer from severe procedural infirmity and have no sanctity in the eyes of law
especially in view of the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Babu
Varghese v. Kerala State Bar Council reported in 1999(3) SCC 422, which
reads as follows:-
“It is the basic principle of law long settled that if the manner of doing a
particular act is prescribed under any Statute, the act must be done in that
manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is traceable to the decision in
Taylor VS Taylor (1875) 1Ch.D 426 which was followed by Lord Roche in Nazir
Ahmad VS King Emperor AIR 1936 PC 253 who stated as under:
“Where a power is given to do certain thing in a certain way, the thing in
a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all.”
Now therefore, it is considered necessary to bring a legislation to annul
the action taken by the previous Government without proper approval of the
State Legislature and thereby as a resultant the decision of the Hon‟ble High
Court in this regard.
Whereas the charges made on the candidates in the trail court has
reached the logical end and no member of KPSC or candidate has been proved
guilty of any offence or convicted in any court of trail.
It is also pertinent to State that the decision of the High Court leads to
violation of the Article 14 and 16 of Constitution of India.
Whereas in view of all above matters it is considered necessary to
validate the recruitment orders issued by the Government to 2011 Gazetted
probationers and to legalise the selection list.
Hence, the Bill.
[L.A. Bill No. 04 of 2022, File No. SAMVYASHAE 02 SHASANA 2022]
[Entry 41 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India.]
[Published in Karnataka Gazette Extra-ordinary No. 104 in part-IVA dated:
14.03.2022]
KARNATAKA ACT NO. 14 OF 2022
(First Published in the Karnataka Gazette Extra-ordinary on the 14th day of March, 2022)
THE KARNATAKA CIVIL SERVICES (VALIDATION OF SELECTION AND
APPOINTMENT OF 2011 BATCH GAZETTED PROBATIONERS) ACT, 2022
(Received the assent of Governor on the 12th day of March, 2022)
Whereas, in Notification dated 03.11.2011, applications were invited by
the Karnataka Public Service Commission from eligible candidates for filling up
of 362 Group-A and Group-B posts. The Preliminary Examination was
conducted on 22.04.2012. The main examination was held from 15.12.2012 to
06.01.2013. Result of the examination was published on 21.03.2013.
Whereas, the Karnataka Public Service Commission had conducted the
interviews of qualified candidates from 07-05-2013 to 27-05-2013. When the
Viva-voce had been conducted, a candidate by name Dr.Mythri.H.P.S. made a
complaint before the then, Advocate General on 28-05-2013 alleging that in
this process, she (Dr.Mythri.H.P.S) was eliminated and the candidate below her
was selected to the post of the Assistant Commissioner. She has also alleged
that demands were made by Smt. Dr.Mangala Sridhar, Member, KPSC in order
to ensure her selection.
Whereas, pursuant thereto, a FIR was registered in Crime no 28/2013
dated 25-06-2013 before the Vidhana Soudha police station, Bengaluru
alleging for the offences punishable under Section 341,120-B,418,423, 465 of
Indian Penal code and under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988. The Government by its order dated 27-06-2013 directed the CID to
conduct the investigation. The CID after investigation had submitted a
preliminary/interim report on 10.09.2013 and submitted chargesheet before
the Hon‟ble XXIII Additional City Civil and Sessions (Special Court )which was
registered as Special Case No.311 /2014.
Whereas, based on the interim report, the Government issued
Government Order dated 15.10.2013/14.08.2014 cancelling the results of the
main competitive examination and also the Viva-Voce, directing the Karnataka
Public Service Commission to revaluate the answer script of the main written
examination and to conduct Viva-Voce strictly in accordance with the
recommendations of HOTA Committee.
Whereas, in the meantime some of the candidates had challenged the
action of the Government order dated 15.10.2013 by filing applications before
the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal. Gradually, all the affected candidates
preferred applications before the Tribunal and the Tribunal granted an „interim
order‟ directing the State Government not to notify for the „362 posts‟ which
was a subject matter of the 2011 Selection List till the disposal of the
applications.
Whereas, during the pendency of the proceedings before the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal, CID had submitted its final report and in its „final
report‟ had concluded that the officials, who are the then Member of the
Karnataka Public Service Commission shown as Accused Nos. 9 to 16 had
entered into criminal conspiracy and had misused the official machinery to do
favours for candidates seeking to be appointed as Group-A and B employees
under the 2011 Notification. The said 8 Accused persons have obtained illegal
gratifications from various candidates and had misused their office to grant
appointments for such illegal gratification and thereby had committed the
offences punishable under Sections120-B, 166, 167 of Indian Penal Code R/w
Section 13 (1) (d) and 13 (2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section
37 of Indian Penal Code .
Whereas, it is pertinent to note here that, although the names of certain
candidates find a place in the „charge sheet‟ for having maintained telephonic
contact with some of the Accused, none of them have, themselves been named
as Accused either in the charge sheet or in the FIR.
Whereas, the Karnataka Administrative Tribunalin the meantime, had
proceeded to hear the matter on merit. After hearing the matter, the Tribunal
by its order dated 19.10.2016, allowed the Applications and quashed the
Government Order dated 14.08.2014. The Tribunal thereafter directed the
State of Karnataka to issue orders of appointment to the Applicants in terms of
the provisions of Rule 11(3) of „1997‟ Rules, within a period of two months from
the date of receipt of the copy of the order.
Whereas, a perusal of the said charge sheet would show that, none of the
candidates who are either selected or had participated in the selection process
have been named as Accused persons. The gist of the charge sheet filed by the
C.I.D discloses that there is a commission of offence of criminal conspiracy by
the Chairman, Members, staff and some middlemen to favour certain
candidates who are otherwise ineligible or less meritorious by accepting illegal
gratifications. The name of these candidates is not forthcoming in the report of
the C.I.D.
Whereas, these candidates alleged to have paid illegal gratification to the
Members or the middlemen is also not forthcoming in the charge sheet. In view
of the matter, this is an aspect to be established before the Court of law after a
full fledged trial. In pursuance to this order dated 17.03.2017, the State
Government has directed Heads of Departments to issue Appointment Order
after completion of procedure of verification. Whereas, Director, Municipal
Administration issued appointment order to 18 candidates. On 27.03.2017 and
on 03.04.2017 the RDPR Department has issued appointment orders to 60
candidates.
Whereas,apart from the aforesaid allegation, prima-facie the CID Report
does not appear to point fingers at any of the other candidates who have
participated in the Selection process and form part of the selection list.
Therefore, the present issue throws up a very pertinent question as to what
should be the fate of those candidates against whom there is no allegation and
no elements of doubt or suspicion. A relevant question arises as to can these
candidates who have apparently undergone certain struggle and put in efforts
to participate and get through the selection process, be punished for their no
fault (without establishing their involvement), by holding that the entire list is
vitiated due to the conduct of a few persons, if at all, any aspersions can be
cast against their conduct.
Whereas, mere allegations of malpractice and commission of alleged
offences, would not be sufficient to justify the end result of cancelling the
appointments in respect of all the candidates. It is only after the due process of
law is undertaken by way of an enquiry or investigation reaches its logical
conclusion if it is so established and proved before Court of Law, then it be said
that the time is right to penalize the delinquent or the offender.
Whereas, the State has initiated (on finding some prima facie materials)
and awaited these proceedings to reach their logical and final conclusion failing
which, it would defeat the very ends of justice to penalize the candidates who
find a place in selection list. No member of KPSC or no Candidates have been
proved guilty of alleged offences or are convicted in any court of trial.
In writ Petitions bearing Nos.13617-13627/2017 in case of
Smt.Renukambike R and Others Vs the State of Karnataka challenging the
order of KAT,the Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka Bengaluru on 09.03.2018
allowed the writ petitions and upheld the G.O. dated 14.08.2014 and held as
under;
“52. In the light of above discussion, we are of the considered view
that, the Administrative Tribunal erred in substituting its opinion
and therefore, the impugned judgment quashing State
Government‟s decision to withdraw the is wholly unsustainable.
Consequently, direction to the State Government to issue
appointment orders to the selected candidates is also rendered
unsustainable in law.”
X X X
55. Resultantly, these writ petitions eminently deserve to be
allowed and accordingly:
a) Writ Petitions No. 13617-13627/2017 & 14529/2017 and writ
Petition No. 11342/2017 are allowed;
b) Common order dated 19.10.2016 passed by the Karnataka State
Administrative Tribunal, Bangalore, in Applications No.
6268/2014, 6395/2017 c/w 6432/2014 to 6444/2014
&6598/2014, 7464/2014, 7941/2014 to 7946/2014, 7950/2014
to 7966/2014, 7967/2014, 7968/2014, 7969/2014, 9112/2014 to
9126/2014, 9592/2014 to 9610/2014 and 8298/2015, is
quashed.
c) Un-official Note, C£À¢üPÀÈvÀ n¥Ààt ¸ÀASÉå: ¹D À̧ÄE 139 ¸ÉÃ¯ÉÆÃ¸Éà 2016 dated
17.03.2017, issued by Deputy Secretary, DPAR (Services),
Government of Karnataka, is quashed;
d) Official Memorandum, C¢üPÀÈvÀ eÁÕ¥À£À ¸ÀASÉå: 19457 rJAJ 32 PÉJAJJ¸ï
2016-17 dated 27.03.2017, issued by Director, Municipal
Administration, Bengaluru, is quashed;
e) All orders of appointment/s issued pursuant to FInal Select List
dated 21.03.2014 prepared by KPSC are declared illegal and shall
stand quashed; and
f) Government Order, ¸ÀPÁðgÀzÀ DzÉñÀ ¸ÀASÉå: ¹D À̧ÄE 53 ¸Éà É̄ÆÃ¸Éà 2014,
¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ, dated 14.08.2014, withdrawing requisitions issued to
KPSC for selection of Gazetted Probationers for 2011, and to close
selection process, is sustained.
“56. In view of disposal of these writ petitions, I.A.No. 16/2017 (in
W.Ps. No. 13617-13627/2017 & 14529/2017) for impleadment,
filed by the applicants claiming to be candidates in 2011 selection,
does not survive for consideration and is accordingly disposed of.”
In I.A.No. 4/2018 in Writ Petitions No. 13617-13627/2017 Renukambike
R and Others Vs State The Hon‟ble High Court in Division bench has held on
13th July 2018 as follows;
“30. For the reasons recorded above, we answer the point No. (i) in
the affirmativeand record our finding that results of written
examination are vitiated.”
Re-Point (ii): Whether fresh viva voce can be ordered, if
the evaluation of answer scripts are not vitiated?
31. While answering point No. (i), we have recorded that the result
of written examination are vitiated. In view of the said finding, we
answer this point in the negative and record that fresh „viva voce‟
cannot be ordered on the basis of existing results of written
examination.
Re-Point (iii): Whether fresh evaluation of answer
scripts can be ordered, if written examination results are
vitiated?
32. While considering this option, it is necessary to take note
following aspects:
that recruitment process in question is for Gazetted
Probationers, 2011;
that the preliminary written examination was
conducted on 22.04.2012;
that the written examination (main) was conducted
between 15.12.2012 to 06.01.2013;
reckoned from any angle, nearly 8 years have elapsed
from the designated year of recruitment and 5 1/2
years from the date of written examination
33. Thus, keeping in view the facts of this case and the time lapse,
we are of the clear opinion that, it is not a fit case to direct re-
evaluation of answer scripts.
On 13.08.2018: New SLP was filed by Mythri VS the State of
Karnataka bearing the dairy no: 30195/2018 before Supreme
Court challenging the Hon‟ble division bench high court order
dated 13.07.2018 and Supreme Court ordered as follows:-
we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment and
order. consequently the SLP is dismissed.”
Whereas the state Government filed a new SLP (Dairy No-21729/2019)
before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court challenging the high court order dated
13.07.2018, The Hon‟ble Supreme Court. In this case has ordered as follows:-
“We are not inclined to interfere with impugned odre(s) passed
by the High Court the SLP are accordingly, dismissed.”
Pending interlocutory applications forms are disposed”.
Having examined the above judgments it is apparent that the Hon‟ble
High Court has relied in arriving at such decision based on the interim report
of the CID. Unless the tainted candidates are segregated and a detail
investigation are held and proved guilty in the court of law after due trail it may
not be proper to hold the examination as vitiated. Whereas in respect of
untainted candidates their sincere efforts has to be respected and their
legitimate expectation for having appointed shall be honoured.
It was also bound duty on the State Legislature under article 323(2) of
the Constitution to annul the withdrawal of requisition made to KPSC before
issue of Government order dated 15.10.2013 on the basis of an interim
investigation report of the CID.
It is apparent from para 45 of the High Court judgment in Renukambe
Vs. State of Karnataka case dated 9th March 2018 which reads as
follows;
“45. In the light of facts recorded by the CID in it‟s investigation
report, we are of the view that there is no error in exercise of their
powers under the transaction of business by the State Government
in withdrawing the requisition given to the State Public Service
Commission.”
Here, in this case the very basis of the judgments in the vitiating the
examination process based on the CID interim report itself is misleading.
Hence, the Government Orders dated 15.10.2013 and 14.08.2014 respectively
suffer from severe procedural infirmity and have no sanctity in the eyes of law
especially in view of the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Babu
Varghese v. Kerala State Bar Council reported in 1999(3) SCC 422, which
reads as follows:-
“It is the basic principle of law long settled that if the manner of doing a
particular act is prescribed under any Statute, the act must be done in that
manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is traceable to the decision in
Taylor VS Taylor (1875) 1Ch.D 426 which was followed by Lord Roche in Nazir
Ahmad VS King Emperor AIR 1936 PC 253 who stated as under:
“Where a power is given to do certain thing in a certain way, the thing in
a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all.”
Now therefore, it is considered necessary to bring a legislation to annul
the action taken by the previous Government without proper approval of the
State Legislature and thereby as a resultant the decision of the Hon‟ble High
Court in this regard.
Whereas the charges made on the candidates in the trail court has
reached the logical end and no member of Karnataka Public Service
Commission or candidate has been proved guilty of any offence or convicted in
any court of trail. It is also pertinent to State that the decision of the High
Court leads to violation of the Article 14 and 16 of Constitution of India.
Whereas in view of all above matters it is considered necessary to
validate the recruitment orders issued by the Government to 2011 Gazetted
probationers and to legalise the selection list.
Now therefore, be it enacted by the Karnataka State Legislature in the
seventy third year of the Republic of India as follows:-
1. Short title and commencement.-(1) This Act may be called the
Karnataka Civil Services (Validation of Selection and appointment of 2011
batch Gazettedprobationers) Act, 2022.
(2) It shall come into force at once.
2. Definitions.-(1) In this Act unless the context otherwise requires,-
“2011 batch Gazetted probationers” means candidates selected in the
2011 batch Gazettedprobationers selection list by the Karnataka Public Service
Commission;
(2) Other words and expressions used but not defined shall have the
same meaning as defined in the Karnataka State Civil Services Act, 1978.
3. Validation of selection of 2011 batch Gazetted Probationers.-
Notwithstanding anything contained in any judgment, decrees or order of any
court, Tribunal or Authority to the contrary and in order to provide Justice to
the 2011 batch Gazetted probationers for their no fault, it is hereby enacted as
follows:-
(a) 2011 batch Gazettedprobationers selection made by the Karnataka
Public Service Commission shall be valid in accordance with law;
(b) All orders issued on 15.10.2013 and 14.08.2014 by the State
Government withdrawing the recruitment process of 2011 batch
Gazetted probationers shall stand cancelled.
(c) The State Government shall take immediate steps to issue
appointment orders to 2011 batch Gazetted probationersas per the
Karnataka Public Service Commission selection list.
(d) All appointments of 2011 batch Gazatted Probationers shall be within
the extent and in accordance with the provisions of rule 18 of the
Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977. The
seniority of the 2011 batch Gazatted Probationers shall come into
force on their date of report to the respective post in accordance with
the provisions of this Act. The 2011 batch Gazatted Probationers shall
not be eligible for the retrospective seniority at any time.The 2011
batch Gazatted Probationers shall not claim seniority retrospectively
as matter of right at any time.
(e) No suit or other proceeding shall be maintained or confirmed in any
court or any Tribunal or before any Authority for the review of any
such appointment made in accordance with the provisions of this Act.
(f) No court shall enforce any decree or order to direct the review of any
such cases contrary to the provisions of this Act.
4. Power to remove difficulties.-If any difficulty arises in giving
effect to the provisions of this Act, the State Government may by General or
Special order make such provisions as appears it to be necessary or expedient
to remove difficulty.
The above translation of ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಸಿವಿಲ್ ಸೇವೆಗಳ (2011ನೇ ಸಾಲಿನ ಗೆಜೆಟೆಡ್
ಪ್ರೊ ಬೇಷನರರ ಆಯೆ್ಕ ಮತ್ತು ನೇಮಕಾತಿಯ ಸಿಿಂಧುಗೊಳಿಸುವಿಕೆ) ಅಧಿನಿಯಮ, 2022 (2022 ರ
ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ಅಧಿನಿಯಮ ಸಂಖೆ್ಯ : 14) be published in the official Gazette under clause (3)
of Article 348 of the Constitution of India.
THAAWARCHAND GEHLOT
GOVERNOR OF KARNATAKA
By Order and in the name of
the Governor of Karnataka,
G.SRIDHAR
Secretary to Government
Department of Parliamentary
Affairs and Legislation