THE RAJASTHAN MONEY-LENDERS ACT, 1963
Rajasthan Act
- Act 1 of 1964
- Enacted: 1964-03-09
- Ministry: NO MINISTRY
- Department: Revenue Department
- Status: no repeal is recorded
This text is shown as one document.
Full text
1
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
THE RAJASTHAN MONEY-LENDERS ACT, 1963
(RAJASTHAN ACT NO. 1 OF 1964)
[Published in Rajasthan Gazette, Part IV-A, Extraordinary, dated 3-1964.]
List of Amending Acts & ordinances
CONTENTS
Sections
1. Short title, extent and commencement
2. Definitions
(1) Bank
(2) Business of Money-lending
(3) Capital
(4) Company
(5) Co-operative Society
(6) Interest
(7) Licence
(8) Licence fee
(9) Loan
(10) Money Lender
(11) Principal
(12) Provident fund
(13) Recognized Language
(14) Register
(15) Suit to which this Act applies
(16) Trader
3. Appointment of Registrar General, Registrars and Assistant Registrars
4. Registers of money-lenders
5. Money-lenders not to carry on business of money-lending except for area
under licence and except in accordance with terms of licence
6. Application by money-lender for grant or renewal of licence
7. Inquiry into and disposal of application
8. Grounds for refusal of licence
9. Registrar's power to cancel licence
10. Term of licence
11. Dismissal of suit by money-lender not holding licence
12. [Omitted]
13. Application for cancellation of licence
14. Application of section 5 of Central Act IX of 1903 to certain appeals
15. Registrar, Assistant Registrar and authorized officer to have powers of civil
courts
16. Power of authorized officer to require production of record documents
2
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
17. Court's power to cancel or suspend a licence
18. No compensation for suspension or cancellation of licence
19. Persons debarred from doing business during period of suspension or
cancellation of licence
20. Person whose licence is suspended or cancelled not to apply without giving
particulars of endorsement of disqualification
21. Transfer of licence to heir
22. Duty of money-lenders to keep accounts and furnish copies
23. Delivery of statement of accounts and copies thereof by money lender
24. Fees for certain statements supplied to debtor and Assistant Registrars
25. Debtor not bound to admit correctness of accounts
26. Procedure of court in suits regarding loans
27. Maximum amount of interest recoverable on loans and discharge of loans in
certain cases
28. Power of court to direct payment of decretal amount by instalments
29. Limitation on rates of interest
30. Prohibition of charge for expenses on loans by money-lenders
31. Notice and information to be given on assignment of loans
32. Application of Act as respects assignees
33. Reopening of transaction or accounts already taken
34. Application to court by debtor for taking account
35. Deposit in court of money due to money-lender
36. When interest to be paid for entire month
37. Money-lenders to exhibit their names over shops
38. Entry of wrong sum in bond etc. to be an offence
39. Penalty for molestation
40. Punishment for contravention of sections 5, 22, 23, 29, 30 and 37
41. Offences by corporation etc.
42. Cognizance of certain offences
43. Compounding of offences
44. Arrest and imprisonment in execution of decree for money- against agricultural
debtors abolished
45. Every officer to be public servant
46. Protection to persons acting under this Act
47. Provisions of Rajasthan Act 28 of 1957 saved
48. Power to make rules
49. Repeal
SCHEDULE
APPENDICES A, B & C
3
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
List of Amending Acts & Ordinances
1. The Rajasthan Money Lenders (Amendment) Act, 1976 (Raj. Act No. 13 of
1976) vide Notification No. F. 2(37) Vidhi /75, dated 13-2-1976, Pub. in Raj. Gazette,
Extra-ordinary, Part IV-A, dated 13-2-1976, Page 181 to 185.
2. The Rajasthan Money-Lenders (Amendment) Act, 1986 (Raj Act No. 6 of
1986) vide Notification No. F. 2(4) Vidhi/86, dated 13-2-1986, Pub. in Raj, Gazette,
Extra-ordinary, Part IV-A, dated 13-2-1286, Page; 105 to 107, and shall be deemed
to have come into force on 30-12-1985, the date of Raj Ordinance No,l3 of 1985.
List of Ordinances
1 The Rajasthan Money Lenders (Amendment) Ordinance, 1975 (Raj Ordinance
No. 14 of 1974) Pub. in Raj. Gaz., Extraordinary Part IV-B, dated 15-8-1975, P. 65-
67,
2. The Raj. Money Lenders (Amendment) Ordinance, 1985 (Raj. Ordi. No. 13 of
1985) which come into force from 30-12-1985, Vide No. 4(13) Vidhi/1 5. dated 30-12-
1985, Pub. in, Raj, Gaz., Extra-ordinary, Part IV-B, dated 30-12-1985 Page 15 w.e.f.
30-12-1985,
THE RAJASTHAN MONEY LENDERS ACT, 1963
(RAJ, ACT NO. 1 OF 1964)
[Received the assent of the President on the 9ih day of March, 1964]
An Act To make better provision for the regulation and control of transactions of
money-lending in the State of Rajasthan.
Be it enacted by the Rajasthan State Legislature in the Fourteenth Year of the
Republic of India as follows: —
1. Short title, extent and commencement--(I) This Act may be called the Rajasthan
Money-lenders Act, 1963.
(2) It extends to the whole of the State of Rajasthan.
(3) It shall come into force on such date as the State Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint in this behalf.
NOTIFICATION
Notification No. F. 23 (2) Rev. (D)/54 dated 25-8-1955.
In exercise of the powers conferred by sub section (3) of section 1 of the
Rajasthan Money-lenders Act, 1963 (Rajasthan Act 1 of 1964), the State Government
hereby appoints the 1st day of October, 1965 as the date-on which the said Act shall
come into force.
4
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
{Pub. in Raj Gaz , Extra-ordinary, Part IV-C, dated 1-9-1965.]
SYNOPSIS
1. Application of the Act & Scope of application
2. Construction of provisions
3. Object of the Act
4. Principles of interpretation of statutes
5. Amending Act No, 13 of 1976 - Extent of retrospective effect
6. Order 41, Rule 27, C.P.C & Sections 22 & 23 of the Act.
7. Statement of objects & reasons
COMMENTARY
I. Application of the Act- Scope of- It was held that section 29 has not been made
retrospective and section 29 of the Act does not apply to transactions entered into
before the Act came into force—Nanu Ram vs Vishwa Mitra, ILR (1968) 18 Raj.
534=1968 RLW 358 (AIR 1953 Bombay 125, relied on.) J|
The application of the Act is not restricted to loans only by professional money -
lenders. - Ramula Bose vs. Manmath Nath, AIR 1945 FC 108. "\
The provisions of the Act do not apply to a loan to trader for trade, — Wassiahmul
vs. Good Luck Pictures, 64 Bom. LR 549.
The rule of Damdupat applies to all classes of money-lenders and money- lending
transactions in the State- Sajan Lai vs. Gulabchand, AIR 1953 Bom. 123 : 54 Bom.
LR 132.
The rule of Damdupat does not apply to mortgages—Gopal Ram Chandra vs.
Ganga Ram, 20 Bom. LR 72L
The rule of Damdupat does not apply to decrees but the court has discretion in
the matter—Achyut Narayan vs. Ramchandra, AIR 1925 Bom 362 : 27 Bom LR 492
The rule of Damdupat has no application where The original debtor is a
Mohammadan-- Hiralal vs. Nagar Jayram, 21 Bom. LR 38.
The section conferring power on the Court to limit interest applied to all leans
whether they were to traders or other parties — Wassiamull vs. Good Luck Picture,
64 Bom. LR 549.
The provisions of the Act, except sections 23 & 25, do not apply to a trader, (ibid).
The Act does not apply to a suit for the redemption – Chunilal vs. E. Christopher,
AIR 1926 Born. 65: 27 Bom LR 1462 & Thakan Sahu vs. Ram Partay; AIR 1950 Pat
201
2. Construction of Provision.—In construing the Act which takes away vested
5
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
rights and curtails freedom of contractor, the court should interpret it literally and
strictly- Bhupendra Nath vs. Debendranath, AIR l942Cal. 370.
In clear case of repugnance, in the subject or context, the-court can assign
another suitable meaning to the expression—The Official Liquidator vs. Jugal
Kishore, AIR 1936: All Secretary of State vs, Arunachalam, AIR 1936 Mad. 711.
3. Object of Act —The Act was intended to put down a very serious evil in the
society. It was intended to keep control over money lending transactions and to see
that excessive rate of interest was not charged by money-lenders, and the only way
that such control can be maintained is by providing penalties for doing money lending
business without a proper licence from the State—54 Born. LR 160: 21 Bom. Or, C.
317: ILR (1952) BOM. 914: AIR 1952 Bom; 276 (276,297),
The object of the Act appears to be that unwary agriculturists and non-traders and
parties who are into banking and commercial transactions should be protected --
Wassiamull v. Good Luck Pictures, 64 Bom. L.R. 549.
The Act intended to keep control over money-lending transactions and to see that
excessive rate of interest was not charged by money-lenders- In Re. Parshuram, AIR
1952 Bom. 279: 54 Bom. LR 549.
It was the view of the legislature that commerce and business methods of loans
should in no way, be hindered by reason of provisions of the Act — Wassiamull vs.
Good Luck Pictures, 64 Bom. LR 549.
The provisions of the Act have been enacted to prevent unscrupulous money-
lenders exploiting the needs of the poor and a breach of the provisions cannot be
countenanced—State vs. Devi Dose, 62 Bom. LR 316,
The object of the rules is clearly to protect debtors from unscrupulous creditors —
1951 NLJ (Notes) 92 : 1951 NLJ (Notes) 10.
4. Principles of Interpretation of statutes having Retrospective effect.
It is a fundamental rule of interpretation of statutes that no statute shall be construed
to have a retrospective operation unless such a construction appears very clearly in
the terms of the Act or arises by necessary and distinct implication. A statute is not to
be construed to have a greater retrospective operation than its language renders
necessary.
The question arose whether the rates of interest fixed by the State Government
under section 29 would be applicable even to those transactions which had been
entered into prior to the coming into force of the Act. It was observed that there is
nothing in section 29 to show that the legislature intended that the maximum rate of
interest fixed by the State Government under sub-section (!) of section 29 shall also
apply to those transactions which had been entered into prior to the coming into force
6
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
of the Act.
It was held that section 29 has not been made retrospective and does not apply to
transactions catered into before the Act came into force (AIR 1953 Bom, 125 relied
on); Nanu Ram vs. Vishwa Mitra, ILR (1968) 1« Raj. 534=1968 RLW358.
5. Amending Act No. 13 of 1976 —Extent of its retrospective application —
Since amending Act No. 13 of 1976 prohibits issue of licenses with retrospective
effect licenses shall have prospective effect henceforth. Thus contravention of section
5 of this Act cannot be condoned.—Narayan vs. State of Raj., 1979 RRD »24,
According to section 6 of the Money-lenders Act, the persons doing the business
of money lending are bound to obtain licenses within the stipulated period before
actually carrying on the money lending business. Time factor is an important element
for applying for the licence.
Section 7 of the Act envisages issue of licenses prospective and not with a
retrospective effect. Old sections 11 & 12 of the Act enabling issue of licenses
retrospectively stand amended and thus omitted to have retrospective effect
thereafter on and from the application of Rajasthan Amendment Act No. 13 of
1976.—Narayan vs. State, 1979 RRD 124.
Normally all legislation is prospective and an intention to divest citizens of vested
rights, will not be imputed to the legislature unless it is expressly mentioned.—Sajjan
Lal vs. Gulabchand. AIR 1953 Bombay 125 • 54 Bom. LR 632
Sections 11 and 26(b) as Amended by the Amending Act No. 13 of 1976 have
retrospective effect Sec.11 and 26 of the Act were amended in 1976. In section 11
the Legislature expressly provided an exception of its application to pending cases,
but no such exception was earned out in Section 26(b) when the legislature acts at
the particular point of time in legislating two provisions in the same Act and in
retrospective effect is avoided by making an exception and in the other drastic
consequences are contemplated by not enacting such an explanation, this court,
while interpreting the law has got no option but to respect the wishes of the
legislature though seemingly it may create hardship to those money lenders who
have already filed their suits and were not aware of the drastic consequences of non-
compliance of the section of the Act. Such an intention of the legislature cannot be
changed unless it lapse any legislative authority or become violate of any of the
constitution. None of the two contingencies contemplated have been shown to exist
as there is no challenge to plenary authority nor there is any violation of the
constitutional provisions. General Principal of interpretation of the statute is that the
statute should be treated prospective and not retrospective, more so, when the
provisions are penal in nature. However, it all depends upon the scheme of the Act,
intention to enact a particular statute and merely on the basis of generalization when
7
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
expressly by providing contra language in Section I in contra to section 26(b), the
Legislature expresses its intention, this court cannot enter to the contrary (Para 5 &
6), Ramchandra vs Prabhulal, 1982 Raj LR 275.
Section 27 of the Act should be given retrospective effect (AIR 1953 Bom, 420,
(1889) 9 Q B D. 672, AIR 1936 Rom 37, AIR 1949 Ori. 37, relied on AIR 1936 Cal
334. AIR 1938. Nag. 112, 1968 RLW 658 S.B. Civil Revision No. 270 of 1969,
decided by the Rajasthan High court on October 29, 1969 unreported, Man Mohan v.
Ram Gopal explained and distinguished Durgadas vs Kanhilal and others, IL R
(1971) 21 Raj 1127=1971 R.L W. 50=1970 WLN 563
6 Order 41, Rule 27, CPC & Sections 22 & 23 of the Act. -Money advanced and
documents, executed in 1967, statement of accounts, not sent to debtor. Fresh
documents executed in 1973 without showing interest and adjustment of money,
repaid—Held, Ss, 22 and 23 not complied with.
In the first appellate court certain documents were sought to be produced under
Order 41, R. 27, CPC and the court having considered the implications of these
documents cannot save the Plaintiff from the drastic consequences of dismissal of
suit in as much as they relate to the year 1974 to 1976, It was then held that in the
documents of 1975 and 1976, the rates of interest have not been shown nor any
payments have been adjusted and it has not been shown for showing compliance of
Sections 22 and 23 of the Act that any statement of account was sent to the latter. On
these findings the first appellate court after examining the document submitted by the
plaintiff has held that sections 22 and 23 have not been complied with. Held, finding
about non-compliance of sections 22 and 23 of the Act does not call for any
interference (Para 9). -Ramchandia vs. Prabhulal, 1982 RLR 275
7. Statement of Objects and Reasons,—The Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
regulates and controls the business of money lending in the State. This Act is,
however, not applicable to certain registered societies, insurance companies and
banks. It has been felt that certain bodies institutions engaged in financing housing
schemes, etc. also need exemption from the said Act so that they can give loans to
the public for housing and other welfare purposes. Sub-clause (iii) of Clause (10) of
section 2 of the Act is, therefore, to be substituted so as to empower the State
Government to exempt an institution from the provisions of this Act by issuing a
notification in the Official Gazette.
Since the Rajasthan Legislative Assembly was not in session and the circumst-
ances existed which made it necessary to issue an Ordinance, the Governor of the
State of Rajasthan made and promulgated the Rajasthan Money-lenders
(Amendment) Ordinance, 3985 (Ordinance No, 13 of 1985) on 28th day of
December, 1985.
8
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
[Raj. Bill No. I of 1986 vide Notification No. F. 13(1) ,- oh-“kk-/ 86 fnukad 23-1-
1986 tks jkt- jkti= foks’kkad Hkkx III-d, fnukad13-1-1986 ds i`’B 47-50 ij Nik].
Vi Sha./ 86 dated 23-1-1986 State Gaz. Notification Spl. Part III-A, dated 13-1-1986
Printed at Page no. 47-50
2. Definitions.- In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or
context;
(1) 'bank’ means a banking company as defined in the Banking Companies Act,
1949 (Central Act X of 1949), and includes the State Bank of India and any other
banking institution notified by the Central Government under sec. 51 of the said Act;
(2) 'business of money-lending’ means the business of advancing loans whether
or not in connection with or in addition to any other business;
(3) 'capital’ means a sum of money which a money-lender invests in the business
of money -lending;
(4) 'company’ means a company as defined in sec. 3 of the Companies Act, 1956
(Central Act I of 1956);
(5) 'co-operative society’ means a society registered or deemed to have been
registered under the Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act, 1953 (Rajasthan Act IV of
1953) or under the Co-operative Societies Act, 1912 (Central Act II of 1912) or under
any Act of any other State Legislature relating to co-operative societies;
(6) 'interest’ includes any sum, by whatsoever name called, in excess of the
principal paid or payable to a money-lender in consideration of or otherwise in
respect of a loan, but does not include any sum lawfully charged by a money- lender
for or on account of costs charges or expenses in accordance with the provisions of
this Act or any other law for the time being in force;
(7) 'licence’ means a licence granted under this Act;
(8) 'licence-fee' means the fee payable in respect of a licence;
(9) 'loan means an advance at interest, whether of money or in kind, but does not
include: —
(a) a deposit of money or other property in a Government Post Office Savings
Bank or in any other bank or in a company or with co-operative society;
(b) a loan to or by, or a deposit with, any society or association registered or
deemed to be registered under the Rajasthan Societies Registration Act, 1958 or any
other enactment, relating to a public, religious or charitable objects;
(c) a loan advanced by Government or by any local authority authorized by Govt.;
(d) a loan advanced to a Government servant from a fund established for the
welfare and assistance of Govt. servants and which is sanctioned by the State Govt;
9
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(e) a loan advanced by a co-operative society;
(f) an advance made to a subscriber to, or a depositor in, a Provident Fund from
the amount standing to his credit in the fund in accordance with the rules of the fund;
(g) a loan to or by an insurance company as defined in the Insurance Act, 1938
(Central Act IV of 1938);
(h) a loan to, or by a bank;
(i) an advance made on the basis of a negotiable instrument as defined ju the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (Central Act XXVI of 1881) other than a promissory
note:
(j) except for the purposes of sections 27 and 29.
(i) a loan to a trader, or
(ii) a loan to a money-lender who holds a valid licence;
(10) "money-lender'" means:-—
(i) an individual or
(ii) an individual Hindu family, or
1(iii) a company (not being a banking company as defined in section 5 of the
Banking Regulation Act, 1949;, body or institution other than such of them as may, by
notification in the Official Gazette, be exempted from the provision's of this Act by the
Stale Government on being satisfied that it is necessary or expedient so to do in
public interest, or]
(iv) an un incorporated body of individuals,
who or which—
(a) carries on the business of money-lending in the State; or
(b) has his or its principal place of such business in the State.
(11) "principal” means in relation to a loan, the amount actually advanced to the
debtor;
(12) "Provident Fund” means a Provident Fund as defined in the Provident Funds
Act, 1925 (Central Act X of 1925) and includes a Government Fund and a Railway
1
Substituted for the original expression—(iii) a company other than a banking company as defined in sec. 5 of
the Banking Company Act, !949, or by the Rajasthan Money-lenders Amendment Act, 1986 (Raj. Act No. 6 of 19e'6)
vide Notification No. R 2 (4), vidhi/86, dated / 3-2-1986 Pub. in Raj, Gaz., Extra-ordinary, Part IV-A, dated 13-2-1986
at pages 105-107 and came into force w e.f. 30-12-1985 the day on which Raj. Ordinance No. 13 of 1985 came into
force.
10
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
Provident Food as defined in the said Act;
(13) 'recognized language’ means—
(i) Hindi written in the Devnagri script, or
(ii) English, if the debtor so desires in writing, or
(iii) where both the parties speak the same language, that language;
(14) ‗register’ means a register of money-lenders maintained under sec. 4
(15) 'suit to which this Act applies’ means any suit or proceeding—
(a) for the recovery of a loan made after the date on which this Act comes into
force; or
(b) for the enforcement of any security taken or any agreement
made after the date on which this Act comes into force in respect of any loan made
either before or after the said date; or
(c) for the redemption of any security given after the date on which this Act comes
into force in respect of any loan made either before or after the said date;
(16) 'trader’ means a person who in the regular course of business buys and sells
goods or other property, whether movable or immovable, & includes—
(a) a whole-sale or retail merchant,
(b) a commission agent,
(c) a broker,
(d) a manufacturer,
(e) a contractor, and
(f) a factory owner,
but does not include an artisan or a person who sells his agricultural produce or
cattle or buys agricultural produce or cattle for his use.
Explanation.—For the purposes of clause (16) an 'artisan' means a person who
does not employ more than ten workers in manufacturing process on any one day of
the twelve months immediately preceding.
Notification No. F 2 (2) Rev /Gr. 4/85/5 dated February 3, 1986.
S.O. 185 -In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-clause (iii) of clause 10 of
section 2 of the Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963 (Rajasthan Act 1 of 1964) as
amended by the Rajasthan Money Lenders (Amendment) Ordinance, 1985
(Ordinance No. 13 of 1985), the State Government, hereby exempts the Housing
Development Finance Corporation Limited a Company incorporated under Indian
Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) from the provisions of this Act. [Pub. in Raj. Gaz.
Extra-ordinary, Part 1V-C, dated 13-2-1986, p. 381],
11
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
SYNOPSIS
1. Business of Money lending—Meaning explained
2. Interest
3. Licence
4. Loan
5. Suit - Meaning of RL.L. XV—27
COMMENTARY
/. Business of Money lending —Meaning explained -The word 'business‘ imports
the notion of system repetition and continuity,
'Money lenders‘—Meaning of causal money lender not a professional money
lender business what does it import.
The mere fact that the money was advanced on interest on more than one
occasion would not necessarily import that the person was not engaged in the
business of advancing loans nor does a man become money lender merely because
he may on one or several isolated occasions lend money to a stranger.
In the present case the statement of the plaintiff simply showed that he was a
casual money-lender and not a professional money lender who alone is contemplated
under clause (10) of section 2. (1006) 1 KB 584, 1896 AC 325 and 17 ALJ 1147
relied on Gaurishanker v. Magbaram, ILR (1974) 24 Raj, 658=1974 RLW 106 = 1974
WLN 93=AIR 1974 Raj. 238.
The provisions of the Act relating to licence do not apply to Foreign Money
lenders.—ILR 1947 Nag 137=1947 NLJ 385=A1R 1947 Nag 201.
The creditor must plead that he is merely a causal money lender .- AIR 1974
Patna 103.
Cooperative society.—Since the Rajasthan Co-operative Societies Act 1953 (Raj.
Act 4 of 1953) has been repealed and substituted by the Rajasthan Co-operative
Societies Act, 1965 (Rajasthan Act 13 of 1965) reference to the said Rajasthan Co-
operative Societies Act, 1953 shall be deemed to be a reference to the Rajasthan
Cooperative Societies Act, 1965 under section 8 of the General Clauses Act;
A Co-operative Society is deemed to be a validly registered Cooperative Society
who holds a valid registration certificate issued or deemed to have been issued under
the respective law for the time being in force arid which has not been cancelled as yet
by the competent authority in accordance with the law.
2. Interest — An interest is essential ingredient of loan- AIR 1955 Nagpur(NUC)
2456 = ILK 1955 Nag. 513 =1955 Nag. LJ 359
12
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
An interest free advance is not loan as contemplated under this Act—
Ramchandra vs. Bhao Rao, 1960 Nag. LJ (notes) 89.
The use of word 'includes' in the definition of the term interest denotes, it is not
exhaustive.
Original amount is principal and balance is nothing but the interest — Maganlal
Pragibhai vs. State of Bombay, AIR 1958 Bom. l54=-56 Bom LR 139(FB).
There must be something more than the excessive rate of interest to satisfy the
court that the transaction is unfair.-- Mehdi Razvi vs. Panaa Lai -- AIR 1917 Pat. 336.
Where there is a payment covering the entire amount of the interest due at the
bound rate also towards the principal the excess payment will certainly go towards
reduction of the principal—Ramswaroop Mahtar vs. Mathura Prasad Singh, 4 DLR
Pat. 237.
If the excess amount bears to the loan a ratio higher that the rate of interest
prescribed, the money-lender comes within the mischief of the Act —Maganlal Praggi
Bhai vs. State of Bombay, AIR 1958 Bom 92.
An agreement for payment of interest in excess of the maximum rate was void.—
In Re Parshuram, AIR 1952 Bom. 276.
Where the interest charged in excess of the prescribed rate, the court is required
to presume that the transaction is pot fair—Elias Suleh Mahammed vs. Khumull, AIR
1959 Mys. 132.
The executing court has to investigate the contention that the decree holder was
recovering larger amount by way of interest than principal.— Ramlal vs. Shrinhar,
AIR 1960 MPLJ (Notes) li.
The court cannot decree on account of interest, a sum greater than principal.—
Pandurang vs. Nuru Miya, 62 Bom LR 547.
In view of the words, 'Notwithstanding anything contained in any other enactment,
the court had power to reopen the transaction and disallow interest—Bisanlal vs.
Malilal, 1960 Nag. U (Notes) 83.
As the plaintiff failed to maintain and send accounts he was not entitled to
interest—Dattatraya vs. Maroli, 1959 NLJ (Notes) 113.
Even though the note did not make any specific mention of interest, the plaintiff
was entitled to interest at 6% per annum by virtue of section 80 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act—Abdul Hussain vs. Seth Fazal Bhai, AIR 1957 Bom. 529.
The court could disallow interest where the plaintiff did not supply the statement of
accounts--Shankar vs. Rania, 1956 NLJ (Notes) 148.
13
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
There is no inconsistency between Sections 27 and 33 for determining quantum
of interest Transaction can be reopened. Principal being Rs. 1689.11/- and interest of
Rs. 1500/ already paid. Held, Plaintiff can claim Rs. 189.11/- towards interest
Section 27 of the Rajasthan Act can only be construed according to the definition
given to the word ‗principal' in section 2(11) and for determining the quantum of
interest, the transaction between the debtor and the creditor can be ripped up and re-
opened and to me there does not appear to be any conflict or inconsistency between
the provisions of sections 27 and 33 of the Rajasthan Act
The principal of the loan is Rs.189.11/-The Plaintiffs can only claim a sum of Rs.
180.11/-by way of interest and beyond that the defendant is not liable to pay any
interest. The total liability with regard to interest can be to the extent of the amount of
Rs. 1689.11/- and a sum of Rs.1500/-has already been paid by the defendant to be
appropriated as interest. Thus the plaintiffs are only entitled to a decree of Rs1879/ -
Basti Ram v. Ghewarchand and anr. 1979 WLN 51=1979 RLW 50= AIR 1979
Raj.148.
3. Licence—It is mandatory for every person to obtain licence 'before" doing
money-lending business--Desai Bhao vs. Kaniram, AIR 1952 Hyd. 142.
4. Loan—The expression 'an advance at interest' covers cases ".-where the
interest was provided by the contract as well as cases when the interest was payable
under a statute. In a suit filed on a promissory note in which the rate of interest was
not mentioned and no interest was claimed in the suit, the question was whether the
transaction was a 'loan' within the meaning of the Act. Held that by virtue of sec 80 of
the Negotiable instruments Act, ' 88', the advance made under the promissory note
was an, advance at Interest and, therefore, a loan within the meaning of the Act -
(1971) 73 BLR 458=1971 Mah. LJ 608.
The legislature has not made any provision that the interest payable in respect of
loans borrowed before the Act came into force be reduced- Sajjanlal vs. Gulabchand,
AIR 1953 Bom 125=54 Bom LR 635.
The word 'loans' in plural in the definition points out that if a person tends money
on a single occasion on interest, he cannot be considered to be a money-lender --
Binapani vs. Ravindranath, AIR 1959 Cal. 213.
The advance of money in cash or by a cheque is loan.- Shivlal Seth vs. Devendra
Kumar, 1960 MPLJ (Notes) 166.
The definition of 'loan' covers a loan which is unsecured. -- Emperor vs. Jheverilal,
AIR 1960 Bom. 119= 51 Bom LR 991; Bansilal Ramgopal vs. Harishchand, AIR 1953
Bom. 420=55 Bom LR I44=ILR 1953 Bom. 1055.
The amount advanced without interest on account of cordial relations did not
14
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
amount to a loan—Ranuhandar vs. Bhao Rao, 1960 NLJ (Notes) 89.
Debt is not necessarily a loan.—Radha Krishna vs. Keshavdeo, AIR 1957 SC
743.
The goods sold on credit do not amount to loan -- Mangilal vs. R.R. Contractor,
1952 MFC 442.
The renewed bond where interest is capitalized is loan although no money is
actually advanced—Fatehchand vs. Akimuddin, AIR 1943 Cal. 163.
A compromise decree allowing the balance to be paid in instalments with same
rate of interest does not convert the unpaid purchase price into a loan—Radha
Krishna vs. Keshavdeo, AIR 1957 SC 743.
The transaction of selling gold ornaments does not amount to loan.— Daulal vs.
Ramsingh, 1961 MPLJ (Notes) 301.
There may be debt contracted without contracting a loan.—Mangilal vs. R.R.
Contractor, 1959 MPC 442.
The unpaid purchase price converted as a loan by an agreement, is loan.—Fateh
Chand vs. Akimuddin, AIR 1943 Cal. 108.
A promissory note taken in satisfaction of the unpaid purchase price, amount to a
loan—Nirode Barani vs. Sisir Kumar, AIR 1942 Cal. 538
Price of goods supplied on credit with stipulation to pay interest is a debt and not
a loan—Surendra Sekhar vs. Lalit Mohan, AIR 1941 Cal. 538.
Rent realizable from tenants by the mortgage in possession is interest as the
mortgage transaction is a loan— Maherunnissa Bibi vs. Satish Chandra, AIR 1944
Cal. 288.
A security Bond taken for the balance of the price of the goods already supplied
and to be supplied in future is not a loan Kunj Behari vs. Satyendranath, AIR 1941
Cal. 689.
A mortgage essentially falls under the definition of loan--Ganpatrao vs. Jagannath
Das, AIR 1940 Nag. 19=1940 NLJ 1940 NLJ 187, Emperor vs, Jhaverlal, AIR 1950
Bom. 119 = 51 Bom. LR 991; Bansilal vs. Harish Chandra, AIR 1953 Bom. 420=55
Bom LR 444.
Where the purchaser of bullocks executes a bond in favour of the seller agreeing
to pay the purchase money within a certain date and its case of its failure to do so to
pay interest the transaction was held to be a loan. Dattatraya vs. Maroti, 1958 NLJ
(Notes) 113.
A deposit of money may under certain conditions amount to loan.— Mohammed
15
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
Akbar vs. Atarsingh, AIR 1936 PC 171: 38 Bom. LR 731; Suleman Haji vs. Haji
Abdulla, AIR 1940 PC 132 : 42 Bom. LR 871.
Lend and Loan—Meaning explained, AIR 1966 SC 495.
5. Suit—Meaning of—The word 'suit' includes pending suits court to dismiss suit if
provisions of secs. 22 & 23 are not complied.
Keeping in view the purpose and object or the reasons and spirit of the Act the
provisions of section 26 (b) of the Act as they stand after the amendment by the
amending Act of 1976 will apply to the pending suits also and if sections 22 and 23
have not been complied with then the court has to dismiss the suit as the word -suit'
as used in amended section 26(b) embraces within it the pending suits—Kanhiiyalal
vs. Shri Lai and others, 1980 WLN 469 = 1980 RLW 301.
Secs. 22, 23 and 26 provisions of secs. 22 & 23 not complied with in respect of
whole claim. Held, amended sec. 26(b) to apply to pending cases.
The intention of the legislature has been clearly and undoubtedly expressed that
the amended section 26(b) is to apply to the pending suits. It is enjoined that the
court shall dismiss the whole suit where it finds that the provision of sections 22 and
23 of the Act have not been complied with by the Money lender in respect of the
whole claim —Ranchordass vs. Malook Chand, 1980 WLN 580,
In a suit to which the Act applies the Court must take account even if the
defendant is absent.—Vithal Krishan vs. Sogmal Nathmal & Co., AIR 1958 Bom. 92:
59 Bom. LR 1048.
3. Appointment of Registrar General, Registrars and Assistant Registrars —
The State Government may, by notification in the official Gazette appoint such
officers, as it thinks proper, to be a Registrar General, Registrars and Assistant
Registrars of money-lenders for the purposes of this Act and may define the areas
within which each such officer shall exercise his powers and perform his duties.
NOTIFICATIONS
1. Notification No. F. 23(2) Rev./D/54, dated 25-8-65.
In exercise of the powers conferred by sec. 3 of the Rajasthan Money lenders Act,
1963 (Rajasthan Act 1 of i964), the State Government hereby appoints the Registrar.
Co-operative Societies to the Registrar General of Money-lenders for the whole of the
State of Rajasthan and appoints Deputy Registrars and Assistant Registrars, Co-
operative Societies, for the areas within their respective jurisdiction to be Deputy
Registrars and Assistant Registrars of Money-lenders respectively, for the purposes
of the said Act.
This notification shall have effect on and from the 1st day of Oct. 1965,
16
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
[Published in Rajasthan Gazette, Part IV-C. Extraordinary, dated 1-9-1955]
2. Notification No. F 23(2) Rev./B/M, dt. January, 1967.
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 3 of the Rajasthan Money Lenders
Act, 1963 (Act I of 1964} the State Government hereby makes the following
amendment to this department (second) notification No. F. 23(2) Rev./D/64, dated the
25th August, 1965, published on page 215 in the Rajasthan Gazette Part 1V-C, dated
the September, 1965, namely: —
AMENDMENTS
In the said notification, after the words "appoints Deputy Registrars‖ a comma
shall be inserted and for the expression and Assistant Registrars, Co-operative
Societies for the areas within their respective jurisdictions to be Deputy Registrars
and Assistant Registrars of Money Lenders respectively for the following expression
shall be substituted, namely:—
"Co-operative Societies to be Registrars of money lenders and further appoints
Assistant Registrars and Additional Assistant Registrars, Co operative Societies, to
be Assistant Registrars of money lenders for the areas within their respective
jurisdictions‖
[Pub. in Raj. Gaz. 4(Ga)-Dt. 15-6=67 Page 208]
…….
3- vf/klwpuk la[;k i- 2(6) jktLo xzqi 4@75] fnukad 20&9&1975-
Tkh-,l-vkj- 15835%& jktLFkku lkgwdkj vf/kfu;e 1963 jktLFkku vf/kfu;e 1 lu~
1964 dh /kkjk 3 }kjk iznr “kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djrs gq, rFkk fufer tkjh fd, x;s
leLr fo|eku vf/klwpukvksa dkvfrdze.k djrs gq, jkT; ljdkj ,rn~}kjk mDRk
vf/kfu;e ds iz;ksukFkZ Jh vkj- eq[kthZ lnL; jktLo eaMy] jktLFkku vtesj dks lEiw.kZ
jktLFkku jkT; ds fy, lkgdkj egkiath;d fu;qDr djrh gSA
rFkk leLr ftyk dyDVjksa vkSj mi[kaM vf/kdkfj;ksa dks viuh vf/kdkfjrk {ks=ksa ds
fy, dze”k% lkgwdkj iath;d vkSj lgk;d iath;d fu;qDr djrh gSA ;g vf/klwpuk
1&10&1975 ls izHkko”khy gksaxsA
[jkt- jkti= Hkkx 4 (x)(1)] fnukad 25&9&1975 i`’B 530 (64)]
……..
4. vf/klwpuk la[;k i- 2(6) jkt@xzqi 4@75] fnukad 5&10&1976-
bl foHkkx dh foKfIr le fnukad 20&9&1975 ds vkaf”kd la”kks/ku esa ,oa jktLFkku
17
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
lkgwdkj vf/kfu;e 1963 jktLFkku vf/kfu;e 1 lu~ 1964 dh /kkjk 3 }kjk iznr
“kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djrs gq, rFkk fufer tkjh fd, x;s leLr fo|eku vf/klwpukvksa
dkvfrdze.k djrs gq, jkT; ljdkj ,rn~}kjk mDRk vf/kfu;e ds iz;ksukFkZ Jh ds-,l-
jLrksxh lnL; jktLo eaMy] jktLFkku vtesj dks lEiw.kZ jktLFkku jkT; ds fy,
lkgwdkj egkiath;d fu;qDr djrh gSA ;g vf/klwpuk rqjUr izHkko ls izHkko”khy gksxhA
5- vf/klwpuk la[;k i- 2(9) jkt@xzqi 4@75] fnukad 26&8&1976-
jktLFkku lkgwdkj vf/kfu;e 1963 jktLFkku vf/kfu;e 1 lu~ 1964 dh /kkjk 3 }kjk
iznr “kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djrs gq, jkT; ljdkj ftyksa ds leLr vij ftyk/kh”kksa dks
mDRk vf/kfu;e ds iz;ksukFkZ dks vius vius vf/kdkfjrk {ks= ds Hkhrj ,rn~}kjk lkgwdkjh
ds jftLVzkj (iath;d) fu;qDr djrh gSA
---------
vf/klwpuk la[;k i- 2(6) jkt@xzqi 4@75@33] fnukad tqykbZ 23]1984-
jktLFkku lkgwdkj vf/kfu;e 1963 jktLFkku vf/kfu;e 1 lu~ 1964 dh /kkjk 3 }kjk
iznr “kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djrs gq, rFkk bl fufer iwoZ esa tkjh dh x;h bl foHkkx dh
lela[;d vf/klwpuk fnukad 14 tqykbZ 1982 dks vfrf’Br djrs gq, jkT; ljdkj
,rn~}kjk mDRk vf/kfu;e ds iz;ksukFkZ Jherh d`’.kk HkVukxj] lnL; jktLo eaMy]
jktLFkku vtesj dks lEiw.kZ jktLFkku jkT; ds fy, lkgwdkj egkiath;d fu;qDr djrh
gSA ;g vf/klwpuk rqjUr izHkko ls izHkko”khy gksxhA
[jkt- jkti= fo”ks’kkad Hkx 1(d)] fnukad 26&7&1984 ds i`’B 37 ij Nik]
4. Register of money-lenders. — Every Assistant Registrar shall maintain for the
area of his jurisdiction a register of money-lenders in such form as may be
prescribed:
Provided that any such register maintained in any area immediately before the
commencement of his Act under the provisions of the enactments repealed by
section 49 shall, in so far as it is not inconsistent with this Act or the rules made
thereunder, be deemed to have been maintained under this A7ct.
5. Money- lenders not to carry on business of money-lending except for area
under licence and except in accordance with term of licence.--Save is provided
in section 49, no money-lender shall after the expiration of six months from the date
on which this Act is brought into forces carry on, or continue to carry on, the business
of money-lending except in accordance with the terms and conditions of such licence.
6. Application by money-lender for grant or renewal of licence. — Every
money-lender shall make an application in the prescribed form for the grant of a
licence to the Assistant Registrar of the area within the limits of which the place,
where he intends to carry on the business of money-lending, or, if he intends to carry
18
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
on such business at more than one place in the area, the principal place of such
business, is situated.
(2) Such application shall contain the following particulars, namely: —
(a) the name in which such money-lender intends to carry on business and the
name of the person proposed to be responsible for the management of the business;
(b) if the application is by or on behalf of —
(i) an individual, the name and address of such individual;
(ii) an undivided Hindu family, the names and addresses of the manager and the
adult coparceners of such family;
(iii) a company, the names and addresses of the directors, manager or principal
officer managing it;
(iv) an un -incorporated body of individuals, the names and address of such
individuals;
(c) the area and the place or principal place of the business of money- lending in
the State;
(d) the name of any other place in the Slate where the business of money-
lending is carried on or intended to be carried on;
(e) whether the person singing the application has himself, or any of the adult
coparceners of an undivided Hindu family or any director manager or principal officer
of the company or any member of the un-incorporated body on behalf of which such
application has been made, as the case may be. has carried on the business of
money-lending in the State in the year ending on the 31st day of March immediately
preceding the date to the application either individually or in partnership or jointly with
any other copartner or any other person and whether in the same or any other name;
(f) the total amount of the capital which such person intends to invest in the
business of money-lending in the years for which the application has been made;
(g) if the places at which the business of money-lending is to be carried on are
more than one, the names of persons who shall be in charge of the management of
the business at each such place;
(h) such other particulars as may be prescribed.
(3) The application shall be in writing and shall be signed, —
(a) (i) if the application is made by an individual, by the individual;
(ii) if the application is made on behalf of an undivided hindu family, by the
manager of such family;
(iii) if the application is made by a company or un-incorporated body, by the
managing director or any other person having control of its principal place
of business in India or of its place of business in the area in which it
intends to carry on the business; or
19
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(b) by an agent authorized in this behalf by a power of attorney by the individual
money- lender himself, or the family or the company or the un- incorporated body, as
the case may be.
(4) The application shall be accompanied by a licence fee at the following rates:
a if the place at which the busi-
ness of money-lending is to be
carried on is not more than
one
Rs 15/-
b if the business of money-
lending is to be carried on at
more than one place within
the limits of the area of the
Registrar.
Rs. 15/- for the licence for the
principal place of business, and Rs.
6/- for the licence for each of the
other places in the area.
Explanation. — For the purposes of this section, "place" means, in relation to the
business of money-lending, the shop or address or place at which the money-lender
carries on his business of money-lending.
(5) The fee payable under this section shall be paid in the manner prescribed and
shall not be refunded, notwithstanding the fact that the grant of the licence is refused
or the application is withdrawn.
(6) An application for the renewal of a licence previously granted under this Act
shall be made within two months before the expiration of the term thereof to the
Assistant Registrar referred to in sub-section (1) in the prescribed form and
containing the prescribed particulars:
Provided that where an application is made after the expiry of the period specified
in this sub-section, it shall be accompanied by a licence fee at double the rates
prescribed therefor.
(7) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, the provisions thereof shall, as far as
may be, apply to the renewal of licenses and to renewed licence in the same manner
as they apply respectively to the grant of licence granted originally.
(8) Where a licence granted to a money-lender is lost, destroyed or torn or
otherwise defaced in such manner as to reader it illegible, the money-lender may
obtain a duplicate licence in the prescribed manner on payment of such fee as may
be prescribed.
COMMENTARY
Scope of sections 6 & 7 of the act, effect of—According to section 6 of the Money
Lenders Act, the persons doing the 'business of money lending* are bound to obtain
20
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
licenses within the stipulated period before actually carrying on the money lending
business. Time factor is an important element for applying for the licence.
Section 7 of the Act envisage issue of licenses prospectively and not with
retrospective effect. Old sections 11 & 12 of the Act enabling issue of licenses
retrospectively stand amended and thus omitted to have retrospective effect
thereafter on and from the application of Rajas than Amendment Act No. of 1976
Since Amending Act No. 13 of 1976 prohibits issue of licence with retrospective
effect, licenses shall have prospective effect, hence forth. Thus contravention of
section 5 of this Act cannot be condoned --Naravan vs. State of Raj., 1979 RRD 124.
7. Inquiry into and disposal of application.—(U (a) On the receipt an
application under section 6 and after making a summary inquiry in 'accordance with
the prescribed procedure, the Assistant Registrar shall forward the application,
together with his report, to the Registrar. The Registrar may, after making such
further inquiry, if any, as he deems fit grant a licence in such form and subject to such
conditions as may be prescribed and direct the Assistant Registrar to enter the name
of such applicant in the- : register maintained by him under section 4.
(b) If the application is in respect of more than one place of business in the area
under the jurisdiction of the Registrar, a separate licence in respect of each such
place shall be granted in the name of the applicant and the person responsible for the
management of the business at such place.
(2) If the application also contains a request for the grant of a licence to carry on
the business of money-leading at any place within the State outside the jurisdiction of
the Registrar who granted the licence in respect of the principal place of business of
the money-lender, the Registrar shall forward copies of the application and of the
licence granted to the Registrar having jurisdiction, who may grant a licence on
payment of the licence fee provided for in section 6 without making any inquiry in
respect of the application.
8. Grounds for refusal of licence.—(1) The grant of a licence shall not be
refused except on any of the following grounds:—
(a) that the applicant, or any person responsible or proposed to be responsible for
the management of his business as a money-lender, is disqualified from holding a
licence;
(b) that the applicant has not complied with the provisions of this Act or the rules
in respect of an application for the; grant of a licence;
(c) that the applicant has made willful default in complying with or knowingly
acted in contravention of, any requirement of this Act;
(d) that satisfactory evidence has been produced that the applicant
21
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
or any person responsible or proposed to be responsible for the management of
business of money-lending has—
(i) Knowingly participated in or connived at any fraud or dishonesty in the conduct
of or in connection with the business of money-lending, or
(ii) has been convicted of an offence specified in the Schedule to the Act and
sentenced to imprisonment for any term with or without any fine:
Provided that the State Government may at any time on an application in the
prescribed form accompanied by the prescribed fee remove a disqualification under
clause (d) (ii) of this subjection having regard to the time which has elapsed since the
order and the circumstances under which it was made or to the time that has elapsed
since the conviction and to the nature of the offence.
(2) The Registrar shall, before refusing a licence under sub-section (I), give to the
applicant a reasonable opportunity of producing evidence, if any, in support of the
application and of showing cause why the licence should net be refused, and record
the evidence adduced before him and his reasons for such refusal.
(3) An appeal shall lie from an order of the Registrar refusing a licence under sub-
section (1) to the Registrar General and may be preferred within sixty days from the
date on which the order is communicated to the applicant.
(4) The decision of the Registrar General on such appeal shall be final.
9. Registrar's power to cancel licence. — (I) The Registrar may, during the
term of any licence, cancel the same by an order in writing on the ground that the
person to whom it was granted has been guilty of any act or conduct for which he
might, under section 8, have refused him the grant of the licence and which act or
conduct was not brought to his notice at the time of the grant.
(2) Before cancelling a licence under subsection (1), the Registrar shall give
notice in writing to the licensee and may hold such inquiry as may be necessary.
(3) An appeal shall lie from an order of the Registrar cancelling a licence under
sub-section (1) to the Registrar General and may be preferred Within sixty days from
the date on which the order is communicated to the licensee.
(4) The decision of the Registrar General on such appeal shall be final.
10. Term of licence.—A licence shall be valid for a period of three years from the
date of its issue:
Provided that when an application for renewal of a licence has been received by
an Assistant Registrar within the prescribed period, the licence shall, until the
application is finally disposed of, be deemed to be valid.
22
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
2[11. Dismissal of suit by money-lender not holding licence.—
(I) Where a suit to which this Act applies is filed by a money-lender and the court
in which it is filed is satisfied that at the time when the loan or any part thereof to
which the suit relates was advanced, the money-lender did not hold a valid licence, it
shall dismiss the suit forthwith without going into the merits of the claim and shall
order the refund of the security, if any, without repayment of the loan.
(2) Nothing in this section shall affect—
(a) suits pending in any court on the date of the commencement of the Rajasthan
Money-lenders (Amendment) Ordinance, 1975, which may be disposed of according
to the law existing immediately before such commencement;
(b) suits in respect of loans advanced by a money-lender before the date on
which this Act came into force; and
(c) the powers of the Court of Wards or an Official Assignee or a receiver or an
administrator or a court under the law relating to insolvency for the time being in
force or a liquidator under the Companies Act, 1956 (Central Act 1 of 1956) to
release the properly of a money-lender.)
NOTES
Sections 11 and 26(b) as amended by the Amending Act No. 13 of 1976 have
retrospective effect. Sections 11 and 26 of the Act were amended in 1976 by the
Amending Act No. 13 of 1976. In section 11 the Legislature expressly provided an
exception of its application to pending cases, but no such exception was carved out in
Section 26(b) when the legislature acts at a particular point of time in legislating two
provisions in the same Act and in one retrospective effect is avoided by making an
exception and in the other drastic consequences are contemplated by not enacting
such an explanation or exception, this court, while interpreting the law has got no
option but to respect the wishes of the legislature though seemingly it may create
hardship to those money-lenders who have already filed their suits and were not
aware of the drastic consequences of non compliance of the section of the Act, Such
an intention of the legislature cannot be changed unless it lapses any legislative
authority or become violative of any of the provision is of the constitution. None of the
two contingencies contemplated have been shown to exist, as there is no challenge
to planery authority nor there is any violation of the constitutional provision. General
Principal of interpretation of the statute is that the statute should be treated
prospective and not retrospective, more so, when the provisions are penal in nature.
However, it all depends upon the scheme of the Act, intention to enact a particular
statute and merely on the basis of generalization when expressly by providing contra
2
Substituted by section 2 of Rajasthan Act No. 13 of 1976, published in the Rajasthan Gazette, Part IV-A,
Extraordinary, dated 13-2-1976, page181 to 185,
23
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
language in Section II in contract to section 26(b), the Legislature expresses its
intention, this court cannot enter to the contrary (Para 5 and 6) —Ramchandra vs.
Prabhulal, 1982 Raj LR.275.
12. 3(Omitted).
13. Application for Cancellation of licence.—(i) Any person may, during the
currency of a licence, file an application to the Register for the cancellation of the
licence issued to a money-lender on the ground that such money-lender has been
guilty of any act or conduct for which the Registry may, under section 8. refuse to
grant a licence.
(2) Along with in such application the said person shall deposit such amount not
exceeding one hundred rupees as the Registrar may deem fit.
(3) On the receipt of such application and deposit or of a report to that effect from
an officer acting under section 16, the Registrar shall hold an inquiry i:i the prescribed
manner and, if he is satisfied that the money-lender has been guilty of such act or
conduct, he may cancel the licence of the money-lender and may also direct the
return of the deposit made under sub-section (2).
(4) If in the opinion of the Registrar an application made under sub-section (1) is
frivolous or vexatious, he may, out of the deposit made under sub-section (2), direct
to be paid to the money-lender such amount as he deems fit as compensation.
(5) Any person aggrieved by an order of the Registrar under sub-section (3) or
sub section (4), may within sixty days from the date on which the order is
communicated to him and on payment of such fee as may be prescribed appeal to
the Registrar General and the order of the Registrar General on such appeal shall be
final.
14. Application of section 5 of Central Act IX of 1908 to certain appeals.—
The provisions of section 5 of the Indian Limitation Act, 1908 (Central Act IX of 1908)
shall apply to all appeals made under sections 8, 9 and 13 and for the purpose of the
said section of the said Act, the Registrar General shall be deemed to be a court.
15. Registrar, Assistant Registrar and authorized officer to have powers of
civil courts - For the purposes of sections 7, 13 and 16, the Registrar. Assistant
Registrar and, as the case may be the officer authorized under section 16 shall have
and may exercise the same powers as are vested in a civil court under the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (Central Act V of 1908), in respect of the following matters:—
(a) enforcing the attendance of any person and examining him on oath;
3
Omitted by section 3 of the Rajasthan Amending Act No. 13 of 1976 Pub. in-Raj. Gaz., Extraordinary, Part 1V, dated
l3-2-1976. Paces 18 to 185,
24
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(b) compelling the production of documents and material objects;
(c) issuing commissions for the examination of witnesses; and
(d) proof of facts by affidavits
16 Power of authorized officer to require production of record or documents
—(1) For the purpose of verifying whether the business of money-lending is carried
on in accordance with the provisions of this Act, any Registrar, Assistant Registrar or
any other officer authorized by the State Government in this behalf in may require -
any money-lender or any person in respect of whom the Registrar, Assistant
Registrar or the officer so authorized has reason to believe that he is carrying on the
business of money lending in the State to produce any record or document in his
possession which, in his opinion, is relevant for the purpose and thereupon such
money-lender or person shall produce such record or document.
(2) The Registrar, Assistant Registrar or officer so authorized may, after
reasonable notice, at reasonable time enter any premises where he believes such
record or document to be and may ask any question necessary for interpreting or
verifying such record or document.
17. Court's power to cancel or suspend a licence.—(1) A court passing an
order of conviction against a money-lender for an offence under this Act, or a court
trying a suit to which this Act applies, if satisfied that such money lender has
committed such contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder as would, in its opinion, make him unfit to carry on the business of money-
lending may:—
(a) if it is a competent court, pass an order under sub-section (3); or
(b) if it is not a competent court, record is opinion and forward the proceedings to
a competent court having jurisdiction in the place where such court is held.
(2) A competent court to which the proceedings are submitted under clause (b) of
sub-section (1) may, if it thinks fit, examine the parties and recall and examine any
person who has already given evidence in the proceedings and may call for and take
any further evidence and pass such order in the case as it thinks fit in accordance
with the provisions of sub section (3).
(3) A competent court referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1) or to which
proceedings are submitted under sub-section (2),—
(a) may order that all the licenses held by any money-lender in the State, referred
to in sub-section (l), be cancelled or suspended for such time as it thinks fit,
(b) may if it thinks fit, declare any & such money-lender, or if such money-lender
is an undivided Hindu family, a company or an un-incorporated body, such family,
25
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
company, or body and also any person responsible for the management of the
business of money lending carried on by such family, company or body, be
disqualified from holding any licence in the State for such time as the court may think
fit:
Provided that no order or declaration shall be made under this subsection unless
a reasonable opportunity has been given to the person concerned to show cause
against the order or declaration proposed to be made.
(4) Any person aggrieved by the decision of a competent court under sub
section (3) may, within ninety days of the passing of the order, appeal against such
order to toe High Court; and the competent court which passed the order or the High
Court in appeal may, if it thinks fit, stay the operation of the order under this section
pending the disposal of the appeal.
(5) Where a court convicts a money-lender of an offence under this Act, or makes
an order or declaration under clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (3), it shall cause
the particulars of the conviction, order or declaration, as the case may be, to be
endorsed on all the licenses held by the money-lender convicted or any other person
affected by the order or the declaration and shall cause copies of the order or the
declaration to be sent to the Registrar by whom the licenses were granted for the
purpose of entering such particulars in the registers.
(6) Any licence required by a court for endorsement in accordance with sub-
section (5) shall be produced by the person by whom it is held in such manner and
within such time as may be directed by the court, and any person who, without
reasonable cause, makes default in producing the licence as required shall be liable,
on conviction, to a fine not exceeding five hundred rupees for each day of the period
during which the default continues.
(7) The powers conferred on a court under sub-section (3) and sub-section (5)
may be also exercised by any court in appeal.
(8) For the purposes of this section, a ''competent court means a court of the
District Judge or in any area, .such court subordinate to the High Court as the State
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, designate in this behalf.
18. No compensation for suspension or cancellation of licence. — Where
any licence is suspended or cancelled under this Act, no person shall be entitled to
any compensation or the refund of any licence fee.
19. Persons debarred from doing business during period of suspension or
cancellation of licence.—A person whose licence has been suspended or cancelled
in accordance with the provisions of this Act shall, during the period of suspension or
cancellation, as the case may be, be disqualified from holding any licence ii) the State
26
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
20 Person whose licence is suspended or canceled not to apply without
giving particulars of endorsement or disqualification.—No person whose licence
has been endorsed under section 17 or who has been disqualified from holding a
licence, shall apply for, or be eligible to hold, a licence without particulars of such
endorsement or disqualification.
21. Transfer of licence to heir.—
(1) Where a licensee under this Act dies, any person claiming to be his legal
representative may apply to the licensing authority for transferring in his name the
licence standing in the name of deceased.
(2) Every such application shall be in such form and shall contain such particulars
as may be prescribed.
(3) The licensing authority may, if it is satisfied that the applicant is in fact the
legal representative of the deceased and that he is otherwise eligible to obtain a
licence under this Act, transfer the licence in the name of the applicant after obtaining
from him a declaration in the prescribed form.
Any licence transferred under sub-section (3) shall be deemed to have been
granted to the applicant himself and shall be valid for the period for which it would
have been valid if the licence had not been transferred find the provisions of this Act
shall apply accordingly.
22. Duty of money-lenders to keep accounts and furnish copies.—
(1) Every money-lender shall keep and maintain a cash book, a ledger and a
receipt book in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed.
(2) Every money-lender shall,—
(a) Deliver or cause to be delivered in the prescribed manner—
(i) to the debtor within three months from the date on which a loan is made, a
statement in the prescribed form and in any recognized language showing in clear
and distinct terms the amount and date of the loan and of its maturity, the nature of
the security, if any, for the loan, the name and address of the debtor and of the
money-lender and the rate of interest thereon and such other particulars as may be
prescribed
Provided that no such statement shall be required to be delivered to a debtor if he
is supplied by the money-lender with a pass-book which shall be in the prescribed
form and shall contain an up-to-date account of the transactions with the debtor;
(ii) To the Assistant Registrar within the said period, a statement containing the
particulars referred to in sub-clause (i);
27
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(b) upon repayment of a loan in full, mark indelibly every paper signed by the
debtor with words indicating payment of cancellation, and discharge every mortgage,
restore every pledge, return every note and cancel or re-assign every assignment
given by the debtor as security for the loan.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of sub
section (2), the State Government may, by order in writing, permit such class of
money-lenders as may be specified in the order to deliver or cause to be delivered to
the Assistant Registrar a statement containing the particulars referred to in sub
clause (i) of sub-section (2) in respect of all loans, made during every such period as
may be specified in the order; and upon the issue of such order a money-lender
electing to deliver a periodical statement as provided in this sub section shall deliver
or cause to be delivered the same within a period of thirty days from the date of
expiry of the aforesaid period.
(4) No money lender shall receive any payment from a debtor on account of any
loan without giving him a clear anti complete receipt in the prescribed form for the
payment and shall take the signatures of the debtor on the counterfoil of the receipt
maintained for the purpose.
(5) No money-lender shall accept from a debtor any article as a pawn, pledge or
security for a loan without giving him a plain signed receipt for the same with its
(description, estimated value, the amount of the loan advanced against it and other
particulars as may be prescribed. Such money-lenders shall maintain the duplicates
of such receipts in a separate register.
COMMENTARY
Money advanced and documents, executed in 1967—Statement of accounts, not
sent to debtor. Fresh documents executed in 1973 without showing interest and
adjustments of money, repaid-Held, Sec. 22 & 23 not complied with.
In the first appellate court certain documents were sought to be produced under
Order 41, R. 27, C.P.C. and the court having considered the implications of these
documents held that these documents cannot save the plaintiff from the drastic
consequences of dismissal to suit in as much as they relate to the year 1974 and
1976. It was then held that in the documents of 1975 and 1976, the rates af interest
have not been shown nor any payments have been adjusted and it has not been
shown for showing compliance of section 22 and 23 to the Act that any statement of
accounts was sent to the latter. On these findings, the first appellate court after
examining the document submitted by the plaintiff has held that sections 22 and 23
have not been complied with. Held, finding about non-compliance of sections 22 & 23
of the Act does not call for any interference (para 9).— Ramchandra vs. Prabhulal,
1982 Raj L.R 275
28
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
23. Delivery of statement of accounts and copies thereof by moneylender.—
(i) Every money-lender shall deliver or cause to be delivered every year to each of
this debtors a legible statement of .such debtor's account signed by the money-lender
or his agent of amount that may be outstanding against such debtor. The statement
shall show —
(i) she amount of principal, the amount of interest and the amount of fees referred
to in section 24, separately, due to the money-lender at the beginning of the year;
(ii) the total amount of loans advanced during the year;
(iii) the total amount of repayments received during the year; and
(iv) the amounts of principal and interest due at the end of the year.
The statement shall be signed by the money-lender, or his agent, and shall be in
any recognized language. It shall be in such form and shall be supplied to the debtor
on or before such date as may be prescribed.
The money-lender shall, on or before the aforesaid date, deliver or cause to be
delivered a copy of each statement to the Assistant Registrar.
(2) In respect of any particular loan, whether advanced before or after the date on
which this Act comes into force, the money lender shall on demand in writing being
made by the debtor at any time during the period when the loan or any part thereof
has not been repaid and on payment of the prescribed fee supply to the debtor, or if
the debtor so requires to any person specified in that behalf in the demand, a
statement, in any recognized language, signed by the money-lender or his agent, and
containing the relevant particulars specified in sub-section (I).
(3) A money-lender shall, on a demand in writing by the debtor and on tender of
the prescribed sum of expenses, supply a copy of any document relating to a loan
made by him or any security therefor to the debtor, or if the debtor so requires to
any person specified in that behalf in the demand.
(4) For the purpose of this section, "year" means the year for which the accounts
of the money-lender arc ordinarily maintained in his own books.
24. Fees for certain statements supplied to debtor and Assistant Registrars-
-(I) A money-lender may recover from a debtor fees for the statements supplied
under sub-section (2) or sub-section (3) of section 22 or sub-section (1) of section 23
to the debtor and to the Assistant Registrar.
(2) Such fees shall be recoverable at such rates and in such manner as
prescribed, subject to the maximum of two rupees per debtor, year, irrespective of the
number of statements supplied to the debtor or to the Assistant Registrar during the
relevant year.
25. Debtor not bound to admit correctness of accounts—A debtor to whom a
29
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
statement of accounts of a pass book has been furnished under section 22 shall not
be bound to acknowledge or deny its correctness and bis failure to do so shall not, by
itself, be deemed to be an admission of the correctness of the accounts.
26. Procedure of court in suits regarding loans.—Notwithstanding anything
contained in any law for the time being in force, in any suit to which this Act
applies—
(a) a court shall, before deciding the claim on merits, frame and decide the issue
whether the money-lender has complied with the provisions of section 22 and section
23;
4[(b) if the court finds that the provisions of section 22 and section 23 have not
been complied with by the money-lender in respect of the whole or any part of the
claim, it shall dismiss —
(i) the whole suit with costs where such contravention has been in respect of the
entire claim in the suit; or
(ii) so much of the claim costs proportionate thereto in respect of which the said
provisions have not been complied with by the moneylender.]
Explanation.—A money-lender who has given the receipt or furnished a statement
of accounts or a pass book in the prescribed form and manner, shall be held to have
complied with the provisions of section 22 or section 23, as the case may be, in spite
of any errors and omissions, if the court finds that such errors and omissions, are not
material or not made fraudulently.
(a) Interpretation of statute—General principles discussed. Raj. Money Lenders
Act, 1963 Ss. 11 & 26(b) as amended in 1976—Held, amended provisions have
retrospective effect.
Sec. 1 and 26 were amended in 1976. In section 1, the Legislature expressly
provided an exception of its application to pending cases, but no such exception was
carved out in Section 26 (b) when the legislature acts at a particular point of time in
legislating two provisions in the same Act and in one retrospective effect is avoided
by making an exception and in the other drastic consequences are contemplated by
not enacting such an explanation or exception, this court, while interpreting the law
has got no option but to respect the wishes of legislature though seemingly it may
create hardship to those money lenders who have already filed their suits and were
not aware of the drastic 'consequences of non-compliance of the section of the Act.
Such an intention of the legislature cannot be changed unless it lapse any legislative
authority or become violative of any of the provisions of the constitution. None of the
two contingencies contemplated have been shown to exist, as there is no challenge
4
Whole of sub-section (b) of section 26 was substituted by section 4 of the Rajasthan Money Lenders Amendment
Act, 1976 (Raj. Act No. 13 of 1976) Pub. in Raj. Gaz., Extra-ordinary, Part 1V-A, dated 13-2-1976 at pages 181 to
185.
30
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
to planery authority nor there is any violation of the constitutional provisions, General
principal of interpretation of the statute is that the statute should be treated pros-
pective and not retrospective, more so, when the provisions are penal in nature.
However, it all depends upon the scheme of the Act, intention to enact a particular
statute and merely on the basis of generalization when expressly by providing contra
language in Section 11 in contrast to section 26 (b), the Legislature expresses its
intention, this court cannot infer to the contrary (Para 5 & 6)—Ramchandra vs.
Prabhulal, 1982 Raj. LR 275.
The word 'suit‘ includes pending suits—Court to dismiss suit if provisions of
section 22 & 23 are not complied with.
Keeping in view the purpose and object or the reasons and spirit of the Act the
provisions of sec. 26(b) of the Act as they stand after the amendment by the
amending Act of 1976 will apply to the pending suits also and if sections 22 and 23
have not been complied with then the court has to dismiss the suit as the 'word' suit
as used in amended sec. 26 (b) embraces within it the pending suits—Kanhaiyalal vs.
Shri Lai and others, 1980 WLN 469—1980 RLW 301.
Sees. 22. 23 and 26—-Provisions of secs. 22 & 23 not complied with in respect of
whole claim—Held, amended sec. 26 (b) to apply to pending cases.
The intention of the legislature has been clearly and undoubtedly expressed that
the amended section 26 (b) is to apply to the pending suits. It is enjoined that the
court shall dismiss the whole suit where it finds that the provision of sections 22 and
23 of the Act have not been complied with by the money-lender in respect of the
whole claim—Ranchcrdass v. Malook Chand. 1980-WLN 580.
5[27. Maximum amount of interest recoverable on loans and discharge of
loans in certain cases.—(1) No money-lender shall recover towards the interest in
respect of any loan advanced by him, an amount in excess of the amount of principal.
(2) Any loan in respect of which the money-lender has realised from the debtor an
amount equal to or more than twice the amount of the principal, shall stand
discharged and the amount, if any, so realised in excess of twice the amount of the
loan shall be refunded by the money-lender to the debtor :
Provided that no refund shall be made if such excess amount had been realised
prior to three years from the date of commencement of the Rajasthan Money-lenders
(Amendment) Act, 1976.]
5
Substituted by section 5 of Rajasthan Act No. 13 of 1976, published in the Rajasthan Gazette, Part IV-A
Extraordinary, dated 13-2-1976. Page 131 to 185
31
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
COMMENTARY
Conflict between sections 27 & 33 of the Act—There is no conflict or in
consistency between the provisions of sections 27 and 33 of the Act.— Basti Ram vs.
Ghewarchand, 1979 WLN 51=1979 RLW 50=AIR 1979 Raj, 1-48.
Retrospective effect.—Section 27 of the Act should he given retrospective effect
AIR 1953 Bom. 420; (1982) 9 Q.B.D. 672; AlR 936 Bom. 37 AIR 1949 Ori. 37, relied
on) AIR 1936 Cal. 334, AIR 1938 Nag. 112, 1968 RLW 33; SB Civil Revision No. 270
of 1969, decided by the Rajasthan of interpretation of the statute is that the statute
should be treated prospective and not retrospective, more so, when the provisions
are penal in nature. However, it all depends upon the scheme of the Act, intention to
enact a particular statute and merely on the basis of generalisation when expressly
by providing contra language in Section 11 in contrast to section 26 (b), the
Legislature expresses its intention, this court cannot infer to the contrary (Para 5 &
6)—Ramchandra vs. Prabhulal, 1982 Raj. LR 275.
The word 'suit‘ includes pending suits—Court to dismiss suit if provisions of
section 22 & 23 are not complied with.
Keeping in view the purpose and object or the reasons and spirit of the Act the
provisions of sec. 26(b) of the Act as they stand after the amendment by the
amending Act of 1976 will apply to the pending suits also and if sections 22 and 23
have not been complied with then the court has to dismiss the suit as the 'word' suit
as used in amended sec. 26 (b) embraces within it the pending suits—Kanhaiyalal vs.
Shri Lai and others, 1980 WLN 469—1980 RLW 301.
Sec‘s. 22. 23 and 26—-Provisions of secs. 22 & 23 not complied with in respect of
whole claim—Held, amended sec. 26 (b) to apply to pending cases.
The intention of the legislature has been clearly and undoubtedly expressed that
the amended section 26 (b) is to apply to the pending suits. It is enjoined that the
court shall dismiss the whole suit where it finds that the provision of sections 22 and
23 of the Act have not been complied with by the money-lender in respect of the
whole claim—Ranchcrdass v. Malook Chand. 1980-WLN 580.
6[27. Maximum amount of interest recoverable on loans and discharge of
loans in certain cases.—(1) No money-lender shall recover towards the interest in
respect of any loan advanced by him, an amount in excess of the amount of principal.
(2) Any loan in respect of which the money-lender has realized from the debtor an
6
Substituted by section 5 of Rajasthan Act No. 13 of 1976, published in the Rajasthan Gazette, Part IV-A
Extraordinary, dated 13-2-1976. Page 131 to 185
32
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
amount equal to or more than twice the amount of the principal, shall stand
discharged and the amount, if any, so realized in excess of twice the amount of the
loan shall be refunded by the money-lender to the debtor :
Provided that no refund shall be made if such excess amount had been realized
prior to three years from the date of commencement of the Rajasthan Money-lenders
(Amendment) Act, 1976.]
COMMENTARY
Conflict between sections 27 & 33 of the Act—There is no conflict or in
consistency between the provisions of sections 27 and 33 of the Act.— Basti Ram vs.
Ghewarchand, 1979 WLN 51=1979 RLW 50=AIR 1979 Raj, 1-48.
Retrospective effect.—Section 27 of the Act should he given retrospective effect
AIR 1953 Bom. 420; (1982) 9 Q.B.D. 672; AlR 936 Bom. 37 AIR 1949 Ori. 37, relied
on) AIR 1936 CaL 334, AIR 1938 Nag. 112, 1968 RLW 33; SB Civil Revision No. 270
of 1969, decided by the Rajasthan High Court on October 29, 1969 unreported, Man
Mohan vs Ram Gopal, explained and distinguished. – Durgadas vs. Kanhiyalal and
others, ILR (1971) 21 Raj. 1127=1971 RLW 50=1970 WLN 563.
S.27- Suit decided before promulgation of Act- Appeal pending when Act
promulgated Law can be applied by Appellate Court.
The Appellate court is entitled to apply the law as in force at the decision by the
Appellate Court (AIR 1938 Nag. 112, Explained and distinguished AIR 1941 FC 5 and
AIR 1963 SC 358 relied on).
Held, the appellant is entitled to invoke section 27 of the Act in this appeal.
In this case the Act was promulgated after the decision of the suit and during the
pendency of this appeal and a question arose whether the appellant could invoke
section 27 of the Act in the appeal —Durgadas vs. Kanhiyalal and others, 1LR
(1971)21 Raj. 1127=1971 RLW 50=1970 WLN 563.
S. 27 of the Act promulgated after decision of suit but during pendency of appeal
the date of application is date of decree of trial Court
The relevant date with reference to which the principals of section 27 of the Act
should be applied, should be the date of the trial court's decree (AIR 1969 SO 671,
relied on) Durgudas vs. Kanhiyalal and others ILR (1971) 21 Raj. 1127=1971 RLW
50=1970 WLN 563.
28 Power of court to direct payment of decretal amount by installments.—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (Central Act
V of 1908), the court may, at any time, on the application of a judgment debtor, after
notice to the decree-holder, direct that the amount of any decree passed against him,
33
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
whether before or after the date on which this Act comes into force, in respect of a
loan shall be paid in such number of installments and subject to such conditions, and
payable on such dates, as, having regard to the circumstances of the judgment
debtor and the amount of the decree, it considers lit:
Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply to a decree passed
under Order 34 of the First Schedule to the said Code.
29, Limitation on rates of interest. —(1) The State Government may, from time
to time, by notification in the Official Gazette, fix the maximum rates of simple interest
for any class of business of money-lending in respect of secured and unsecured loan.
(2) No money-lender shall charge or receive from a debtor interest at a rate
exceeding the maximum rate fixed by the State Government under sub section (1).
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force, no
agreement between a money-lender and a debtor for payment of interest at rates
exceeding the maximum rates fixed by the State Government under sub-section (I)
shall be valid and no court shall, in any suit to which this Act applies, award interest
exceeding the said rates.
(4) If any money-lender charges or receives from a debtor, interest at the rate
exceeding the maximum rates fixed by the State Government under sub-section (i),
he shall for the purpose of section 40. be deemed to have cont- ravened the
provisions of this Act.
NOTIFICATIONS
Notification No. F. 23 (2) Revenue/D/54.
In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section I of section 29 of the
Rajasthan Money-Lenders Act, 1963 (Rajasthan Act 1 of 1964), the State
Government hereby fixes the maximum rate of simple interest for any class if
business of money-lending in respect of secured and unsecured loans to be NINE
percent and TWELVE percent (per annum) respectively.
[Pub. in Raj. Gaz , Part IV-C, dated 1-10-1965].
………
vf/klwpuk la[;k i- 5(8) jkt@xzqi 4@75] fnukad 19&2&1975-
,l- vks- 233%&jktLFkku lkgwdkj vf/kfu;e 1963 jktLFkku vf/kfu;e 1 lu~ 1964
dh /kkjk 29 dh mi /kkjk (1) }kjk iznr “kfDr;ksa ds iz;ksx esa rFkk jktLo foHkkx dh
vf/klwpuk la[;k ,Q- 23(2) jktLo Mh 54 fnukad 1&10&1965 esa izdkf”kr gq, gSa dk
vfrdze.k djrs gq, jkT; ljdkj ,rn~}kjk lkgwdkjh ds dkjkckj ds fdlh oxZ ds fy,
izfrHkwfr ;k izfrHkwfr jfgr m/kkjksa ds laca/k esa lk/kj.k C;kt dh vf/kdre njsa
34
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
dze”k%X;kjg (11%) rFkk pkSng (14%) fuf”pr djrh gSA
[jkt- jkti= Hkkx 4(x)] fnukad 20&2&1975 ds i`’B 233]
COMMENTARY
Section 29(2)(3).—Section has no application to transaction entered into before
the Act—Interpretation of statutes—Retrospective operation.
It is a fundamental rule of interpretation of statutes that no statute shall be
construed to have a retrospective operation unless such a construction appears very
clearly in the terms of the Act or arises by necessary and distinct implication. A
statute is not to be construed to have a greater retrospective operation than its
language renders necessary.
The question arose whether the rates of interest fixed by the Slate Government
under section 29 would be applicable even to those transactions which had been
entered into prior to the coming into force of the Act. It was observed that there is
nothing in Section 29 to show that the legislature intended that the maximum fixed by
the State Government under Sub-sec. (1) of section 29 shall also apply to those
transactions which had been entered into prior to the coming into force of the Act.
It was held that section 29 has not been made retrospective and does not apply to
transactions entered into before the Act.
It was held that s. 29 has not been made retrospective and does not apply to
transactions entered into before the Act came into force (AIR 1953 Bom. 125 relied
on)—Nanuram vs. Vishwamitra, ILR (1968) 18 Raj. 534= 1968RLW358.
Excessive interest—What is.—The term *excess interest* is a relative term and
whether a particular rate of interest is excessive or not is to be determined with
reference to the current law (such as Raj M.L Act, 1963) prevalent at the time for
such determination.—Balchand Mahta vs Munshi Lal Raut, AIR 1955 Patna 494
The rate of interest may not be excess according to the prevailing custom or in
respect to the Indian Interest Act or the Usurious Loans Act, it will be excess if it
exceeds the rate so notified in the gazette.
The scale of determination is quite simple. The notification as to of interest is final
scale to declare an excess rate of interest for the purpose of this Act.
30. Prohibition of charge for expenses on loans by money -lenders. —
No money-lender shall receive from a debtor or intending debtor any sum other
than reasonable costs of investigating title to the property, costs of stamp, registration
of documents and other usual out-of-pocket expenses in cases where an agreement
35
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
between the parties includes a stipulation that property is to be given as security or
by way of mortgage and where both parties have agreed to such costs and
reimbursement thereof, or where such costs, charges or expenses are leviable under
the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Central Act IV of 1882) or any
other law for the time being in force.
31. Notice and information to be given on assignment of loans. —
(1) Where a loan advanced, whether before or after the date on which this Act
comes into force, or any interest on such loan or the benefit of any agreement made
or security taken in respect of such loan or interest is assigned to any assignee, the
assignor (whether he is the money-lender by whom the money was lent or any
person to whom the debt has been previously assigned) shall, before the assignment
is made —
(a) give the assignee notice in writing that the loan, interest, agreement or
security is affected by the operation of this Act,
(b) supply to the assignee all information necessary to enable him
to comply with the provisions of this Act, and
(c) give the debtor notice in writing of the assignment supplying the name and
address of the assignee,
(2) Any person acting in contravention of the provisions of subsection (1) shall be
liable to indemnify any other person who is prejudiced by the contravention.
32 Application of Act as respects assignees.—
(1) Save as hereinafter provided, where any debt due to a money-lender in
respect of money lent by him, whether before or after the date on which this Act
comes into force or of interest on money so lent, or of the benefit of any agreement
made or security taken in respect of any such debt or interest, has been assigned,
the assignee shall be deemed to be the money-lender and all the provisions of this
Act shall apply to such assignee as if he were the money-lender.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any other law for the time
being in force, where for any reason any such assignment is invalid and the debtor
has made any payment of money or transfer of property on account of any loan which
has been so assigned, the assignee shall in respect of each payment or transfer be
deemed to be the agent of the money lender for all the purposes of This Act.
33. Reopening of transactions or accounts already taken — Notwithstanding
anything contained in any law for the time being in force, the court shall, in any suit to
which this Act applies, whether heard ex party or otherwise.
(a) re-open any transaction or any account already taken between; the parties;
(b) taken account between the parties;
36
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(c) reduce the amount charged to the debtor in respect of any excessive interest;
(d) if on faking accounts it is found that the money-lender has received more than
what is due him, pass a decree in favour of the debtor in respect of such amount:
Provided that, in the exercise of these powers, the court shall not—
(i) re-open any adjustment or agreement purporting to close previous dealings
and to create new obligations which have been entered into by the parties or any
person through whom they claim at a date more than six years from the date of the
suit;
(ii) do anything which affects any decree of a court.
Explanation - For the purpose of this section excessive interest means interest at
a rate which contravenes any of the provisions of section 29.
COMMENTARY
Comparison between sections 27 & 33 of the Act. — No inconsistency between
Sections 27 and 33. For determining quantum of interest transaction can be
reopened Principal being Rs 1689/- all and interest of Rs.1500/ already paid-Held,
plaintiff can claim Rs. 189.11 towards interest.
Section 2(11) and for determining the quantum of in interest, the transaction
between the debtor and the creditor can be ripped up and reopened and to me there
does not appear to be any conflict or inconsistency between the provisions of
sections 27 and 33 of the Rajasthan Act.
The principal of the loan is Rs. 1689/-. The Plaintiffs can only claim a sum of
Rsl80.1l/- by way of interest and beyond that the defendant is not liable to pay
interest. The total liability with regard to interest can be to the extent of the amount of
Rs. 1689.11/- and a sum of Rs. 1500/- has already been paid by the defendant to be
appropriated as interest. Thus the plaintiffs are only entitled to a decree of Rs.
1879.6/- Basti Ram v. Ghewarchand 1979 WLN 51= 1979 RLW 20=AIR 1979 Raj.
148.
37
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
34. Application to court by debtor for taking account.-- (1) Any debtor may
make an application at any time to the court, whether the loan has or has not become
payable, for taking accounts and for declaring the amount due to the money-lender.
(2) Such application shall be in the prescribed form and accompanied by the
prescribed fee.
(3) On receipt of such application, the court cause a notice shall of the
application to be given to the money-lender.
(4) On the date fixed for the hearing of the application or on such dale to which
the hearing may be adjourned from time to time, the court shall make an inquiry and
shall, after taking an account of the transactions between the parties, pass an order
declaring the amount, if any, still payable by the debtor to the money-lender, in
respect of the principal and interest, taking accounts under this section the court shall
follow IP visions of sections 22 to 33 and section 36.
35. Deposit In court of money due to money-lender -- (1) At any time debtor
may tender to a money-lender any sum of money due from to the money-lender in
respect of a loan by way of principal, interest or both or may remit to him such sum of
money by money-order.
(2) If the money-lender refuses to accept any sum so tendered or remitted, the
debtor may deposit the said sum in court to the account of the money-lender.
(3) The court shall thereupon cause written notice of the deposit to be served on
the money-lender, and he may, on presenting a petition, verified in the manner
provided for the verification of a plaint and stating the sum then due in respect of the
loan and his willingness to accept the money so deposited, receive the same and
appropriate it first towards the interest and the residue, if any, towards the principal:
Provided that in accepting any sum deposited under this section, the money-
lender shall not be bound by any statement made by the debtor while depositing the
same.
(4) A deposit made under sub-section (2) shall operate as an acquaintance for the
amount so deposited in the same manner and to the same extent as if that amount
had been received by the money-lender to whose Credit the deposit was made, on
the date of such deposit.
36. When interest to be paid for entire month.—Notwithstanding any
agreement between the parties or any law for the time being in force, when a
statement is delivered or pass book is supplied to a debtor under section 22 or if
accounts are taken under section 34 or a tender or remittance is made by a debtor to
a money lender in respect of a loan under section 35 before the tenth day of a
calendar month, the interest due shall be calculated as payable for fifteen days of the
said month and if the statement is delivered or pass book is supplied or accounts are
taken or tender or remittance is made on any subsequent day, then for the entire
calendar month irrespective of the fact that such statement is delivered or pass book
is supplied or such accounts are taken or such tender or remittance is made on any
such day.
37. Money-lenders to exhibit their names over shops --Every money lender
38
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
shall always keep exhibited over his shop or place of business, in Hindi written in
Devnagri script his name with the word 'money-lender' and the number of his licence.
38. Entry of wrong sum in bound etc. to be an offence. -No money lender
shall take any promissory note, acknowledgement, bond or other writing which does
not state the actual amount of the loan or which states such amount wrong!; or take
from any debtor any instrument in which blanks are left to be filled after execution.
(2) Whoever contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) shall, on conviction, be
punishable with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees or with imprisonment
of either description which may extend to six months or with both.
39. Penalty for molestation—Whoever molests, or abets the molestation of a
debtor for the recovery of a debt due by him to a creditor shall, on conviction, be
punishable with imprisonment of either description which may extend to three months
or with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees or with both.
Explanation.— For the purpose of this section, a person who, with intent to cause
another person to obtain from doing any act which he has a right to do or to do any
act which he has a right to abstain from doing —
(a) obstructs or uses violence to or intimidates such other person, or
(b) persistently follows such other person from place to place or interferes with
any property owned or used by him or deprives him of, hinders him in, the use
thereof, or
(c) loiters near a house or other place where such other person resides or works
or carries on business or happens to be or does any act calculated to or annoy or
intimate such other person, shall be deemed to molest such other person,
Provided that a person who goes to such house or place in order merely to obtain
or communicate information shall not be deemed to molest.
40. Punishment for contravention of sections 5, 22, 23, 29, 30 and 37.—
Whoever fails to comply with, or acts in contravention of, any provision contained in
sections 5, 22, 23, 29, 30 and 37 shall be punishable—
(a) for the first offence, with fine which may extend to two hundred rupees,
(b) for the second or subsequent offence, with fine which may extend to five
hundred rupees.
41. Offences by corporation etc.—If the person contravening any of the
provisions of this Act is an undivided Hindu family or a company or an unincorporated
body, the person responsible for the management of the business of such family,
company or body shall be deemed to be guilty of such contravention.
42. Cognizance of certain offence.—No court shall take cognizance of any
offence punishable under section 40 for contravening the provisions of sections 5,
22 or 23, except with the previous sanction of the Registrar.
43. Compounding of offences.—(1) The offences punishable under various
sections specified in the first two columns of the table next following may be
compounded by the persons mentioned in the third column of that table:—
Offence Section
applicable
Person by whom offence
may be compounded
39
Rajasthan Money Lenders Act, 1963
(2) The Registrar may, either before or after the institution of proceedings for
any offence punishable under section 40, accept from any person charged with such
offence by way of composition of the offence—
(a) for contravening the provision of section 22, sub-section (2), or section
23 a sum not exceeding fifty rupees;
(b) for contravening the provisions of section 5, a sum not exceeding five
hundred rupees in addition to the arrears of licence fees payable by him under
this Act.
(3) The composition of an offence under this section have the effect of an acquittal
of the accused with whom the offence has been compounded,
44. Arrest and imprisonment in execution of decree for money against
agricultural debtors abolished.—Notwithstanding any taw for the time being in
force, no debtor who cultivates land personally and whose debts do not exceed fifteen
thousand rupees shall be arrested or imprisoned in execution of a decree for money
passed in favour of a money-lender, whether before or after the date on which this
Act comes into force.
Explanation:—"To cultivate personally'* has the meaning assigned to it by clause
(25) of section 5 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955 (Rajasthan Act 3 of 1955).
45. Every officer to be public servant.-Every officer of the State Government
acting under the provisions of this Act shall be deemed to be a public servant within
the meaning of section 21 of the Indian Penal Code,1860 (Central Act XLV of
Receiving payment
without a receipt or
accepting any article
as pawn or pledge or
security for a loan
without giving a plain
signed receipt.
Charging or
receiving interest at a
rate exceeding the
maximum rates fixed
under sub-section (1)
of section 29
Charging any sum
for expenses on loan
by money-lenders.
Entering of wrong
sum in bond etc.
Molestation
22 (4) and