THE UTTAR PRADESH VALUE ADDED TAX RULES, 2008
Rules made under THE UTTAR PRADESH VALUE ADDED TAX Act , 2008
- Made under: THE UTTAR PRADESH VALUE ADDED TAX Act , 2008
This text is shown as one document.
Full text
TAC Was TAT
| Ree Fe, Be es Pere aTAPT-2
WET Foh{o-2-1052/AB-9(295)/07-Souosftto-s-2008-Jotttolz
PreATasft-08-s7291(15)-2008
WET-27 A, 2008
; att ;
‘ aie Tee AH St ae aA St Tae fe ae Ra F de we sasas
FAL, AT, SAT TET STITT vs afer, 1904 (sat yee afer dear
1, FL 1904) Ht MT 21 B arr wor sax veer aver datefa ae aera, 2008
(Sort vest afaray go 5, ay 2008) Ht a-74 S aa wa aT-79 B ais
fet Bt TAT ots wt atari aftegen se Hofto-2-02/7ae-9(295)/07
Soyo FMMTEN-37-2007 Yotftode Framraci-os-ses-(01)-2008 fiw 01
ae Oe aa Senor Sexe emirate & Prafetad fraaract
al TSaaet chr Te VATE St Ta S fe Tet veers rer , rr are
Se Tod aay Sch sae earth So oaag, were aa sat afar
St IMI-79 Bt sree (3) } wes & aie feat of wars & Preafafea
fFreraracit sara &:—
TAT We ArT aati ax Praqadit, 2008
AATA-TH
mnt
Pray 1. afer are site sres—(1) ae Praaractt sax vest yer Waftfa ax
Praaracit-2008 mel ae |
(2) ae 01 Waa, 2008 HH Waa BS GAS TTT |
Pret 2. aftereang—(1) ore ae fer fore ar weet F arg ota are 7 et, ga
Prraracit #; i _
(&) « “afetrar” or arered Sart west For Safer ax afaPray, 2008 (sar
yaa afar ao-5, AY 2008) F&I
(@) “aac after (Addl. Commissioner)” a aed OH alae a F fret
TT A aT at Seat APT a S aT A vs at aa Het
at Poet Se Us HI HA at sera ar WarT er We Paar
fear Tar Sr | . :
ete ke blob bi IK Whelk Bile) BEB Bib biinD bist» Ibbin
meplth gpl Pallbyh Ibb # GEL bhbjate aoe gPim pHID ke ,dKeIpb, (3),
— Bb PI Dh Lelte> @ beywiek) B PLOT S'S dbo) DIP PLOT ‘[pbikbb (biaIEP bh) dp PRiJbb bok hp +z
BQ bo Lpk i jpbels > Br bh oF
‘Sh Dib ‘bebe @ Uke DEK & S bbb) ‘p bi}bi Jp} wb Lidl ()
Ba pb fb Penk BO Lips
We Jpbe|is Ibbie bBpk) Ke jist s Pichi rhb Mb fy Sake Ip] (1)
Rieke Mb bolalib Bike bh DBL) DIF Mek Ibble dukbIe sbIaD Lb
AekRKe bE Dib DIP dese Lb DIP 2>B bold Ibhio DEBE) DIP 21>» hap (42)
(Indjtake) 2b) dekh DEER DIK» bh EBL) Ba poe selbh Mb JpbEUE Bh
* BMP) Jee Ypeb sb Piebiall Indlteb| Deb fe WSnke DzbdIe IP! DIF r1e>B fad (wh)
12 Derk] Diebele o> ,MPRIK Drab Mb,, (12),
—PbpldRIN Dh ble S PRYwiksk) B PLOTS 2S Hib} IMF PLOT ‘|pbibbb| (LYE bbh) 2 DhJbB bdk “KD “1
| 242 Didpier|h 2emebie> 22 Dejledh lial
# OS6I “kbbjajio aepibh pbb bh 23> IpD Poep Ypbr Deja h leh fe
OB6I Dbh InYoep [pein Dipbuio DYE lo bidP I LinlhaP diepID
bik lphelk Dkjb) BE B Sib bin) bly IbbiO Bef s>/p
PbjibYh liebe & 676I bbbikile meplbh SPib PhD I> , IDL, (3):
- 12.2 Dojo Diep Ba pre
— ehPK 1 fbbbpiis tp dbsbI> dblab DIP dab bh bePk) eK BS
DIB 21> pop pbb kb ,,(JQUOISSIWIWIOD JUR}SISSY) dbEbI> high, (8)
| BQ pede Deplheld Lie[pbekd D> fe LUE Upbebd Job Jobs|
LUBED @ jmbho & [oblbbb} {ple Yplbb Dd} SBS bh kbhbjrie (Lt)
£ De pe blph lb {bbplle ( 6b ba Sb ‘Sh Dik
Ppbsie & lke bok b S bbb) & bidihich {pb} & Irleb{ (2)
£ Be poe f Wonk BO bibK I Jpbeye
ph baph le {wb & Pibhjik DYbb) db # WSnk {oJ (w)
“IPR bd
belgjib Dibp bh Bebb) DIF bebe Lbblo dLsh| blab lb Mesh|e
AD DLP DIT dsb ibblo LP bold Jo LeBL) DIF Mew bod (2)
By deb PI heb Ublpbeb 2b fe LEDIUS Lbb/p heb
42 telitle} Lalo @ Ypblkebb} {ple plkb hij Re Ye kbbjale (B)
: Be po bibs I Jppplls bd bepp]
Me {wh @ piri Indjhe| Me fe Waa DYpdIe Ypiel (*)
Uesne BRP Dibp ph BeEw) DIP Urb bel (ed)
~:2{2 DRJWibrl] Pibo sb ,,piebjlk PYbk) Le, (he)
Z debby Mbig}pbih Mb Dpjbp bik ies ae
12
b&ppe Ba pe bibK i [polis | Phish jak} Le
8 bibkjidh f WSak bh Ddwpe Ba -pwhb be Fle mle
biped © kbbibiie BS lb Sadpie ‘ols ‘de bh Q bajke|h
[RDEUE kb Lab BABII pio} (hb 2b) ebel he —(BLb)
| 2 afb Ld Yp_RYS kb picbbLks ndjtae|
2b } WSak B bibkjidh MS bdibsb] kb pid dk pip |p-brb
BBUSK DelbiD [in (RUSK) LER hO Dik fp WSok Ip) (1b)
(Iodebljoh) deter he bike BE
foe bf Sok DEP LibK lb pbplls WBE ba bb bolbeb Le
(ee & Lids Indinb} 2 (Busodjo anyia Aq) kipjI>h
bh bib DPhb) I> [Whik [pb bbiinh © DiBbre Ib
kde Bib) ‘bd Deeb] ‘bob Bile fb Bblinh & WSak |p| (L{p)
1Q Bee BQ pe bibs Ib Ippels kp sy
Dib bh Sh Dib DIS & Ikbb} BS [in (Is bIpPEIo pled!)
desk bf lb (EPPS) desk be ‘(Welp Blin) desh\ he — ({p)
(Ind{fiel 2b) Deki be Dike BQ poeb bib Ib Ipbels BE bh
2b beleB ke |v } Pichi Srhel Mb b WSak |p} (wh)
—2 Bbjie|p
bEYWierb| RBS Ib 2B Pejho Pebb) f he & db holalib duebIe
bP DIS Neb bol pb Ip I ,,( 49UOISSIWIWOD Ajndaq) debe he,
12 8 bike) 2 polajib Noe be PhIb lb _bikbl,,
| BI2 Qiabho le @ MK BE aapiblb) DIP & deen ID
blk) “[pbr phils} 2B WSnk b> helallb BA phib i ,WSnk Db,
12 PRikye | bSob Phibb} Biel “2 B WSnk db
helgjip DeiPhjie bible @ [bbb bS DIP esbi> ppp I> Denk,
12 & Bete
Diep bh bebbh} 2K BS DIF debi PhP > _BidhIo de bolallb,,
| 12 12) be>R I> bipiio
hilebhe Us @ Bibs PA bibh) Boh ‘a i> pinie
I Dejh bhelo B dbdh| spridh dip 12 19) b2db I> Ibb dp
Dbibe BQH UAE Iphie Ibe 24 belalib ISSR Mas |e Bbjbo Bb (Jb)
Ib {2 Bejhe Iblt 19> f IbB lb [eb kb Pabbo |b th (wh)
“Ue bh 'Q
Ilo Zaléje) Italo Ib MPOE php Ddieh Diy @ Lr pK
Hh kp }labhe Bh pRie| @ R Belo BA Php > J hibipIK Dp,
Ss 800Z ‘Ipblkbhl 2» Dhibh bok ie pe
(2)
(ls)
(4)
(is)
(@)
(B)
z@ bbb
«l 2 So BD bhi
pile) QB ER Oil Ele Bis sb lbp ebhalte [Ye (bible) deeb DEER pIDID ke Jblleb,,,
—Dbllb2b)k dh Llp? @ PRybisk} B 6OOT'T'OG sold} DIP GOO ‘|pbizbk| (BU kek) 2 Dabp pik “KD
holt Heb $b (ible) Maske DPB Lb (idle) ebb rhip “Iai
‘(eisIpe @bW2R) bible bhidbbo Diplikb pip Ie , JeIDIK hob,
12 @bho pina Sh tele dd
ble) 2B lel BS cb Wok DY lhbIO lab DIP desield> prop Jeb Sob,
‘ 12 Dib kb bbbikiie pip ib _Dik,,
| Jee Ie le pbs bh bOI Ite [hdd gp
desk bleh} ln 2B Bolbo beBh| fp he % 2 holalib deskI> ied}
DIS Hopp h bold Phi 14> ,(42UOISSIWIWIO4 le199dS) dbehI> biebI,,
| elie Lee} 2oplbib} fe splie lb IbbBajie Piln bile
€ hbk} Bl 2 2 ke BA lb 2 Sob BP ihbd bbl 2p kB Llp
$lle 2Dits IDyIbblie {db (LPbK) deeb DePP Ip (IBUE LipPEle
Algb)) MhekIe DEBE Lb (WI bplt) Mebbj DEP ph ice , lellee,,
: i28
KB Bib ble 2Dijs g Ipsbh|io yb dakbjee ho PLS1y' kb eR,
12.2 dbl B bhalk SbiAbPs I bjb} b PIP
Se @ [be Pik B PIP dbp ge [b> bib pioip lb bibl BBD bite,
12 8 JP 2b lap de Ibpbrye bélish &
Dah hip) bipritt Ibiale PiyJh Whlb] held [pd] fpbo1p Le |,Wkpb,,
| (Iod{fake} 24) DbBeI> DEER DIED by Sale DphDIe
Ip} Debio Ba b> Ini Ie |pbbIs {yb PidbialIK ddl} > (Dia)
: (UBUS LisREI jib!)
desi DEEP lb (bPbK) MBI BERD ‘(Wyle Blin) Peskefee
bebe perio Ba po bibs i [pbels fe 8p bn sy Dib (LIP)
‘(oipie) desk BeBp vere Ba
bo LibK ie |bBbIIs (yb iPkK hippie bile Ss Dik (2)
(doWihpid) dbskeld BeEB le (Lin) Lib pe} (eh)
= 2 DWjyjh Delbert}
wily QB elke ipa weBby fr ie op bb hnlalb Doble BEBE
DIS 21> bol pid Ib ,,(4BUOISSIWIWOD wulor) beh bbb,
12 2 pith DP f bpbikbh| BE pbb Lp filth,
12.8 LDLR pie bbale SEISD—S pip 14> ,bDLA SeLErps,,
S bbb Ib|sp>blk 2 BR|bB bik Isek 2S
(4)
(b)
(4)
(8)
(2)
(2)
(b)
(10)
(2)
(s)
(2)
| Prat 3 SA Ter AT dafla ae Pramas, 2008 5
Ra Tea BAT sr afar He ar Seat aie a Pea ae F
date A WH Tee SU By WHT AHI sree HA ara Paget seers
ahr & oT sea or ortrart & sit zat Pre afafera
(qe) ae aot Price often foray frente ones oft eer & |
(tl) We ater Ser aieat are Peet fare are saan ari
ct Sef & aenkeatea cee acer ar afsat ar waht ae
® far aqahaa afraen a add wares |
(fm) wea ofa & aaa sea seared squat a cm F
at Seat a aged seat are fear er & aftr
eee Heat 8 ae ofa or aftrert |
(aR) Fe afea ret aera after @ ae ofa ar eeniter fear
Br att ga Pitre aereat are aftrepe St; at ae afer Sit Sere
TEM APY HC aT HAA SAT TA ATI HC Va HT AaeT
Ter & fara US es SG Aa SAT Sr Ta TET aT |
(3) “SAM” er aera Sat west tea aterm 4 @ rasa soar
* arated ert |
(a) “after ts)” a aed ant afte at aftantar @ Aer ar
aa aa a & frat on 2 oF a ae (ohm) afer aT |
(2) ae Prana oraftenite Rg often a oftentie set od wet &
aé ae ett ot afifran 4 sre fore argefina & |
Prat 8. HRT, FT, AT TS TST Thott BET Ht MeaT— (1) WHT ATH WATT
F ag & ant—
@) «afta waar wart at aad &
(UH) HOt HPT aT URATT
(Qt) aged oftert (ero), aged area (aie) at aT
(re) ot afieat (ite are) oo are (Fads) aT oT SAT
(AAT HPAI MET) St AI; A ASA A AST Sl ATT
am @s at ankatr ta cts, wm, as a a F
afaferd &, ar aftrafra et aadt & |
(@) wee atten & after F aM at ase A AST ST APT AT
. aus a faitase He aad B |
(2) afrgat BP Haat FATT HC TH F—
(=) auser oie seat der ar Prater at gariater
(@) wee #* After as ait aes at dtr a Prefer set
Garteter |
QitbrLie MB elejip ti (ndjfale} 2b) diskijte dobi¥ (lade) Dh) DLR AE ke ke YEH} )
tb ‘(upus bibpEIp iit) Melee bE lp (LedpH) Deblate he (bl alin) Diskilee hO Je ve Upc) (1)
Ub ‘(Indjale} Mb) dekh DEBE fb WEak PUbbide {Pee} “(dpidlh its) desley BEBE “(ia|pIe) debe DEBE by Inte “(hDpK) dese beBP Lb (UUs bin fie AigkI) Debio DeBD le dekielde dhl fe lela Yh [B! (4s)
~ Heels Ute) Inde) Ide LD )dbhalie eb )pidbhalie db otal We Lesblajte ebi@h “Deblajse bo gb ely {(Indltabl 24) dekbit DERE fe WSale DbdI [pe ‘(bllb pte) dhe ale eB ‘(Lypk) debe DEBE Lb (UDIS kIpBEI6 bnltbl) 1etele> DEBE tp
Dbl YhiO fe Ilha ‘DIP Leki Jab "8 WILY PUbaile WeIbeliak) hE» wh yale (6),
—BbjleRps 2h Lela» @ Bey ilerk} f 6OOT LOS Ybiky) DIP GO0Z ‘WPblebb) (bBUSP bes) 2 Dalbe bhp +]
| We Uble 1316 DIP Yicblaybh db 2B Bin) 2 IWdb dep
Habits 2 22 {PP lodlbdk) Lee loMbls Yicbralio Yahi dDIK Mio Yd) [lb Lh. dbho
BE IPyltee}o fe Pieeje YableRIK RO Ib Piibejle BE sb bw dil dey
Hplle APP} tnel fide Ulataule B Lpbfbey BE bk bln Mio ‘Ye2> dh Job & JbdI2bho Ip
Apyjidiieiee £20 LPpfidrlalle fe (picblalte [pb] Sof @ piri 2 DeIbIb| Qh debe
Ht ibe DYlisiele Lbeidblelle {go pdltblalle DieDslo go (E) JebeaJbO—Inddbloah»
{pltbajle 22 bola/ib
He (ladfteke} d4e) det lajte deblals (ladliabe| Mb) dbeblce bE fe kw Ip} — (L)
Ae (UBUE biREIe bisbj) dabtele
AD Lh (bpbK) Meche hO “(\¢olfa bilo) Mébe/ce AO fe Lite IB} — (1B)
‘(@wihple)
Lethje DPB (Wyplo) Muskid DEER (4Pbi) Lbebjte DEBA Lp (LIDLe
kipbEie ites) deter beBR (wyplo) dedbsde Lhie fe delteb Ye) — (®)
Helen Lbeey' Jadot) Ide WY KerasIO {ge pkblalie 2b
holojite lke Lablefte deblah ‘dbblelce bE do ket (lodrk) Mb) Lodtelce DBE fy WSale 2Ubdlte {2de) Lip (dpldlhfolde) deckejte eEL ‘Up (Iwjplo) Leeye LEED Le (apes) tht BED Ip (InUs LibpEle bith) Leek) BEER (Wyplo) dkekjee dhl fe deltenbs ‘DIP Dbtielce {2b ‘g Diep [plcbb/lo BR/Wlr) dello ~ sh Jain (6),
@ bl Kb|gjpjrle de Dajbh bik ibys dae 8
| 2 Ip 2 bibp
tone fy pubis ule “pis Djs Imp Bll Jaa ll ‘2EDD a
BQ bbb © |pbibbLy [ple Iplkb kipbb bh JelablIK & bbbjblio BS (8)
|b) Dibhiin Drb belo bibh Me [pbele bh
Ip bl bIP b WWbikbbl jp ipieb bLipbb bh wbbipje BE (Lr)
| wpe Ib ie [pbells
bh bab) I |bbi> be bib DIZ phe Ibbip balb| lpblabb}
Pbk} LPP bh bbbjblie ubh\ bo do ebb Bebe Dbe (2)
| epee ts
debk|e dhio bh debhl% fisbl Lbs WM pes Pal} b Uebel — (#)
—n8 pa? bipiap & lnicbh| belbIb desbI (2)
| 12 Dbelb B Ibesls |e bbelplt> op ibe}
Pkiplb| kipSb bh JbibbiK & bbbiblip BE lin [yd Pls Ke Iprblbie Eble leak
U5>| BUBB % Jbbb| Pilbjb| bipbp bh Ibipblis & kbbiblio BS desb\ (9)
| b2¢ bibs ie IbBbIE Bebb bobbipK DIP Lp2IIblalle blll
BEDI & els bipibip LEK b SS Dib ip bb Lib > [pels bh Labbe} Ib
Ie bl bib kip © Ibbb} bl bike bipbb ba kbkipiio BE debi (3)
| Lo Libs i |pbbiis dp bebbl I |i ble bIp bibip Iabb|
bh bike bpp ph ZS Dib i bbbibjie mp bh kale Inphiie (F)
| 4:24 Libis ie pbbjis bh b2bb| kb Ibo bh hip biplo & Jeph) ble
blbb bipdb bh SO Dib I bbkiblip Db bh iehelp & Libiip khiterbte (¢)
| Upi2 2h peld
lobab Wp Mtb deb b| die Diblbb I Indbbip ‘Ielblis hibebte (Z)
Qibhie Ibe bly de dhbhie pebp
deb |b YP hBb| rhe “Desb| bisbI
Bie 1} Libi bhibebho Spb} Ib bibl bhitebho
Biek i bibie bhipebho ieeb I bible bhitpbhe
A}
a]
e]
oO]
©
Dibibe Ib Inder bePb Id Indcta|io
DeEb| Hp BibIbB Ie Indbhiie
214) bel> ‘bake I> bible hitb "1
latebb} Bh lable peer ite
| @ f lnkebh) beIPUEK bh lnflple @ QibhiN pRY~E b (C) baDe BlebhIls
PRY by Z-laab pdb PEYDIIP Ie (L)—PUPRIIK biple @ bbbjalio *y ebb
6 8007 ‘IPbikbh) 2 Phibb bot IbpK pp vy bbb}
sat wat yer daftts ae antafitar Pram 5
(9) sa afer 4 fafea wife oreo arftrenfter, star Pe ga
afetan ud gaaat Perec & orefrt cee ater are fates at aftr
ern, # sft or wart HUT |
(10) Saeret ST B area Us Veer, are H TH Us Tay s .
afatadt oer aret orererd afreat & ateflert ast aaa Pease F ted EU ge
aftras ar Parad art ved afeaat ar wart SeT |
(11) fedt ar fray A apafiee fedt aa & et gu dt wa ate
otra tart, agate ar fedt oer aren & art Get ar Prater at
# oravet et ar fedt ore afer, agar wher, aratrr + alg Rise Bt
at fer F afer at ae arfrer err fe ae ones 4 zenfariess Va aI
arn oat ager ater at wryqefe (assigned) gat ar frdet ae aay
afer a aged wet at at & fre med at! sa TWAT S set
ae ores ant fog art oe ore after ar aya. wre, rae va H tar
giftrere fear var et, at td araterr F arftenttar wat art seneatt, aI
Hae a aged seat et are sfeaar Brit :
2(12) TT We sea wT aa a oF ala & ahr ar feat
WT & eT a snaka a ane wet ws sar Premact & sreftt feat
wat et wat att a aaa der a ase a afta ar!
Ted wast ae & fe oe ga as Paar ud oteftary are F ordieita
aftreert at arg ter anes, Pest, ar Freer vet Sr frees artieftr orfereeret J
amet arf & fadarrer 4 carat et |
Pray 5. at Praer aor aiteant Hk gas STNG THT (incidental matters) — (1)
ay area, dere Heat sit ae ae afters Sr aeft-aret orftreanitar
Hae Prater orfreart at afedat ar garter at safer ett |
(2) oo afer, were afte, sea ae ar afer at arr 45 ud
48 a wferat ar aT SET Sg Aad B, ak wets fered ara We after
@ wt aftea axe oferertt & Fret ced ar at, at ot art 49 } aetna erate
aire Beast at Are Ut Aare Bi, Sa AvSet F He Prat orferarét Arar oa re
wea F 0a afert a arate fea 2 |
(3) Fraz 6 & seat & ates wed ee, fest aredite aver F Aa aga
area (ax Fra) fet avse F Sara ot afeant, aera asaz, ar afte
at aftreart arodt arftreeritar at drat F arta araetat S ax Fratee wrferart
By, st Tet feat arate ese F dara ayaa HAs (Hx Peat), or whreaz,
aera Hea, a area ae after at azar araertat ot aaadt aftrearftar
* 10
1. BH. ART water ae (wert weiter) Prasad, 2009 ant ath 30.1.2009 F Fer TAT |
(2. Sa. are wafefe we (facta asi) Praract, 2010 art Rais 4.2.2010 F FST TT |
| Q Bhd} bidipit ope
HBG) Unhile Leis Qisdtape Inde} 2 fe Sak BG dskb|e dbIgH Lb eeb| ho
BORO Lb DEI bi L1 DibhO kb CE Di ‘palllolbs 4 |bebbj 5 (2)
| WpR2 IAI Ye [Pek BIB d BibhIIK Indlhbl db & [Salk Ib WSnks & IW PYKebhyio
APRS ‘Kg Bible DbIR fp (S) bebo Ba ow pio bk Bp bh St Dik (9)
| Ung Llp Ibe) 2 B DkBieh keb dekh lbs Ib
Rise DIS @ Bite Dik~ jy bi|bid d LEI Yb] Q ab bebdIK 2H
Wea Sepsis WEE |e Yih ddbas pile ij sb lelbK g DoE Lp)
Ke Hebi bee b ke @ ib B IMD ( IDIIRIle hip | 3 Bb hebvjk
ae mabey ne] Queaye Eb hue ImIb & IRYLRYE ~ AMERYE
inbBRye b IP Libis bbifebho 2s (jobio) ek Dehp
Iehin deb>b |‘(Wipie) desi dhie ‘DR bh PiIhIRB & Indbblin bb
heb | Bin | ba (eUOISsIWWOD JUaWAaas) Bhalp & Ilblie hitb bo
| Bike Mb holalib bh
Sok Mesh HIP WhskIe> bo DIED be Wake
WSok PYbrd | (lode) Mb) desklé DEH DIEB f WSak D2elbd> JPb)
(kelod}) LeLbee be (SWibbi) deel Depp
Nideka fe Pde bolalib bkb\d dplaP dbebld ho PhP
Dikb 2h Iblb Ib |b biln Ip We WEE ‘LIE
bippBle Bibb) Uap ‘(Welp Blin) dsb he
Ise Josh (EBpK) heh bo (bBpK) dekkI DEBE
Qierjie Me pelalib Le bsklt diab Deeb ho
126 Jol | ‘bbkki> BER Deeb PhP DIED b bWIbIe ~ dEkbIb
z . I
eB MERE sha bh kb QUAY
TTT
—iye &
Key Iyleaye Biole fe S tebe Din OK DEA Bidwlin Dial b T bbe © Hm PRYRUEIO “Libis Id bbls |p| Ibkip DekR kb Bb dle Sb Dib (3)
HH? Iyipjie [pbb bib 4 |pribhiis wdltak) do DakB de wok
BE be Gibbs laddplinh Diep biel Dillle DIP Msi fs Sake [pep (P)
| Ue YplbraYe sbdtele} Yb Webbe) Piephiie DOK Ih ob} Lye 2ad|pJb} 2b BRE pb ob Jolb Ib bib Ub Jeb % b2jlablbo Ib ‘YpeIlebho ‘urbe 1b ‘2 Lt BOOT “YPblkbk| db Dajbh bok ispk poe ¢ bbb}
i
s
|B dé Dik b DibEIbA BRR Bajo b Ibi Rib
{PIs bE Ye ‘B Qlebkajie baba|iK DIP Mebield> Up eble|e hid) db bib 1B 2b Yb) “bb bin 19>
Ape uUBEio Jeb “Ya ytd) |p [Pp deb Uninlta Ub 24> ePb>Jh fe Uokih BE‘ 12> WhDIP by kde
Mobis Js Us\}s isk Zale) ble) Lp Q {yb Uni Dieple tb Jebbjhf BbPhO fs 21abte |b) dlp (g)
| Unt® pldeba|is dp>lisie| Dep ‘ia| gb {bit JBL Dijio Yb kbb|blip BE ab ‘2 Lbdpl
Pie Eb spills IBA ke Ylvblalte Wl} fx Indi bole tb ‘Pirillo DibK Ie [yl falls ‘2 Ihde
Unde) Ball ich Didbiajtls Ite bl dh ob Bab 2 bib Blin Dil Ze Di pBiof Indi Bh (2)
| Ua QldPlay sedtele) 24> tb Dpiabke Ph 'Q ibdb Dibk| LpPbelbib DIabbo 1B fy
In{p IDYMoRaS Webbie) Mebblde bblak Bp ‘Q Jake hd Db>i4> piled Iu }IAbto 1B! vib (9)
| Unj2 bie} pink) Qb re B
Iie Ne BYIRbIC [pisbhailK dd|tale| dee Ib Qiabbo Ph kup Meslvtd YpbIDE Ipeb| B dIle Iuka
Qibye fe khsle B belh Mb desk DEBE boialis DIP LA Ibbie dekb|e '2 Sie up Jk Mablp Diplo <b list bib Papi bel fr(b) bbelhO Ibbie (2) bejhe DIP plabhe |b DIp (3)
HAR QiteeIK Indl} 2b Is Bidbbo BE 2 bh db LOE Dpjils DdbK BE by Woy
SPBIG) Deka} sbbide Bb | ¥ lhe Nbr helo PHO fy Ualp Wlkbballo [dbp I> eb pbeleb BRIAR {hE be Lee yo rio Yb Dhl hd pdLb tbh by IBPK DDD DDIb tb kb} OF Low Bel Medlie QiBbbhe Leh‘ Web Dibdiee fe lhl WH blie sb Debalb HIP whl p wh fe BPH MAE "plabte ab de B bhy Bib B IPK LH bh brie HOP Iu plabhe [pe BIp (p)
| Unk? Qicbbl sbdltale} Mb Id Blabho BH ‘8 fe IPN PDO Whd dbri Iep Gidbine fe kip IDYylebble ‘PBle| Dsblalse hIBP Ab BL g Ir MedIe> Dh Llbd [2 wh WED by BRE ANE pidbte Bb die @ Bhd lb B Ike 2LO wh Dupri LOR kb Blake Web) bp (6)
ine bale 9 i Uslp IBY e kb Debi dbhIDB sbille B wh Bhs DEL Ebi
MRE BE Ab i Debice seh pee lo Bb Ws <b kb) RIP kode IRD DURDUE fe Bike| pd 4 Bb Dibdite fy nlp IRDWelajle We ebb PIP wee Bh pidbto Sie al (2)
—BbllD)K 2b bi? B RRUWisk) POLO‘ sp PIER} DIP OTOS ‘Yabiith) (LislSB bye) Mb BRIbR bole ep “I
HdbOlin Jhb Died bd pak popes
8 12 2dr Dbdie 2p fein dibs ah AYO Weld PieaJUN bdpak) 2b Ke Ylabke Bh GiPRyHO Mb {2 12) deb LUbdiee fe Und IDYURIIO fo Lbdbee BIW wh Whe
Gide Ale ef (1),—(uoRapsynf) wieke Kb Qlddbl Gd Utah} 24 “9 bets
9 bbb Ilsbiel 24 Dajbb bs lek 28 Sl
| Uni Tels Dapp
HpbYh sbbkbieh Yh “Q Wb pleb [yp IodGals ie JeH|le labile lke AIH ‘kAbh fp held lp
Belts Blas Lb lth seh kipibe tb ahvyys ‘RDIA Uhh MO dab Lith dba Pidy ‘|bdblie lawElo
Mbhio “sRlbR “(eb Ah) 2PINHIS behL|hO DH belo DEPDLIE @ (OT) bh (Z) bbk|bs (TL)
| Unk \piebtajis sdftake} 24> ddl
JAB Undffale} 2k Johale Bebralts sod tale} Ded ieb lalla Iselle ye Deri Jer sb pb Indtabe Dob
BE “hile BW YUPRUS Sd4hk} 2 cite B wh hig) ~ fab Indjtbs 2M Sh hb) kellndh Bis
ANS Q bse) Epp yh fx Whe Mr bie Lb led] blo IPH] Pho w dik! DK sb bedIK
AB Indah) Mb [heb) & Yigbke Biel dK BD ‘ys hI Pe @ kab belo fe kbbJho ype) (Ot)
| Ute Bbele jake) Bb kb debbisb Ie ly Debio PiddwIIK |b) Mb ke Hidde BD ke
Bases Sebi [ee} Meblale °Q Ala 1ale Li bbbhe $b kb kbbI PS lb 'y Bld Fie Is Jain (6)
debh\ BEB Bébhiis DIF SUS Ibialo Bbc “B Ele [eb [Ble nl Beale & Lisl
bkR aibiel & (Ph) bbbjbo Ibis (Z) bbb|ho DIP Piabho {pe} Bb (3)
| U2 plete Indftae} deb
i }iabbo BS ‘g Whe deri POR Polis NOs BS f Woylohie \pbis} Mekb|ee
Shigh Sb | 2 Whe tbr mis SRE & ll IPelsR}is Keble} Ure ke desktp
PpIdh |B LO IbEB jobs die dd Dail Whe Mbr bh b ISK MO ie
be} OF @ bX bdIS Nbr Bisbbo ID “A lib Nbr fe Llp LYleka|le &
DesRI HIP hilo P Sh f LEK WS ‘Yiwbto Bb Ie Deg) dale B IK
DBO Bh? dibri LOE ie Hiabbo jp jek) B Plabbe whpleolie |] ajb (F)
| U2 BIR 4b) Mb Ie Diab BH ‘R fe IRVK
2H bid Ub le Hiab f lb|p Wyldwhe SBie| Week} ShIVb ab BY Y
IP Dibr I> dh bike JQ HH Bee & [RK MH Hisbbo |b die Q Pky} dlp b
IB2K 2S Whe bri POE lo Piabro [PH] ek) P Liable well Bb (6)
| Ina Qiddye Bribb) Mb ‘Q ible Ibs) Dalia Whe Ube HOB fe
IPH DWH DIB HIESh We Sle “hBhS ‘bieb} “Yehste “lbe) fe Us|p Wepleelalie
\pBin) Deeb hia ab {Q WEE 2 IWEie Hw) S OS Pojib Wed Neri pak
hb IDK DDO [ Wh? Mr wh IPO} S MINS Mle lb “bAhO “ble “bee
‘Likb| BA lb ‘2 IWS dh Digi Hidwiie dik} Me “Q Bhy Bhs dere &
Ib|p IWyePRYo {bin} Deeb dha SK Dia) © BINS h We Fhe “HEEHH “Helek}
‘Ypbu ‘Libe) BD ‘pibbyle Fue Bore Ba BS DIP Ss lp Mebkye *Y fe LklR IWYjwhyo |p WwI dplah dhjio B Sh Bh? Merle lobia LINYSh Ne Fhe
HeQshO “Holela) ‘Waheed Lp Leite} dp 2id>>B old Lp Me>>e bis do) Q Ab Reis
12 Bids sje} Mb Lb Pirie BS Bb ‘Q ible lbs} PRWE
bm Meri HOB Jy lnjp wWyebleyie ke eke PIB Bia} | @ Whe Wb ble
(PO fy UnIP WYLRYS ble) We kb Wede|ee SHIAB |AB AE Web yews DT pe
Pail Wh? b> LOF b IWEK 2A |b Whe MeN wh [Pe bhig ab ih B
bd} BID o> bd badlS Dire fr Pita) {PD ‘Q lWre> Didi fe lel WWelekayke BB
Dhak pad she B doh Bidbhe Fb kek) B yidbho sbkyalie Qh (6)
el BOOS ‘jWbikbbh) db DpJbR poh kes 2H 9 bbb}
14 Bat west Fer safer ae arfafepr Prot
a ofr a ale arftrenret saat ait & fer aera Brea a te aeerh
ax ax Prafee safer arwenfte ax waver B ait ae fioke oe oe
(6) aft feet araertt or were arent err Tet t; ae aeTre Bree Prat
siftrentter ear F Gar eacertt arava Frere acer &, Ye exes ant ae Prertres
ofr er |
(7) Be araet F fora ere so arent oftaleer are F area aver arerar
WATE AAT BIT IT 52. orate wraenfres was ot Prarie seas & sorts Feoer rer eh OS Are wT A. Tee a OT H cree TET & aPheaz, ae Prater
wet arefevs: at artarét tq, aerator orftrert arf at |
(8) ate fret arent 3 outer Sota & orerhe Seon a & a7 Pee
arr ater F Stoo eet creme ter b, sa eto F oftatt wt ar eee cot Set ot Refer St, ar organ Te eer ore ar fe ae dar ae F re whiter oT sR arer safe safer A, ohre oe are & ater Sar a fara are, qatgah
TWIT BCT |
(9) ret +t ang arte &, ot ge Pry an ats oof any set eter &, area Feat wert oferta GS arrerdt ar ax Patees wife ortenfta a2 aie ost a ae Pei afar err |
(10) feet softens a ore crear & Sy Ee ah, BS varcor Pree caer & Reh ox Prateer at & sreer & gery fetes & sora Peet omer fate a ara area act 4 aftachs feat 8 oie fired afters sree om ae Prater at & fre os & afte aoe Patter siftert et ome, sa ax Prater av & dem area & aren AIT aor eet Prater safereartt eget ax Prater at & feet ase Prater safer ear |
(11) safrae (7) vat (10) & arf ora ener saPtes tard alae arsaez,
TATE Saar GH Tee Hera SRO PLT, WAL STH STUART arereT Bax ake MAIEST SAAT AUST eet are eta Bo TEMA ota aE A, BoM |
Fray 6—ahtrrr aeereh Prof
1 wars ote Hat Prater srftrearet, Ges-1, Ae y se arene ae aretevs wa Fas carareh & coftert waren oat at ere afer we A et we at fore Pree aaah 3
srfeber # ae srrafer sort et fas ame Prater arftrerd, wos-1, wep at ora aftr ata aret Et &, orfty evs-s & afta at rer &, After saftrancor 3 ge AAT quer
Punj Lloyd Ltd., Satoha, Mathura vs C.C.T., Lucknow, (TTR No, 368 of 2008
Dated 09.11.2011); (2012) 18 VLU 128
sgh Malin tbe}
opto de elle de OT ube bh 6 Iupb IndltabIo Kb Pile {le} be Yeh pbUle kk) se Bep
Dsb09 fe lll lndb98 Dota Ide ls se Bae oh Abb lie de ej Ble BERRI
2D [4 2+ OOL
SE ey 7 eee
—slirhlln Lbte| B kb bab} Jelolelte 1p 1g |Dpbts
ub 2 ‘@ Lbtb) Jat Whb B bible dM bb b plabke de Bibe le bebrb P buek)
{ped} [ale fp UR kb Bidbte lek) BQ pe Li 9 Dib f bebb gpbinj ‘pidbre BR. (IE)
1Q Bir tb Bhb Bible BElbS
babe fp hi sp dé B IG DIP Wh) yp lbp DIB Bb Wp Mb by rh Kye} Ye Bre (ele)
12 eB bewb) I Ibinth bbe pak wh 9 Dib kb kbb|alie bh bllae @
Mobb ‘bb|belb DIP Iplable by hubs dbbie) LkjDbh DEP kb Philo yee] yp Yee ee (bi)
, | 2 Deh de
punBie g \eltablIK op (lz) tebe (2) ibs Ue Jeb Up pblie Yah] LP ab yp LeBee —_(*8)
| Igjbie Jobe Wb pli yee) ye YeBe beh b kbkjajie — (Bib)
| Ibe DIK BL bépiph 2 Spm pris DK ke Yeh 2k ble — (21)
| IbjDie Balk hObrwWth Ye b> bush] B hd seB Mprite Iehie DIP piebhe (e1p)
12 Djs}> ‘2 Ul: Lhe) ebBle 2] 2eiye Ube WeyDbets He |
Whip Bee Isla} ¢blleD| Ab de dolby] IM IPblib ile b [yebj Wi kABR —-(B2)
| 3 Balk alle
DIS B Yidble ID Ib ‘YW flim Dike 2eIds kb plate Ie ‘YiBbbe ye] ——(#)
2) 2 abe bebb|i
biglDieb bebPie [we ibys DIP Ides
hb) (Philp wile Bie Ise dips sb Bik 9 sb \esb] ‘bijshale s IbliabIK we bbk|pile BS (Ip)
| 12 Bie Yb idk hOBip ob lye balls Mee Dipl ‘2B
Qh DIB Ppidble sj 2 ab bebDIK ‘2 Bl: Me bIDK & bY 4 2B Un [bigjpbh bake ab. — (&h)
-Q DWlidh b Pblie {gp} Bb Vib lchiie |p de bb IejDbbs
PRWeb] Ble Pbllo kee) Dynbie hABie & Z-bbb) ‘BQ indibble b Philo {se} ib Mb,
—Dbllb28] db bbe
DH Week| BOLTS Hla} DIP OLOT ‘|pbikbk} (LISP bIPR)) > DRjbP DI KD “TL
-2 DWjinje b Pblie (ge) Bb 2b
Iphiln Jp d be IbjDbb DHIWiinb) Bb Philo sb) Dibie hebie @ Z-khb|
‘BQ idiabie Philo Yb) belb 24>,—lndlabiP Kb bile db) bel Mb “S bbb}
\dsie| BF Diplo 4 (kp) lp (Ip) (deh) Soho 4 (42) Som Z Dib ‘BQ Indible
% Phi |ysb|—(UOeUIW0}0Q) IndikbiN ke (JeAOUINL) Pblie jb) *Z eb}
(Ang] pue eouepsou}) Ih? bh bible ke db
i>-blkale
SI 800% ‘\Pbikbh) d+ bhjbp bok JseK do Z bbb}
Tiles Unde} BeBe dee} Uae eb ABIDE yb de> "42 Lndpy
Hbb B Line 2b be Wb g wlio hij @ pbb 2 B Lbip Ip
Qidbhe We Q bp dé f febsD ob bus] |p) Jain be UD up Bidbre keh) 2 'Q (pla WB 9 Dib b bbb pbin) ‘Diabte ph
1 fl kb Bbb B Lilo b BBIbs Abe b bo Mb p
IPE DIE Lbisk) [lo IblDkets eR Bb |b Mb be rh Jeb) ju Bop
12 UsB bot) I Winth LiDER pe oh
#9 Dib ke bbbipiie dh bbe sb db sbbiib DIF piabho
4 Bib bin) BiDbh Bk |b Pblie |dsb) fb LeBsb Lo
| Bel dp 2ipbie sb Jbibis > (12)
Bob Se (2) Di Ye Ibbkh eb Philp jb) BHR Bb |b jeDop
Wee Jobo ub pile usb) iy UeBeb peR fp iebbltalic
| 1S|> bt
tals B kdd bédbIbh de DoD B dh Bik Lb eB ab bib
| 18) Dts
Pali heb ith to fd bdsp| b bo hb Dib hin DIP p1abho
12 bie Wa Lb
Ite) be Ble Die rely Lp Ibis (tb [Phil Dba pbicl
ibe} Ap Lo dele) Ide |Phib Wik bh js) Wik fe Ls (IR)
| 2d IK alk 2ki B Liabhe ids
Mabe “de Jlln Alle 29\4s Ich Qiabhe Ides ‘Yiaha Lest) (to)
(4s)
(ou)
(bub)
(:)
(Bib)
(ep)
ej @ Sh bes
Wolbers pebBio Joo ids DIP lds) id) Yb |pbjite Wile Ble
Ye is fe filly 9 se lyse) ‘bijsrale fo elbbiK sb kbkjlle BS
1 \Pi@ WJOdJh B dololp bbb
Midle| fp ho te maple) 2% Italo Ibip Alo fplgjidbty Deeb fb
8 Inbb| Ipjbjojells 24a Wfajap tal Ibe dae
(2)
(wh)
91
frat 9 BAT Tear RT aafifkr we roar, 2008 17
Fray 9. feet dart dar (Works contract) & Promet F eretwren rer a fers
@ oTect BT TTATTT—"(1) ger Preerereht a over wafer a atelier weet Bo, taf
ard after & Proaey A wae eey, rere ot ah oreet afer B wr Fy (as
aay S ST A see otez feel we A) aierer wart & ay Pay one oe ae a TAT |
Be AT RT DT HT AT PA orrecé oe ait oneal wet orev ferkeerer FaPrfese afsrat
aft vat ort after Ft grat gf &, ar aren wt are aroha F afeafere B,
at ee ger feat are
(@) wert are efter a Pee % eet (Consumed) BF 71g agai, forte
sat TAS B a FH at gor BB yer a aver sro;
1. SH. Tea Sather Be (fate deters) Peaqraet, 2010 are Rare 4.2.2010 & Prevferert &
wart oe were —
“(1) ge Pramract & area sfterst & orefty cet oy, cent core efter a Progret A aT Tey,
forever feat ah sreeat Sas Har + (ns gay H wa A reer ort Pel wT A) aATCT Bo
B, aot few orreret x eae BM ToT ape ate ere MAT ape eee Fart rrereh oe at TTC et reste eeret
fates after aft aeret amret after A seer ee &, ar seer ert areht errafirat F aeafera &,
a Se Ger fear ae |
(ae) det ene after & Prone & oro et ae geal, Rrra otereer rahe B ws F Tet Es
&, & yee Ht are erase;
(@) wopRT age B art after yee, at erat craft,
(a) wart cord after & Proven 8g oS oe aft ag safle Ge STH IC PTAA Sl AS STAT
Sas AT AST at TET erase;
(a) Sar oie argh os ge Oe aT, Bt THAT TTA,
(s) dart art after & Premed & orien Peaite aed ar ape Pree wae H BT A otereT
afreita ara ar ary F gar & |
(a) dart ane after & Proves 8 archiver Pratt seg aor yee Perea ah S BT A greet
area a eter & aver Prafa F ar ae at stat H shee area F Bor BI
(8) Sa AAT TRPSHT Hr HT Perea Past a Sr stereo TT H wT A MT S aT BaF |
(=) gant after are aor Promres eet are Saaerkt, at Aet aeqait Ht alla ae He ay F Ferg
waa art &, B art wet S hee aS |S wy aA Fe TSS St HET orafera
(=) araert are cater areeret & atdt ag aT-Ae seal S APT Bl MrT Tra;
(51) aifardt & eer HAE STAT HUA Ts Sar wart HET S Maer eer Hr we aT eT
gent & aren ae, Ut ST TT aT aT TATA |
eqete—wavs (am), va (S.) & (or) rem Plies eget & yer A oe ae are A afRafere TT |
(2) aiferar a Pareit sref aor eerert BA a saree afer arr eer eT S aaret Mg erraH sa
fear a fer aferarcnre a era aot AT eee TAT AT STA |
(3) afte eifererenre aren ca ay eta A ora et Vaaeh oT RT, eT TA Te ASH ATA SECT
a cof a ot ar arererdt rer TA Ty He Pega ae a wt, aT SeETE T eHlg Ha TA et Te,
arate came moar a wwe HY ferfter reg a ayer srrert at orererfRer wwe a Fer ATT a ereeHt A
agfoter amredt ay crferterer rer aoreih AY exrererdh aay weer BY Geet AT MTT VY arch TewT TTT eT
ster farce rare, Ser err er after evry At re ase rect Beret Fee oT Are ser
At arcoft a were 2-H aftenftrer ar Ofer eneoit HF ore Map ere 3 FH sifewer wae ae a
arora eh Bem yee rer a Te afer are A TOT HTH TUT TE A eer FRAT TT
(NT SPT Ys TEccssene )
a | Wijoilh bh ‘eet pub
: bel) BOER kb ba) Inb| Ub lok ‘Inbal
Lepelh) bh plhile ke Bais bh doh ‘bie ‘BabIe
bhi Id LK!
ae bh Ube lee SP) ‘|SHAI ‘Lalo Ie jnib>» ‘jnlb>>
| doje) Ide have) Ink bh Inbip ‘LisbEls
YE bb b Why ‘inde ‘bib “Sh ‘WE ‘kbk Bin pi WEI)
ZOE Bhifeb bd lojise| le 2h Webi bh 221 Lip
bade Injsk} Ie 2WS IHS iSlb kb LOlb Ile
‘EL
ZL
"TL
OL
, Injiab) Ide Lele Dike
ol bhp PHY th Iie Sle bie pe) plhue Die pi
ple Lp LinsB S2IBIie
%OT ipb Lbe\h) bh pfbite Yb intb! bbb) bh dal bch
Shite bh pih ib 2 DajayP DABS
%OL feBin} Jodteh® Yplnb| ‘reith} bh plhiie jy Lileib |pinb|
Yor bhipeR bh Dihie it DISK Bib PA EWEIDIb
bhi? bh plhlie |p ‘2
‘ BBP (bith [shibas)) lodP¥|ele bh (a1 bladeHlishib2)
%0l bp Indpiplie ‘EP SEDs ‘Dols HIS bBlel ‘be LWeE wip
%01 bhib>® bh lojieh| ke PEPE bh adi}
%OT bhieb ba lofiek) db GIRO [pb bYs
2 DPa|b led ISH bh lh ‘Inlisbl kt b51>b
%01 ‘BBS & 2I_ bBlal lk 1S BO bh lojisk) Ke Lielebrp
Ol Eble Pb ajok Kb Beigh BA EDR
(e) (2)
» Indbb) ke DbIB PSR ob ots
dl
WpIgIDb DER | ‘hiD 2h BS ph YSink Me Ibe
“bight PHP |e Ig, belb LIDAR Ibplo Ble |e bib dh
Inthe bh bis 3h |) 2h Sik Be bblish) @ IebjP ple fp
‘pigIDbb IH ke ‘bsh pajp bi @ YeB pefre
6 hbk b\g}>bik Ye DRjB bib Ises Ve
(ia)
(i)
(8)
BI
Ib ‘Ja b belb Bibsb} Bb bk O> DIF abte lp 2 b joe B bbip BID Dintin
th BS Ib ‘pe i> JlolbR bh DBink b JO} Di B> DIF dd>ldbIp dlp (E)
| Aehlin Jtis JED [db Jello Jeo LILA |e 2e>Idb|P Did) 4 Ibjh BE Iejde Bp
tpl B bok Ipbjp DIS Jpbjb Indie go p/2 bho Ie PIs [Ped} Kb Labje (2)
| U2 poh PW) Pyle Iasi Flr Bibb
B bapbs © Indibh) PhS be b ebb > bik © bik Dpble
6681 abh be DIS PidbIlwin| DhsJb:h pilD Ie bik dbJp1b
Mp kif [bib bla BEEK b Injkk| bb DIS dabei 2Sdb
12 Dawe Ye lbjDb fe BID BBS “12 Ile Ld)
DijeB bok ib bik |e iain b ‘bb (In) B (8) Ibb (&) Spl
(1!)
(1)
~‘ladbipah>
: 2 Bk bh BiPbR [Dib LB BK lbRP IDE
bol
dik |b be beRS b loth) @ (LSdbj) bbb
Q Lb Ibe) bIDL, Id dé Didi ob
Jelmbis se abn Ib 2 Ible Lhd) Pailin bln be bk fd
Dk he) Ikin AB) S Bibim db hele DIB dMdlpbIBhE — (\I)
Q bbiph Dpbie kbkibje MelpbIphe —(\)
| \2 DiglikK 2b PRs} Ie PBK ich-lolik
Bib B PitrllK dprliak| de MblebiPhh “f Bebb Isp
(pir ge bib heb 4 bdlhob) o IbbIP db ‘Web dibIDbIBhE
| 18jD bet
ke bl th bE bh ‘pe blo % 2K BB do BH lb Ihe
Dre P bd bibK IbR bh pb pldho Pink DIE sb |pbip
‘UpIg|>ts Deb Jeo
poh @ \eB>b 2b-blb Sl [PRR B Yisbim Pblinh DIP Plabho
‘IblgjDb DbR kb pS 2b bik he
RRB B Iih & Bel DIS @ "2 lpi bbe A be db dh bY
ke YeBeb Ip lle ‘Qiabhe Lib p> bbibeh) I pi Ibib pbb
[2 Ue 2b B DIK b he
2 Rjbrh Ibis LeDhe gb |dse} Ibbin) poh Ib eByb Dep bo
1@ U3 b Biblio 2D & IIB
Dil lp & Dipk) ib g Ikip fe Dik IDB bk bo } DjheB
lbin bob i Bib bigs) Perle fe bblish] IbID pid pap
12 US & bolgllp Ib bike bipeb-rieie Ibi fp bo g D)red
lpBin| bo ie Bab Didsb) Detpeie b bbiteh) 4 IPbIB pi Jeb
61 800% ‘dblbbh| 24> Delph beh leek pe
(th)
(h)
(12)
(4)
(18)
(a)
(2)
()
6 kb!
OV
%OE
Ol
WOE
%OE
BAA) Beko (ge ban! InbIp Ib Nes nba
Beh) bh plhiie (> pois bh diwh ‘b—e “AISI
EhineB
| Init) Id bade) Ine ph Inbip ‘biab3is bh
R Bhy ‘lobe ‘hib “Sp ‘DE ‘Lbk Bip pie bbINy
‘OL
“SI
‘PL
Sl
“SL
%0E
%*OL
Bhi bd loft} ke 2): We|ple bh 2215 LID
lnjiake) Ite 20% De |SLb kg kAlb dolls
“LIT
“OL
*OL
%OL
Uofisbe} Leb Jelee
AYE Bie Be dh nde 2S bl pe) pihiie DIF ppp
Pie Ite [nek se4DUe Itb Jebel}
bh pple Yb sblnlib| “Meibeh) bh dajch
*OL
bhih bh pih kb 2 Bilielh NHB pBiol
IodPhS |Pieb| ‘kelth) bh pihile |b bikIB |Winb|
%*OT
*OL
bhibeh bh phe | spisK Bib bh LPbpIDIp
bhi bh plhile (yp ‘2 pidjtelp (epich
ISkth2-)) Inepsjinio bh (ald bikebylishiba) pp
loddISile ‘ich QEbIs dint his Rin) ‘kb WEE pp
*O0L
%01 bleh bh Iolite) Ite SWIRS Id bes
%*O01 @ Dial led 1S bh plh ‘Iojbb} eb b3)1>h
‘S
*%O1 bhi bh inal kb Deijsk bh EbR “1
(8) (2) (t)
Jodbe| ie Lek} be fyb
"hs
6 bbb
pdb
| Urniin Ihe} Jab
B Pbiip Wer gdb Uelolr |e KID Diojle dh BO Ib bye lbh bh YSink p dv
DISRIS Bbfle f € bebe DEP bho fb [add Dlalb Lh BEAWIG fr Z beD? & |fad1b
\go Dro NO Ishin lpe| lek P Phim WR b Dk | iD Dine dh BS ID lbp
‘Pls DISRJS Bip le Ij Web |plb ba Lis Lb (eB 42 Bik ke Qiebko &
Jbl bee De'Y_Ye 4 fbi Diab & Yoib Ye pip Dw) & bp DIIRbIe Ke Polis
bik Dap bybie & be & Limb b UP IPR ‘Bb YB O BP Hw & Biabte
Ib|s}>bik Mb Dpjbh bok kph dbo 0G
Reb PrP pilrld db bith I IRBDIK 98g DeBio 4 bibbIp 4] Ibi Ibi b Blob} ps
@ [phate Soh DobS bbl | lb) b (FOS IplPBh 88-C661) lo ba bold blero blab
tele PD {pehre Sod PbS bey b lb bib|p |e pilbi» balbb bipbla :bh Ibis
IbBin| blk Be bt (OZE IpIPBA S2-6861) IbS/3 HO bbb/h bbb Ibol3 hilo bishbUbD
PSX8) & lp bikklb kb bibl: balbb bipbik WHbiiPph ke bRIEP POP °S
| le}
& PBibi: bolbb bibbilt Ik b (60% IBIPRA ZF-BZ61) ‘KD 2% Lb| Debi
felb “RY'LK ‘Yobr> IrdipeiinS 2B Ljojp Whip» Pir zh | lells IPiejh {ee ysl
k (S61 IPIPRA Sh-6261) “6D 2 {ob DEBUO bib’ Pbb LYbhilins Bap
Sof 22) kD & bPiblb» polbh bibbilt | lsbi> bh Init} I bY b Bk! (I!)
| Hrd Jb 2d dh |ehIB DPRK b Ibb>R bh Dihiie lojeb} Jp
jSokj “Bip? Bish) fb lebis blr pllb id} 1p>b fol py 2 Lelie pd tale
bajph bibbit b (PRA 89Z IPIPPA 97-0261) BDEL Libb bol blind (|)
2 biptblbbie blob) Jahbab Ink) b ADR BE | bok
Un Lpde} [Pls Bape Deb dh [fell DEBK fe Injiele] bbls 4b) Ubllt bs bidibplbs bal fllsblie
b (PRD ZIP [piphA 6-8S61) fol blinh Hibb 2RYI2 W1LP/Im IRD (IPRA BBE IpIPRA
6-861) bob Jeph bak bib belo bh Pith ‘BID [PUbb VEJh | |e [Bb Ib>bho |b
fel: 24 dh [ki Ul jo DPRK f bP WhIP! Pinlinb|ie Ph B ERUER Pov “T
blob} Jahbalr bhdikb—B bbl}
| JD ke [Pie DIE ipIP & be & PAIR B MdIbIR — (2)
| WD |e [ples Fle fe DIP [opie B Hib Bde) pele Lp Lelie Jp
Sp lp bibeh bd p bla bbwA I PIs jp) fb IbiIp B NdrbIR —_()
[42 Peps
\plin | |piee & be o IPP Lh di Ye |pe) in WIDER ab — (4p)
“tpn ge Jeb [pled P {biajiK Bb Ibis|Peb fd pie PEI atl}
BQ bib blnlilie Ie Ike yp Dike Digs) bib) gb IpbIB pebb pjpbato
hk} BS %) 2 Iblis Ibe) zak Sb DISD hid} & IGP) @ ap (7)
12 Wlb bi2 Blk Ibtle 2 $3 DIK f bblbh) ob pi gK
@ IpbIP ple ob} [in pl [2b baie B BIBI & Iejbbts Jobb
2b ‘12 Ibe lbp) D2 ddl>bib-h® Ibtale dMbIDbIH LbI> Id>bin|
‘Hl Diplo 2h BH dle IbB bh Pink Q iin bo) palpi
BQ bblish} (tb ebldb|P-hO Leib Bib ie IbbIP pie lp Dh Iain (hr)
ible \2 Iblis & Make
Ieb\P pide ke jb bem ‘plbippi Ibi: Ibe} \d> Me>ipb|R-he Jain (152)
ible 2 ible Ibi} & fb Indiisk) dp $e lp Shih
Bee fb beltsk| it Ipbib pbb |p) dip bilo @ bbb} pS — (x)
—! In>4b}pahe
1G 800% ‘IWbikbh| db DpibR bok pK 2D 6 bbk|
“2 BuO bob) Mee) b bpp © RY GP MP dh BE |p Q ldlin tbe) WprIPk Ele Dip kb diwIDbIp DIS IDbIp “a (bidlielte bah BIS Sr IPRA SE-z66r) HOPIP Hiab “bj Pbhd Soh bi (A)
(2ipSoP bibl» bap [bah
60S IPiPBh 29-Z661) fel PD bold M2) bbb bie Mb dU Ldbbjlnd dip (Ai)
(bidlipliee bat Ike Ke LOZ YBiPBA E8-1661) UoIpYP blLb ‘Wy Seefh (It!)
(98 {BIPBA FF-6261) bold EDK bak bibb Pb dbIS (\I)
(bible bap I Z6E Ipl>Rd 99-6661) {elpbA bike Bhif tw (I)
, “2 Jobb2h Plob) DENI In
B BEB BS | @ QB deb Pk lbh BO Ail Mb Plo IB-pldh Biepnlio Wo g wp rw
REE (yp eBeb lib p12 ible $e bibs It Ip-plth BQ ibelb ple dubIDbID “p
«LR Pb db bajjehl [fs De [yb 2 Lvie-LIin P Ina] ® [leBob Ibtin ‘2 pep rw»
Rubell tls 2D (pe 2p Jp oh dieb>b bold AMY sb [FHIPDEBK fr IPb|P ple Jp) | 2 Pow IB
LBL Dg) se pale HOW [ln 2 [PP 1d bipbIIK kb [Pie pd» Pas}b] bh Whi
biPLE Dik & BPR & IbB bh kate b ob) Ibke bd] lh Mbblo Bb kb Die>B hab “g
| Bib Bik DRjPb P pI de dbp (IIA) ‘PE & Mess pele
PRIPB B BP|p the 2b (IIA) “2 B IPR bh bis BBP [Bin Jp [pbB Iehik>
Kee didpl>b}B (IA) ‘dls Ie [eB eb hollsho (A) ‘|om I abeeblio die Lis Lng|
“Leejd (Al) ‘UeDde) ible Ibe) bij BS? bh Pelish B2 pips & bIPpi
(I) “Hub ple Uteeb) fe Inbh 4 IbR bh dite | debI>bJPho (II) ‘“injale 2b» (1)
“2 2 ‘2 Iwlle Lp
nish) belpp 12 Bibsh bleh B & bIDLR bp |b IspER DRI BLO bipie jeRap
ek} B & bbb Bin 2pEie phi} Ib) PEI Me Uhh Ai} bwIbe] bh pep)
bel Mb SE bidlblbs palbh bipbib 4) Ile lh ab tab JohbDak PBR br blob) BE | 2 {pb db |p Deiisk| (SNS) hiedbIe le [eb) 21> bol b BPR [456] PID KDE
|ibk Ibe} Skis |b |eBab beh b ibbjbpi DS pr BRUSB b Iblhh | lYsb|
2 ZOOZ'S'TT ibd) IP Ibd} 24> Philedjh b bbb RIO Mb jYsb} plat |e abs |e> opp
B SO07'S"EL sblbd| DIB SOOT abh BEBIh } 21> Be AT pm | LelPiskb! Dblo
Qipp | b> blk & BPR & Ibi pple bi bibbils ST bh y1-Db lb biRbUIK ¢
bh 7’ Dib big | 2 [pb Pebsblie |b BRUTE |p) Alyy SPH |p 2B 12> Lin [eb Doiheb
bejPpit Sib Bib DED @ bbk|piie Mb [dob] bist 4b) Ible 1B | Bb be blob] BE | 2
Kp [tb Ipbjb b debipbyb [dbb) We YoPob bo oj 2 WO Lin Lele Bp Vitel ‘2 Ible Lb fp
IPbIP ple Jel 1ebbein} GP Leb 2d dh Dele Jt [OBeb bh 21e>>H old ob) 2 Ile Ip! de
bibblIk 2b bb B bbs por Boje ‘2 Ila \Bb MaBIS Ie RIO Ib 2D, Bub Wow
WP 2 ipus jhip Bob Phyb) bho ~ Inj) |e \pjP DIP MiDbIp I Lele | bidlblbe
hojbb bibbit b Pink} [pS | 2 Ipl2 [2k lhe Bib dh Bio} 2 DRJbR P bb bh bis
Iebjb BBS bh 2 {pid Ibhpdb dh Bin) 2 kp Indie & Iejbpl @ LeBeb bp yah | 2
Ik Ip] }> Dotebl fr Iielts Jp 1 JobIP Diniikblio B he biel Ibtale B hs wbjhdi De
® LBUSP POP | 1k/2 PhiPile Mb JZ dh LR bash) Dhdjedyh PEO ‘g 1/2 Inddie le [eBap
bin} ho Bhp ‘Wehiin iby] J2b Dp|Pile 2 db WIPER DEP we RBEIC 4 Bin ‘2 pe
Delibbis Dw) jabba & pidiblbs balbb bliblis fr bjok) BE | LUerlin Lede) DP ddd
6 bbby lp|e}>jlk db Dajbb bh Ispk das i
| petals. |faLte
Isto] ‘2 Ublin Idd fe | Linipibe I>bie| PibUe Lph ke Bab) & beh DEslby
oh Me) MIDbID DIB [IP [eb lel bt blob (22% IPIPRA 01-9661) bod
Bibb bbgh bbb LIRARIPD pars) 2/2pj Be & bibl bajbh bipblie
BDhPibb| dh |pink| LS | [pJ2 |b [ys] Bl bP 2 12> Lin Ibe} 2H che
KS, DhwPb Bb Pip HI Iblk & bidipiy pap DIbIBIDE Pipblk: fx bok) &
(99% IpIpPA ZOI-9661) “HD 2 [esb| BeBlio bbb bide By WBE Sad
HPO bop ‘[philn [ple {bj eb debIpjh DE JpbIP Bp BL Q Iblis Id)
B & Be} DBo5 Die dipwe binjbibh IHS die 2 1D>> BrP dh DI Dba
wh bie bh 2hlp Ba Liph fy Lb p pit | ppl>bIp [pbjb dh [ais s} Q 1p
& RDlpiPp» balbh bibbib b (89 {PipBaA 22-6861 JbP pbiPi» bah lépb
Blk PSP [BIPRD ZOL-9661) bol JePK BI H1bb “Bf Lieb) Pies b/P ald
b BbR BS | 2 \ph (2 fehl chile MhBIS Ye Bh WS B wh wh J Ulenlio Ip}
bit 2b Indlt> % p12 IelbH Lb YeBeb LO fy IDbJPpl 4b) 2 IDiln JB [pk Lh
bpd I Lib] B bp 2% Sb Bb re 2 BE Jub) Wb [eB 4) Yb BH) Bh
2b ) 2 2h $ Likbj dk Bb Jz Web Ln Ipbd} bjok} ajo [ab ‘2 bifbills
Ibb ¢ Bpbio '2 1oaB Ib |v |ieh Jbl> 4 2 lblin Ipc} Dajb} 2h Mble @
Js BEEIC b Phib Spo Bb | 2 [pdb Ln Iblis [Pe [sb] Mp ffekIb BS f
By} APA “2 [Pun kb Bhib | Ipbjb Ih [ebib 33 pb dhe 2 ile pep) Bhib
Bb DDhO © Libis DIP 2>e ‘plln \Y IbaglbIN 2eIe Me 2bis fb Lepsh
Ip 1? Bie “g jplln ye Bub |b kb LirbjB fy bs @ {p95 DIP |pbjp rh
IBin | 2 2h PHP 4p|bio ‘Ie ele Ueda) Pdllh elO dh Ibi OT-lnlidp
bbe © BbE b blob} ~ Bhi “kD J Ibh We PRE 12 Ip |b”
Job th Seb) BE B MP) b Iplnkl (99ST [PiPiph 6861) “WyLb Inffosns
Soh LIPAIK DBO Bibb “HD 2% Jdsb) Debue ba (212 Ipipiph Z661) 2
{@b| Debio bi-b Bbpio} [ple (62S Ipiplhh Z661) Debio d@ fsb) bib’
Lisl By BL Sad Belle Ike (6ZS {pipibh S66I) 2b [dsb] dbebJe>
beibb [dpb ‘Ublip “bj beaphlh MesiWelh Ph bpSs vib binkl
Belk “bD'ED | le pl ple 42 blab} le (15B)inSiS shie RIbhbIIBA pSrp|
ft BUSH @ bbl pajlpP Ribkib Rh Pe Rink) 2h p) 2 Id) b Indie
2» Dike kbg|h & Plokl 2 (EO! PIPBA 98-2661) be Wikb bbejh Lb’
febb DeWhb bib | Urhiin Lp) Pape db IEbK 2h BH ‘2 jPiin 1 pihuie
{ge {fbb fin [de 2idlppib 11S [pbb el lig Ibi & PidiPie polbb bibbil: b
lnk} & (IPRA 89F {PIPRA 22-6861) Le/PRD bbb [phe Soh While “bd bA
Piphb} SHS | 2 IPle [ak IPhp>b |g Indl b12 b PAle) Joh chile dh DIS
BRE BP “2 1b2> Ink-fb} {2 1 D>H HRP dh |ebIP IBA dip | 2 Ipp Dd
cnye 19s, B2 Libis ff bP ple pep) de> w [in pplin Ill 2 dh LeBeb Le |
2 Bb Usk 2h Ip Weebelipb| I liz 8 Bh b bink| & (OL IPRA OZ-2861)
BIEARIPA pabelb hie bIRSth Pilblp balbP bibl b BEB BS | Uhl
Kp IPE PRIUG IDE IBA b bb bes) belo bp ‘2 1d» 2» Jab Bhd
bol; Pith pho de Q Ir PIblle Kp Wis A) & Da 12 bhip PpIB Bb
i Ielt 2h & Oh blikb|p [op bidiplie palbP pibbilt b blob! & (pha OE
4pipha €2-7861) Ipsjs die bbb bbb IbSIS HUO LIKDRIDD PSopy IPP (I)
eS 800 ‘|Pblkbh} db PRibR bok Isp pho 6 bbb}
24 wat sae arr daft ee artatatar PrA 9
9. Tart Bea TH SS Seer oT aT HT BP ga Te A er THE atte
efor qarr asta mer (1998-110 TAA 113 TERT Ter AMAT GSTS); SEA ae
ae FAT oTaTT TT (2002-127 Trtet 561 merch ser ~arenra astis) F
oat F Aaa ar wert Fer aa Taw ae fer. TIT Her Wer (2002-128
cada 452 Ber Tar ATTTT GSMS) B ae H Taye TTA TC SSL STT GA TET eT
rad amcafeite fat Rafe wet omrere a aor fest At Fifer af ora: ae sifted cae
At Tar | eras} orqede-206 H starter orcutatter feat aera arena oe Prater ar
a aft ret faa oe TT ATH HVS HT aaNet TST He Tet @ | Tet Profs Aer wear Ser
arr Ht got tte + oreawarer galfrge TT wer Tee TT (2007-6 Agr 1) 4
fear | se dae F arite aates srarera F Aer fears ae fee & fe fet orefefear
® ae der TT aes Pe Rear Rewer os Sette feet He aferhrara St a 3,4 Ta 5 a
daft 31 sear art 2a H ae A TT oradte few ot orfafaar A wget are 4
daft ona 2, sa ox & ae yataas ome ae fe fart area aot, atetee at
ere ar wftarctar Rraffta at ait afer | ga dda At ter arent ath shear a7
agtar wee (2000-3 cadet 200) & ae # aria water NAT H 3 Wot F ae
gitar Rar Braet orpercn arte acter arava 7 et vera srreedt gars fenracr
gear (2000-3 vadtet 319) + Pre, sad are gt Profal & ded A arta Ser Ararera
3 artery rote faa 8, Ss Re ores es eae aaa organ fast ax (2001-124 Tart
2 Word ser =rerere eres); Ager wer sare oredr Ws STAT (2009-20 aga
42 Meret seq arate a@ustie) ane |
7. sri geet ox raat afta arebafaar & chest ware ST B, HT
arate aét Rear on apa | Sharad Carer Ta THeMst WT (2004-137 Tackett
306 Uae ser zara @vedis) Ud seat Hele wenger afd FATT He
ar (2009-26 dead 213 aia ser Maa Grete) & aet F aE Ara AT z |
8. af ae at svafaaren & At aan ona @, ca Ht hat UH et Hara
dae atk un & Bs Aa ae oe | wea Cos eget fer. TATA ATE Fear WHT
(2006-148 Tada 616 org yee ser mara austis) & ae F ads eye FST
afeerare & | seit ortent are srdfaarenre ar Sie feet | afaet ar get Saafararant F HR
argaer wet or aie vet Gare rem farferas ater a | ferarr + ara fee ger at feats | Test
ouefiarnt & afaeran ar att gat yer dfacrnr & afact at | aatla Sea ~raeta 4
art fi sadfaerax hat daca & wie & or 4 art areal s | aa: Saat UH et
arare feat & | soefaarare are are afadh at stant sits wroet at tet , gafere fear
amet ar at aftern ot wa srafearare We | Face AAA Ala Aateq wads F
ane gear wer ware anda ws ezait (2008-9 Geet 191) A fear sa Pref &
ayant srefearan & fear et ot Set ar arenas Te, + fee afearenre wr | Para:
areal giant ath wrod st Jee oe @, gafera fore ETT IT Tea Hr aire ST WETS,
ae ae dfaarnnt et sear srafaarare, ararfter SH TAT Ie STAT z |
9. Tea HT aA 3 Te a eta S| Tee Galas Krad oraret waferat F ar
aaferat atafte at ort &, ore oy oe Fear STAT | GAT Wart gat Ter Paferal S
are oer aafet et Gist art &, re fe feret asf ar ast H eax order aire fOefesr | free
asia er wa SN or Poe, I Te
|
rar 9 Sat West yea daftfa ac Praaraci, 2008 25
10. 46% Gsitery B are ae Rar aT arasan at & Pe feet are afar F Sriri|
aiadae ea 2? sarect & Pre calfaufes dhe art fer. eat Aha. (Gengene 2001
vad 862) & Puta 4 area eae arerera & 3 ~arareltsit > arat fer afe feat ayer
H yer ae Ulta & aire Geet aegait ar gerne aE HHS at oh Oe gaa site sat
og ardefeer AA BU He orf ear ore | arate Sates areata AF ge feared a
falfaanet oa war fra fates aart afters ate steer (gangare 2006 vaet
1983) % fear & | saa ved tat were da sary TET Weer THT (GaTEIK 2000 Tat
gos) % fra Aa Grad frat at Brat Gres F afta ger eA SF aren Hreast
adftan ot aetaan vet art act a, afer ae Pofe cetfaefes Ht aartt fer. (Ga)
frofa orarer ape fear se & aie set Prot H arene we aed ware te Wes eefoat
aa ardtet (2004-134 wadidt 570 ante seq rearerey GSMS) H are H wHreraTHleh
ara ot He arretfter fear sar |
11. wrbefeer ya feet st sitet F atae-
za dda & ove gee cer aay ara uctided (sar) fer. (gengene 2005 Taet
1581 gee Yio wae) & fof # rama vitae ee 1a S| ae agda ot at 1,
aeat ox, oft ox oltx vail & araareit oc Prk ore & | ale fare deat ar feed Fea
} fare Prat wet aes ara or ged a ae sete AB, eT H TF ar HAT FT
fectat & ont 8, aa ae fast ar agqde Heo 81 arta water aI 7 Fe
feared oferatfet fear fer:-
“In a ‘contract of sale’, the main object is the transfer cf property and delivery
of possession of the property, whereas the main object in a ‘contract for work’
is not the transfer of property but it is one for work and labour. Another test to
be often applied to is : when and how the property of the dealer in such a
transaction passed to the customer : is it by transfer at the time of delivery of
the finished article as a chattel or by accession during the procession of work
on fusion to the movable property of the customer? If it is former, it is a ‘sale’;
if it is the latter, it is ‘works contract’——The essence of the contract or the
reality of the transaction as a whole has to be taken into consideration. The
predominant object of the contract, the circumstances of the case and the
custom of trade provides a guide in deciding whether the transaction is ‘sale’
or ‘works contract’.—— It is settled law that the substance and not the form is
material in determining the nature of transaction.”
12, arora + Hantlle ar Prahy fear & frat teats ararit ar garr fear * aa
QS AM aaa fever ar fort ot HT ae AMT et | He Prater arftreare + ga arene az
at arta fran fer fafa sentte wn at rar aeq & | atftracor J adits we sa arene
UX Aare fre fs Hate & frator 4 oygat aferatsr aed Gwaad & six etar & Prafr
4 dt ae veer seqatt ar wart gar @ | feat getter get otrenre at oredienre fever aa
fee orftrencot ar Profa ofa & |
C.C.T., U.P vs R.P.G Transmission Ltd., (TTR No. 771 of 2011 Dated
12.12.2011); (2012) 18 VLU 107
18. arortt us fafaa dfaaren & frat oy. cat orders fetes waa cer
ufax fis arcaitert site gfar S ore afar h wa A grater aes at taro, Beer afkx
Ublols ye eb bese) AE Diebie & (\)(\p)(Z) sone Dis vp bbbeltalse dep Dihlho of Malls 1A
12 Oe & Peippl dol) S “AD bibs MPO dip 2 Dilele Wis fy be MaBIS I> p
B Bip 2 lh 2b @ “B'S bls bh BbdDlo bain [Ypbin| 2 dIDbIB Piblbo “BT
LOLITA SL (LLOZ) Grueay sebey myay ‘SuapBly NUBYS SA ‘JD
12 dpb Dajky IWhe de Flee Indide
@ EE Shbee YihIb Ink RRO de 2 bb\Pple pie Bp uj ‘eb Dejh |e Dkr b Inddbyie
Ae Ibe) Uelpe ff bbipip bee bibbik DS pe Wis Lb Ybink| |tbhlo Bis} Lb
Dbl> InP EA f Leib} | Up | Ihelh |b bbb tb Pihibo B Wiple [> kK beb|id ‘Iplew
Me Molly BB dth abel, BE f Plbhjie laditeb) db | 2 1Bk [Whe db Sie bo AWIES
‘2 BOK Mb [ebb DYDio ib “g IpIa IWhd Mb dh Yeti DEBK pBinj 2 bIPplw ap
SR) Ui UnSte Id Feline | ke Bob BIB [gbhe dode> Inltsb) [eb Jpalb2> dh DIU Bin) Lode)
Bpbie teh bie6 | fp PMb Spm kb Wore LaA{t) De Inlalte Sh? Bihito “AT
OLA
St (LL02) ‘peqeizeys ‘peoy 11'9 ‘b9-J “PIT Wd SIA|U OISUY SA JN “LL'D
| Ukhlis Lede) DbjDue 2d 4) Lets be biditeite
Bee Dill ft lol} bijelisb) hip ‘Ye [Pky IWhp jv Pibibo f |Wihie {PARK | Lie
12) 12 Ke IPblinh® Indbie i jeB>b Jb BS 4) ible Ibleb 2 AD pik Bb b hd-6 Dib
Me inbkeayie 24 Phi | Le Wile Ut) DIP beh Libs Ie Webi bh bE HHS | Lie Wiin
MRR) SE lolelte bebe) fe Prep pit Ib LePa|h) |e 22) BIW dh bbIIn Biblto "PL
/eunqut QL (8p ‘10A) NLN (zL02)
‘d'N 1'0'D SA pegeizeyy ‘Jayey BnAAeNn ‘p/ELL “PIT UOISSIWSUBL, “Dog
| Able Uiells PRje kp de DhIDUO 2h BE :PiO fe spb Lin Pld JBk Wb) DDE 1p yeB>b helhbh | be) 2 Pilbb Mb Pajlle 2h 2ipdbi> } ladhjie dh Ibe BE | Q Ib Ip dw
2b YeBbe yile 2hip “hip DB biphe f kdb dike pS wojp 'B Jpb Ie up dw Sit»
B Lube dh BS dye Q Ill pe) br ble db bSd}bj Inthe Lbbiey 2 Bab Ypib Jello eb dpb
fe Unde) (fb lnjisle) <2 LSYej sbojp ‘pla ple Bob ‘bpolajib Bi ab ‘2 Pr Uhp apww
He 2k Ne Mplbly) 2k fete b Yelh “Dib ‘Dblp fr les) Mb Inflate} PSdb) 4) B Ihde Lbdy Rjok) 2b fr bib sisi (796-C0h 9-bhwlb (PIPB 9861) Wk “WDD blab bold So)19h
22 (eb) Metkese » bible hah Fblt piptelk |g JoheJE Welln Led) PdNhe} de depLute Ib MRE fy boleh} { IPbIP Mbikb Bap wile apie b> b lipho & ieDop
eS 3B so) Q eB Mb Indibbite | Q ibe) PhILU 24> dh DOM Me vio ‘ip du) pi
SREB lbdiihike Diehie Me 2 yb biDs Delidw & Biphiio dh DUP Sb? | ¥ Pajlh
PUR be bE bo '2 Ue8 ltt lin iu pluie {PDL ‘Dub Wah ‘DbIp fr bd Lape :Die | B
Mle Ub’Q) Helle Le2pdbd> eb Ubeds|is Ice pee INA |eb pple BE due 2 kl Ip [bins 2blbDHe) Leth
MEDIS Qiile 12109 ‘2halp "ip pho wre FB [o> |DDe fe kelfeln Dw) & op 1S rosin
RIB @ jPbink by bitin b PbI2 sb LEU LIBRIDIS 4) 2 PhD P JPwLE ) IBD) b
lope | Uple ke Dbpt> Wihie PIPE) Bb Heb) Pin} Uhle Lb) DAIKHIK Dib b Diplo Hei
| Uble Inte) BhiDUe 2b Jp dh Bie Bh 2p [bP ‘Hollneng ‘2hVg ‘Sue ‘Ibe pip hBdp
Rolahf ApYv}le PRE | Ip} Phidlle Mb dh Bib fpr Iplkb B awip do sty “Dip
SRAEZ 4 Qikbaio | Q ky Dicbip> Ihe dh DIVE Ukr kb B Bibiinhio | [lle 19k Ib rep
Fue dh Bin) ke DBE (ve dito SP “BO'kD ‘2bIP SWZ ERO |g lb) ple 1 bby
6 bbb] Idpi|pllk db BRjbh bok IbeK pop 9%
bIb¢)|-bIBAl Ib Lj > PP Fb Bib DEH bed ‘2 (yp B |bplhike Déljeh DE \yeBS de
2 Ib] pie I plap) PO do Slab |e bBlh b1B-H Mp) Leth) didplp> & Qlbiiee fe PAE
Balle by 1Z-Dib | B be) bln OO'OPE'SO'F “B Lab 00'00Z'ZS'T “B 00°679'08'E “Ss
Ikh4s 1k OOOZT-6661 bh 6661-8661 ‘8661-2661 pb L125 J Iblr Iplh B Bilis |p pip
‘2 WI fp DIbIaDS “bp 2bISH) I pth PubsK 4] bl lblh P DPI O Diptieyie bide
4 Inph 12h % Jath dials DbiaiS ‘hEih LEB Whlssod DIS 5lbs “Us Ele‘ j “61
00€
PTA EL (OL0z) ‘pegeizeyy “pr (Ad) 9a, ByjaadS aoUeApPY SA dN) “L'D'9
12 mifie 2h jos ppvie & (1)(\p)(Z)HdE Dib :Pie “palin
Yplit Yio} Lp DPR DEdIS % hip bI|KPie [ln B lbp] Ielpho LAH fy bj plip |
bbb 2 B B8h MYO 2 Ibi: ik & Pihibo B BIS Did) dlp DK & bo ~ Mable sles
{| Ibi & Diels pas bibl: be lolRDER pilrliebs | [lr |g di4>|p> Bible {oe plhitze Lab
[pele gp dd>| pele Wibie eb Lelbeb| | {yp Mele WYple HIPS] 12 be bl elie) Lab Ylblte Zsee}
bio} Ib) Pajk is Dib & Hiphile piible bts | Lple Inde] peblpete Bis} Ate ld)
ppfie i pia B & kh bésb) Wi PS bpvie & (|)(\p)(@)Hde Dis Ue le lle B
Hpi Pps! lb & DK phic biblb o& hyj @ bibs Ipejp pie & ible "BT
GZZ PIA EL (OL0Z) dN “L'0'9 SA euqeyyo Jewny Yyoyusy
| [ple JP 2% DIEVIK F 2h
bib? gp DISDIK Z db (eb dé Mplip ‘Lp [pir Iplld wre bbl? RIB & bbj>b] [SL sailine
‘lle JBke WW |e Plhiho } Pidiielf bas bible | 2 gs) bip|Kbele kb [Bb 2b ARDS
‘2 Uple ello p dp) B2 ilps fe Lb| ble Bp Mj Ip aBeb Ib Bibibo fe InlepeA | Le Le”
Iptp| |Bl> jnlp 24> |gsb] bls dh BE op Ibi: & IndtPhajie | Ile Lede} bb 2D> Inddpla}ie
bphb IBS | Ip ibe) debIpeie Bis} [pl ible Deji DS Pele |b) bipelirie
BS Diplo ‘ple Pejfrw prio & (|)(\p)(@)HdE Dib dh PHB ke ISP & ibibo | Bip
dh Whe IbbIP fy IShib Do Lple Ibe} Bokjaj2 [b [eB |el> f |aoy} Dib PAH ‘PPR
b DRb bub) ie PED b dle & DIK [SP pPin| 2 dblPb|p WEIR) Bibi “ZT
PPT bL (OLOZ) ‘pegeizeyd “pyT (Wd) 9a, eJDadg aoueApY SA qf “11D
| Inshiis Ibi Bp bt
Lb b&bj BER bit b&b) PRjbh Pie & (\)(Ip)(Z)HhS-Di J Lb] PyJab) do
Jbl DieDie o €-Dib ie bhki{riie Mp [ysb| bist lie [> dhBIS dled BE b pba
b2af bibblh Ph dbl & frlob} jb bE | lbh bik Deligalio B S-Di bly |b
Diabrob BS | Ie Ibi Ba ide & bbjPple f “KD Wik 2b B 12l ‘le b leh Beale I
ibibo Bin} B |} Dib (29 ooh ‘6E Hhelb LAiPbA 6007) eh “B/IK BbbR Bibb “5
‘D ‘24 Dihito dbskid bad Jab | 2 WP led Jb d> “KA dh Bin| Ip Dolisailo B S-Dib
bis :Die ‘lie Iplie Dw} Iebjppi rye Ba byihak| © Lobj|Pplt bik hi} @ “KD B
Jpop} UPEIo yb pip | Ie Wr Lib f lojiehl LSd}b) fp EBS delet Wik Bb p Bin
\p Jp b {P22} Bailie in |p ibibo f Phik (ETS [pipiph 6EGL) 2 Mhiho dbsb|
Hike jpn’ Soh SIP p2h BRS 4) 19 & PWiblbs hao hibit | lb) dbl> InBPEA b
Jette) | |b IDK 28 B 2 dh bh b&b) Pajbh DF Phils [dsp) biplKie PL_IE w S-DIb
RS & Inddbbiie spin ‘Lele Lede} Mdlbrle SP Dihie BRK bet ab | 2 |b) Pip |Kb-lo
bpp -Dib pis ap dbEie bo | Dgjip ibloh | bh past) poligaiie PRE &
Le 800% ‘[Wbltbh| 2 Rib beh Ik pe 6 bbb}
@ Rn ab Bible & (A)(p)(c)snhe Dik ky inpbjayo 22 dihIne by Lelie Bb DD prep
Duel Inlbtpeb ip lille ha blll | WY Dodlh IBRLiO sobbed Qibtaye Diakh SM Biblb LERS <All ‘2 While B Aspley bh Yama} BE Ub arbi Balto ‘2 ipl L9InLi6 BEM Sib) RO $2) Ibtb| Webb) Bb DF pre YUE fe pidlbipe bao blblls Je pthiko
| ISEB Up Use} WPle DhIDUE Mb BD “Bible Ip} IelbK fe hd PO Is w/e bh Lrblie
UP RED “lshlls Lee} Dhjile Yeo dh riddlb|p bb "2 Uble led) Inllsh) Id Bab ketal Dip
ONO @ Ke Uchibe Lebo Mblbb ops wir Bob dak) BBE AO hdl ‘2 Ih) Bb wip» PD Ebblle te \pblp kb Dbwe bj bee) els RIK nib db IPL BE [eb Ipitblale Ind|iek| 2 B ABE Dihle hips) Dib ap Lie ldbbile | 2 Bop kk) B Mdbilo bh wip? [in Ibi pab%
Bit Eb acbipch B WIP IpP kdbile BO & Bible | Ubi bby ait B fs kIDLE Bib jlin
RQ) KP Dibite bok bh de {ye BIB 12} ID bbl dite lb>| [be Ie bl-b ppb%)
MU fe DS op dbldpIp ky |p BLEEK bls) ‘2 “Ip ibe ba pbIp fb bib BE "1g
Ch TA LL (6002) ‘d'N “L'9'D SA Seung jeAoy
| Ie} bit
MP Welle Inditsk) Mb Dyjih DB pr Derby [eb [RUS Dejth DIT IndbRLO Ited deBiele> J>.5) EAS | Uebh} 28 2h bh besp| BS b (\p)(z)smhe Dip de 2 oP bw Jae pw Sup
Ab Bigj 2 lblle fe DS b |yob) pipedle 2h] Ip) DryIkl Bb Ye lp} dedlps InieGER f bllblb bap pipbik | ie UeS pwiindih vaD © neEIe ph Be bibs b
PUPPS bib 2b |p Bb [2 bho » Delp ville dhh SB bh (Sb 4) Bin wie BMP Ye Ue lle Ipllels fz be <b [Ysb) DiP|KdHo B Bb Y DIK Wile Ishi HABle w jepLite
lB) 1? BQ lefts be Lebel ple ce] Inde) irs Ide kde DbJlROp Bb ie Ihe] UDI! Le dPplakl Ot ¢ bibl bao bipblls be Qlblte fy loWQLE | Iple lp’) Dbl Ineo ab Baby wie
‘Bis ine) PAIR RIS Me Gitbraie Indltole| Mb bib DS peep p1blp> B he wigllie BE | ple ep AAO Bb se ndpaile Ps] debe) Bb Biel bi AT be bi kb “Bh Ip lap AS pre tlio {ee 28 Yple 1p 2h 1PM IBD & LOOT'9'SZ Hlky| De > [Bibi DUDIE ® (Ip)OT
Bib & debut fas) Pab| Ieelio BE | [pls Je Ihe rw Er PebIo w (4p)(z) ane
Hilfe DS pbells (Yee) bipe|pidie (go Wik bl QM B 2Vb LK fe Pitielte Inditak) de | hate ge (kbs) Libeeejh Jnl Ibe Die Ute Ubiise BQ bblbabe be LobILaplep Bee Hit B 2b sb bel | jbl ke BPP bieismio bh pia Ba tipi b Ibi plD | Le bbills 2% Jab bikeihbIS bh be ‘Dil Kb llr bBle) In’) RELI Dinjtieblle Ig DbliNs
Sybille f lojeb| ~~ Sup Bibb) pA bIpBE w jth wh b Ishi b Pinto “Og
00k FIA Zt (OL02) ‘aN “:L'0'D SA peqeyely ‘adiq auinyy peqeyeny
| Blis |p dh tiie eb) 2% | aie B DISDIK OF 4) OP Ip JaE Se 2b 2b Bepbile PBS | Q 1B Lin heb) Uhl de> 2h BS de 2 ES b |poynino Belin PRE Se OP deb Jpk BA) P bball @ We) bY Yiblko \Ilteb ‘Lklle BRIO |e IDO w MPRHO fp bidllpe bof bible DS prep dip Bin) Ibe) dol lnkDeA finite |
1B Un thee] Mb dh BE LHe Q Yplr Yb B |bpdjibiho Delish DOP ap Lb) HE 12 BH) Pain| ‘B ie Brh SYM Fe Bih & Bible | |e Yo Deeb Ip dh DIRVIK OZ AIgbIO inp Jp 2B ky PIERIK OF fp Dit DIllo MY BIRO | lhlls DeIBbUb BS fb Indo_YO | kp
PID bible bipR) b liek) eb) obo) Ible lbp) Balik BEE BO B wWihle kh LEIP Abd) Me Dojblie Me 2h LILA Wik Pak DT Phi bIBbI> BO b DlwRie | 2 jae
6 bbb} Ip|SJoilk 24 DpjbR bok IPH do 8%
frat 9 at Fea Aer daftla ax Praaracit, 2008 29
gs afaat ant afaara a Prat yer st ae Tas at oreht, ae ga fama ot Fa
eae TET | SA SET H Aer awet ae ferear B fos sang at we ae ar set wr aie
acpeet & sree Roem TET | FRY weer ait eT a aferanTe wt Ra aT, Se ae are
aa ra aes Praesent ar et cer B, ars Sahare tT HET at et, SAA aaa aT
St a SE AT SAT Bt | Tat Raha we ae at Fa aifererenre erat eifereh wt eT ATA
qrett, waite Ga oe wea Praca afeet ar at wer 8, Ser ae afaaran was ay TY
eqfear & ott sean watt are after tamer 8, aa oe seg S ier H acta Prater wt
caret | ATT Se warereTer 3 arer fs saferemeer are fea wa Fear ge Star Tew Tae
art TE A TETATT HT Preateor crferanre wee AAR are ear Prey HE |
R.S. Avtar Singh and Company vs C.C.T., U.P, (2008) 8 VLJ 258
aa. caret wa Berane & | we Prateor & are aafireerdh F te sore oe Fa SATE
ac at aman Pi Saat woe F saat Wega wet fea or ae, Shea Fe HT GE T Aa
rere OC ae HEE ATT Ta RRs ae Pr eet A TE wa B, F aA ahora H ae & |
facdt coftrgae 3 aret 10et & sicher dat a Res Sar Te eatery ae ree, Bailes ete
rea wet Sega Pa or ws whe arene ae Rerw et e a a fs fara seat @ ke ae
red & cee aererrs atorar HE | order after F ae areet Freer aoe Pea fore fee
Peart} qatar erat fave fra etteare Het ET AAT 10-4 # onfter area ser TAT feat
mem oie we AIT Ter Pe re eer cATUTEY ait & fs a ae Are wt fH edt at TG
cet fee OT Sart &, aif a safer err so (2) (eh i) areRT e |
C.T.T. vs Chakrwati Construction Company, 2012 NTN (Vol. 48) 209; (2012)
20 VLJ 233
a, aeieifter % seer tet art Poraar arerr orate dia B, sae Tart
cease oer Ore ame ameter et Far EAT cer Hope as roe err Preece AAT Se
vein mer ee BY EE TET | HT eer HH ae AT ohare ae FR TH
S| gear Feet Prot afre7Tt AIK He sa. gam sar tad waged Ht fer.,
amr (2007 VAAGT AeGA-32 93-273) wt & | ge are FH are A Waa SF ree BT
seer rar er | ga FE ae rt & oie & at aT tet & che sree B STE FH
Tay a Serer FARRIS ATT S aa w free ee a Serre PH Tee Fer aT
a ire gates 3 & ave ata H gehen OA Bg M aATT Ss. H are A oe
ay artnet Mae AAT FRG et aT fart Fla S sg eI TTT ER
sre ag sear aber & ier Bg GT. & Ferg Gow | ore: ae aATETe st aT
meee ahre weet wer RAT HT TET 9TH) (AH) stents rete sear TAT
Be megrer apr HQ eve TMT aT GA Te A ae flower at occa ET cea | a
dag % gaa asap Frfa gary aos aul, ag Reet sat afrert BATT HT (1999
GAAGT AeYA-15 grs-604) an & | ge wen at Ahert Goifae OFS. Te, BETTS NS
ee teeta Pree sierer Uehara & ecare, egftvat ae aetee aH ATE TH Se
cece set ait afte eT SH (2) (AH) & skater ee Pree | get ere A fereeT at eT aT
BE Bb bb bésb| PRibR p Phe Yb YeByp Diy) bbb) bh bash) belb> die WEP
12 [Pb PbjDue 2 dh bok Wesrs} kb kip BE Debio SS bd F ‘E Dib [> bbbiRIo
24 [sip] Bled >| Le Ls2e I> Pilih | Le 1D 1B) JYHN UOoI!, Biaie bik I> [pbjb
dh [ebB |B | Ul ied) DeRE fr pit Ink) de Ublto bh Wd pelt pip Ys Iblet 2bIb B
dale 4 DelK DI) fale lnjieh) BE biBo | fe Qd Mb pled I JrbIb Whi) Bilt “Ze
OL (LE IOA) NIN EL0% “PIT Wd Aujeaed yoajosy SA 1°90’
| 2 1b & \bPpjh j2 B& Un 2 leplie Diwib Dbdip Iepile 2h-+ Maal
| 2 Lb] Jefeh Kb Isplip
@ lnMeRje - biiblh: hap bipbik DS Pe bb) Pin} Lee) dpl> InwBLH Bdb) HE b
Jnlivte} | lig In& 2b (281-29h 9b-bhdb AIPKA 110Z) bbb) 2h It Joao | 2 1DI2 JBb
TB BBS blob) Ie 2iehwbs Ung? “Yb Di | Q lle Lhe} DYLIS kv Yowes Jplle IP Dib
PBS "2 Yple Ip PRS miad dh BO de 2) db Inlisk| Ke BPH JP Di} khie Pilko bl
Ibe Lp) Dib dh Mile BE db 2b DIP Indbialio | It) Dh|Die 2 dh [hip BEBK by
Anjists) DUS Lelie) | fe Q> Deb felt Jee Infill de WD h Phen eb blbain |hip [pihlko “BZ
OL (LG 10A) NLN EL02 ‘dN “1'0'9 SA ‘pIT Sjeaujoa/z Aneay josey
| Able Let) Heb |p? InbeipeA Utald Utple Lede) |, rode
Ke Jojok) Yih Ph fp BEB BE | 2 ible ibd) biablin fe (!)(Yp)(Z)mbe Di ] Whim ‘yphtin
{pier 2 & bib Bik bop we yp jeBep BS HVIBE ‘2 PPM Pip|KDIe pabhoR ab $j Uellt & beilielhs pas plbelelis | led} dbl InlRR EA & ibibo :Die | Ipk ISUn Jk |e bb
bis) 2 Mebbob pib-imiwie BS Ai) bo Phillie db fs bIRPI> BE | Ibi be Pb DIbI2IDS IRD |b Mbp P Sia “hike Wh Bb & beEIe w Ieplie ~ dNeDbIS
| Adi Irellblede PBS de jeep Ushi? PRE ‘ppb Pile db BEB Lepbin Winks fe pth
hy Wee & bj ibd) bebe wh p dipiaws Hist [othe Ip» P Worp ‘WbIIE “Juans
HBS | 2 WD>eb Injisb| Ith 2hhipbE [be Lin 2 bloabIK doh eb 24> Dike [hibo “ge
LL TA 02 (ZL0Z) ‘qe7 snojog ojny juejsul SA “1") ‘5
12 pb
PRUE bibee Sip f iplie ~ ladle IRD 2 JBe Balk} jas} je Bob jpop) pp abroR
AS lye Q iblin intel 2 BeElo bei Db DIP [ph ips b BeLio w [minora J ible & (ZE YUpRA £1-SO0Z) Ibsl3 Alle beh bibb lelpie) “b/p & bwibih»
HQJEB biplelis 2) IDI) & pWlbib: bap DIbIsIS bibl | Lb) dbl InPEA fe Lelie)
Bae) Bis) ple Ihde) Dik dp Bp DIB Indbjie | 2 IbIDbI Bh DEbIe w she Din
AP bbbejtalte deo Pihite> Yo) Uple Lalit ItaD Lie Lbd>| DhIDite 24> dh BH '2 Le ladbIo eb 2hh
Slltlelh Ae fr pli BB | pre ppltb lub LebJlobS die LAI) \eb shitilelth pihlbo “HE
| Ltr Lp) Ite fe bib b (Sb LAlPLA OZ-Z00g)
BE 2b Unibo debi Hib Dibibink “W)'IK P2bIB) “PH'p blok| Bh IRD bab PR | Ibe Udiba kb blabl s (see Lpipinh $261) BBb/2 Ho 2SebIKB HIeb “Iyj Ips
Sake DIP bidlbie balbp bipbi f BBB BS tie 2 sijbIKn ab ‘BE Joh bh ab [eb | WP ln Ubi) JBk DhJLUO 24 dh kh bes) DpJbH Indl LIP Dpliealle b E-Dik SP biblelfayte deb [dsie) ele Yb) Ute Ublslis Leb bible bah falisilis dblbin “hQllte Lali 4p
8 bbb Ib\s}>ilh 2 Prjbp bs IwPK 28 oe
fram 9 Sat yes Ae daftft ax Prasad, 2008 31
get afer | rare ar met afte eat aH ae AMT aT | GACT GAT HTT IT
ada sea wares FAT fH art > azar arftrencr + ae fea wet fear & fH ga
aiiz or Garart Sar S at sae wey eet ora are H fre Pear wars | ae: Ara Gea
saree Qe Fa ar Sate Ver wu, sa fh aale Ces at TAT HPHAT ATI HT (1999
waaay aeTA-15 YS-604) aa afer Ae HT TTA TSaT Sager eH, (s7.) fer.
(2010 WAACT aeTA-43 YSS-231) + ae aT fH <a arenas S|e aH Aer Fey, Tat
fad at A 8 ae Het ey et ae afta eT |
Ircon Intemational Ltd. by Manager (Finance) vs C.C.T., U.P., (2013) 21 VLJ 222
28. gattamract ferfaer aferare at Fetter sears Paver ar re fast art ET
at arate Bear war | ofrecer are ga ae SY ee ae ot aT fever re fe eat
aaa carat arate ga frat ar €t ter & | Get M/s N.M. Goel and Co. vs Sales Tax
Officer (1990 UPTC 865) and M/s Rashtriya Spat Nigam vs State of Andhra Pradesh
(1998 STC 423) & are # arate ates sarees & Protea ar Tate Hee EE Te Ae fear
fread Pree Part 3 garter crac fare Bre get arene oe aretenre fever ara fas saferenceT
x gait S aren ox & Prof at wafea weet ga omar Unter fever S |
C.C.T., U.P. vs Adhishashi Abhiyanta 2013 NTN (Vol. 51) 82
a9, arart X use Be sere St aA a cH TTT Per Pras set TE
fate & aad cat oe Se Rae weed or ote ay aor Serr ake Seest AeTT aT
oor WTST GOT | saferenr gy F rita atte faa IK 15 Ursa & Ht oT ar | TAA Setter
aedta Be H are otra 3 se are 1 tifa ae dt fe ae Hrifere aw S| Ses
fare careret & garteron ree ate Ey Pe Paver fs Tea ATA SaaS & athe HC Tel
an aan & | arate Ser rarer F qatar aioe wet ET AMAT fe ogee Gaither
genie ar &, aiitte sat word oft Rafat cen Aerie at ft B, cafere HC Gael TH
are UC AT aM &, afer SaaS HIS are He oars et fewer oT Tea F |
C.C.T,, U.P, Lucknow vs Meeraz Decorators, Lucknow, VSTI 2013 (Vol. 16) B-56
go. ant et Sa F wets at saciftin oe ifs a ard Het A | AMAT HT
eaferrare a art 3-0 & Siero Bt Saeftin ate fer case wtetaftoay AAT TK ah
areas AAS BE BC TET Tar fore aaferameer jaar Phar | gees fea BATT A
eater erere fever Fa rector weet gE Ae Gea Arar fer feb Atta Sette
=qraraat 3X Shri C.K. Jidheesh vs Union of India & Ors. (2005-13 SCC 37) & fasta F
mat & Re we are alee arsae & forait fave reg at feat Pte et & |
C.C.T,, U.P. vs Instant Auto Colour Lab, (2012) 20 VLJ 11
91, Prarr art afaerenre at Ferhat Hr weg at Tet Sra Te He oa AT Fave
mre, afer crferarcor Br ge ATT ee Ae eT | ga PE wT A Tate TAT
ae BU ge are Te at fee fos Ata eats sare Mis NM. Goel and Co. vs
Sales Tax Officer (1990 UPTC 865) and M/s Rashtriya Spat Nigam vs State of Andhra
Pradesh (1998 STC 423) % Rofat F tet agit at fast F sieht ara Fl ea
segeeree Te SAENATON TATE TC fT Fe fH afreHEeT A eet a TATE ae TR fer
a fas dete carafe A Tah eqatt Te wee care ar smerret Tere |
CCT, U.P. vs Adhishashi Abhiyanta, VSTI 2013 (Vol. 16) B-364
32 Gat wes yeo daltfa wr arfefsfar fr g
S2. cnantt ¥ ordefacr 4 sett tq ad ote & wer ret S eee} ay ay
Stare eer fore ae ae Prater aaftrerd % ae order far ste wert snot & seeq
Sere Gam | oefeercor = omer we Ser SATETE Te eaTeT Fe fe a Ree mY opie &
Seo TE TGS Mee oe aT A aoretefeer A weit Sy ore et 1 were eer erat qatar
Paced fesar crear, aatfes arftracor a onder afera at |
C.C.T., U.P. vs Value Line Interior Pvt. Ltd., VSTI 2013 (Vol. 17) B-667
88. caTantt = Hebftaret weer ar Premes fear & fora fre oes oT & wer a ®. 1,41,79,668=00 oF Ate HrF-31 8 Wee a Ha ort BS aan sie Saher % AGAR Se we setae H weer foe & | Ta ae aT Ae ae ara) & Sremfed et & wren SS ore ae safer a aT se (2)(A)(il) & akerta gq omc terre ot we fret afee | aie Seq Warts + Garg Photo Films, Agra vs Commissioner of Trade Tax (2004-25 NTN 1281; 2005 UPTC 230) and Commissioner of Trade Tax vs S/s Indian Railway Construction Company, Agra (2008 UPTC 964) & Frefelt aor garen fear afte set wfenfeer Rrart BH caren Bey ey career at ave wf fasar fer Fee Rear & orgare ga: onder onfta ak Pres ate IT See sresfes fees oy at atta & dot F wat Power ae FF eer ST SUR | Gee fry soefeerare arr fe TY are S eee Fa ma qa ae He ert & awh A ar | orfkecer A ge arene Ge eae aT aes Ree Re onal ae Row ae
Ot Ue & fe afecrane F ore ane afer Sous H OS ar a at cite rere
Saat tra are area seq arts S ane sare fe soar ar ae Prater
Smear oft Feber or gear & fore ax Oe yar oe we adits et gar 8, Aer aera
ST AAT FST STENT I TS ATH Ft Ae BU attra S Prete ar aris Ree Re ae
aed at Prater oftert & eax ot vet & Rar arr aes ar |
Mitsui Kensetsu India Pvt. Ltd. vs C.T.T., U.P. 2014 NTN (Vol. 54)-62
34. are at ae afahran ait aNI-28(3) & site sift ax Prater tg atte
ardl fear rar oft ae At ferent var fee & anf act os orf-26 ft rhea BE | coach
1 gah fea Re creat Hed EC Her fH a at a arent & ate a A oad are en en ae
qe argae & sets oat & |S hae varit ar Prater aad &, ara: arar ax Prater wet
fear oT aaa & | fearha aftaen ar we wea ar fee arity wafer are + Gea
Wie + Larsen and Toubro Limited and another vs State of Kamataka and another
2014-1 SCC 708) 4 3a dae F frefa & yen-97, 118 wd 119 * fen a wat HF
free arene ot earadt arer fear var arf arefdfter & stata ovat & | arate ae
wararera +t fern fe arte sated ararera ane fea wa frofe a ast & eee 3 fH Set
areal 4 wea aa &, safere sah are fer va ard arefafeer & site one & afk 2
arnt & aa a aeare = | Re aedten at wea |
U.P. Rajkiya Nirman Nigam Ltd. vs State of U.P., 2014 NTN (Vol. 54)-215
35. arardt ferqe wa Gah Bar oda & Prafr atte tare ar arf axa F | seca
Uaioe arate fect +S cer hast mhrarae 4 8 sit ata afters FF | orf vale
tet & fe mes ata F anes ea &, HA ars aad = fa Sat meee F Aa Rar
Oa &, Wet Wt ataae Fax Gere Head fogs Fare fear ona & ik Saar sepitest ars
(18) 224
LSA 89 (pLOz) ‘suo BuyeoujBuz 'P jBOLN08/3 BABIIA SA BYB}ELIEY JO B}8IS
| Q ith} bWdih Ib kjk} Ye (OS FOZ OLS 8B
-C661) uBYISeleY JO 8)B)S SA ‘09 9 Aeueyunq uouey bleh fb BEB BS | 2 \peh 2
Pj) 2D blew wh hig) ~ JleBeb Ypw bA Ab 4) QBs P|s 2he [ob 2ie>b hele dh deltae
QbH Q YIM RD kp de [lp J UD [yp [Yh] bel fyb YeBe behaj) bybIe f 1bb| pple
IBY J Ibe) DAIbh) Bp & OlpSah | bbiblb: han elie f 22) BS ‘Le
(dv) ;
28 LSA 89 (P4102) ‘Ysepeld BiYypUY JO @}e}g SA payUi!T (4) Buueeujbuz “SA
12 Jab BIbIe I bh bsb| belb> b be WAYIK bibpsh Die | 2 lp) Bb bp
Fide ig) PBS Ih b delve) PY | Bleep) [Pk hb db ys) Feb 2h BS b Pibibo | le able
Shyle igs RUB Bh 42) Ul Uelte DE pr Meblp> Pin} [pir jy Leyle bis\Ph) 22) ake Berb|
BE | Ushio Lee) Doi Dite Mb ffs db BH ‘2 ible Ibe] WhlPle Dee He IOs Me Zo DIB”
REY die 2 lab) | bd | siedeajs ejas0u0d pessajs-aud YOO;|q OUOW Bb 4} Ibi
Ibi Ble 4b Be & Ind4phIie 4plbln ‘2 Ipb| Ppl Ab 4b} Ie LB Le Pibibo | Ue Lblln Ip
lojih} Bhd) ahd bib Ipbin| B bl pd) Bildsb (spueuys) auim yjGuejs ajisua}
yBiy pue spasu! od! jsed aiqeayjew ‘sGuluajsey ad chile Ids bm bb» | le hafie »
kbblls bh BIS JDK IND pide blyeeb lolgjo [ln > du Did & Ine SI % BD? Intel) ep
$J9d8a|S 8}810U09 pesseijs-asd YD0/q OUOW ‘}sEI/eq ‘siadagis Aemjies Pihibo "9g
SEL-(PS 0A) NLN PLOZ ‘NpeN jjwel JO aJe}g SA paywiy saujsnpu| FOQ.
| Ae Apple eb ype
{pik $e b bleh bok PRjbh p UabboR PiMlKisle b Ibb| ppl de 2 Yeh) bida|K Dao
2p DRJBS 'Q 1d Leib De Leb Bb DThid) Mle B IWlln Bib IWoibho whie| LEDS
B 2b 42) Ip bie Sp Whe Ke bib | 2 ible 2h Bh IPO fi Wit We 2 WES LI} Wh Jeo
Ibplah® Dib PBS bib) ‘2 IIR) bkbie “by OSoS BPS pies Pblis! | 2 jy wh Weilie (ye klibi BblpS fe laprie +e) lel bidibibs bof bible | Ibis tb! dplD
lobeipich 2p Bele) <pbiel lle (Yee) bipiiad BE DB Pre» depips | lndPRLIo thie dbl» DIE Uline) ite} ‘2 le B aiblblelle bth Diy WY LWDIED Mb Bile BAD RO rie Lt Late! Buf 2plle gee Xb BLE & be $b) Q abd BBs) B DID Helle Kb IY thie dhe “Ia) InSad
Ae ERE |g IPR Dedbe Ib be 21) We & BbibuS pbIDS) Jap due 2 Ibn i Whe
34 Se Te Aer daft ae artef ster Frat 9
88. 8 aig 4 ae fare annie aston Ser eres at Eves Fh eAe are aay
Fes carer ae Faferer eaaremre B | Se oh gras ret &, seat & Fort errahT at art a
STAY, Se Te eprebeifaer H weiter By ave aatiergt a oe Perera oe ret Pasa aE at ee
Tat ere Berar are aT Tet | ga aafaftar Fs stftrer ate Corre sift F Revete
ar ot wat cat ote affe at weg oS dae F feet wer &, ae sera oe aT ae |
arte Sea rarer A ATT fA SaTaret arr Gt areas wat rer rar &, we eerar oe
7 fas Pata wftertean & arene oe | Gee Reg ae att er fas meres H ott aax oe Gut ey
mar S aT get were aH ara are fea va B, A ge arene oe ae wert or wet E Pe oe
DAT Srl ToT F ser Hey er aie Va |e Alorcas ed wa a | aa a ors ae yg
ara FS earehfors fea oT awe ora wet | ge Pes oe ane wes =a a
He oT fi amet at arate fame oq Parat ara eae ya FB ot amt ak 3
Ferg wret fear war 8, wert oat |
Larsen & Toubro Ltd. vs State of Kamataka and others, (2013) 23 VLU 97 (SC);
(2014) 68 VST 353 (Kam)
So. saad thalterst oe afifeir aie sre ar are ae & forad re wet F aera
appt Br Sree Het f | ga arfefar AAs EC saat Tee B wet ax aR omaha
fear wan | ofercr + art fe org ore Stir B ongder F grax atte sreet Aiea
wet &, safer ge feet Ss de arene ae ordfda at Pear oT daa F | gas Bes
Ferarr at garetaror ere feser fret eleare ae BU ate Ser waa F ara fe ae Peet
RT STENT OX fee ater FT case Stee ae oar & ait Ge Haw sa omene wt ae at
AMT ST Geet fe gaat site steet wet S| Shee wa Ss ant are SAT Ht a
we & fh gah giawr site soet af &, salem dfn H watt oe ata ait
ame Bg wx afte fear aT | Oe
State of Tamil Nadu vs S.S.M. Processing Mills (2014) 25 VLJ 37 (Mad)
40. arardt weet sactute ar art wee & | sat am arses sienfe start ath
wroet fafea ert & | aeria sea wre 3 art f aera faa ot Prorrt & fac
sat aft or ape wet Sisto Ae S stat GA ar ey Beran TET site Har stata
anh at ste sey Te Sf Heese Prater et |
. State of Kamataka vs Reddy Structures Pvt. Ltd. (2014) 70 VST 329 (Kam)
41. arartt we facsx & frat sare ar feened FAT | Are Seq wars SKI
qe ATT Tear Fe TENT TST ST TOT HT TTT SATE Vg MTT TU a Seat aa ape aT
GST TAT |
State of Kamataka vs Vaswani Estates Developers Private Limited (2014) 70
VST 411 (Kam)
an, carardt feifear amr ane aaeer S | ToT A ort AAT | starter Sf Sra TET
ax fife Ata Ht Tes Het F | TT IT STAT HT AKT TET ATTA BAT FA STENT
at aaret fee war Pe Ais Aira at sites ara A ag area avg wet B, Taree
& dare Yu wT a am Us are H oterher oe S frat ag aredaer Miser ae & |
State of Tamil Nadu vs Rainbow Printers (2014) 69 VST 506 (Mad)
4s, cared 3 Rarer BET HARA sity Bar F ase S Prater wr aegaer far 8
Rarer free ore aeatt Barer are urea B ave etter aor ait cere Fever re B ait ete
frat 9 Sat wear APT dafiit awe franracit, 2008 35
ange TC STAT aT GH A TT IRCON Alc NHAI fear Barr ar | a aac Rewer err a tet
wera TAT AT | HHT H apart sa ae ane andsfefhaara arent weit ar | araret are
eat Fatty So Ht ST APs seg ~ararera + ara fee aarordt ase ar a Prater ae
@ &, He St sere seatt set Ear @, TG Saat Gera Bar B | ata: Santosh &
Company, New Dethi vs CTT (1999 NTN vol. 15-604) and Commissioner of Trade
Tax vs Indian Railway Constructions Company (2005 UPTC 984) and CTT vs Advance
. Spectra Tec. (P) Ltd., (2010) 13 VLU 300 wa arta aates =rarera at afters dre arr
Gannon Dunkerly & Co. and others vs State of Rajasthan (1992 NTN Vol. 1-417;
1993 UPTC 416) & arat # eet fag ax fed wa Preah & gene A Arr var fe Aafert
dae F areaer erat aaa Aaa ot F eeret eu ot Hea Pata at are |
Ircon Intemational Limited Thru' Manager (Finance) vs Commissioner, Trade
Tax U.P, (2013) 21 VLJ 222
44. 54 al 4 amH promoters, builders, developers, real estate agents and
owners of land 4 ft arag at ait ae Prater anear erat sad fers ore ae h few
@ | a4 Ge Het ver fH Sas at at ates ar Pate fear on wer @, set Pea are
UX Hea Felt S Ua fore chor at fast at or cét 3, ae Affa astea 2B | arta seq
wararera + ferar f& Larsen & Toubro Limited & another vs State of Karmataka and
anothers (SLP (C) No. 17741 of 2007) & ae # ae art wart at fe K. Raheja
Development Corporation vs State of Kamataka, (2005) 2 VLJ 100 ® ae # Arta
aatet eae at eesti ant fear war feta staat wé & six are gea to at
Haftfa fear war gea dls # Larsen & Toubro Limited & are # feat 26.09.2013 at
Profa afta art aa ae Pratta fran f% K. Raheja Development Corporation & are #
fear var Profe ofaa & | aria sated areata & ge Prete GH WaR-101, 107, 114,
115, 116, 11s ot Gragfe at eg anche sereare Sea aaa Ft are fof &
yert-5 4 ae frat fe K. Raheja Development Carporation & Prfa & aaa
Assotech Realty Pvt. Ltd. vs State of U.P: and others, (2005) 5 VLJ 393 & ae #F
area salerare Seq aes at Gestis + ae Praffte fear ar fe Ws aaa S Prahr
4 oged arnt a alg acta set et @, eae faced acten or Pater act F sow
saat fast axe we 21 ge Pola & fase Coo ater 4 Ai adter area F Vere
fera fodtars arfteer at ef frat yorere H sree ux ferare + Het ee Prefer far ar fH
fared tafton aan & siete anita cae att | Sota at Prefel & arene ot ae
sfaa a omar & fe sete are F R-Fr cen & fora ore ax Prater afiartt } ax
ux at a aed & | at faa afeaaarr 4 fraea fear fos saat fe are ar & fra ga
frat & ara ara feoar rar fe Fae Pater aftrenrtt & aaa oto vat vega Hey sit
area wdfer saree at anit ta & Pofat ad arene ax car ara Profat #& arene ax
irae serra fear var @, ait Gusts are feat wa &, teat at fac Heat ee seat
unite Ht |
Express Projects Pvt. Limited vs State of U.P. & Others, (2013) 23 VLJ 200
45, arartt wietarp at farer ot soeftir ar apref aed & | gat waar wretaftha
tox at Seda aa ee aah He ar atfIHey KAT S TANT fea Tar a fora free
ae atta aftgat 4 ara fear | arte Seq mararerea Ht eet Sts F araenfter Pear fe
array eater sara 4 C.K. Jidheesh vs Union of India and others, (2006) 3 VLU 119
36 Sat west Aer wae ae arfefefenr fra 9
(SC); (2005-13 SCC 37) ¥ Fraffta forar & fe feral eefSet qekehy FH aah wr ares
afad areas & frat ants farstec arate set erat & | ge Prof F ores oe aera owe
aqrarera + arta a Pref at ofa art |
Commissioner Trade Tax vs Instant Auto Colour Lab 2013 NTN (Vol. 51) 1
46, oalen fant ar afatrar & orate aia 01.7.1989 & geet ven aaitery
waft ag 7g Aras anger Wai cs wang arn Heras, oer fre vet grey Ape
wt ateaa Pratt at ws | saat dena at aria ger =a a avs die
git et 7S | AP Sea =a A M/s. Keshoram Surindranath Photo Bag (P) Ltd.
& ofhers vs. Asstt. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (LR) City Division, Bangalore
and other [121-2001 STC 175] va ara # fea fPrefa H arene oe ga arehenfrey art |
gad fea we eer 2 ae ate ae F cee. afer atl ae cau.
fetice 20.04.2000 ot Arata gta ae ENT Rainbow Colour Lab and Another vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh and others [2000-16 NTN 210] & are 4 Arrita gurr ard
& facie & stent oy fetis 20.04.2000 at Freed at Tea Ter ae ArT rar fe ae ars
afte ose & frat age at aed wre ert & gaferd coe ar Ieqe-7 a
Gel at at mais 25 oe Oe ofafte sat or aendt B | dara Gray Here fr. (Gur)
Pref & un av F ster & area qin até Ht gee the 7 ACC Lid. vs. Commissioner
of Customs [2002-20 NTN 73] & Frofa F tat wax fares ah are H atftreqac faféres
Pref ot steer oper St cen. ga are ot fears caer eu fh aor sa Profs & one a
wal Hat tat B are F fear var Prete atavent ef var & seer wet | cata. ferfres
& ae + Pee at & ysart aftea ax afteae aafew F ae after ord fear fH
waft Her 25 FH arene ae He Prater ancer onfta feet ora | ga afta Ht GA: M/s.
Golden Colour Labs and Studio and others vs. The Commissioner of Commercial
Taxes. [ILR 2003 Kamataka 4883] & ae # aera fear war | Arla Teq waar
wt avstio ¥ feats 30.07.2003 af fte stare art ey ae waiter fear fee ate feet
mia & ua at areca aka ae fear ver & at Art gerahren Pest & arr se
gf sffaa wét fear ot ana & car ae Ht Her fe Saray (Go) as Profs F ofate
Get 25 a ate afta a & asad ae waa: ytohifear wet St aed F we aH
fie we aan Fr: fatter sifafarr a aaa | ota: Sales AEH + A: Gafew Re oT
Ue 2004 F ant wt aH 29.01.2004 at afer F ara | GA: ANT 2(3) B Areay
@ wfasst 25 at wr oat get F oe at ve fafa feria 01.07.1989 & wnfta fear
wa ae sfafte ser ax ong ag at | ga Sater H fea gaat Fea S ware F GH:
fte aac at ag ud area sea roma 3 fei 19.08.2005 HY eo Fa: aeerarege
nfta afte fear | ae Feta aa aaa are sea ararera + ge efteentor F ferare set
frat ar fe wate. fares (aor) & Pare 4 trat Hert a (Go). H Profa at oor
aifea art ar war ar | sa Profs & flea wee aeart 4 arte als ad GB Ga ae
fafa arte dem 1145 af 2006 aac at et | arvite air ard + Profe & wer 8
% fra ® fe arta sea =rarea are ga gate ar yer STS Sa oe Ae orate
mite arat ar fe Ger aet at waa HF afte ar get alate steer Safer war & wet
aeat S stacy ar aa aeeit HA ee S| Ta Aes qs are + wre aferear at
gant ox fae & sal at & 1 Se arse fear fH Mal ax ae or Prefs area
aie ae & firs Pofat ox onenfta 8 & wa aed dire deter F ved B A ger
Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. vs. State of Kamataka [1984-2 SCR.248] ate |
Prat 9 TA wer AT aaftfs ae Praaradi, 2008 37
arcta ave art & Pei } we 19 F ae ferar fe cata. fees gar
Larsen Toubro and another vs. State of Kamataka and another [(2013) 23 VLJ 97
(SC); 2013-53 NTN 65) anfe & Profa & ase & fe tral Hare eet aT frofy araret @
mar 1 area ae a & Profs ar ae wer neayet & frat C.K. Jisheesh vs.
Union of India [(2006) 3 VLU 119 (SC); 2005-13 SCC 37) & Frfa ar wr afer Frofar
aét aT vat @ 1 ge wer FH Refs S vex 19 H neayeh cea aehferfat |
19. In view of the above, the argument of the respondent assesses that ACC
Ltd. case did not over-rule Rainbow Colour Lab's case is, therefore, clearly
misconceived. In fact, we are not saying so for the first time as a three member Bench
of this Court in M/s. Larsen and Toubro has already stated that ACC Ltd. had expressly
over-ruled Rainbow Colour Lab while holding that dominant intention test was no
longer good test after 46th Constitutional Amendment. We may point out that learned
counsel for the respondent assesses took courage to advance such an argument
emboldened by certain observations made by two member Bench in the case of C.K.
Jidheesh vs. Union of India, wherein the Court has remarked that the observations in
ACC Ltd. were merely obiter. In Jidheesh, however, the Court did not notice that this
very argument had been rejected earlier in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. vs. Union of
India. Following discussion in Bharat Sanchar is amply demonstrative of the same -
"46. This conclusion was doubted in Associated Cement Companies Ltd. vs.
Commissioner of Customs, [2002-20 NTN 73]; [2001-4 SCC 593] saying :
"The conclusion arrived at in Rainbow Colour Lab case [ 2000-2 SCC 385), in
our opinion, runs counter to the express provision contained in Article 366 [29A] as
also of the Constitution Bench decision of this Court Builders Association of India and
others vs. Union of India and Others [1989-1 NTN UNRP-43; [1989-2 SCC 645]
47. We agree. After the 46th Amendment, the sale element of those contracts
which are covered by the six sub-clauses of Clause [29A] of Article 366 are separable
and may be subjected to sales tax by the States under Entry 54 of List Il and there is no
question of the dominant nature test applying. Therefore, in 2005, C.K. Jidheesh v.
Union of India [(2006) 3 VLJ 119 (SC); 2005-8 SCALE 784] held that the aforesaid
observations in Associated Cement (supra) were merely obiter and that Rainbow
Colour Lab (supra) was still good law, it was not correct. It is necessary to note that
Associated Cement did not say that in all cases of composite transactions the 46th
Amendment would apply.
a wae # aad ws zal (Ga), Taha. fer. (ga) HRT Ha fers fer. (Ga)
& Pofg F at adt aa eenfte fear @ | ge eT F aa dar From fees S ae F
ara aren Prof & war 64 4 fret ger afraredt St WEF :—
“64. Whether contract involved a dominant intention to transfer the property in
goods, in our view, is not at all material. It is not necessary to ascertain what is the
dominant intention of the contract. Even if the dominant intention of the contract is not
to transfer the property in goods and rather it is the rendering of service or the ultimate
transaction is transfer of immovable property, then also it is open to the States to levy
sales tax on the materials used in such contract if it otherwise has elements of works
contract. The view taken by a two Judge Bench of this Court in Rainbow Colour Lab
(supra) that the division of the contract after Forty-sixth Amendment can be made only
if the works contract involved a dominant intention to transfer the property in goods and
not in contracts where the transfer of property takes place as an incident of contract of
service is no longer good law, Rainbow Colour Lab (supra) has been expressly
overruled by a three-Judge Bench in Associated Cement."
war west ar dalla ae artetsfer Frat 9
satet Rrartetia ata air até Pret wet reat Prepret :—
"Keeping in mind the aforesaid principle of law, the obvious conclusion would
be that Entry 25 of Schedule VI to the Act which makes that part of processing and
supplying of photographs, photo prints and photo negatives, which have "goods"
component exigible to sales tax is constitutionally valid.”
qat seat F yfaft 25 at ater AMT | et dae Sa Ys ware Sy ar Wee
& | arte ate are A aren Pofat ox fra aed ee cen faftres Peat ar sera at
Be sa Garett were & ward) Are ofa ArT |
State of Kamataka Etc. vs. Pro Lab and Ors. Etc. [(2005) 27 VLJ 293 (SC);
2015 NTN VOL-57 PAGE 102]
— 47, aed BA At ade KPTCL & area great aga & Prater cer greritsrt era
at ear at ogee feat ar | afadt F gq orgeer at 4 anit AF ferred fren:—
(a) Technical specification of laying of stations; (b) Supply of materials; (c) Civil
portion of contract; and (d) Erection
arate art ot ser ear fe ae va aferanra afer & atx wa aH ae at
cored Up are yt wet St ore &, apart ar ceva sf reef a ora | aftrartt 3 Pater
ae & aay A stata agai we at omifta fear fret a aga ot gege F enfta
at ot ot 4 ofeere at ax S He oT Tar at wen afaanfta aeqeit ax 12.5 oferta
Re TF omifte fear arr gat & weg F oe Gar Sf aah amet eu ae
ecg Tet APT | Geter arftrart + ae ara eu fe sar arqaer eat H arene ax
&, wert amet fewer at ox ax arate ane fear fre atrmet + Reet ae au ax fre
rer rftrenrds & onesr at of wenfte Pear ust ae ara fe ae um ne afaer z
fired fefeer viet ame areas & war F stafte art ox wef daar F oa a az
at TT eT | ae U ue St ox afta art sax & waka 31 aa: exh waar F
ale et ores wet feoer ree | ferart + se area H fea gatearr ara Pear fare
ate wales Seq Marra Ht avedts + aredterc fear |
State of Kamataka vs. Transglobal Power Limited, [2015 NTN Vol-57-226]
48. arartt 4 fers ealga watet (WIG) at eget aT aera far rad araer
Haya & am & fea ar agqde fea | we am a :—
1. laying down of civil foundation
2. — supply and installation of electrical line
3. supply of electrical items
38
4. erection and commissioning of WTGs supplied by customer
arnt + eaten ae ofefrer at ae 15(1)() & ate aaa adore
omar at | wet ger 3 art & fore acca ete at, afer da arf S awa &
sara fe WTG ar Prater marafedt & gy at sat amet adsl goer saat ees 3
fear ar | seit haet gaeht waa at S at fag stax ar ara & Pre at 2 afta Bae
ot & gated ga ord & wakes rat at aoe Romer F aA UT aa S Re
Tel aitgr ore | ax Prefer orfereerét | aver fe caret abt repfer oyster at ser uct qrahe
Tt vat at aa & ere & fe art WIG at ware us ante ard) cated ae
oss arifore, feinet ot eiites argae & ait Gey art ait oecit F wey F
Prat 9 Sat Wat Ava wafer ae Presa, 2008 30
gree MTT TE TET oes etARr fer | carer aot err cet etre order orecteare att
ag | at Arete Gates Ser area at Gvedts a are gattery arax far rer |
pratt sa oretenre Her ET ATA fas
"This offer letter demonstrates that the offer was for the services required for the
erection and installation of WTG, which is a single integrated contract. For the sake of
convenience, if the work orders, pursuant to the offer letter, is segregated to execute
the unique wind farm project at specific location at site addresses given by the customer,
it does not lose its composite, single, integrated nature."
frofa & Wat 14 wt 16 Heal & cer Prt va S:—
"44, Thus it is clear that in a works contract involving transfer of goods and
labour, tax is payable under Section 15(1)(b) on the total consideration of the works
contract. If the labour contract is an individual contract involving only labour, no tax is
payable. In the case on hand, the assessee has segregated the activities as per the
work orders executed against the offer for erection and installation of WTGs. It is not
the case of receiving labour related charges for executing pure labour work without
transferring any property in goods. The entire contract, if perused as a whole, is in the
nature of composite single integrated contract, through designed as it is four separate
work. orders. All the segregated activities are related to the very same project with the
very same customer involving transfer of goods and labour."
"46. The arguments advanced by the learned Counsel for the assessee that
service tax has been paid on the labour contract receipts and as such is not amenable
to the provisions of Section 15(1)(b) of the Act, is not acceptable as the two different
enactments are operating in different fields. If the works contract executed by the
assessee falls under the definition of ‘taxable services’ amenable to levy of service tax,
the assessee cannot be absolved from the liability of composition tax under Section
15(1)(b) of the Act."
[Suzlon Infrastructure Ltd. (Subsequently known as Synefra Engineering and
Constructions Ltd.) (Presently known as Aspen Infrastructure Ltd.), Bangalore vs. State
of Kamataka [2015 NTN VOL-59-9]
a9. arartt X erat B wT HF aad ade BPCL F UH BAI B. 61770494.
90 wr Rear | Sax Us Gar svafraran F aya wed ET ae TAT Het Soar
St &. 47177732.00 % Ata fear | sor arcs &. 4592762.90 sat aay ay & fa
cat ft art gear Ya afaet Prange va acer & oe efearare rt 2oat F set
cae Pretheor caftrartt S wa WATT TA MTT He aiferat ar ae & frat weft fear sre
& fe wet se are Bian H per F MTR He wr Pra we Re S| afereoret At TAT
oa ont wer & oe se UT oe ae oT wer & fore aftr S Her Prat set aT
aqafer arat ah fart are H arftramrd a fas Her one Her Ie aw He sUST sek
cra aoc foe arf caftrenr et GA MaeT we ea | ST MATT TT H ore ae faa Testt
BPCL % 3& &. 4592762.90 a Aart wt ae feat afer rare + oH Re Tax wet
ge fader ferar fe sad are sett ge sara oe fAATT Gt Tit. 579836.00 & Ht ST
Rca mar & Sa are feorar Ta | aefreoret A farce var at HUI ET AE
wat fH wrt godt & wart va aa ara aoe 4 ae wer a fe set we arate
zeraat & wet Us aa cen Baer oe aT He A ott eft oft ge TTA a GE Ara
ae aferran & fraa 10(2)(1) % oar vet at | AER Ata Set Aaa AAT
aeat ax Prartaxia ae rer fr dfedt oe aaron & vem ale ae ays eet z
40 Sat west Aer aafefa we Arfafeer Frat 9
aft afferent wet are ford srefaarere & mam & oa det Ratt F zheree ome
mast srafterore & afadt at at F gt were A arrie grr ae & state of
Andhra Pradesh and others vs. Larsen and Tourbo Ltd. and Others [(2008) 8 VLy
326 (SC); 2008-38 NTN DX 31] & Fria & ve 19 % fraftften oer Ae:
"19. If one keeps in mind the above quoted observation of this court in the case of Builders Association of India [1989-73 STC 370] the position becomes clear, namely,
that even if there is no privity of contract between the contractee and the sub-contractor, that would not do away the principle of transfer of property by the sub-contractor, that would not do away the principle of transfer of property by the sub-contractor by employing the same on the property belonging to the contractee. This reasons is based on the
principle of accretion of property in goods. It is subject to the contract to the contrary.
Thus, in our view, in such a case the work executed by a sub-contractor, results in a
single transaction and not multiple transactions. This reasoning is also borne out by section 4(7) which refers to value of goods at the time of incorporation in the works
executed. In our view, if the argument of the Department is to be accepted it would
result in plurality of deemed sales which would be contrary to article 366(29A)(b) of the Constitution as held by the impugned judgment of the High Court. Moreover, it may result in double taxation which may make the said 2005 Act vulnerable to challenge as violative of articles 14, 19(1)(g) and 265 of the Constitution of India as held by the High
Court in its impugned judgment."
Sa eae ease & fe ore carondt after F are art saderac at div Rar
Sto sae se omar ar ATT Gat orf 20 wa ye wx fra & Re wer acter
SAH ENT Tet St Mg F ae Sr UP a ra sear F ory oa we & ae Saw
Sas wT H wT & ust Sa ats Haar we at BF aif sat sige sre west
Pree vet S| ora: ge TTT oe otrartt A ott we at Rams ate Ge aura Per
Ore & Us at aS BY AA UM st are wet S Ager Vy ory F |
Surya Constructions vs. Commercial Tax Officer (WC and LT), Emakulam
and Another [2015 NTN Vol.59-1 9]
50. ea ate Foret afaer & ted A qe stehar wr at ae | ces
were # fea wa ad at aaa qa FA wert B Pde at oftert ary aia
Rear aren at apeeiire Feraserery sufter firar | onftrarer + stadt ag oder areaiterr
THA WETS Wy (2000-16 wa.dhaa. shure. 425) 6 ae # area oie at &
Prfa & orem ot ge ot ge ct fire fees fer are ara gaia Arete seq
aera TST STANT Te oreteere feat fe ge fg oe after are a gar yee
TAT TAT Te aN Be sitet ary (2008-36 wz.a.aw. STAT. 47) & Prof
Farr & anes # Profy fear mar 3 |
Commissioner, Commercial Tax U.P. Lucknow vs. Abhilasha filling Station,
[2015 NTN Vol.59-39]
51. afer Tet ar Prater ea awreh after FT see sire aH Te A | afta
+ wet grat 4 30 vite wt ge oes Hat eer ae one Bae A yet aA.
free fae after aro gaéet get srere oe orefiere Phar ar Ri efter a
met qeait ot arenfta & |
Commissioner, Commercial Tax U.P. Lucknow vs. The Indian Hume Pipe
Co,. Ltd. (2015) 29 VLJ 87; [2015 NTN VOL. 59-292]
Ib? > Bi Ib 2h NabhOR BS | Ibo! Lblio 2b BH H deswKe & [pl | Ie GS
LRIBIK kb BDU Lalo WrbIESIh bh YOpkS bikele hw) PbS ke [pik 2h BUS
LIDLE bipie © Inpoys bh pas a yeTie pain Ine) npbie fh Bib PES Ee
“Yr kby We | 2 2@ dhite 1b [pew dpbahip bh LRIBIK [21S Whew |plb T
6b FIA SL (LOZ) ‘sopueya ‘AuojoD seyiA semy ‘equiny JeUUNy JemMay SA LL
1.2 Lpb I> DrIBb] 1B B be PRs bhp
DPS ‘2 12) 1P Ub HeLb) BEDI Inkebby IpIAs be RII Dayphie dh Be ee Lele DE Ve
BBP 1 POW kteib| > Inpho | pwibl>= bao bibl | B lplls Dajs Ippre 1p Pad
bh eltblibp bei ba k 700% Bb £29 IrOb InbDER & vibiopk ‘Wh We pike bbe
2 Dihlip ekkI> & pwibib» BS oj ible LpIbe DIP IWebhyte Ipiled | Lple bie) 2pIP
InB_EB pipinb| Hab) hS | Q 1d IP Kb Belo BS Dklib) dh kp I lplr Le UES
Dh Dini BS wipe pips) bh bbs Beb) BE | Ushile Ibe) Dojdue we DE Pele delle h2
BO 2h Der Lis DIP Dejpo BE Phin) 2 lbklk Le dds & epic S kph S Pe
Qh | Iie DD Pre dubipeio kb Idelpah & Dini & Blhye | phe rebhe De} S
pb € 2D Pb dh BOY DEvIe & hphie wh B bhkj bby SSB WE & ple
bjpk} jabbele BhRIS—OT bk}
| Urblin Jobb Dobie B ke
hhh @ pb inbjbk| 2b bok ab hij @ job phio pHs g ued lpbires ue Bap
ly pb Indypk) Mb Bin} BQ eink: pile Wyte} nal de ke pb whi PRE Z Led
Idbipra Lb Deb by Ab IndJPb] 2 Biol | 12 pb ldjpk} Me pnpe B eh LipK ke
Debbie BE URE & PYEHB o eho Me dvs B ips ge Bep—ledeipabs
| Bible B dal op Llp [Yb Pris Le Pipb] pale oe Liste yp beth (eip)
lb \gsbj tale B BI (Ie)
EDI & belejib Ip bite bipeppie (wh)
—Q IDE lb b12 BK B {yk} Ke dK kak} ke jb 1Zh B
bh je nbh kp pfbile ip bidjh ‘Inds! Bop heeprith b Rjbab
Ib bebElo @ IndDDa dohIlo ke Link ~ Bap Dey ~ bye Yee} (Lr)
| kjDbr |pib bie
DIK fs inbh (b BYR ‘Sable dh bile bb) beDb|po f bIDLA Ip p12
LIBGE jp) pp Bap N18 Dojbo [Pdilbho WDYho & Inpipe BH — (B)
| Adj lb b12 DIK B Ind D192 Kb debhIlo Ielbs @ Bop pe rp pee} (&)
“inhi Ibe} 2h JP ‘g Dwjelb WIDER BHIWIPIC alb b e|beR ke Lee)
bop kb Bb Bs hy ~ HS DYIhbe Kb pblie [2b] belb Me | IIa db Pee S
3p) > Bab belb 2 Bh bloblio kb 2 5b Ke Aw) S bapIK bibpsh bee le
Lipef Dimi ‘bib (Leb) SRS lb PEP DEAL ip) DI IndDp22 dkehI ie Le
Lips DW) DEBS Is pep) ‘Wsb) IPA Ke Dep bilb db BBin| do dh pollo 1B)
cp Bab—indinbio ib PbUlO jg} fen) D-IDDB NOHIIo Kb ibKK Bile IPS} “OT bk}
Up 800% ‘|Pblbbh} }> BRibB bet eK pe OL bbe
Pe hb & ipylbeye Webipie seb Bp WP 2 WYkeb Wale Quite Bh aly oo) @ nae Ap ie Qiblbe sb 12in | Unk (Be YBIK blob) 2b fb IbbIeePIh [ph Di} "2 bikbiis b Tleplpake 2 (Bh)% Dib bbb 2 dhite sbi | 2 IbWe Ibe) ELIE dh iain IDR Mb PhIRLC 2 hold Bb 4D Bd ‘2 Pb LibbIIK DPB] Bb by lebklhlle wL bin
SQ 9 ib 2b & blolblbe talbb bipbils by Pilly d BIE DEBI DEP IpOT | |shlin Sele Wp Up (gee) DUDS 'Q eS “KD bib I yeh IB Yale & DK Ibhie ‘IB vl Ibe) Dole BK Bb EIO 2 Wh ‘2 Ib) bibh Lb JeUeh b UNI fp pjble BO dh Iain ‘Apis Alls Bh elias BE lush DoiO Mb “168 MBEIe eb L-ladbipahd @ (lh)Z Dib le W plln
HAS) Hells Sip Hig) se sbb Rib $e) 18 fe biibibs baw plpbile | 2 Uble led} 12 fe Yad) Ube
bpble <Q) IDB pls PB) 2b RAE ID 2 ble DPM B YAde] dhh hel>> dlp | 2 lklk B DIO % eMPRHE 2h Dblle — joaP 4) IW) & pidlblps baw pibbills | Ibtb) dbl InbpEE p Sibine | Uple bb die|eee ible bie) ph bis | lb’) Dob) & bible bap bibbls Jib S(IEZI JpiPibh gooz) WY Boh Soh UAE Licwh bib de> dbiho dbe ele ID
(986 Ipipibh 8661) dkbMrhinf s1040y DADs “Woy Inlsn3 BASIE HOp>/Inb/ hub? Pa
Bip 2 Pi? Upk Whbde dh IBID Lal DOD o imple w Let bo ABIES ‘2 hhh Mile bibl: 2) ple 18 | 2b | lle lpi [bh Sadie PEDIC & ()(L)AST Dik 2h YRS
BES | lbpee) ltsin deb JP be de IIS) JP b PE b KhhO bibl ‘Ie ped) LIK OO'OPE‘ZE'RE
Se BSS BDH & BIRR) ihlp bie Boye GPE | 2 wep > je bIdUE Pp 2h bE hold “H'f th dhe & blob! bl bd] fb bib (6s [piPIph 0002) bab
“bleh bib bj bleypdie BES PEP pOT DID bidlblp: balbp bibl DwIES ‘2 Ned
HARES MARIE le Dibiate sb bob IbK @ jeBeb DIES Ibe) b LD) HEELS lo G66r
OGG Ploy AO We PIPED fe ade) Ahh bnla> lB Mb} Le Led |eb Ppiblbo | Lhe) PhIpie
*P & Piek}e bebie @ sane Dik kb bkbiRyo db dhiko PEbIE & ,asn Oo} JYBIY, | ele Ieee) Balk Ibe) OOOZE'ZZ'SL'L “S & feb BS de babe Beh bliss dh
Pie) DS 10-000% fab 2H b Mb) I bt) ETI p why uf Abi & Ipip *g
£92 FTA LL (6002) “PIT
Wd saujsnpu] pue svajndwioy BYON SA Aequiog ‘eujyseseyey) J9 FBIS “L Ss'9
(IT 2b2K)
«l 122 PbO PbjDi1b [tp YP Ye'ba [lO dh [laMbhO blo ID Pr Pub pbb Ie
PS) O} 2 ipl BPI Ife Fler DW) sb Ld DUK 2h | fe [Plin [Qe bIDK [ob YP Yo"kd
HO DIF WI WE/ hE Dibp B& Dro Hbin| ‘ie [pb Kb dhallo p L>bjb lbp
$d UebroR Led bak Ip ye" te PH WIP WE/PhBIK Med pk [ee Ppbsb,
«! DIP fledjia fed gb YP Yn A [ie Sj be ‘Ue Win Lede) {2 DIP {fed Iba Jece
© WiPrwe YhbIK LvIbB Ib Pru & BER Db pe Bue ‘p pun Be pnw
fle Ibbie fe bid{tele tb DID WE/PbIK Pibke © Ip Yyo'kh le & kb Degyb)
BO Uab Uple Lede) Bejbiie pL A hsb) 26 IPEUPpIO ke yp Yo kd te 2] 2 Web
42 2 ‘ple fed) [pk [eb Up yorkh ‘Ye Yfe fre p ‘Bd fe [per @ WIDDE/ PALIN beh
Lbefel> DIP >2Foreth Diao J) 4] 2 Dab? 2h P {lee DioJb ph f IndMbK bibpb,
~:2)} 151) piibib: bah biebiis HT Pdb didojp> Bio} Led) Ppl
nie Qieh Ob ke disblalte :ie | {ple {2 ditblp? Ye dplr kb Dale Wiple BAB ~p Inkba}e BER) SBE | g App Abby ab db be “Ye YP ye Api eb Ye nab AE bie ie inh
Unde) Dh Ise Dito db kdb Isp Wis? KBE kb 4p yer eh he sy 1B & debe ¢y
OL bby Ibjgj>jeie 2 PRjbB mk bes das “
bipbis vp Uh) lb Lllnb) 1g WE IB ple PELE we) BEB Up Inky
Ris) § Sik b leek) BEE ipipipk 8661) lp bd bod ‘BD bbe ee
DBDSIN WNplplisp HWE? nD OOOT pl 71 IkOB iRBEE “w) Basel Sob bis
ia hb BY ol lf Bl Ub plo fale) Ubte} JAYLe YEE te lalla | @ bs AE
fe {Sy Ibk Ibe)) BikB th Uplle HE Mb ap B bible DIPR) BYE ph tp 2B ile B
ble BRK | Lele Lele 2p bjrbte se ish ‘b 2D, 2b Bie} ‘e Beej Lal 00000 08 Ls
'o DB Be dh phe) QUljsh bh abr LIB! |g Wyre) W dbp Dhldé IpLRIE
96 £'1A 6 (6002) 'd'N “LL'O SA BIdND PUBYoYsHIS)
| @ Ul tb} lp e djaby (629 pipypk 2661) hele pb eal “BP bts!
mle bh Ipjoh BSE unSue ph (008 {piplpk £002) IpBUOIp Helle LUD blpb Dia2{te
blob) Ib fs IbDIAeYh IVE |B Wb | Ie Phjdue Me Phe —S ish S 23D, ppbie
@ whe Dip i Bj) Ipd [lp Bib |p B pile hyp aay) ie PPPS rh bind WS B
nila #h In’ Bip abo ‘hibjah fA Bigllb> Me bi de) Lelie BD Pode eels LnlBIPEB
pidlblbe a follsbells | ple bd} Did InkQEA ap Berk) sobiol ke Neplp> |iple BUA
ie Ind@baplO LUD] ‘Uae Und} Balke Be WIPO tals Bio} Unde) Boyle Dee te Biderake PRES
% ish 3 25D, 2h BS | liz Ible Ibby ribtalie Ive eb ifs Woe | fe pe Whe rallies
DIK PhS ST DEYLIe SAE ikb le Bho OOS bh SZ sbi Ibe} skye NERS | Mp
> 2b RDG bly kb HB Hiab wold b.8 5 lp Me wh Iehie & Blblke “gs
Szz PTA Ob (6002) ‘peqepeIOW ‘IYpUeYD ‘p9-v YeUINy YseUUeH SA J) “LL'D
ol 2 JBl Indele Bee Ie ebtajte Leltehe
Ibb [ple [p 2h SE DIB Diblbo f \pels 2D Ibale 2 pk Hei Me bLbie S Be Dip ke
bbbjjlo dh Biblio YehOjs tb} 2 1B! Db|iplbs Undlisble 2p [gp lapis da) Q Lble PIPH
lob Dah b Sb BS & IWebhijle [pled LR) BR ‘DT pd birael> ke japdyh bes
| 2 bel plin pe} Db? Indl ba Pab\bIPIs Undinble Delle DIS Iodeae | Ue
loka) Joh 2h Dpto Dlr Bb Iple | 2h BD) B wh PIS) Le (wh bas) “|p |p die
‘po'p’ J 2 DigllzK 2b 2b B 22b B hab bE | Yb Whb lb) B Ibklib Nye Yep Pils
22] dp) Ute bbl lu dabSnéb | née bldlh 1M USph) ph [dalle e rabsate Hef] NIP (|p
‘goue' php’ biple) Bb bas lb bab |g rib Beep) | Wi2 Qitepeep ep Ib PPR) Mee We
Ypirdise iid) % jis pb phie lip ‘kde pee sible Ye PO ft Divi Bip Ke Bie Ye {p 2h
oe 4) 2 Jbl 1B? bdIpli> Leb (|plbi-b2ib Dile) eh biPR) de) 2 Bh tab, 4b} UD) lbp Bh bias
| illo all eb JOD BBB Ye MHBIS Ide blbioh lal? Uh? ee bleh) Kab >Yh Inkabbe) bh bible
db bale DajpEin 4p) 2 igh AP PIs ah We ReBIS +b) IW) b Dilblh: ba bible AT pee
Hib|p> ia} Lede) dl InelpAh fe elk) Bede) PHS | @ |p DA) Wyre Pip fy MabLob
J lbte) Diilbk) DS Pr Pb Iselle Idfk| Mb IP IE bIDIbI® kK b loki
Bible pipe) | led B Wile RK bpkb Weblo) lpibd 2 Dppie @ lok Bb aR, &
Qiao dh Bis) ip |p dh PD) Bb |ahie (tb bib) bab Nh bibiod “KD » [plb "p
P62 FIA
LL (6002) ‘dN “L1'D SA peqaizeyH joyiey Bndéaen LE-0¢ “py7 yueg BASAA
| Able Ince) Dieblpeie Ine bh DME BE | Ye DRL Yell [pURa} fe \ALL’) ARE gs) ke
‘BHO | Ue Ute dee) 4B ia) sb MUD) BBIP Bb kdjw “|B dale Loeb) fe Dobe Ip ke LALA Le RASH “b) Q DPJ eae Jeb lodibaYO |e dh Bip] BO 'R MSH Le Sodhto wh |Aln | le Lele IIOl
“y 800% ‘\pbibhh| 2 Dajbh bok Isek pap Ol bbb}
44 Sat wes yea dati we artafsfer Fat 10
sarees PGT ae Rew fer. TaTT aetaet site Feo vRNGT (HZ. 1997(10) wae
82) % faate Prefa et & art gq Petal a gaia sragae 8 1 Arete Seq =e
3 wea at fades Hed ee ferar fe area ated ~rearere ar Prefa rst ceil ox orrenfte
Bl are Ue aan eat Fret St S SRT aaa Wafer F | Aa: AE YEe SH Aol F as
ot & Ta aa FS ones ar anes far azar |
C.T.T.,, U.P. vs Agarwal Pulp and Paper Lid., (2009) 9 VLJ 145
7. STR F AEST St a wsde aafrat a ort aa Paar rot oe wert at et
fe ae oferta at cad ax S Gast ate Sat Sar SF ore | ge are Read oz aftr
4 Use = a © Set IMRT 3TH (2)(@) S sieefa ae wea | Terr order eter