The Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004
Regulations made under The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997
This text is shown as one document.
Full text
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
A-2/14, Safdarjung Enclave,
New Delhi 110029
NOTIFICATION
File NO: 8-26/2004-B&CS Dated: 10th December, 2004
In exercise of the powers conferred upon it under section 36,
and paras (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11
of the Telecommunication Authority of India Act, 1997 read with the
Notification No.39 (S.O No. 44 (E) and 45 (E))dated 09.01.2004 issued
from file No.13-1/2004-Restg by the Government of India under
clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 11 and proviso to clause (k) of
sub section (1) of the Section 2 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of
India Act, 1997, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India makes the
following Regulation, namely:
1. Short title, extent and commencement:
(i) This regulation shall be called “The Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
Regulation 2004” (13 of 2004) (The Regulation).
(ii) This regulation shall cover arrangements among service
providers for interconnection and revenue share, for all
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services
throughout the territory of India.
(iii) This regulation shall come into force with effect from the date
of its publication in the Official Gazette.
2. Definitions:
In this regulation, unless the context otherwise requires:
(a) ‘addressable system” means an electronic device or more than
one electronic device put in an integrated system through which
signals of cable television network can be sent in encrypted or
unencrypted form, which can be decoded by the device or
devices at the premises of the subscriber within limits of the
authorization made, on the choice and request of such
subscriber, by the distributor of TV channels to the subscriber;
1
(b) “agent or intermediary” means any person including an
individual, group of persons, public or body corporate, firm or
any organization or body authorised by a broadcaster/multi
system operator to make available TV channel(s), to a
distributor of TV channels;
(c) “authority” means the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
established under sub-section (1) of section 3 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act;
(d) “authorized officer” has the same meaning as given in the
sub-section (a) of the Section 2 of the Cable Television Networks
(Regulation) Act, 1995, as amended;
(e) “broadcaster” means any person including an individual, group
of persons, public or body corporate, firm or any organization or
body who/which is providing broadcasting service and includes
his/her authorised distribution agencies;
(f) “broadcasting services” means the dissemination of any form
of communication like signs, signals, writing, pictures, images
and sounds of all kinds by transmission of electro magnetic
waves through space or through cables intended to be received
by the general public either directly or indirectly and all its
grammatical variations and cognate expressions shall be
construed accordingly;
(g) “cable operator” means any person who provides cable service
through a cable television network or otherwise controls or is
responsible for the management and operation of a cable
television network;
(h) “cable service” means the transmission by cables of
programmes including re-transmission by cables of any
broadcast television signals;
(i) “cable television network” means any system consisting of a
set of closed transmission paths and associated signal
generation, control and distribution equipment designed to
provide cable service for reception by multiple subscribers;
(j) “distributor of TV channels” means any person including an
individual, group of persons, public or body corporate, firm or
any organization or body re-transmitting TV channels through
electromagnetic waves through cable or through space intended
to be received by general public directly or indirectly. The
person may include, but is not limited to a cable operator,
direct to home operator, multi system operator, head ends in
the sky operator;
2
(k) “direct to home operator” means an operator licensed by the
central government to distribute multi channel TV programmes
in KU band by using a satellite system directly to subscriber’s
premises without passing through intermediary such as cable
operator or any other distributor of TV channels;
(l) “head ends in the sky operator” means any person permitted
by the central government to distribute multi channels TV
programmes in C band by using a satellite system to the
intermediaries like cable operators and not directly to
subscribers;
(m) “multi system operator” means any person who receives a
broadcasting service from a broadcaster and/or their authorized
agencies and re-transmits the same to consumers and/or re-
transmits the same to one or more cable operators and
includes his/her authorised distribution agencies.
(n) “service provider” means the Government as a service provider
and includes a licensee as well as any broadcaster, multi system
operator, cable operator or distributor of TV channels.
3. General Provisions relating to Non-Discrimination in
Interconnect Agreements
3.1 No broadcaster of TV channels shall engage in any practice or
activity or enter into any understanding or arrangement, including
exclusive contracts with any distributor of TV channels that prevents
any other distributor of TV channels from obtaining such TV channels
for distribution.
3.2 Every broadcaster shall provide on request signals of its TV
channels on non-discriminatory terms to all distributors of TV
channels, which may include, but be not limited to a cable operator,
direct to home operator, multi system operator, head ends in the sky
operator; Multi system operators shall also on request re-transmit
signals received from a broadcaster, on a non-discriminatory basis to
cable operators.
Provided that this provision shall not apply in the case of a distributor
of TV channels having defaulted in payment.
Provided further that any imposition of terms which are unreasonable
shall be deemed to constitute a denial of request
3.3 A broadcaster or his/her authorised distribution agency would
be free to provide signals of TV channels either directly or through a
3
particular designated agent or any other intermediary. A broadcaster
shall not be held to be in violation of clauses 3.1 and 3.2 if it is
ensured that the signals are provided through a particular designated
agent or any other intermediary and not directly. Similarly a multi
system operator shall not be held to be in violation of clause 3.1.and
3.2 if it is ensured that signals are provided through a particular
designated agent or any other intermediary and not directly.
Provided that where the signals are provided through an agent or
intermediary the broadcaster/multi system operator should ensure
that the agent/intermediary acts in a manner that is (a) consistent
with the obligations placed under this regulation and (b) not
prejudicial to competition.
3.4 Any agent or any other intermediary of a broadcaster/multi
system operator must respond to the request for providing signals of
TV channel(s) in a reasonable time period but not exceeding thirty days of
the request. If the request is denied, the applicant shall be free to
approach the broadcaster/multi system operator to obtain signals
directly for such channel(s).
3.5 The volume related scheme to establish price differentials based
on number of subscribers shall not amount to discrimination if there
is a standard scheme equally applicable to all similarly based
distributors of TV channel(s).
(Explanation: “Similarly based distributor of TV channels” means
distributors of TV channels operating under similar conditions. The
analysis of whether distributors of TV channels are similarly based
includes consideration of, but is not limited to, such factors as whether
distributors of TV channels operate within a geographical region and
neighbourhood, have roughly the same number of subscribers,
purchase a similar service, use the same distribution technology. ”)
3.6 Any person aggrieved of discrimination shall report to the
concerned broadcaster or multi system operator, as the case may be.
If the broadcaster or multi system operator does not respond in a
satisfactory manner in a reasonable time period, but not exceeding thirty
days, the aggrieved party can approach the appropriate forum.
3.7 The provisions of clauses 3.1 to 3.6 shall apply to the contracts
already entered into, after 90 days from the date of this regulation
coming into force.
4
4. Disconnection of TV channel signals
4.1 No broadcaster or multi system operator shall disconnect the TV
channel signals to a distributor of TV channels without giving one
month notice indicating the brief reasons for the proposed action:
Provided that in case a distributor of TV channel is re-transmitting
signals for which he/she is not authorized and thereby affecting the
commercial interest of the concerned broadcaster or multi system
operator, the notice period shall be two working days giving reasons
to the concerned distributor of TV channel for such action.
Explanation
A distributor of TV channels is said to be authorised if there exists any
agreement between the broadcaster, including his/her agents
permitting the distribution of the broadcasting service by the said
distributor of TV channels, either through a written agreement or
through an oral agreement. Consequently no notice would be required if
there is no agreement, written or oral, permitting the distribution of the
broadcasting service.
4.2 Broadcaster/multi system operator shall inform the consumers
about the dispute to enable them to protect their interests.
Accordingly, the notice to discontinue signal shall also be given in two
local newspapers in case the distributor of TV channels is operating in
local area and in two national papers in case the distributor of TV
channels is providing services in a wide area. Alternatively consumers
can be informed through scroll on the concerned channel(s). Where a
Broadcaster or a Multi System Operator decides to give this notice
through a scroll the Multi System Operator or the Cable Operator, as
the case may be, must carry the scroll in the concerned channel(s).
5. Explanatory Memorandum
5.1 Annex A to this order contains an Explanatory Memorandum for
the issue of this regulation.
(Rakesh Kacker)
Advisor (B&CS)
5
Annex A
Explanatory Memorandum
1. The distribution of cable TV in India is characterized by a few
dominant broadcasters and large multi system operators (MSOs).
Some of these players have become even stronger as vertical
integration has taken place. Last mile operations on the other hand
are highly fragmented and therefore there are large disparities in the
bargaining power of various players of the distribution chain.
2. The vertical integration may improve efficiency as it reduces the
transaction between upstream and downstream operations but at the
same time vertically integrated companies may be able to use the
vertical integration in certain circumstances to reduce competition.
The anti-competitive behaviour could take the following forms:
(i) Vertical Price Squeeze may happen when a vertically
integrated broadcaster increases the price of a TV channel
for competing operators but maintains the same price for
operator affiliates. The effect would be to reduce or
squeeze the margins.
(ii) Exclusivity of the Content could be another form whereby
popular TV channels can be denied to a competitor so as
to promote the broadcaster’s own distribution network.
(iii) Denial of carriage by a vertically integrated cable system
of TV channel of the rival company.
Non Discriminatory Access
3. In India, competition for delivery of TV channels is not only to
be promoted within the Cable Industry but also from distributors of
TV channels using other mediums like Direct To Home (DTH), Head
Ends in the Sky etc. It is important that all these distribution
platforms are promoted so that they provide consumers with choice. It
would be very important that at this stage vertical integration does not
impede competition. Vertically integrated broadcaster and
distribution network operators would, in the absence of strong
regulation, have the tendency to deny popular content to competing
networks or to discriminate against them.
4 One method of checking these practices is to stop at the source
any chance of anti-competitive behaviour by ruling that vertical
integration will not be allowed. This route could, however, impede
investments and in the long run adversely affect competition. The only
DTH platform today has a degree of vertical integration. There is
another pay DTH platform which is awaiting approval from the
government that also has a degree of vertical integration. DTH is the
6
platform most likely to provide effective competition to cable operators.
Restriction of vertical integration could therefore lead to a situation
where the DTH rollout could be affected and hence competition. It is
for this reason that the alternative route has been looked at;
controlling anti-competitive behaviour wherever it manifests itself.
These issues are dealt with in the following paragraphs.
5 Generally TV channels are provided to all carriers and platforms
to increase viewership for the purpose of earning maximum
subscription fee as well as advertisement revenue. However, according
to some opinions, if all platforms carry the same content it will reduce
competition and there will be no incentive to improve the content.
Some degree of exclusivity is required to differentiate one platform
from the other.
6 Exclusivity had not been a feature of India’s fragmented cable
television market. However the rollout of DTH platform has brought
the question of exclusivity and whether it is anti competitive to the
forefront. Star India Ltd and SET Discovery Ltd do not have
commercial agreements to share their contents with ASC Enterprises
on its DTH platform and at present are exclusively available on the
Cable TV platform. ASC Enterprises claims that the future growth will
remain impacted by the denial of these popular contents. Space TV a
joint venture of Tatas and Star, is also planning to launch its digital
DTH platform. It has applied for license to the government for the
same. The DTH services have to compete with Cable TV. If a popular
content is available on Cable TV and not on the DTH platform, then it
would not be able to effectively give competition to the cable networks.
7 The issue has to be seen primarily from the consumer’s
perspective. If all channels are not available on one DTH platform then
the consumer may have to install more than one dish to view his
favourite channels. If the content is not available on all platforms then
they would not be treated as the same and would be presented as
different products having different content. If content, especially
popular content, is exclusively available on one DTH platform then
there may not be effective competition. The consumers would also
have limited choice as subscribing to one particular DTH platform
may not ensure the availability of content of his/her choice.
8. The DTH platform would have to be seen as a carrier of TV
channels and its vertical integration with the broadcaster cannot be
the reason for content denial to the other distributors. The DTH
platforms would have to compete on the strength of the quality of
service, tariffs and packaging of the TV channels and not on the
content.
9. DTH is quite clearly the most effective competitor for Cable TV
today. It would be illogical for a consumer to establish two
7
arrangements to view the differing content of two platforms when he
has access to the entire content through cable. Moreover if a popular
content is available on the cable network and is not available on the
DTH platform, it would never be able to give an effective alternative to
the cable services. Competition between cable and DTH will be
enhanced if all the content is available on both platforms. Similarly
the cable industry should not be denied content that is available on
DTH. Therefore in the interest of consumers it is essential that all
channels are available on all platforms on a non-discriminatory basis.
This would promote competition amongst different platforms and thus
would be beneficial for the consumers.
10. The Authority has also looked at international experience in this
regard. In India, the problem is that broadcasters may not provide
content to rival platforms and this could adversely affect competition
in terms of price and quality of service. It is therefore necessary that
there should be regulations in place that can be invoked if content is
denied in a manner that stifles competition. Thus a general ban on
exclusivity at this stage has been envisaged.
‘Must Provide’ through whom
11. There is high cost involved in the distribution of TV channels if
the market is fragmented. To reduce the distribution costs
broadcasters/ multi system operators should be free to provide access
in the manner they think is beneficial for them. The ‘must provide’ of
signals should be seen in the context that each operator shall have
the right to obtain the signals on a non-discriminatory basis but how
these are provided - directly or through the designated
agent/distributor- is a decision to be taken by the broadcasters/multi
system operator. Thus the Broadcaster/multi system operator would
have to ensure that the signals are provided either directly or through
a particular designated agent/distributor or any other intermediary.
12. In order to expedite the interconnection process the Authority
has further provided that in case an agent does not respond to the
request for providing signals within one month of the request, then
the applicant would be free to approach broadcaster to obtain signals
directly.
Quality of TV Channel Signals
13. Some cable operators had apprehended that in case TV channel
signals are provided through cable and not directly then the quality of
transmission could deteriorate and accordingly it was suggested that
agents must provide services through IRDs. The Authority through
this regulation has framed the principle of non-discriminatory access,
which also includes non-discriminatory access in terms of quality of
8
signals. Operators can seek relief if it is found that the quality of their
signals is being tampered with.
Safeguards for Broadcasters
14. In this context it must be recognized that certain basic criteria
must be fulfilled before a service provider can invoke this clause. Thus
the service provider should be one who does not have any past dues.
Similarly provisions for protection against piracy must be provided.
However, the content provider must establish clearly that there are
reasonable basis for the denial of TV channel signals on the grounds
of piracy.
Volume Discounting Schemes
15. An important aim of non discriminatory conditions is to ensure
that a vertically integrated supplier does not treat itself in a way that
benefits itself, its subsidiaries or its partners and has material effect
on competition. The broadcaster/multi system operator must offer the
required channels on terms that are no less favourable than those on
which it provides equivalent services to its own affiliated operators.
16. Broadcasters and multi system operators are also offering
discounting schemes including volume or bulk discounts. Such
discounts are not considered anti competitive if these are consistently
available to similarly based distributors of TV channels. However such
discounts will be treated as anti competitive if provided on preferential
basis to one or select group of operators. The Authority has identified
three factors which may not be exhaustive relating to the subscriber
base, technology of the distribution of TV channels and geographical
region and neighbourhood.
Discrimination in providing TV Channel signals
17. In case any distributor of TV channel feels he/she has been
discriminated on terms of getting TV signals compared to a similarly
based distributor of TV channel, then a complaint must be filed with
the broadcaster or multi system operator, as the case may be. In case
the complainant is not satisfied with the response, he/she may
approach the appropriate forum for relief.
Disconnection of Signals
18. An important issue in the cable industry is the disconnection of
signals to settle a dispute. Usually this means that without notice the
signals by a broadcaster or multi system operator are cut off leaving
consumers in the lurch. This implies that the consumer who has not
defaulted nevertheless has to bear the brunt of the dispute between
the operators. It is, therefore, necessary to find some solution that will
9
protect the consumers without compromising the ability of the
broadcaster/multi system operator to settle their dispute. It has
therefore been decided to impose a restriction on the
broadcaster/multi system operator that they cannot cut off the signals
without giving at least one month’s notice. This would give some time
for the affected parties to obtain relief. This notice should also be
given through the newspapers so that consumers also have an
opportunity to approach the necessary forum to ensure that their
interests do not suffer on account of a dispute to which they have not
contributed in any way. Broadcasters have suggested that this
requirement of notice period should be exempted when disconnection
occurs for piracy and copy right violation and violation of the non-
financial terms and conditions of the interconnect agreement. In the
case of unauthorized re-transmission of TV channels, it may be
necessary for Broadcaster or Multi System Operator to disconnect
signals of TV channels without giving one-month notice. In such cases
the Authority has decided that after giving a notice for two working
days, the signals may be disconnected.
10
Annex A
.
Consultation on draft Regulation
19. The draft Regulation had been put on the website of TRAI and time
was given to all stake-holders till 5th November, 2004 for comments on
the draft. A number of comments have been received and these have
been carefully analysed. Since the number of comments is very large,
and in some cases are in the form of modifications to the draft, the
gist of the comments have been briefly summarised, section by section
in the Annexe to this Explanatory Memorandum and the response of
TRAI for each of the comments has been set out. Wherever necessary,
the draft has been modified in the light of the comments received.
Some other changes have been made to make the regulation clear.
Some issues have also been raised which are not relevant to the issue
of these regulations – these are being separately examined
11
Annexe to Explanatory Memorandum on “The Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation
2004” ( 13 of 2004) (The Regulation).
1. Short title, extent and commencement:
Stake-holders comments
After the words “service providers” the words “and distributors
of TV channels” should be added.
TRAI’s response
Service providers include distributors – a definition of
service providers has been added to clarify this point. (new
definition added at clause 2(n) of the Regulation)
2. Definitions
Stake-holders comments
i) Agent or intermediary should not be directly or indirectly a
distributor of TV channels.
ii) Broadcaster should also include his/her agent or
intermediary.
iii) Broadcasting services – it should be clarified that these refer
to those services intended to be received by the general
public in India.
iv) Cable operator – the definition should include one who
provides such a service either directly or indirectly.
v) Cable service – it should be clarified that this means the
transmission only with the authorization of the broadcaster.
vi) The definition of MSO should exclude with reference to
consumers, since an MSO is not supposed to reach
subscribers directly.
vii) The regulation should apply only to those distributors who
meet certain minimum qualifications.
viii) The definition of addressable system should be expanded to
include other technologies such as DTH, Broadband and
MMDS.
12
ix) Definition of DTH operator should clarify that there are other
intermediaries like Broadband provider, MMDS provider, etc.
TRAI’s response
(i) At present this is not the practice – MSOs supply signals and
also provide direct connections to subscribers. If this definition
is to be amended as proposed it would mean considerable
realignment of the business – this should therefore not be done
unless this is shown to be absolutely necessary; accordingly this
need not be done now. For the present therefore this is not
being done and if there is enough evidence that this practice is
causing problems then this would be considered later. However
to address the likely problem it is being provided in clause
3.3 that broadcasters and MSOs will have to ensure that the
agent or intermediary acts in a manner that is (a) consistent
with the obligations placed under this regulation and (b) not
prejudicial to competition. (proviso added to clause 3.3).
(ii) There is no need to change the definition since the recourse to
the broadcaster is only after the agent or intermediary is not
able to satisfy the person aggrieved. Broadcasters would in any
case be liable for the actions of their agents and intermediaries,
because a representation would lie to the broadcasters after the
agent/intermediary is not able to provide satisfaction. At this
stage the Broadcaster would either have to satisfy the person
aggrieved or the aggrieved person will have to go the appropriate
forum. The proviso to clause 3.3 also makes this clear.
(iii) This is not necessary since the TRAI Act in any case applies to
the whole of India.
(iv) This change is not required; the definition of cable operator is as
defined in the Cable Act and does include one who provides
such services indirectly.
(v) This is not necessary – if signals are carried without
authorization of the broadcaster then no protection can be
given; this is also being clarified in clause 4.1
(vi) As discussed in (i) above such a change is not desirable at this
stage.
(vii) This is not necessary for TRAI to specify – each company
should decide its own policy which should be applied uniformly
and without discrimination.
13
(viii) The definition of addressable system has been modified by
replacing the word “cable operator” with the words
“Distributors of TV channels” so that all distributors are
included (clause 2(a) amended accordingly).
(ix) The definition of DTH operator has been modified to make
reference to all distributors of TV channels rather than only
the cable operator (clause 2(k) amended accordingly).
(x) In addition the definitions of “agent or intermediary” have
been changed replacing the word “entity” by the words “any
person ,including an individual, group of persons, public or
body corporate, firm or any organization or body” to bring it
in line with the definition of broadcaster.
3. General Provisions relating to Non-discrimination in
Interconnection Agreements.
Stake-holders comments
(i) Non- discriminatory access should not be mandated by
regulation. Ban on exclusive contracts will hit premium
programming and adversely affect competition.
(ii) Even under the MRTP Act exclusivity is permitted if this is not
prejudicial to the interests of consumers. Exclusivity should be
dealt with under the provisions of the MRTP Act.
(iii) Transition clause is required for change over to the new system
or a provision should be made providing that the regulation is
not applicable to old contracts. If time is being given for
transition then for this purpose time may be given upto January
1, 2006.
(iv) The regulation should be applicable only to non addressable
systems.
(v) The proposed regulation is violative of the freedom of speech
guaranteed in the Indian Constitution and the rights of
broadcasters in the TRIPS agreement and the Berne convention.
(vi) The Regulation should only require vertically integrated
companies to offer their content on terms no worse than what it
has agreed for its own platform.
(vii) It would be advisable to spell some outlines of the controlling
mechanism on the operational aspects of “Must Provide”.
(viii) It may be useful to have a description of DTH in the main
regulation itself.
14
(ix) The Explanatory Memorandum should be clarified to bring out
that grounds of piracy cannot be invoked if the distributor of TV
signals has deployed anti piracy measures and installed
transparent subscriber management systems duly accredited by
BECIL.
(x) The provisions will hurt rural consumers who cannot afford
terms offered by urban consumers. It may also not be
administratively/economically viable to provide services to small
operators.
TRAI’s response
(i) This issue has already been discussed in the Recommendations
sent on 1.10.2004. It is the Authority’s view that given the
present stage of the market it is necessary to provide non
discriminatory access across different distributors and
correspondingly not provide for exclusivity.
(ii) As has already been explained in the recommendations
exclusivity at this stage will only harm the consumers. The
provisions of MRTP apply to all consumers and industries. In
the case of the TV programme market the Authority has already
come to the conclusion that exclusivity at this stage would be
harmful after examining the issues in great detail. The
Authority has a mandate to provide effective interconnection,
promote competition and protect the interests of the consumers.
This it has to do under the powers given to it. Non-
discrimination is a well known regulatory principle and similarly
not allowing exclusivity is also a practice followed in some
countries to foster competition.
(iii) A new clause is being added -3.7- to provide that 90 days
will be given for old contracts to be renegotiated and bring
them in compliance with the new regulations. This time is
sufficient as it may not be necessary to renegotiate all
contracts – provision has already been made in clauses 3.4
and 3.6 for redressal of alleged non- compliance before
recourse may be had to the appropriate regulatory/legal
forums. ( Clause 3.7 added) .
(iv) The Authority has already indicated that prices of new channels
will not be regulated in CAS areas except for the limited
regulation on the discount on prices of bouquets vis-à-vis prices
of individual channels. However, these prices should be
uniformly applicable to all similarly placed distributors.
Allowing discrimination in these prices could lead to unfair
competition in the addressable segment of the market.
15
(v) It is not correct that the Regulation is in violation of the
Constitution. TRAI is under obligation under the TRAI Act to
ensure effective interconnection and protect the interests of
consumers. This regulation will help in promoting competition
and providing more areas to cable services. Further there is no
infringement of the right to get equitable compensation in these
regulations. The restriction on prices is through the tariff order
which has not been challenged on these grounds. There is also
no question of the TRIPS Agreement or the Berne Convention
being violated by these regulations as it is a well established
principle of our law that international law has to be translated
into domestic law before it becomes enforceable. No violation of
the domestic law protecting the broadcaster has been made out.
Thus if the rights of the broadcasters have been impacted under
the relevant international law the remedy will be to get the
offending domestic law changed. Till then TRAI would have to
fulfill the mandate given to it under the TRAI Act read with the
relevant domestic laws.
(vi) It is necessary to ensure that access is provided to all content
and not merely that of the vertically integrated companies. This
is required for content to be available on all platforms which
would ensure fair competition amongst rival platforms.
(vii) These have been spelt out in the regulation. Essentially it
would be for an individual service provider to seek remedy, in
the first instance, from the broadcaster/MSO or their
intermediaries. If this does not succeed, then the service
provider has to approach the appropriate forum for relief.
(viii) DTH has been defined in the regulations and a DTH operator is
included in the definition of distributor of TV channels and thus
DTH is automatically included in the body of the regulations.
Nevertheless clause 3.2 has been amended to make this
amply clear (clause 3.2 amended).
(ix) Normally there should well accepted standardized measures
taken for preventing piracy, at least on well established
technologies where there would be standard requirements and
procedures. However if there is no such standard then the two
parties could refer the matter to a well known technical expert.
TRAI would not be in a position to specify the expert.
(x) In the industry today there exist wide variations in the prices –
by providing for geographical variations in prices in terms of the
explanation to clause 3.5, this variation will not be affected. Also
by allowing for content to be delivered either directly or through
agents/intermediaries it has been recognized that broadcasters
16
need not deal directly with all operators. This is already the
industry practice. Further, it is for each service provider to have
a well defined policy that can weed out non-serious players but
at the same time ensure that there is no discrimination. It is
also pertinent that this issue has been raised by broadcasters
and not by MSOs- it is the MSOs who have been in an
increasing way dealing directly with the last mile operators.
3.1
Stake-holders comments
i) This Clause should not apply for content made exclusively for
addressable systems.
ii) The clause should be applicable to broadcasters as well as their
agents/subsidiaries.
TRAI’s response
(i) This has already been dealt with in 3(iv) above.
(ii) In view of the provisions of clause 3.3 this is not necessary.
3.2
Stake-holders comments
i) Apart from non-discriminatory access, provision of access “on
similar/equitable commercial terms” should be added as a
principle.
ii) The exclusion of operators having defaulted in payment should
be qualified to provide for a minimum of 15/30 days notice for
the defaulting distributor to make good the default in payment.
The Authority has made similar provisions for telecom service
providers for disconnection on the ground of non payment of
dues.
iii) In view of the bandwidth constraint in analogue systems, it may
not be possible to re-transmit all the channels requested by the
distributor.
iv) After the words Multi-System Operators “and Cable Operators”
should be added.
v) It should be stipulated that the broadcasters should provide
their signals within 15 days of the request having been made.
17
vi) Apart from those who have defaulted in payment, this clause
should not apply to those who have indulged in piracy or
material breach of commercial terms like under-declaration of
subscriber base.
vii) Pricing should be uniform irrespective of technology
viii) All distribution platforms should get the signals on the same
effective commercial terms.
ix) The word “defaulted” needs to be suitably defined.
TRAI’s response
(i) The essential purpose of the regulation is to promote
competition by ensuring that content is made available to all
distributors so that competition is developed. The addition of
the words “similar/equitable” would not help in meeting this
objective.
(ii) Clause 4.1 already provides for a 30 days notice. This would
include disconnection for non payment. For operators seeking a
new contract and who have defaulted in the past there is no
need to prescribe a time period as such operators can get the
new contract as and when the default is removed.
(iii) The clause does not require all channels to be re- transmitted.
All that is required is that the MSO should not discriminate
between cable operators. The clause applies only to requests
from distributors of TV channels and not from broadcasters.
The issue of “must carry” is being separately looked at by the
Authority.
(iv) This is not necessary as by definition a cable operator cannot
retransmit.
(v) The time taken to respond will vary from platform to platform
depending on the technology and other factors. Rather than
prescribe different periods for different types of
requests/problems clauses 3.4 and 3.6 are being amended
to say that the request/complaint must be responded to in
a reasonable time period but not exceeding thirty days
(clauses 3.4 and 3.6 have been amended accordingly)
(vi) Piracy is too wide a term and can also include underdeclaration.
Unless underdeclaration is defined correctly this would be
difficult to enforce. Piracy, if invoked as a ground for refusing
content to a new entrant will have to be justified as already
18
explained in the explanatory memorandum. For existing
operators the provision of 4.1 will apply.
(vii and viii) This has been addressed in 3.5(ii & iii)
(ix) The word defaulter is well understood and whether a person
has defaulted or not needs to be determined with reference to
the facts of the case and the contractual arrangements between
the service providers.
3.3
Stake-holders comments
i) Broadcasters must be held responsible for the actions of their
agents/intermediaries.
ii) Multi-system operators should not be allowed to act as a
designated distributor agent.
iii) This clause should not be used by broadcasters to defeat the
Tariff Order of October 1, 2004.
iv) The agent or distributor should not be an MSO or a distributor
of TV channels within that territory and distributor should be
able to receive signals of a channel directly from the satellite.
v) The second and third sentences of this section can be deleted.
vi) The words “on an equitable and non-discriminatory basis”
should be added at the end of the second sentence.
TRAI’s response
(i) This is already provided for in the regulation; to make this
explicit a proviso has been added. (proviso added to 3.3)
(ii) This has been addressed in 2(i) above.
(iii) The tariff order is an independent order and its provisions will
have to be complied with.
(iv) This has been partially addressed in 3(ii) above. Whether a
distributor should be entitled to receive the signals through
cable or directly from the satellite is a matter to be negotiated
between the service providers. If a distributor of TV channels
finds that he would be discriminated against and the
19
broadcaster is not able to rectify the problem then he can
always approach the appropriate regulatory forum.
(v) Both these sentences are necessary since the Broadcaster/MSO
have to ensure that the signals are received by the distributor.
The primary responsibility has to be that of the
broadcaster/MSO.
(vi) As in 3.2 (i).
3.4
Stake-holders comments
i) If the agent denies content, the broadcaster must respond to his
complaint within two days of the receipt of the complaint and
the agent/broadcaster should be made liable to pay
compensation for the loss caused by any wrongful delay in
providing services.
ii) An agent who has defaulted in payment to MSO should not be
allowed to take signals directly from a broadcaster.
iii) Distributor should be entitled for compensation for any losses
incurred by them because of them acts of omission/refusal on
the part of a broadcaster, MSO or their agent/intermediary.
iv) It should be stipulated that the broadcaster must provide the
signals within 15 days of the request having been made
provided that there are no pending dues to the broadcaster/
respond within 30 days.
v) After the word “broadcaster” the word “MSO” should be added.
vi) The broadcaster/MSO should ensure that signals are provided
to the applicant within 7/30 days.
vii) This clause should apply even if the broadcaster is not located
in India as long as the broadcasting services are marketed in
India
viii) Imposition of terms that are unreasonable will be deemed to be
a denial of the request.
ix) The response of the broadcaster and MSO should not be
specified by a time limit; instead it should merely be specified to
take place within a reasonable amount of time.
TRAI’s response
20
(i)(iii)(iv)(vi) and (ix) This has been partially addressed in 3.2(v) above.
Damages cannot be awarded by TRAI .
(ii) The proviso to clause 3.2 already provides that there is no
obligation to provide signals to a distributor of TV channels
who has defaulted in payment . If an MSO wants to ensure that
a distributor of TV channels who has defaulted does not get
signals from a broadcaster then this should be done by a
contractual arrangement.
(v) This has been done ( clause 3.4 amended accordingly).
(vii) This is already provided in the law – there is no need to make a
separate provision for this.
(viii) A second proviso has been added to provide for this in
Clause 3.2 (clause 3.2 amended accordingly)
3.5
Stake-holders comments
i) The broadcaster should announce a standard scheme regarding
rates to be charged as well as declared subscriber base.
ii) The words “based on number of subscribers” should be deleted
from the clause as well as the explanation and the words “use
the same distribution technology” should also be deleted from
the explanation.
iii) The words “use the same distribution technology” should be
replaced by “irrespective of the technology used for distribution
of signals”.
iv) The clause should provide that a standard scheme equally
applicable to all similarly based distributors of TV channels
should be drawn up in this regard.
v) Volume discounting should be left to the market and there
should be no insistence on a standard scheme.
vi) The quantum of discount needs to be specified to prevent
exploitation of this provision.
TRAI’s response
(i)(iv) and (v) It is for each broadcaster to decide on whether or not
there should be such a policy. If there is a policy then
21
discrimination would be allowed based on volumes. If there is
no such policy then such discrimination would not be
permitted. If different distributors are going to get different
prices the there must be some justification for it – in the
absence of such justification such discrimination could be used
eliminate/reduce competition.
(ii) and (iii) It is necessary to retain these words as the intention is to
allow volume based discrimination and also permit different
terms and conditions of supply based on the different
technologies being used. However since in non- addressable
systems payment is normally made only for the number of
subscribers negotiated and agreed upon while in an addressable
system payment is made for all the consumers it should
normally be expected that price in an addressable system would
be lower than in a similar non addressable system.
(vi) It is not necessary to quantify the discount, as the only purpose
of the regulation is to prevent discrimination. The extent of
discount would depend on the benefits perceived by individual
broadcasters/MSOs from higher volumes – a uniform ceiling for
this purpose would be difficult to fix.
3.6
Stake-holders comments
i) There should be safeguards in place to prevent this clause being
used to harass the distributor.
ii) The “appropriate forum” should be spelt out.
iii) It should be clarified that the aggrieved party can approach the
appropriate forum for various reliefs such as injunction,
restoration of signals, damages, etc.
iv) Disputes should be resolved within 30 days and in case the
broadcaster/distributor does not cooperate then the signals
should be made available to the subscribers, subject to the final
decision of such a forum.
TRAI’s response
(i) Safeguards have already been provided in the draft; the
additional safeguards proposed have not been spelt out.
(ii) and (iii) The appropriate forum could be TRAI, TDSAT or a High
Court/ Supreme Court depending upon the nature of the case
and relief sought. This cannot be specified ex ante. Relief to be
22
obtained will be as per the TRAI Act or the Constitution and
other relevant laws. These cannot be defined by Regulation
(iv) Whether signals should be provided as an interim measure as is
being suggested has to be decided on a case to case basis. This
cannot be specified by Regulation.
Disconnection of TV channel signals
4.1
Stake-holders comments
(i) Disconnection period for unauthorized distribution should be 7
days since two days is too short to obtain relief in cases of
unjustified disconnection. The words “authorisation” and
“commercial interest” should be defined.
(ii) A one month notice is too long and would provide a distributor
an opportunity to earn money from the consumers without
paying the broadcaster.
(iii) The distributor and not the broadcaster should be responsible
for advising the consumer on whether the distributor has met
his/her obligations to the broadcaster , notice should be placed
in the monthly bill and the consumer should get compensation
from the distributor such as a discount in the monthly bill.
(iv) In case of piracy the distributor should be given an opportunity
to rectify the problem and protect the commercial interest of the
broadcaster/MSO.
(v) For checking piracy certain safeguards should be specified in
the Regulation.
(vi) The words “for which he/she is not authorized and” should be
replaced by the words “by stealing the same in an illegal
manner”.
(vii) Distributors should be entitled for losses suffered by them due
to wrongful acts of broadcasters in disconnecting such signals.
(viii) The word “thereby” should be added before the words “affecting
commercial interest”
(ix) For unauthorized retransmission no notice period should be
given; a brief notice can only be required when there is a
business relationship.
23
(x) No disconnection should be allowed for disputes on subscriber
base.
TRAI’s response
(i) In such cases since a period of two working days has been
provided this should be enough – given the nature of the
problem allowing a larger period would not be desirable. The
word “authorization” has been clarified to mean any
agreement permitting the distribution of the broadcasting
service, either through a written agreement or through an
oral agreement. Commercial interest is well understood and
need not be clarified further.(Explanation added to clause 4.1)
(ii) This is necessary to provide time for dispute resolution and for
consumers to ensure that they can continue to have access to
the content for which they have not defaulted. Broadcasters/
MSOs can protect their interests by making appropriate
provisions in their contracts.
(iii) The onus of making the decision known must lie with the
person making the decision. The regulation does not bar the
recovery of costs/damages from the person who is found to be
at fault later. Such recovery has to made under the contractual
terms between the parties and TRAI cannot provide for such
recovery. However it is being provided that if the
broadcaster/MSO does give a notice to be carried as a scroll
on the concerned channel then the distributor must carry
the notice as a scroll in the concerned channel(s).(necessary
amendment carried out in Clause 4.2)
(iv) This has to be mutually settled between the contracting parties.
Given the nature of piracy more then two days notice would not
be desirable.
(v) These safeguards have to be determined contractually as they
can vary depending upon the technology used and perceptions
of the copyright holder. The only restriction that can be placed
in the regulations is the need to ensure that this does not
become an obstacle for fair competition and hence the principle
of non discrimination has been incorporated in the regulation.
(vi) This suggestion has been examined. It would be better to use
the words in the draft with the clarification for the word
authorised as in (i) above.
(vii) This is beyond the scope of the TRAI Act and hence these
regulations. The Act only provides for fines as provided in
24
section 29. Damages have to be claimed through other legal
forums.
(viii) This correction has been done.
(ix) This has been clarified by adding the following in the
explanation after Clause 4.1 “no notice would be required if
there is no written or oral agreement permitting the
distribution of the broadcasting service”
(x) If such a clause were to be added, this would imply that
broadcasters would have to provide their services irrespective of
the subscriber base declared. This would not be desirable as
the subscriber base is a negotiated number and changes in this
lead to disputes. Such disputes would have to be settled
mutually or by using the legal process available under the law.
4.2
Stake-holders comments
(i) The payments for ads should be borne initially by the
stakeholder who is planning to discontinue the signal and the
payment can be mutually shared in any ratio during
settlement.
.
(ii) Public notice should be both by scroll and newspaper ad since
a scroll is sometimes not noticed by the consumers
(iii) Broadcaster/MSO should not be responsible for informing the
consumers and it should be distributor who should place a
placard or scroll advising the consumers of the dispute.
(iv) The scroll should not hamper/restrict the view of the channel
for the consumers.
TRAI’s response
(i)As has been discussed in 4.1 (iii), the cost of informing the
consumers would have to be borne initially by the service provider
who is disconnecting and later this can be recovered from the
service provider who is found to be at fault.
(ii) At present both the options are available. Depending on the
experience with the scroll option, the regulation can be reviewed
later.
(iii) This has already been discussed in 4.1 (iii).
25
(iv) It is presumed that if a scroll is inserted, it would be done in a
manner that does not affect the consumers ability to view the
channel. The regulations need not specify such details.
26
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
No. 3-57/2005/B&CS March 3, 2005.
New Delhi
In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, and paras (ii), (iii)
and (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the
Telecommunication Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, read with
the Notification No.39 (S.O No. 44 (E) and 45 (E))dated 09.01.2004
issued from file No.13-1/2004-Restg by the Government of India
under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 11 and proviso to clause
(k) of sub section (1) of the Section 2 of the Telecom Regulatory
Authority of India Act, 1997, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
hereby amends the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable
Services) Interconnection Regulation 2004 (13 of 2004) (hereinafter
called the “Principal Regulation”), as follows, namely -
1. Short title, extent and commencement:
(i) This regulation shall be called “The Telecommunication
(Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection (First
Amendment) Regulation 2005” (2 of 2005)”.
(ii) It shall come into force from the date of its publication in the
official Gazette.
2. The words and figures “120 days” shall substitute the words
and figures “90 days” in clause (7) of regulation 3 of the
Principal Regulation.
3. This regulation contains at Annex A, an Explanatory
Memorandum that explains the reasons for this amendment
to the Principal Regulation.
By Order
(DR. HARSHA VARDHANA SINGH)
Secretary-cum-Principal Advisor
Annex. - A
EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
1. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India had notified “The
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection
Regulation 2004” (13 of 2004) and it came into effect w.e.f. 10th
December 2004. As per the provisions of this regulation, all the
broadcasters /multi system operators and their agents/ intermediaries
through whom they provide the signals are required not to engage in any
practice or activity or enter into any understanding or arrangement,
including exclusive contracts with any distributor of TV channels that
discriminates against any other distributor of TV channels. A period of 90
days was granted in respect of the contracts already entered into before
the provisions regarding non-discrimination in Interconnect Agreements
would apply to these contracts. This period of 90 days was given for old
contracts to be renegotiated and brought in compliance with the new
regulations.
2. A proposal was received from a broadcaster to extend the transition
period for another 60 days to enable all the agreements to be compliant
with the regulations. The reasons given for seeking such an extension
are: -
(a) The broadcaster has more than 6000 contracts with various
distributors of TV channels that got signed at different points in time. In
addition to the above, before the enforcement of the Interconnection
Regulation, they had launched several new channels and signed up
addendums/ contracts with various operators.
(b) They are now working towards transitioning their various contracts
and addendums to make them compliant with the Interconnection
Regulation. In addition several internal organizational activities are being
implemented to ensure that the transition is entirely smooth, such as
• Formulation of a Policy for distribution of its channels in India to
clearly articulate to the distribution personnel the Company’s
position on various issues related to distribution with step by step
instructions on ensuring all activities are compliant with the
Interconnection Regulation.
• Review of existing contracts and addendums. On finalization of
Distribution Policy, the existing contracts and addendums will be
modified to comply with the Policy. The 6000+ contracts will then
be re-signed in the modified formats to the extent required and
subject to negotiations with their associates.
• Several workshops have already been conducted for distribution
personnel and distributors across the country to help them
understand the provisions of Interconnection Regulation. The
inputs received from these workshops will be used to resolve
outstanding issues and queries. Company executives are being
briefed in detail regarding the process to be followed for executing
the commercial arrangements.
• Organizational processes and systems are being defined to
streamline all new activities required to be undertaken by the
Company to comply with all the provisions of Interconnection
Regulation.
3. The Authority had considered the request to extend the transition
period for another 60 days and in line with its consultative approach, it
decided to seek comments on the proposed extension of the transition
period from 90 days to 150 days. A Press Release was accordingly issued
on 11th February 2005 seeking comments in the matter till 18th February
2005. The following are the major comments have been received on the
issue:-
(a) Jaipur Cable & Broadband Society has stated that increase in
transition period will have adverse effect on those cable channel
distributors who raised their voice against broadcaster/ MSO
monopolies. By giving more time broadcasters/ MSO will have
enough time to manipulate things on the ground. It will delay the
upcoming competition in the market. It has further said that there
is only one MSO in Jaipur and it is capturing cable networks by
increasing connectivity amount. Extension of transition period by 60
days would mean that broadcasters would not give decoders to
cable operators for 150 days and it will be difficult to sustain 150
days without Pay channels.
(b) Cable Operators Federation of India has objected to the proposal
for the following reasons :-
• All the major broadcasters have made alliance with each other
for distribution whereby they are distributing channels in
bouquets through a joint distribution staff.
• It is not true that they are unable to renew their contracts as per
the new terms in 90 days as the broadcasters have a very large
distribution department comprising of distribution heads,
regional managers, area managers and distribution executives in
each major town. Apart from this, there are distribution
companies in every major city who deal with LCOs. Thus at a
lower level, a distributor may not have to deal with more than
40-50 contracts in 90 days.
• The broadcasters are not taking any interest in revising their
contracts with existing operators and they are busy in forcing
the cable networks to increase their connectivity by 40-60% by
appointing minimum guarantee agents in each area. Additional
60 day period will give opportunity to these minimum guarantee
agents and their affiliated MSOs to extract the maximum from
the existing cable operators.
4. The additional time period of 30 days being granted by this
amendment is considered adequate by the Authority for the reason that in
case any complaint of a discriminatory interconnection agreement is
received by the Authority, the broadcasters /multi system operators/ their
agents/ intermediaries would be given an opportunity of explaining their
position and rectifying the same. This would give them an opportunity to
make such a contract compliant with the Interconnection Regulation.
5. Although the Authority had earlier approved only 90 days for the
transition period it is considered that in view of difficulties experienced by
the broadcasters and the steps taken so far a further extension of 30
days can be given. Moreover, this is only a one time provision and will
have no long term impact. On the other hand if all preparations are not
completed there could be unnecessary litigation.
6. Therefore, after considering the proposal and the objections, the
Authority decided to extend the transition period from 90 days to 120
days.
1
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 24th August 2006
F. No. 11-13/2006- B&CS - In exercise of the powers conferred by section 36, and sub-
clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 11 of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), read with the Notification No.39
{S.O No.44(E) and 45(E)} dated 9.1.2004 issued from file No.13-1/2004-Restg by the
Government of India under clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 11 and proviso to
clause (k) of sub section (1) of section 2 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
Act, 1997 (24 of 1997), the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India hereby amends the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation, 2004
(13 of 2004) (hereinafter called the “Principal Regulation”), as follows:-
1. Short title, extent and commencement.-
i) This regulation shall be called ‘The Telecommunication (Broadcasting
and Cable Services) Interconnection (Second Amendment) Regulation,
2006 (9 of 2006)”
ii) It shall come into force from the date of its publication in the Official
Gazette.
2. In clause 2 of the Principal Regulation, sub-clause (a) and entries relating
thereto shall be substituted by the following sub-clause and the entries relating
thereto, namely: -
“(a) “addressable system” means an electronic device or more than one
electronic device put in an integrated system through which signals of
television channels can be sent in encrypted or unencrypted form, which
can be decoded by the device or devices at the premises of the subscriber
within limits of the authorization made, on the choice and request of such
subscriber, by the service provider to the subscriber.”
2
3. The existing clause 5 of the Principal Regulation shall be renumbered as
clause 7.
4. In the Principal Regulation, after the existing clause 4 and the entries
relating thereto, the following clauses and the entries relating thereto shall be
added as clauses 5 and 6, respectively, namely :-
“5. Standard Interconnection Agreements
5.1 All broadcasters, multi system operators and cable
operators shall mutually negotiate and finalise their interconnection
agreements in respect of areas notified by the Central Government
under section 4A (1) of the Cable Television Networks (Regulation)
Act, 1995 (7 of 1995) vide notification no. S.O. 1231(E) dated
31.7.2006.
5.2 In case any of the service providers in the areas as notified
by the Central Government vide notification no. S.O. 1231(E) dated
31.7.2006, are not able to arrive at a mutually acceptable
interconnection agreement within a time-period to be specified by the
Authority through a direction, then they shall enter into
interconnection agreements in terms of the standard interconnection
agreements as specified in Schedule I (between broadcaster and multi
system operator) or in Schedule II (between multi system operator and
cable operator) to this Regulation, as the case may be, within a time
period to be specified by the Authority for entering into standard
interconnection agreements.
Explanation
For removal of doubts, in respect of areas notified by the Central
Government referred to in clauses 5.1 and 5.2 above, it is clarified that
if the service providers have already entered into mutually acceptable
interconnection agreements by such date as specified in the direction
issued by the Authority, then they need not take recourse to standard
interconnection agreements specified in Schedules I and II. Further,
3
those service providers, who have a pre-existing interconnection
agreement as on the date of issue of this regulation, will also have the
option, after the expiry of their existing agreement, to either enter into
a mutually acceptable interconnection agreement, or failing which to
enter into interconnection agreements as per the standard agreements
specified in Schedules I & II, within a period to be specified by the
Authority in the direction.
5.3 If the provisions of the standard interconnection
agreements in Schedule I and II are in conflict with any Act, rule,
regulation, direction or order of the Government, TDSAT or TRAI, as
the case may be, then the provisions of such Act, rule, regulation,
direction or order shall prevail.
6. Prohibition of minimum guarantee clause
Where a distributor of TV channels is using a technology by which
pay channels can only be seen through an addressable system, then no
service provider shall stipulate, insist or provide for any clause in an
interconnection agreement with such a distributor which would
require such distributor to pay a minimum guaranteed amount as
subscription fee for the services provided.”
5. This regulation contains at Appendix, an Explanatory Memorandum.
By Order
(RAKESH KACKER)
Advisor (B&CS - I)
4
Schedule 1
[Broadcaster and Multi System Operator (MSO)]
STANDARD TECHNICAL AND COMMERCIAL INTERCONNECTION
AGREEMENT [CAS]
This Technical and Commercial Interconnection Agreement along with its Schedules and
Annexures is executed on this _____ day of ______ 2006 by and between:
M/s A & Co Ltd, a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, having its
registered office at 001, XYZ Colony ABC City (hereinafter referred to as “Broadcaster”
which expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof be deemed to
include its successors and permitted assigns) of the ONE PART;
AND
M/s. B & Co Ltd, a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, having its
registered office at 00111, PQR Colony ABC City (hereinafter referred to as the “Affiliate”
which expression shall unless repugnant to the context or meaning thereof be deemed to
include the successors and permitted assigns) of the OTHER PART.
The Broadcaster and the Affiliate are hereinafter individually and collectively referred to as
“Party” and “Parties”, respectively.
WHEREAS:
a) The Broadcaster is engaged in the business of distribution of Television channel(s) and
has the exclusive right to market and distribute Television Channels, in particular the
Television channels specified in Annexure A throughout the territory of India or in the
territory comprised in ----- in India
b) The Affiliate is engaged in the business of distribution of television channels including
through a digital /analogue Conditional Access System (“CAS”) in the areas notified by
the Central Government under Section 4A(1) of The Cable Television Networks
(Regulation) Act, 1995 (7 of 1995);
c) The parties have mutually agreed to execute this Agreement between them to govern
the rights and obligations in regard to the subscription and distribution of Television
channels, appropriately described in clause 1.1 of Article 1 of this Agreement read in
conjunction with Annexure A, for the Term and in the Area specified herein
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and the mutual covenants contained
herein, constituting good and valuable consideration, the Parties agree as follows: -
ARTICLE 1: SCOPE OF SERVICE, AREA SERVED, TERM AND ENTIRE
UNDERSTANDING
1.1 SCOPE OF SERVICES
The Parties mutually agree that this Agreement seeking to govern the terms and
conditions of rights and obligations between them shall be in respect of the services
indicated herein below and as specifically described in Annexure A to this
Agreement for the area and for the term indicated in clause 1.2 and 1.3, respectively.
5
Subscription to and distribution of the Television channels whether as an individual
channel or as a part of a Bouquet and described in Annexure A to this Agreement
through the Permitted Distribution System with Conditional Access System directly
or indirectly to the subscriber,
For the purpose of ascertaining the scope of services at any point of time, the scope
of services as indicated above shall be read with additions /deletions, if any, done
through separate addendum agreements/ updation forms executed from time to time
and till the date of reckoning.
1.2 AREA (S) SERVED
The parties mutually agree that the services referred in clause 1.1 of this Agreement
shall have reference to the area specified in the city/cities of …… specified in the
Government of India, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting notification number
S.O. 1231(E) dated 31.7.2006.
1.3 TERM
1.3.1 The Agreement shall come into effect from DD/MM/YYYY ("Effective Date") and
shall be valid for a period of 12 months (“Term”) unless otherwise terminated prior
to the expiry of validity period of 12 months in accordance with the terms and
conditions of the Agreement.
1.3.2 Within 2 months prior to expiry of this Agreement, both parties agree to take steps
towards renewal of the Agreement for extended period if it is mutually intended to
continue the term of the Agreement beyond the date of expiry. The parties shall
inform the subscribers through appropriate means of the intention to carry out the
negotiations and consequences to the subscribers if negotiations fail to succeed.
1.3.3 If the parties mutually decide to extend the term to continue the Services referred to
in clause 1.1 above with or without modification, the Parties may enter into a fresh
agreement, in writing on mutually agreed terms and conditions.
1.3.4 In case if the parties decide not to extend the term and such decision could not be
made before the expiry of the term of this Agreement and the services have
continued in the meanwhile even after the said expiry of the term specified in clause
1.3.1 of this Agreement, the term would be deemed to have been extended till the
date of such decision.
1.4 ENTIRE UNDERSTANDING
1.4.1 The Agreement contains the entire understanding between the parties with respect to
the subject matter covered, in the manner, it is expected to be understood by the
parties and that there is total agreement between the parties as to the manner in which
the other party has understood various clauses of this Agreement.
1.4.2 The Parties agree that in addition to the principal terms stated herein, the Schedules
and Annexures if any attached hereto form an integral part of the Agreement and
shall be deemed to be incorporated herein and failure to comply with any of the
terms, conditions, and/or provisions mentioned in any of the Schedules and
Annexures hereto, shall constitute breach of the Agreement.
6
1.5 DEFINITIONS
The words and expressions used in this Agreement shall have meanings as assigned
to them in the Schedule to this Agreement.
ARTILCE 2 : SUBSCRIPTION RIGHTS
2.1 Subject to due observance by the Parties of the terms and conditions of this
Agreement and in consideration of the promise by the Affiliate to make payment of
the Subscription Amounts which are due and payable in terms of this Agreement to
the Broadcaster, the Broadcaster hereby grants to the Affiliate, for the duration of the
Term of this Agreement, a non-exclusive right to avail the services indicated in
clause 1.1 of Article 1 comprising in the right to subscribe to and to distribute the
Subscribed Channels as described in Annexure A through CAS to the subscribers in
the Area only via the Permitted Distribution System. The Affiliate shall have the
right to distribute the viewing of the subscribed Television Channels only to
subscribers in the Area and not to any other third party.
2.2 The subscription rights given to the Affiliate under this Agreement are confined to
subscribers having an addressable set top box, in relation to whom the Affiliate
compulsorily maintains the complete detailed data and transaction records in its
CAS/ Subscriber Management System (SMS). This Agreement does not give the
Affiliate or his agents rights to transmit by any mode of transmission from the head
end of the Affiliate to the commercial operators and/or its subscribers other than
through coaxial or optic fiber cable. A separately negotiated agreement would have
to be entered into for the purpose of transmission through any other means such as
DTH or HITS or any other mode.
2.3 Without prejudice to the remaining provisions of this Agreement, the Broadcaster
reserves the right:
2.3.1 to commence or continue to provide the Service direct to other Affiliates and
to appoint other Affiliates in the Area for the purpose of distributing the
Service, subject, however, to the observance of the provisions of applicable
law in force.
2.3.2 to discontinue any Channels which form part of the services as Broadcaster
shall deem fit subject to and in compliance with the rules, regulation and
orders , if any in this regard.
2.4 In the event of an increase/decrease in the number of the Subscribed Channels taken
by the subscribers, it is obligatory on the part of the Affiliate to include, delete,
increase or decrease the same, as the case may be, in his SMS/CAS and intimate the
same to the Broadcaster at the time of paying the Subscription Amount for the
respective month according to the terms of this Agreement.
2.5 It is expressly agreed between the Parties that the Affiliate’s right to receive and
distribute the Service shall be conditional upon the performance by the Affiliate of
all its obligations arising under this Agreement and mere possession of the Integrated
Receiver Decoders (IRDs)/ Viewing Cards shall not entitle the Affiliate to receive
and/ or to distribute the Service.
2.6 The Affiliate shall receive and de-code the Subscribed Channels only through IRDs
recommended/approved by the Broadcaster.
7
2.7 The Affiliate shall further ensure that the Services of Subscribed Channels for which
a fee is payable as specified in Annex A shall only be activated through the set top
boxes which meets the specifications prescribed by BIS; otherwise the Broadcaster
shall be entitled to de-activate the Service of the Affiliate. For the purpose of
compliance of this clause, the Affiliate shall give a certificate to the Broadcaster that
a mutually agreed procedure for verification is in place and that the same has been
followed in respect of each subscriber.
2.8 The following conditions are a prerequisite for the execution of the present
Agreement and shall subsist for continuing the same:
• The Affiliate shall install the CAS, which is linked and integrated, with SMS and
activation/deactivation are processed through such SMS. Both CAS and SMS
systems should be as per the standard prescribed by BIS. The reports generated
by SMS should be in conformity with CAS and in a pre-defined read only format
such as a suitable PDF format, which cannot be edited.
• The Affiliates operating system should be able to handle individual channels,
packages, tiers, discounts, free offers, promotional offers;
• The CAS and SMS of Affiliate must have the capability or recording
activation/deactivation history with respect to each addressable device (IRD/VC)
and each service for every activation and deactivation in the system for a
minimum period of 1 year.
• The Services of the Broadcaster shall be provided to the subscribers only through
CAS/SMS and no services shall be provided without recording, authorization,
billing and accounting through the said system.
• The Affiliate shall be liable to provide to the Broadcaster, as and when demanded
by the Broadcaster, from time to time a list of subscribers pertaining to any
location along with the names and addresses of the subscribers within the Area to
which it or its sub Operators is providing the Channel services including each
dwelling for purposes of verification.
ARTICLE 3: COMMERCIAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF AGREEMENT
3.1 SUBSCRIPTION AMOUNTS AND REVENUE SHARE ARRANGEMENTS.
A. SUBSCRIPTION AMOUNTS
3.1.1 Subject to the provisions set forth herein in this Agreement, and in consideration of
the rights granted by the Broadcaster under this Agreement in terms of clause 2.1 of
Article 2, the Affiliate agrees to pay to the Broadcaster the Subscription Amounts,
determined as per the Revenue Share Arrangement indicated herein below, per
subscriber per month and as specified in Annexure A for the services indicated in
clause 1.1 of Article 1 of this Agreement and within the time limits as indicated in
this Agreement.
3.1.2 The Broadcaster shall have the right to vary the Subscription Fees after giving notice
of not less than one month to the Affiliate and in compliance with the applicable law
in force. The Total Subscription Amounts payable by the Affiliate to the Broadcaster
shall also vary accordingly.
8
B. REVENUE SHARE ARRANGEMENTS
3.1.3 The subscription amounts payable to the Broadcaster by the Affiliate shall be
calculated with reference to the subscription fee indicated in Annexure A in respect
of each channel or bouquet of Channels multiplied by the number of subscribers as
recorded in the Subscriber Management System installed at the Head End of the
Affiliate to be availing such service for each month. The revenue share arrangement
for the purpose of calculating the subscription fee for each channel or bouquet of
channels shall be as per the formula indicated below:
I Maximum Retail Price of a subscribed pay channel or
bouquet of channels as Annexure A per subscriber per
month
Rs. X
II Percentage of Amount payable to the Broadcaster by the
Affiliate, per subscriber per month
45% of X
III Percentage of Maximum Retail Price to be retained by
Affiliate (to be shared between the Affiliate and the cable
operator)
55% of X
3.1.4 The total Subscription Amount along with any other payments statutorily required to
be made by the Affiliate to the Broadcaster for each month shall be payable within
21 days from the close of the relevant month (after adjusting/deducting and retaining
the portion of revenue retainable by the Affiliate as per 3.1.3(III) supra).
3.1.5 In the event of default in payment of the Subscription Amount, simple interest at the
rate of 15 % per annum shall be paid by the Affiliate on the arrears of such
Subscription Amounts which may remain unpaid at the end of the 21 days.
3.1.6 The parties may enter into a separate Agreement as regards payments to be made/
received on account of Carriage /Placement fee.
3.1.7 The entire advertising revenue for the Subscribed Channels shall pertain to the
broadcaster.
3.2 CHARGES FOR EQUIPMENT INCLUDING INTEGRATED RECEIVER DECODER (IRD)
IRD: The Broadcaster shall, supply or cause to supply the IRDs, on payment of the
following charges:
(a) IRD Deposit & Processing Fees: Immediately upon execution of the Agreement
the Affiliate shall pay such sums towards the processing fees per IRD
(“Processing Fees”) and interest free refundable deposit per IRD (“IRD
Deposit”), as required by the Broadcaster and specified in Annexure A. The
Processing Fees and IRD Deposit are hereinafter collectively referred to as IRD
Charges.
(b) Other Charges/ Taxes: The Affiliate shall pay courier charges, transportation
charges, and all applicable taxes / levies, if any, for the IRD on actuals.
9
ARTICLE 4: RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTIES
4.1 AFFILIATE’S RIGHTS
The Affiliate shall have the right to subscribe and distribute the Subscribed Channels
conferred through this Agreement and shall be conditional to the Affiliate’s performance of
all its obligations and on the basis of the representations, warranties and declarations made
by the Affiliate to the Broadcaster.
4.2 The Broadcaster shall give to the Affiliate access to the Subscribed Channels, subject
to the Affiliate meeting the following mandatory eligibility conditions: -
4.2.1 The Affiliate provides an undertaking that it has all necessary licenses and permits
required under the Applicable Law(s) for distributing the Subscribed Channels;
4.2.2 The Affiliate provides an undertaking that it has internal guidelines in place to
comply with non-discriminatory access provisions specified by The Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) in its Telecommunication (Broadcasting &
Cable Services) Interconnection Regulation, 2004 and other relevant regulations and
guidelines introduced by TRAI/ Government, from time to time;
4.2.3 The Equipment, CAS and SMS used by the Affiliate shall comply with the following
requirements at all times during the subsistence of this Agreement: -
(i) The systems are capable of monitoring and printing historical data relating to
subscriber activation, deactivation and reactivation, as the case may be;
(ii) CAS and SMS are integrated and any activation or de-activation is processed
simultaneously through both systems;
(iii) The SMS enables the location of each set top box and Smart Card to be
recorded;
(iv) The CAS and SMS is from a reputed, well-known organization, which is
currently being used by other Pay Television Services and has a
demonstrated track record of fulfilling the technical requirements under this
Agreement.
(v) Covert and visible fingerprinting to be supported by all set top boxes which
should be compatible for running fingerprinting whether operated by the
Affiliate or by the Broadcaster.
4.3 BROADCASTER’S RIGHTS
4.3.1 In consideration of the grant of rights in terms of clause 1.1 of Article 1 of this
Agreement the Affiliate shall pay to the Broadcaster, the following on the due dates
with or without any deduction or set-off:
a) All Subscription Amounts and or all revisions or modifications thereof, due and
payable to the Broadcaster shall be paid within the time period and in the manner and
mode as may be agreed to between the parties and specified in Annexure A on the
basis of specific invoices raised , whether or not the subscriber/ sub operator has
been Invoiced or whether or not the payment is received by the Affiliate from his
subscriber / sub operator and irrespective of any discounts or other concessions given
by Affiliate to its subscribers or commercial operators.
10
b) Any other sum payable by the Affiliate to the Broadcaster under the terms of this
Agreement.
c) Any other payments statutorily required to be made by the Affiliates to the
Broadcaster.
4.3.2 In case the payment is not received by the due dates, a simple interest at the rate of
15% per annum from the date of default will be charged from the Affiliate without
prejudice to any other rights of the Broadcaster. For this purpose the due date shall
be the twenty first day of the calendar month following the month in which the
Services were subscribed.
4.3.3 The Affiliate shall be responsible for payment of all taxes, levies, charges imposed
by or under a statute, law, regulations, relating to the Services and payable by the
Affiliate as also for collection of such amounts attributable to such taxes, levies,
charges imposed by or under a statute, law, regulations, relating to the Services and
payable by the Broadcaster and for remitting the same promptly to the Broadcaster
with in the respective due dates.
4.3.4 If the Subscription Amount, or any other amounts payable to the Broadcaster as
specified in this Agreement is not paid by the Affiliate on due date, the Broadcaster
may take all or any of the following actions without prejudice to any other rights but
subject to the applicable rules/regulations, if any, issued by the Competent Authority
including issuance of prescribed notice stipulated by the Interconnection
Regulations.
4.3.4.1 De-authorize the reception of Broadcaster’s services by Affiliate, his agents
and/or his subscribers subject to the compliance of the applicable rules
/regulations of the Competent Authority.
4.3.4.2 Terminate this Agreement, by giving Notice required under this Agreement
and subject to compliance of the Applicable Laws in force.
4.3.4.3 Immediately take back possession of the IRD(s) belonging to the
Broadcaster;
4.3.4.4 Charge a simple interest at the rate of 15% from the date such amounts
became due until they are fully paid;
4.3.4.5 Intimate all the subscribers of such non-receipt of subscription amounts or
other charges and consequences thereof on the subscribers.
4.3.5 Any discounts, special schemes, free periods etc as offered by the Affiliate to its
agents or subscribers or sub operators shall be at the cost and responsibility of the
Affiliate. No burden of such discounts or other promotional schemes shall be passed
on to the Broadcaster.
4.3.6 The Affiliate shall not make his subscribers take other channels or services or fulfill
any other commercial consideration as a precondition to receiving the Broadcaster’s
channels or services.
4.3.7 In the event the Affiliate is required under the Income Tax Act, 1961 to withhold or
deduct tax or other duties or levies that are required by law to be made from a
payment due under the Agreement (including without limitation, the Subscription
Amounts), all of the following conditions shall apply:
11
a) The Affiliate shall, promptly upon becoming aware that it is required to make
any withholding or deduction (or that there is any change in the rate or the basis
of a withholding or deduction), notify Broadcaster accordingly;
b) The Affiliate shall deliver to Broadcaster, receipts, certificates or other proof
evidencing the amounts (if any) paid or payable in respect of any such
withholding or deduction and the Affiliate shall co-operate in completing any
requirements necessary to obtain authorization to make that payment without any
withholding or deduction.
4.3.8 The Subscription Amounts payable by the Affiliate to the Broadcaster shall be
exclusive of all government taxes, levies, cess, including service tax, education cess,
etc., save and except the withholding as provided under the Income Tax Act, 1961.
The Subscription Amounts shall accordingly be increased to the extent of such
government taxes, levies, cess, etc.
4.4 AFFILIATE OBLIGATION ON RECEPTION AND DISTRIBUTION OF SERVICE
4.4.1 The Affiliate shall at its own cost and expense cause the Subscribed Channels as
specified in Annexure A to be received only from the designated satellite(s) as
notified by Broadcaster from time to time, and shall distribute the Subscribed
Channels to subscribers via the Permitted Distribution System using the same
original audio and visual signals and sound tracks (including any stereo tracks) as
provided by the Broadcaster to the Affiliate, in accordance with the restrictions,
terms and conditions set forth herein and in an encrypted/ scrambled form using
encryption and CAS that are capable of Fingerprinting.
4.4.2 The Affiliate shall be responsible, at its sole cost and expense, for obtaining all
licenses and permits necessary to carry on its business as contemplated herein;
4.4.3 The Affiliate shall use its best endeavor within all its means and control to maintain a
high quality of signal transmission for the Subscribed Channels. The Affiliate further
agrees and undertakes that it shall cause continuous distribution of the Subscribed
Channels to all its subscribers during its telecast without blacking it out or interfering
with it in any manner whatsoever, subject however to such continuous and high
quality of service being provided by Broadcaster;
4.4.4 The Affiliate shall ensure that the Permitted Distribution System is maintained on a
standard capable of delivering as per Bureau of Indian Standards Act, 1986 (“BIS”)
specifications broadcast quality signals to subscribers, and that the Subscribed
Channels are distributed to subscribers at such broadcast quality level, which in any
event should be no less favorable than the quality of signal delivered by the Affiliate
to its subscribers for any other channel.
4.4.5 The Affiliate shall comply with all laws and regulations affecting its marketing, sale
and distribution of the Subscribed Channels in the Area in connection with its
performance under the Agreement including, without limitation, (i) obtaining and
maintaining all relevant approvals, consents and registrations and (ii) paying all
charges, levies and duties imposed on or charged to it under any law or regulation or
by any Government Authority;
4.4.6 Without prejudice to the above general obligations as above the Affiliate subject to
the terms of this Agreement shall take the following steps as set out herein under:
12
a) The Affiliate shall on receiving the encrypted signals as prescribed by the
Broadcaster shall decode the same using an IRD which is compatible with the
CAS of the Broadcaster,
b) After receiving the Signals and decoding the same, the Affiliate shall reencrypt
the signals with his own CAS and further distribute the encoded signals through
cable networks only to those subscribers who have installed set top boxes and
whose names and complete details are properly entered in the CAS & SMS, as
per their choice/ request for individual channels on an a-la-carte basis or number
of channels of the different bouquets on offer as opted by the subscriber. The
abovesaid receiving of signals and de-encoding shall be done only at the head
end address as mentioned in the Affiliation Registration details to this Agreement
or as approved by the Broadcaster by an appropriate addendum to the same. The
re-encrypting and further transmission shall be done only through the coaxial or
optic fiber cable network of the Affiliate or of his authorized sub operator only
and shall not be transmitted even partially or intermediately through any other
means such as satellite, head-end in the sky, very small aperture terminal (v-sat),
internet, etc.
c) The Affiliate shall maintain complete records of its subscribers, commercial
operators, their viewership details, like addresses, services taken, periods for
which they were taken,
d) The Affiliate will not distribute the services to subscribers out of the area
without the prior written permission of the Broadcaster,
e) The Affiliate may provide the services to the subscribers either by himself or
through his sub operators,
f) The Affiliate shall be responsible for making all payments under this Agreement
notwithstanding any default by his sub operators and subscribers,
g) The Affiliate is obliged and shall endeavor in the task of protection of
Broadcaster’s intellectual property rights, preventing piracy of the Broadcaster’s
services, disclosing correctly all the information as required by the Broadcaster,
distribution by commercial operator only to persons in the Affiliate’s SMS
database and operating within the limits of the subscription rights as conferred in
terms of this Agreement. The Affiliate shall endeavor in the task of ensuring that
the subscribers shall not further distribute the Broadcaster’s services to others
whether or not for commercial consideration. It is understood that these
obligations would comprise of taking all necessary steps promptly within the
control of the Affiliate.
4.4.7 The Affiliate shall take all necessary actions to prevent any unauthorized access to
the Subscribed Channels in the Area and shall obtain and provide to Broadcaster
regularly updated piracy reports at least once every quarter. The Affiliate shall take
appropriate remedial actions to curb piracy in the Area.
4.4.8 The Affiliate undertakes that it shall not either itself, or through others acting on its
instructions, copy, store or otherwise reproduce any part of the Subscribed Channels.
The Affiliate further undertakes that it shall not copy or store programmes for resale
or deal in any copied programmes and shall immediately notify the Broadcaster of
any unauthorised copying, storage or use of any part of the Subscribed Channels and
shall fully cooperate with all requests by Broadcaster to take such steps as are
reasonable and appropriate to cause such activities to cease. It is understood that this
does not apply to subscribers having STBs in their houses which have the capacity to
record and playback programmes.
13
4.5 AFFILIATE OBLIGATIONS ON SUBSCRIBER REPORTS
4.5.1 The Affiliate shall prepare and provide to the Broadcaster complete and accurate
monthly reports (“Subscriber Report”) for the Subscribed Channels within 15 days
after the end of each month detailing:
i) Total number of subscribers, including their names and addresses and the
Subscribed Channels on the first day and the last day of the month subscribed to;
ii) Maximum Retail prices charged for the tiers that include Subscribed Channels;
iii) Details of tiers that include Subscribed Channels offered to the subscribers
(details such as channels in each tier and number of the subscribers subscribing
to each tier);
iv) Such other information as Broadcaster may require for determining the
Subscription Amounts.
Upon Broadcaster’s written request, the Affiliate shall provide number of subscribers
by category, tier, location, sub-operator/last mile operator that Broadcaster may
require with prior intimation and sufficient Notice to the Affiliate
4.5.2 Each Subscriber Report shall be signed and attested by an officer of the Affiliate of a
rank not less than Head of Department/Chief Financial Officer responsible for the
Affiliate’s SMS, who shall certify that all information in such Subscriber Report is
true and correct. The Affiliate acknowledges that any requests for further information
from time to time by the Broadcaster would not be unreasonably withheld. This
obligation shall survive termination of the Agreement until Broadcaster receives the
Subscriber Reports for each relevant month and all outstanding monies have been
paid.
4.6 OBLIGATIONS REGARDING EPG (ELECTRONIC PROGRAMME GUIDE)
The Affiliate shall create an electronic programming guide (EPG) which shall
contain the details of programming schedules of each of the channels and for that
purpose the Broadcaster shall provide to the Affiliate the required information in a
format that is requested by the Affiliate.
4.7 PACKAGING, PLACEMENT AND PROMOTION RELATED OBLIGATIONS
a. Apart from the packages provided by the Affiliate the channels should also be
offered on an a-la-carte basis.
b. In addition to the other packages/ tiers, including the Subscribed Channels of the
Broadcaster, offered by the Affiliate to the subscriber, the Affiliate shall also
offer the Subscribed Channels to subscribers in the same bouquets as offered by
Broadcaster to the Affiliate.
4.8 MARKETING OBLIGATIONS
4.8.1 In all its marketing efforts including but not limited to on-air and off-air promotion,
the Affiliate would provide the Subscribed Channels:
i) An equivalent amount of marketing support as it provides to channels of the
same genre;
14
ii) Equal treatment in all its material whereby Channel logos or names appear with
the same size and prominence and page as other channels;
iii) Equal opportunity to participate in events/promotions the Affiliate undertakes.
4.8.2 The Affiliate shall not use the Channel Marks or the Broadcaster’s trade names or
trademarks in any manner that is not expressly provided in the Agreement, unless it
has obtained the prior written agreement of Broadcaster. For the removal of doubts,
the Affiliate shall not use the Broadcaster’s trade names or trademarks in a manner
that will adversely affect the goodwill and reputation of Broadcaster and its products
and services.
4.8.3 The Affiliate acknowledges that Broadcaster shall have the sole discretion to approve
the use of Channel Marks by the Affiliate, including with respect to the programmes
included in the Subscribed Channels. The Affiliate further agrees that that by reason
of the Agreement, it shall not acquire any proprietary or other rights or interest in the
Channel Marks.
4.9 OBLIGATIONS OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS AND RIGHTS PROTECTION
4.9.1 The Affiliate shall use its best efforts to promote an awareness of the Subscribed
Channels among its subscribers and potential subscribers.
4.9.2 It is expressly agreed and understood that the Affiliate shall not acquire any
intellectual property rights, ownership or other rights, including but not limited to
rights relating to any trade marks, service marks or copyrights (whether registered or
unregistered), with respect to the Subscribed Channels or Additional Channels except
as expressly set forth in the Agreement, nor shall the Affiliate grant to others, the
right to use the Subscribed Channels or any other rights in and to the Subscribed
Channels except as specifically set forth in the Agreement.
4.9.3 The Affiliate shall not acquire and agrees not to take advantage of any legal
possibility to acquire any proprietary or other rights in the trade names and marks to
which the Broadcaster or its principals (the owners or the channel providers of the
Subscribed Channels) assert proprietary or other rights ("Channel Marks") and
further agrees not to use the Channel Marks in any corporate or trade name.
4.9.4 The Affiliate agrees that upon discovering or coming to Notice of any actual or
impending infringement or unauthorised use by or through the subscribers of the
Channel Marks or any other intellectual property rights or ownership rights relating
to the Subscribed Channels, the Affiliate shall immediately report to Broadcaster
with full details.
4.10 SUBSCRIBER RECORDS, ACCESS & AUDIT RIGHTS
4.10.1 The Affiliate shall keep accurate, complete and up to date records of every
subscriber’s details, details of the location of every set top box, Smart Card, records
and accounts of billings including historical billing data, type of subscribers,
sublicenses and all relevant matters (“Subscriber Records”). The Affiliate shall
ensure that its SMS and billing software allows for monitoring and printing historical
data relating to subscriber activation and/or deactivation, going back to at least 12
months at any point of time.
15
4.10.2 The SMS and all Subscriber Records that are relevant to the Subscribed Channels for
the operation of the Agreement shall be available for inspection and audit by
Broadcaster/Broadcaster’s representative(s) (where such representatives are members
of an internationally recognized accounting firm and agree in writing to be bound by
confidentiality obligations) during the Term at any time during normal business
hours and for three months after the expiry or premature termination of the
Agreement, as the case may be, to ensure compliance with the Anti-Piracy
Obligations, and (ii) on three days prior written notice during normal business hours
to ensure compliance with all other terms of the Agreement up to four times within
any 12-month period and for three months after the expiry or premature termination
of the Agreement, as the case may be. The Affiliate shall give
Broadcaster/Broadcaster’s representatives any assistance they may reasonably
require in connection with their audit investigations. In the event a breach of the
Agreement has been discovered during the course of such audit or inspection,
Broadcaster/Broadcaster’s representatives shall have the right to take printouts,
photocopies and computer copies of the Subscriber Records, or any portion